Sindbad~EG File Manager

%PDF-1.3
%����
1 0 obj
<<
/Width 1
/Filter[/CCITTFaxDecode]
/Type/XObject
/Subtype/Image
/ImageMask true
/Length 4
/BitsPerComponent 1
/Height 1
/Decode[1 0]
/DecodeParms[<</Columns 1/K -1>>]
>>
stream
��endstream
endobj
2 0 obj
<<
/Length 6199
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
q
0.6 0 0 -20.04 134.508 749.988 cm
0 g
/Im1 Do
Q
q
0.6 0 0 -20.04 466.188 749.988 cm
0 g
/Im1 Do
Q
q
20.04 0 0 -0.6 104.868 720.348 cm
0 g
/Im1 Do
Q
q
20.04 0 0 -0.6 476.388 720.348 cm
0 g
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F0 1 Tf
14.34624 0 0 14.34624 134.76 671.16 Tm
0 g
[(The)-369(Mec)34(hanization)-387(of)-376(Mathematics)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 636.6 Tm
[(Mic)24(hael)-325(Beeson)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 202.32 640.2 Tm
(1)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 134.76 615.72 Tm
[(San)-335(Jos)28<13>]TJ
3.42613 0 Td
[(e)-361(State)-347(Univ)26(ersit)28(y)81(,)-322(San)-348(Jose,)-361(CA)-348(95192,)-372(USA)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
-3.42613 -6.46414 TD
[(Summary)93(.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
5.75483 0 Td
(The)Tj
/F5 1 Tf
2.18148 0 Td
[(me)53(chanization)-429(of)-429(mathematics)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
14.06588 0 Td
[(refers)-413(to)-401(the)-401(use)-402(of)-401(computers)-413(to)]TJ
-22.0022 -1.23127 TD
[(\fnd,)-269(or)-280(to)-280(help)-269(\fnd,)-269(mathematical)-292(pro)-26(ofs.)-307(T)80(uring)-268(sho)27(w)27(ed)-281(that)-280(a)-281(complete)-280(reduction)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(of)-307(mathematics)-292(to)-293(computation)-294(is)-307(not)-281(p)-27(ossible,)-307(but)-281(nev)26(ertheless)-293(the)-294(art)-293(and)-282(science)]TJ
T*
[(of)-254(automated)-252(deduction)-229(has)-254(made)-254(progress.)-252(This)-254(pap)-27(er)-254(describ)-27(es)-254(some)-253(of)-253(the)-241(history)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(and)-335(surv)27(eys)-333(the)-348(state)-346(of)-348(the)-348(art.)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
11.95517 0 0 11.95517 134.76 480.12 Tm
[(1)-1124(In)30(tro)-30(duction)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 456.24 Tm
[(In)-386(the)-373(nineteen)24(th)-386(cen)25(tury)83(,)-373(mac)24(hines)-374(replaced)-361(h)24(umans)-374(and)-373(animals)-374(as)-374(ph)24(ys-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(ical)-373(lab)-24(orers.)-362(While)-386(for)-373(the)-386(most)-374(part)-375(this)-386(w)24(as)-361(a)-374(w)25(elcome)-373(relief,)-385(there)-374(w)24(ere)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(o)-24(ccasional)-241(p)-24(o)-24(c)25(k)24(ets)-254(of)-265(resistance.)-254(The)-252(folk)-265(song)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
20.12719 0 Td
[(John)-289(Henry)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
5.33594 0 Td
[(commemorates)-241(an)]TJ
-25.46313 -1.2045 TD
[(o)-24(ccasion)-265(when)-288(a)-277(man)-277(and)-289(a)-277(mac)24(hine)-277(comp)-24(eted)-276(at)-290(the)-289(task)-278(of)-277(drilling)-278(railroad)]TJ
T*
[(tunnels)-398(through)-399(moun)24(tains.)-386(The)-397(\\drilling")-386(w)24(as)-385(done)-398(b)24(y)-385(hammering)-386(a)-397(steel)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(spik)24(e.)-386(The)-397(mac)25(hine)-385(w)24(as)-386(steam-p)-25(o)24(w)25(ered.)-374(The)-396(man)-386(w)24(as)-385(an)-386(ex-sla)24(v)24(e,)-373(a)-385(banjo)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(pla)24(y)24(er)-349(with)-362(a)-361(deep)-361(singing)-362(v)24(oice)-348(and)-362(a)-361(reputation)-350(for)-362(ph)24(ysical)-349(strength)-363(and)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(endurance.)-313(He)-312(b)-25(eat)-313(the)-325(mac)24(hine,)-313(drilling)-302(fourteen)-313(feet)-325(to)-314(its)-314(nine,)-325(but)-314(it)-325(w)24(as)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(a)-325(Pyrrhic)-314(victory)84(,)-325(as)-326(he)-337(died)-337(after)-325(the)-338(e\013ort.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(Ev)25(en)-325(b)-25(efore)-337(the)-337(\frst)-339(computers)-326(w)24(ere)-325(dev)25(elop)-24(ed,)-337(p)-24(eople)-337(w)25(ere)-325(sp)-25(eculating)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.19246 TD
[(ab)-24(out)-410(the)-410(p)-24(ossibilit)23(y)-410(that)-410(mac)24(hines)-398(migh)24(t)-410(b)-24(e)-421(made)-409(to)-398(p)-24(erform)-410(in)24(tellectual)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(as)-338(w)25(ell)-337(as)-338(ph)24(ysical)-337(tasks.)-339(Alan)-337(T)85(uring)-338(w)24(as)-337(the)-350(\frst)-339(to)-337(mak)24(e)-337(a)-337(careful)-337(analy-)]TJ
T*
[(sis)-447(of)-433(the)-458(p)-24(oten)24(tial)-434(capabilities)-446(of)-434(mac)24(hines,)-446(in)24(v)25(en)24(ting)-434(his)-446(famous)-435(\\T)85(uring)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(mac)24(hines")-361(for)-374(the)-386(purp)-24(ose.)-374(He)-373(argued)-361(that)-386(if)-386(an)24(y)-361(mac)24(hine)-373(could)-373(p)-24(erform)-374(a)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(computation,)-314(then)-325(some)-301(T)84(uring)-314(mac)25(hine)-313(could)-313(p)-24(erform)-302(it.)-326(The)-312(argumen)23(t)-301(fo-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(cuses)-289(on)-289(the)-302(assertion)-278(that)-290(an)24(y)-289(mac)24(hine's)-289(op)-24(erations)-278(could)-289(b)-24(e)-301(sim)24(ulated,)-290(one)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(step)-326(at)-325(a)-326(time,)-325(b)24(y)-325(certain)-326(simple)-325(op)-24(erations,)-314(and)-326(that)-326(T)85(uring)-314(mac)25(hines)-326(w)24(ere)]TJ
T*
[(capable)-252(of)-277(those)-266(simple)-265(op)-24(erations.)-254(T)84(uring's)-254(\frst)-266(fame)-277(resulted)-266(from)-253(applying)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(this)-302(analysis)-278(to)-302(a)-288(problem)-290(p)-24(osed)-301(earlier)-278(b)24(y)-301(Hilb)-24(ert,)-301(whic)24(h)-301(concerned)-276(the)-302(p)-24(os-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(sibilit)23(y)-361(of)-362(mec)25(hanizing)-349(mathematics.)-362(T)84(uring)-350(sho)24(w)25(ed)-350(that)-362(in)-361(a)-361(certain)-350(sense,)]TJ
T*
[(it)-386(is)-374(imp)-24(ossible)-386(to)-374(mec)25(hanize)-373(mathematics:)-374(W)84(e)-385(shall)-374(nev)25(er)-374(b)-24(e)-385(able)-373(to)-374(build)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(an)-434(\\oracle")-409(mac)25(hine)-422(that)-446(can)-433(correctly)-410(answ)24(er)-422(all)-433(mathematical)-422(questions)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(presen)24(ted)-338(to)-337(it)-350(with)-350(a)-325(\\y)24(es")-325(or)-325(\\no")-337(answ)24(er.)-314(In)-350(another)-325(famous)-338(pap)-24(er)-338([101],)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(T)85(uring)-326(w)24(en)25(t)-326(on)-325(to)-326(consider)-313(the)-326(somewhat)-325(di\013eren)24(t)-326(question,)-326(\\Can)-325(mac)25(hines)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(think?".)-362(It)-362(is)-350(a)-349(di\013eren)24(t)-362(question,)-350(b)-24(ecause)-349(p)-24(erhaps)-350(mac)25(hines)-350(can)-349(think,)-362(but)]TJ
T*
[(they)-374(migh)24(t)-361(not)-374(b)-24(e)-373(an)24(y)-362(b)-24(etter)-374(at)-361(mathematics)-363(than)-373(h)24(umans)-362(are;)-362(or)-350(p)-24(erhaps)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(they)-325(migh)24(t)-314(b)-24(e)-325(b)-24(etter)-326(at)-314(mathematics)-314(than)-325(h)24(umans)-314(are,)-301(but)-326(not)-326(b)24(y)-313(thinking,)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
3 0 obj
<<
/SA false
/Type/ExtGState
>>
endobj
4 0 obj
<<
/Length 8292
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 134.76 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(2)-3171(Mic)26(hael)-361(Beeson)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(just)-435(b)24(y)-409(brute-force)-411(calculation)-409(p)-24(o)24(w)25(er.)-410(These)-421(t)23(w)25(o)-410(pap)-24(ers)-410(of)-421(T)84(uring)-422(lie)-421(near)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(the)-349(ro)-25(ots)-338(of)-349(the)-362(sub)-61(jects)-349(to)-25(da)24(y)-337(kno)24(wn)-337(as)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
18.32044 0 Td
[(automate)48(d)-385(de)48(duction)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.34692 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
1.95129 0 Td
(arti\fcial)Tj
-29.61865 -1.20451 TD
[(intel)-48(ligenc)49(e)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
4.86618 0 Td
(.)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 186 645.96 Tm
(1)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 149.76 630.36 Tm
[(Although)-313(T)84(uring)-314(had)-313(already)-301(pro)24(v)24(ed)-301(there)-326(w)25(ere)-301(limits)-326(to)-326(what)-313(one)-313(could)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(exp)-24(ect)-421(of)-410(mac)25(hines,)-410(nev)24(ertheless)-410(mac)24(hines)-410(b)-24(egan)-409(to)-410(comp)-24(ete)-421(with)-422(h)24(umans)]TJ
T*
[(at)-422(in)24(tellectual)-433(tasks.)-423(Arithmetic)-435(came)-421(\frst,)-435(but)-434(b)24(y)-421(the)-434(end)-434(of)-421(the)-434(cen)25(tury)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(computers)-326(could)-337(pla)24(y)-325(excellen)25(t)-338(c)25(hess,)-326(and)-337(in)-338(1997)-312(a)-326(computer)-337(program)-314(b)-24(eat)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(w)24(orld)-265(c)24(hampion)-277(Garry)-266(Kasparo)24(v.)-253(The)-277(New)-288(Y)85(ork)-278(Times)-277(describ)-24(ed)-277(the)-289(matc)24(h:)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(\\In)-482(a)-494(dazzling)-469(hourlong)-482(game,)-482(the)-494(Deep)-493(Blue)-481(IBM)-494(computer)-482(demolished)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(an)-385(ob)24(viously)-362(o)24(v)24(erwhelmed)-373(Garry)-362(Kasparo)24(v)-350(and)-385(w)24(on)-373(the)-398(six-game)-361(man-vs.-)]TJ
T*
[(mac)24(hine)-325(c)25(hess)-326(matc)24(h.")]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 233.76 550.2 Tm
(2)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 149.76 534.72 Tm
[(In)-410(1956,)-385(Herb)-397(Simon,)-410(one)-409(of)-410(the)-410(\\fathers)-398(of)-410(arti\fcial)-398(in)24(telligence",)-396(pre-)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(dicted)-241(that)-242(within)-253(ten)-241(y)24(ears,)-217(computers)-230(w)24(ould)-228(b)-25(eat)-241(the)-241(w)25(orld)-230(c)25(hess)-230(c)25(hampion,)]TJ
T*
[(comp)-24(ose)-277(\\aesthetically)-265(satisfying")-266(original)-266(m)24(usic,)-277(and)-277(pro)24(v)24(e)-265(new)-276(mathemati-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(cal)-253(theorems.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 191.76 502.44 Tm
(3)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 198.72 498.84 Tm
[(It)-266(to)-24(ok)-253(fort)23(y)-241(y)24(ears,)-241(not)-253(ten,)-266(but)-265(all)-253(these)-265(goals)-242(w)25(ere)-241(ac)25(hiev)24(ed|)]TJ
-6.41998 -1.2045 TD
[(and)-337(within)-338(a)-337(few)-337(y)24(ears)-313(of)-338(eac)25(h)-325(other!)-338(The)-337(m)24(usic)-337(comp)-24(osed)-325(b)24(y)-338(Da)25(vid)-325(Cop)-24(e's)]TJ
T*
[(programs)-302([33{35])-301(cannot)-325(b)-24(e)-337(distinguished,)-339(ev)24(en)-325(b)24(y)-325(professors)-303(of)-337(m)24(usic,)-326(from)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(that)-338(comp)-24(osed)-325(b)24(y)-325(Mozart,)-326(Beetho)24(v)24(en,)-313(and)-337(Bac)25(h.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 348.36 466.56 Tm
(4)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 149.76 450.96 Tm
[(In)-458(1976,)-433(a)-458(computer)-458(w)24(as)-446(used)-470(in)-458(the)-469(pro)-25(of)-458(of)-457(the)-458(long-unsolv)23(ed)-445(\\four)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(color)-373(problem'.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 200.76 442.68 Tm
(5)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 209.16 438.96 Tm
[(This)-398(did)-397(not)-386(ful\fll)-410(Simon's)-386(prediction,)-398(b)-24(ecause)-385(the)-398(role)-385(of)]TJ
-7.4679 -1.19245 TD
[(the)-386(computer)-373(w)24(as)-362(simply)-374(to)-374(c)25(hec)25(k)-374(b)24(y)-373(calculation)-361(the)-386(1476)-349(di\013eren)24(t)-386(sp)-24(eci\fc)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(cases)-265(to)-265(whic)24(h)-277(the)-277(mathematicians)-266(had)-265(reduced)-277(the)-277(problem)-265([2,3].)-265(T)84(o)-24(da)25(y)-265(this)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(w)24(ould)-373(not)-374(cause)-361(a)-373(ripple;)-374(but)-374(in)-386(1976)-348(it)-374(created)-362(quite)-385(a)-361(stir,)-375(and)-374(there)-373(w)24(as)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(serious)-278(discussion)-291(ab)-24(out)-289(whether)-289(suc)24(h)-290(a)-288(\\pro)-25(of)-72(")-277(w)24(as)-289(acceptable!)-276(The)-301(journal)]TJ
T*
[(editors)-411(required)-410(an)-421(indep)-24(enden)24(t)-434(computer)-422(program)-398(to)-422(b)-24(e)-433(written)-423(to)-422(c)25(hec)25(k)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(the)-325(result.)-315(The)-324(use)-314(of)-325(computer)-314(calculations)-301(to)-325(pro)23(vide)-301(\\empirical")-301(evidence)]TJ
ET
q
56.76 0 0 -0.48 134.748 359.388 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 136.8 352.44 Tm
(1)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 348.6 Tm
[(One)-282(con)27(tro)28(v)27(ersy)-279(concerns)-294(the)-282(question)-280(whether)-281(the)-281(limiting)-307(theorems)-293(ab)-27(out)-280(T)80(ur-)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(ing)-281(mac)27(hines)-268(also)-293(apply)-268(to)-280(h)26(uman)-254(in)26(telligence,)-294(or)-280(whether)-268(h)26(uman)-267(in)26(telligence)-281(has)]TJ
T*
[(some)-333(qualit)27(y)-334(not)-321(imitable)-347(b)26(y)-321(a)-334(T)80(uring)-334(mac)27(hine)-335(\(a)-334(vital)-347(force,)-347(free)-347(will,)-348(quan)26(tum)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(indeterminacy)-347(in)-336(the)-348(synapses?\))-346(These)-361(questions)-333(w)26(ere)-361(already)-347(tak)28(en)-348(up)-336(b)27(y)-321(T)80(ur-)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(ing,)-348(and)-349(w)27(ere)-347(still)-361(under)-336(discussion)-361(\(without)-347(agreemen)28(t\))-360(b)26(y)-321(scien)27(ti\fc)-361(luminaries)]TJ
T*
[(at)-347(the)-335(end)-335(of)-361(the)-335(t)28(w)26(en)27(tieth)-334(cen)26(tury)-334([79,80].)]TJ
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 136.8 286.68 Tm
(2)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 282.84 Tm
[(After)-441(the)-455(game,)-454(IBM)-454(retired)-454(Deep)-442(Blue,)-469(\\quitting)-440(while)-469(it)-455(w)27(as)-454(ahead.")-468(Some)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(said)-334(that)-320(Kasparo)28(v)-321(lost)-333(only)-321(b)-27(ecause)-334(he)-322(got)-333(nerv)27(ous)-321(and)-322(blundered.)-323(No)-321(rematc)28(h)]TJ
T*
[(w)27(as)-267(held.)-269(In)-254(Octob)-27(er,)-267(2002,)-293(another)-253(c)27(hampion)-268(pla)26(y)28(ed)-255(another)-267(computer)-267(program:)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(This)-348(time)-347(it)-348(w)27(as)-360(a)-348(dra)27(w.)]TJ
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 136.8 242.88 Tm
(3)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 239.04 Tm
[(This)-455(prediction)-442(is)-441(usually)-455(cited)-442(as)-454(ha)27(ving)-428(b)-28(een)-442(made)-441(in)-442(1957,)-467(but)-442(I)-428(b)-27(eliev)27(e)-455(it)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(w)27(as)-347(actually)-334(\frst)-333(made)-335(in)-335(1956)-346(at)-334(Simon's)-347(inaugural)-335(address)-347(as)-333(Presiden)26(t)-334(of)-347(the)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(Op)-27(erations)-346(Researc)28(h)-349(So)-26(ciet)27(y)-348(of)-347(America.)]TJ
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 136.8 210 Tm
(4)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 206.16 Tm
[(That)-495(lev)27(el)-495(of)-495(p)-27(erformance)-507(w)27(as)-508(not)-481(demanded)-483(b)27(y)-482(Simon's)-495(prediction,)-495(and)-496(his)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(criterion)-280(of)-280(\\aesthetically)-292(satisfying")-292(m)27(usic)-268(w)27(as)-280(met)-280(m)27(uc)26(h)-254(earlier.)-294(It)-253(is)-281(in)27(teresting)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(that)-320(Simon)-335(set)-334(a)-334(lo)27(w)27(er)-334(bar)-334(for)-334(m)28(usic)-335(than)-321(for)-347(mathematics)-332(and)-335(c)27(hess,)-335(but)-321(m)27(usic)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(turned)-322(out)-347(to)-347(b)-27(e)-335(easier)-360(to)-347(computerize)-347(than)-348(mathematics.)]TJ
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 136.8 166.2 Tm
(5)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 162.36 Tm
[(This)-335(problem)-334(asks)-346(whether)-321(it)-335(is)-347(p)-27(ossible)-348(to)-333(color)-347(an)27(y)-321(map)-334(that)-320(can)-335(b)-27(e)-335(dra)27(wn)-335(on)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(a)-374(plane)-389(using)-375(at)-387(most)-386(four)-374(colors,)-413(in)-376(suc)27(h)-375(a)-375(w)27(a)27(y)-374(that)-374(coun)26(tries)-386(with)-389(a)-374(common)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(b)-27(order)-347(receiv)27(e)-348(di\013eren)26(t)-334(colors.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
5 0 obj
<<
/Length 7570
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 290.52 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(The)-335(Mec)27(hanization)-361(of)-361(Mathematics)-3183(3)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(for)-314(mathematical)-301(claims)-313(has)-314(led)-313(to)-313(\\exp)-24(erimen)24(tal)-302(mathematics")-301(and)-314(ev)25(en)-313(to)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(rep)-24(orts)-291(of)-301(the)-301(\\death)-289(of)-301(pro)-25(of)-72(")-289([53].)-289(As)-302(Mark)-289(Tw)24(ain)-289(said,)-301(\\the)-302(rep)-24(orts)-278(of)-301(m)24(y)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
[(death)-337(are)-314(greatly)-325(exaggerated".)]TJ
1.50563 -1.19245 TD
[(On)-337(Decem)25(b)-24(er)-362(10,)-337(1996,)-325(Simon's)-350(prediction)-349(came)-349(true.)-350(The)-349(fron)24(t)-350(page)-337(of)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(the)-422(New)-408(Y)84(ork)-410(Times)-409(carried)-398(the)-410(follo)24(wing)-397(headline:)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
23.54797 0 Td
[(Computer)-433(Math)-446(Pr)49(o)49(of)]TJ
-23.54797 -1.19245 TD
[(Shows)-361(R)48(e)49(asoning)-361(Power)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
10.50324 0 Td
[(.)-349(The)-337(story)-314(b)-25(egan:)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 151.68 585.96 Tm
[(Computers)-373(are)-374(whizzes)-389(when)-375(it)-361(comes)-387(to)-374(the)-361(grun)26(t)-360(w)26(ork)-373(of)-374(mathematics.)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(But)-508(for)-521(creativ)28(e)-522(and)-509(elegan)27(t)-521(solutions)-521(to)-507(hard)-509(mathematical)-533(problems,)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(nothing)-442(has)-454(b)-28(een)-442(able)-455(to)-454(b)-27(eat)-441(the)-442(h)27(uman)-442(mind.)-442(That)-455(is,)-455(p)-27(erhaps,)-455(un)26(til)]TJ
T*
[(no)27(w.)-522(A)-496(computer)-507(program)-507(written)-507(b)26(y)-495(researc)29(hers)-522(at)-508(Argonne)-508(National)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(Lab)-27(oratory)-358(in)-362(Illinois)-375(has)-347(come)-361(up)-349(with)-361(a)-361(ma)-53(jor)-360(mathematical)-372(pro)-26(of)-374(that)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(w)27(ould)-335(ha)26(v)27(e)-334(b)-28(een)-321(called)-349(creativ)29(e)-335(if)-348(a)-334(h)27(uman)-322(had)-335(though)27(t)-321(of)-347(it.)-334(In)-322(doing)-348(so,)]TJ
T*
[(the)-335(computer)-333(has,)-348(for)-347(the)-334(\frst)-334(time,)-334(got)-346(a)-348(to)-26(ehold)-335(in)26(to)-347(pure)-321(mathematics,)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(a)-321(\feld)-309(describ)-26(ed)-309(b)26(y)-307(its)-320(practitioners)-319(as)-321(more)-319(of)-321(an)-308(art)-320(form)-319(than)-308(a)-307(science.)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 149.76 487.68 Tm
[(The)-325(theorem)-325(w)24(as)-325(pro)23(v)24(ed)-313(b)24(y)-325(the)-337(computer)-338(program)-302(EQP)86(,)-326(written)-326(b)24(y)-337(Bill)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(McCune.)-493(Before)-482(it)-494(w)24(as)-482(pro)24(v)24(ed,)-470(it)-494(w)24(as)-482(kno)24(wn)-481(as)-482(the)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
24.46339 0 Td
[(R)48(obbins)-505(Conje)49(ctur)49(e)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
8.55195 0 Td
(,)Tj
-33.01534 -1.2045 TD
[(and)-434(p)-24(eople)-445(seem)-433(reluctan)23(t)-434(to)-446(c)25(hange)-421(the)-446(name)-446(to)-434(\\EQP's)-409(theorem".)-433(It)-447(is)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(ab)-24(out)-386(certain)-386(algebras.)-361(An)-398(algebra)-361(is)-386(a)-385(set)-386(with)-398(t)24(w)24(o)-373(op)-24(erations,)-375(written)-398(as)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(w)24(e)-397(usually)-410(write)-398(addition)-410(and)-397(m)24(ultiplication,)-410(and)-410(another)-398(op)-24(eration)-386(called)]TJ
T*
[(\\complemen)25(t")-277(and)-290(written)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
11.9125 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56612 0 Td
[(\).)-302(If)-289(an)-289(algebra)-277(satis\fes)-279(certain)-289(nice)-289(equations)]TJ
-13.46631 -1.19246 TD
[(it)-278(is)-277(called)-264(a)-265(Bo)-24(olean)-252(algebra.)-253(Robbins)-278(exhibited)-277(three)-265(short)-266(simple)-278(equations)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(and)-241(conjectured)-229(that)-241(these)-242(three)-241(equations)-229(can)-241(b)-24(e)-240(used)-242(to)-229(axiomatize)-228(Bo)-24(olean)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(algebras;)-350(that)-374(is,)-374(those)-374(three)-374(equations)-361(imply)-386(the)-374(usual)-374(axioms)-361(for)-362(Bo)-24(olean)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(algebras.)-265(A)-301(complete,)-301(precise)-277(statemen)23(t)-289(of)-301(the)-302(Robbins)-289(conjecture)-289(is)-290(giv)25(en)-289(in)]TJ
T*
[(Fig.)-338(1.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.19245 TD
[(EQP)-288(solv)24(ed)-289(this)-314(problem)-302(in)-313(a)-301(computer)-302(run)-301(lasting)-302(eigh)24(t)-302(da)25(ys,)-302(and)-301(using)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(30)-373(megab)24(ytes)-386(of)-385(memory)84(.)-386(The)-384(pro)-25(of)-385(it)-386(pro)-25(duced,)-397(ho)24(w)25(ev)24(er,)-362(w)25(as)-374(only)-385(\ffteen)]TJ
T*
[(lines)-458(long)-446(and)-457(\fts)-459(on)24(to)-446(a)-457(single)-446(page)-445(or)-459(computer)-446(screen.)-445(Y)84(ou)-458(sometimes)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(ha)24(v)24(e)-385(to)-398(sho)24(v)24(el)-385(a)-385(lot)-398(of)-398(dirt)-410(and)-398(gra)24(v)24(el)-361(to)-398(\fnd)-409(a)-398(diamond.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 390.84 323.88 Tm
(6)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 399.24 320.28 Tm
[(Since)-397(the)-398(pro)-24(of)]TJ
-26.54718 -1.2045 TD
[(w)24(as)-337(easily)-326(c)25(hec)25(k)60(able)-337(b)24(y)-337(h)24(umans,)-338(there)-338(w)25(as)-338(no)-337(\rurry)-339(of)-337(discussion)-338(ab)-24(out)-350(the)]TJ
T*
[(acceptabilit)24(y)-385(of)-386(the)-385(pro)-25(of,)-385(as)-374(there)-386(had)-385(b)-24(een)-397(ab)-24(out)-386(the)-386(four-color)-362(problem.)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(\(There)-398(w)25(as,)-386(ho)24(w)25(ev)24(er,)-374(a)-397(bit)-398(of)-397(discussion)-387(ab)-24(out)-398(whether)-398(h)24(umans)-398(had)-397(really)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(giv)24(en)-325(this)-338(problem)-326(their)-325(b)-25(est)-350(shot|)-325(but)-338(indeed,)-337(T)85(arski)-327(studied)-338(it,)-337(and)-326(none)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(of)-349(the)-350(h)24(umans)-338(who)-337(w)25(ere)-337(tempted)-350(to)-350(b)-24(e)-349(critical)-337(w)24(ere)-325(able)-349(to)-337(\fnd)-350(a)-337(pro)-25(of,)-349(so)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(these)-362(discussions)-351(w)25(ere)-337(generally)-349(short-liv)22(ed.\))-338(An)-373(am)24(using)-337(sideligh)23(t:)-362(The)-360(job)]TJ
T*
[(w)24(as)-410(just)-434(running)-423(in)-433(the)-434(bac)24(kground)-398(and)-421(its)-435(successful)-422(completion)-421(w)24(as)-410(not)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(noticed)-337(un)24(til)-338(a)-325(da)24(y)-325(later!)]TJ
ET
q
56.76 0 0 -0.48 134.748 216.948 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 136.8 210 Tm
(6)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 206.16 Tm
[(In)-415(1966)-453(\(within)-429(ten)-415(y)27(ears)-440(of)-428(Simon's)-441(prediction\),)-428(a)-441(computer)-414(program)-439(w)26(as)-441(in-)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(v)27(olv)27(ed)-375(in)-375(the)-375(solution)-387(of)-388(an)-388(op)-27(en)-375(problem.)-388(The)-388(user)-375(w)27(as)-387(guiding)-389(an)-388(in)26(teractiv)29(e)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(theorem)-333(pro)27(v)27(er)-321(kno)27(wn)-321(as)-334(SAM)-322(to)-334(a)-334(pro)-26(of)-347(of)-334(a)-334(kno)27(wn)-322(theorem,)-333(and)-322(noticed)-335(that)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(an)-388(equation)-374(that)-387(had)-376(b)-27(een)-375(deriv)27(ed)-376(led)-388(directly)-388(to)-387(the)-375(answ)28(er)-402(to)-387(a)-387(related)-388(op)-26(en)]TJ
T*
[(question)-361([47].)-400(This)-375(ev)27(en)26(t)-361(is)-374(\\widely)-375(regarded)-374(as)-387(the)-361(\frst)-361(case)-387(of)-374(a)-374(new)-376(result)-373(in)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(mathematics)-292(b)-27(eing)-295(found)-295(with)-294(help)-282(from)-293(an)-295(automated)-292(theorem)-294(pro)28(v)27(er",)-280(accord-)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(ing)-348(to)-347([72],)-361(p.)-348(6.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
6 0 obj
<<
/Length 9508
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 134.76 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(4)-3171(Mic)26(hael)-361(Beeson)]TJ
ET
q
331.32001 0 0 -1.08 134.748 676.188 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F4 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 201.48 661.2 Tm
[(Fig.)-173(1.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
3.49305 0 Td
[(What)-348(exactly)-333(is)-361(the)-334(Robbins)-335(Conjecture?)]TJ
-10.93418 -1.88705 TD
[(A)-335(Bo)-26(olean)-348(algebra)-360(is)-334(a)-347(set)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
12.11192 0 Td
(A)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.09743 0 Td
[(together)-346(with)-335(binary)-334(op)-27(erations)-346(+)-335(and)]TJ
/F11 1 Tf
17.71953 0 Td
<01>Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.62902 0 Td
[(and)-322(a)-347(unary)]TJ
-31.5579 -1.21788 TD
[(op)-27(eration)]TJ
/F11 1 Tf
4.52357 0 Td
<00>Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.07067 0 Td
[(,)-268(and)-255(elemen)27(ts)-280(0,)-267(1)-281(of)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
9.52893 0 Td
(A)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.0439 0 Td
[(suc)27(h)-255(that)-267(the)-267(follo)27(wing)-294(la)27(ws)-281(hold:)-281(comm)28(utativ)28(e)]TJ
-16.16707 -1.23127 TD
[(and)-509(asso)-25(ciativ)28(e)-536(la)28(ws)-535(for)-521(addition)-522(and)-509(m)27(ultiplication,)-522(distributiv)27(e)-508(la)27(ws)-535(b)-27(oth)-508(for)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(m)27(ultiplication)-321(o)27(v)27(er)-307(addition)-321(and)-309(for)-320(addition)-308(o)27(v)28(er)-308(m)27(ultiplication,)-334(and)-295(the)-308(follo)28(wing)]TJ
T*
[(sp)-27(ecial)-455(la)28(ws:)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
6.06265 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.86992 0 Td
0.281 Tc
(+\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.48555 0 Td
0 Tc
(x)Tj
/F11 1 Tf
0.86992 0 Td
<01>Tj
/F10 1 Tf
0.57548 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.54872 0 Td
0.414 Tc
(\)=)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
2.04765 0 Td
0 Tc
(x)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.58887 0 Td
(,)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
0.70932 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F11 1 Tf
0.86992 0 Td
<01>Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.57548 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
0.4015 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.85653 0 Td
(+)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.09743 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.54872 0 Td
0.414 Tc
(\)=)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
2.04765 0 Td
0 Tc
(x)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.58887 0 Td
(,)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
0.70932 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.86992 0 Td
0.281 Tc
(+\()Tj
/F11 1 Tf
1.48555 0 Td
0 Tc
<00>Tj
/F10 1 Tf
(x)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.39187 0 Td
0.414 Tc
[(\)=)-15(1)414(,)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
3.27892 0 Td
0 Tc
(x)Tj
/F11 1 Tf
0.86992 0 Td
<01>Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.5621 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F11 1 Tf
0.4015 0 Td
<00>Tj
/F10 1 Tf
(x)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.39187 0 Td
[(\))-414(=)-429(0.)-441(This)]TJ
-31.70511 -1.23127 TD
[(de\fnition,)-416(and)-402(other)-414(basic)-415(information)-439(on)-402(the)-415(sub)-54(ject,)-414(can)-415(b)-27(e)-415(found)-403(in)-415([73].)-441(The)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(Robbins)-389(conjecture)-401(sa)28(ys)-401(that)-387(an)27(y)-388(algebra)-400(satisfying)-413(the)-388(follo)28(wing)-429(three)-401(equations)]TJ
T*
[(is)-348(a)-347(Bo)-26(olean)-375(algebra.)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
3.43952 -2.11457 TD
(x)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.81638 0 Td
(+)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.03052 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.82977 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.08405 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.76285 0 Td
(+)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.03052 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
-5.55408 -1.55247 TD
(\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
0.4015 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.81638 0 Td
(+)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.03052 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.54872 0 Td
0.214 Tc
(\)+)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.64615 0 Td
0 Tc
(z)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.803 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.08405 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.81638 0 Td
0.228 Tc
(+\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.43202 0 Td
0 Tc
(y)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.76285 0 Td
(+)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.03052 0 Td
(z)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.52195 0 Td
(\))Tj
/F10 1 Tf
-10.89403 -1.55247 TD
(n)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.61563 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
0.4015 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.61563 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
0.4015 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.81638 0 Td
(+)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.03052 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.54872 0 Td
0.227 Tc
(\)+)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.64615 0 Td
0 Tc
(n)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.61563 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
0.4015 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.81638 0 Td
(+)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.03052 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.61563 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
0.4015 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.54872 0 Td
[(\)\)\))-280(=)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
2.5696 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
-16.51503 -2.11457 TD
[(Previous)-347(w)27(ork)-347(had)-348(sho)27(wn)-335(that)-347(it)-348(is)-347(enough)-335(to)-348(pro)28(v)27(e)-335(the)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
25.48186 0 Td
[(Huntington)-389(e)53(quation)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
9.11405 0 Td
(:)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
-31.15639 -2.11457 TD
(n)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.61563 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
0.4015 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.61563 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
0.4015 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.58887 0 Td
0.227 Tc
(\)+)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.65953 0 Td
0 Tc
(y)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.54872 0 Td
0.214 Tc
(\)+)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.64615 0 Td
0 Tc
(n)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.61563 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
0.4015 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.61563 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
0.4015 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.58887 0 Td
0.227 Tc
(\)+)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.65953 0 Td
0 Tc
(n)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.61563 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
0.4015 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.54872 0 Td
[(\)\))-280(=)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
2.1681 0 Td
(x:)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
-17.93367 -2.11457 TD
[(That)-254(is,)-267(if)-254(this)-254(equation)-254(is)-254(satis\fed,)-266(then)-242(the)-241(algebra)-266(is)-267(Bo)-26(olean.)-281(What)-241(EQP)-254(actually)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(did,)-255(then,)-255(is)-267(come)-281(up)-241(with)-268(a)-267(pro)-27(of)-267(that)-253(the)-254(three)-268(Robbins)-254(equations)-254(imply)-267(the)-254(Hun)25(t-)]TJ
T*
[(ington)-281(equation.)-280(T)80(ak)28(e)-268(out)-281(y)27(our)-267(p)-27(encil)-282(and)-268(pap)-27(er)-268(and)-268(giv)28(e)-281(it)-281(a)-281(try)-266(b)-27(efore)-280(reading)-281(on.)]TJ
0 -1.23126 TD
[(Y)80(ou)-294(don't)-295(need)-309(a)-307(Ph.)-308(D.)-295(in)-308(mathematics)-318(to)-294(understand)-295(the)-294(problem:)-321(Just)-294(see)-321(if)-307(the)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(three)-334(Robbins)-335(equations)-347(imply)-334(the)-335(Hun)26(tington)-321(equation.)-334(It)-334(is)-347(imp)-27(ortan)28(t)-347(to)-334(under-)]TJ
T*
[(stand)-240(the)-241(nature)-227(of)-254(the)-241(game:)-253(Y)80(ou)-241(do)-241(not)-240(need)-229(to)-240(\\understand")-240(the)-241(equations,)-254(or)-240(the)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(\\meaning")-320(of)-307(the)-281(sym)28(b)-28(ols)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
11.81748 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.61563 0 Td
[(,)-308(+)-294(and)]TJ
/F11 1 Tf
3.64027 0 Td
<01>Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.28105 0 Td
[(.)-294(Y)80(ou)-295(migh)27(t)-294(b)-27(e)-294(happier)-295(if)-308(y)27(ou)-295(could)-295(think)-281(of)-307(+)]TJ
-16.35443 -1.21788 TD
[(as)-307(\\or",)]TJ
/F11 1 Tf
3.73395 0 Td
<01>Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.58887 0 Td
[(as)-293(\\and",)-308(and)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
6.424 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.91007 0 Td
[(as)-307(\\not",)-306(but)-282(it)-294(is)-307(completely)-294(unnecessary)81(,)-294(as)-307(y)27(ou)-281(are)-307(not)]TJ
-11.65688 -1.21788 TD
[(allo)28(w)26(ed)-321(to)-307(use)-295(an)27(y)-294(prop)-27(erties)-306(of)-321(these)-294(sym)28(b)-27(ols)-307(except)-294(those)-307(giv)27(en)-308(b)26(y)-281(the)-294(equations.)]TJ
ET
q
331.32001 0 0 -1.08 134.748 366.348 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 149.76 333 Tm
[(It)-314(seems,)-314(ho)25(w)24(ev)24(er,)-289(that)-314(the)-325(in)24(tellectual)-313(triumph)-327(of)-313(the)-313(computer)-314(is)-314(b)24(y)-313(no)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(means)-301(as)-302(thorough)-302(as)-301(the)-314(ph)24(ysical)-301(triumph)-314(of)-301(the)-326(steam)-302(drill.)-313(The)-301(computer)]TJ
T*
[(has)-422(y)24(et)-434(to)-434(b)-24(eat)-433(a)-434(h)24(uman)-434(c)25(hess)-422(c)24(hampion)-422(reliably)-422(and)-433(rep)-24(eatedly)84(,)-434(and)-433(the)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(n)24(um)24(b)-24(er)-265(of)-265(mathematical)-254(theorems)-253(whose)-265(\frst)-255(pro)-24(of)-265(w)24(as)-253(found)-265(b)24(y)-265(a)-253(computer)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(is)-350(still)-350(less)-338(than)-350(100,)-337(though)-338(there)-349(is)-338(some)-349(fuzziness)-338(ab)-24(out)-350(what)-349(coun)24(ts)-338(as)-337(a)]TJ
T*
[(theorem)-386(and)-385(what)-386(coun)25(ts)-375(as)-386(a)-373(computer)-386(pro)-24(of.)-386(No)-373(graduate)-374(studen)24(t)-398(to)-25(da)25(y)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(c)24(ho)-24(oses)-265(not)-278(to)-277(b)-24(ecome)-288(a)-265(mathematician)-277(for)-278(fear)-277(that)-278(the)-289(computer)-278(will)-289(pro)24(v)24(e)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(to)-24(o)-277(di\016cult)-290(a)-277(comp)-24(etitor.)-278(The)-288(da)24(y)-265(when)-289(a)-276(computer)-278(pro)-24(duces)-265(a)-277(\fv)24(e)-277(h)24(undred)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(page)-325(pro)-24(of)-325(that)-339(answ)24(ers)-313(a)-326(famous)-325(op)-24(en)-325(question)-338(is)-326(not)-338(imminen)24(t.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.32495 TD
[(Another)-374(analogy)85(,)-362(p)-24(erhaps)-374(closer)-373(than)-386(the)-386(steam)-386(drill,)-374(is)-386(to)-386(mec)25(hanizing)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(\righ)24(t.)-338(With)-349(regard)-326(to)-338(mec)25(hanizing)-337(mathematics,)-338(are)-325(w)24(e)-337(no)24(w)-337(at)-337(the)-350(stage)-325(of)]TJ
T*
[(Leonardo)-217(da)-241(Vinci's)-241(dra)24(wings)-217(of)-241(men)-253(with)-241(wings,)-241(or)-230(at)-241(the)-241(stage)-229(of)-241(the)-241(W)84(righ)24(t)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(brothers?)-315(Can)-312(w)24(e)-325(exp)-24(ect)-325(the)-325(analog)-301(of)-325(jetliners)-326(an)24(ytime)-314(so)-24(on?)-325(Airplanes)-314(\ry)85(,)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(but)-266(not)-265(quite)-265(lik)24(e)-253(birds)-254(\ry;)-265(and)-253(Dijkstra)-266(famously)-254(remark)24(ed)-229(that)-266(the)-265(question)]TJ
T*
[(whether)-386(mac)25(hines)-374(can)-385(think)-386(is)-386(lik)24(e)-385(the)-386(question,)-386(\\Can)-373(submarines)-374(swim?".)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(Since)-252(p)-25(eople)-264(ha)24(v)24(e)-228(no)-253(wings,)-253(the)-265(prosp)-26(ect)-240(of)-253(mac)24(hines)-253(\rying)-253(did)-253(not)-253(create)-253(the)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(anxieties)-301(and)-302(con)25(tro)23(v)24(ersies)-266(that)-314(surround)-302(the)-302(prosp)-25(ect)-301(of)-313(mac)25(hines)-302(thinking.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
7 0 obj
<<
/Length 7747
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 290.52 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(The)-335(Mec)27(hanization)-361(of)-361(Mathematics)-3183(5)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(But)-362(mac)25(hines)-338(do)-349(mathematics)-362(somewhat)-338(in)-361(the)-362(w)25(a)24(y)-337(that)-350(submarines)-351(swim:)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(p)-24(onderously)84(,)-338(with)-361(more)-350(p)-24(o)24(w)25(er)-338(and)-349(duration)-350(than)-350(a)-349(\fsh,)-362(but)-362(with)-362(less)-338(grace)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
[(and)-325(b)-24(eaut)24(y)84(.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 185.64 645.96 Tm
(7)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 149.76 630.36 Tm
[(A)48(cknow)-48(le)49(dgments)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
7.61244 0 Td
[(.)-337(I)-338(am)-337(grateful)-326(to)-338(the)-349(follo)24(wing)-313(p)-24(eople,)-337(who)-336(read)-326(drafts)]TJ
-9.11806 -1.2045 TD
[(and)-265(suggested)-242(c)25(hanges:)-253(Nadia)-253(Ghamra)24(wi,)-241(Marvin)-254(Ja)25(y)-253(Green)24(b)-24(erg,)-241(Mik)24(e)-253(P)24(alle-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(sen,)-338(and)-325(Larry)-314(W)84(os.)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
11.95517 0 0 11.95517 134.76 575.64 Tm
[(2)-1124(Before)-382(T)91(uring)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 552.96 Tm
[(In)-458(this)-447(section)-458(w)25(e)-446(review)-433(the)-458(ma)-60(jor)-434(strands)-448(of)-445(though)23(t)-458(ab)-24(out)-446(the)-458(mec)25(ha-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(nization)-337(of)-350(mathematics)-338(up)-349(to)-350(the)-337(time)-362(of)-337(T)85(uring.)-338(The)-349(ma)-60(jor)-326(\fgures)-338(in)-349(this)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(history)-399(w)25(ere)-386(Leibniz,)-409(Bo)-24(ole,)-397(F)84(rege,)-397(Russell,)-398(and)-398(Hilb)-24(ert.)-422(The)-397(ac)25(hiev)24(emen)25(ts)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(of)-470(these)-470(men)-469(ha)24(v)24(e)-446(b)-24(een)-469(discussed)-471(in)-469(man)24(y)-458(other)-458(places,)-458(most)-471(recen)25(tly)-458(in)]TJ
T*
[([39],)-337(and)-349(t)23(w)25(en)24(t)24(y)-350(y)24(ears)-325(ago)-337(in)-350([38].)-337(Therefore)-337(w)25(e)-349(will)-350(k)25(eep)-349(this)-350(section)-350(short;)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(nev)24(ertheless,)-314(certain)-325(minor)-338(c)24(haracters)-302(deserv)24(e)-313(more)-325(atten)23(tion.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(Gottfried)-338(Leibniz)-350((1646-1716))-301(is)-338(famous)-338(in)-337(this)-350(connection)-337(for)-338(his)-338(slogan)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
(Calculemus)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
4.95049 0 Td
[(,)-253(whic)25(h)-241(means)-241(\\Let)-242(us)-241(calculate.")-228(He)-241(en)25(visioned)-229(a)-241(formal)-242(language)]TJ
-4.95049 -1.19246 TD
[(to)-313(reduce)-313(reasoning)-302(to)-313(calculation,)-313(and)-313(said)-314(that)-326(reasonable)-289(men,)-326(faced)-312(with)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(a)-458(di\016cult)-458(question)-458(of)-458(philosoph)24(y)-446(or)-446(p)-24(olicy)85(,)-458(w)24(ould)-446(express)-446(the)-458(question)-458(in)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(a)-385(precise)-386(language)-373(and)-397(use)-398(rules)-386(of)-398(calculation)-373(to)-397(carry)-374(out)-398(precise)-386(reason-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(ing.)-422(This)-434(is)-422(the)-433(\frst)-436(reduction)-421(of)-422(reasoning)-410(to)-434(calculation)-409(ev)24(er)-422(en)25(visioned.)]TJ
T*
[(One)-289(imagines)-289(a)-289(ro)-24(omful)-290(of)-289(generals)-277(and)-289(p)-24(olitical)-289(leaders)-290(turning)-290(the)-301(crank)-277(of)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(Leibniz's)-350(mac)25(hine)-349(to)-350(decide)-349(whether)-349(to)-350(launc)25(h)-350(a)-349(military)-350(attac)24(k.)-338(It)-350(is)-362(in)24(ter-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(esting)-326(that)-326(Leibniz)-325(did)-325(not)-326(restrict)-315(himself)-338(to)-313(theoretical)-314(sp)-24(eculation)-325(on)-325(this)]TJ
T*
[(sub)-61(ject|he)-373(actually)-361(designed)-373(and)-374(built)-374(a)-373(w)24(orking)-349(calculating)-361(mac)24(hine,)-373(the)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
0 -1.19246 TD
[(Stepp)48(e)49(d)-398(R)49(e)48(ckoner)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
7.60039 0 Td
[(.)-373(He)-373(w)24(as)-350(inspired)-374(b)24(y)-361(the)-374(somewhat)-361(earlier)-350(w)24(ork)-349(of)-374(P)25(ascal,)]TJ
-7.60039 -1.2045 TD
[(who)-385(built)-398(a)-398(mac)25(hine)-385(that)-387(could)-397(add)-385(and)-386(subtract.)-399(Leibniz's)-386(mac)25(hine)-386(could)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(add,)-458(subtract,)-447(divide,)-458(and)-445(m)24(ultiply)83(,)-457(and)-458(w)24(as)-446(apparen)24(tly)-434(the)-458(\frst)-447(mac)24(hine)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(with)-446(all)-433(four)-423(arithmetic)-434(capabilities.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 295.92 329.4 Tm
(8)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 304.68 325.8 Tm
[(Tw)25(o)-434(of)-433(Leibniz's)-434(Stepp)-25(ed)-445(Rec)25(k)24(oners)]TJ
-17.05572 -1.2045 TD
[(ha)24(v)24(e)-313(surviv)23(ed)-324(and)-326(are)-325(on)-325(displa)23(y)-325(in)-337(m)24(useums)-326(in)-338(Munic)24(h)-337(and)-325(Hano)24(v)24(er.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.19245 TD
[(George)-337(Bo)-23(ole)-349((1815-1864))-314(to)-24(ok)-349(up)-362(Leibniz's)-350(idea,)-361(and)-349(wrote)-349(a)-350(b)-24(o)-24(ok)-361([26])]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
(called)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.81853 0 Td
[(The)-349(L)48(aws)-349(of)-349(Thought)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.25056 0 Td
[(.)-325(The)-313(la)24(ws)-301(he)-313(form)24(ulated)-314(are)-301(no)24(w)-301(called)-312(Bo)-24(olean)]TJ
ET
q
56.76 0 0 -0.48 134.748 282.708 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 136.8 275.76 Tm
(7)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 271.92 Tm
[(This)-402(is)-414(the)-388(\fne)-389(prin)26(t)-388(con)27(taining)-415(the)-388(disclaimers.)-426(In)-389(this)-401(pap)-27(er,)-401(\\mec)28(hanization)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(of)-401(mathematics")-425(refers)-413(to)-401(getting)-400(computers)-400(to)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
21.88175 0 Td
(\fnd)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
2.07442 0 Td
[(pro)-26(ofs,)-428(rather)-400(than)-388(ha)27(ving)]TJ
-23.95617 -1.23127 TD
(them)Tj
/F5 1 Tf
2.60975 0 Td
[(che)53(ck)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
2.70343 0 Td
[(pro)-26(ofs)-347(that)-320(w)26(e)-348(already)-333(knew,)-335(or)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
14.58783 0 Td
[(stor)54(e)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
2.47592 0 Td
[(pro)-26(ofs)-347(or)-334(pap)-27(ers)-334(in)-335(a)-334(database)]TJ
-22.37693 -1.21788 TD
[(for)-320(reference,)-321(or)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
7.32068 0 Td
[(typ)54(eset)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
3.31907 0 Td
[(our)-307(pap)-28(ers,)-320(or)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
6.55783 0 Td
(send)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
2.30193 0 Td
[(them)-294(con)27(v)27(enien)25(tly)-293(to)-307(one)-308(another,)-307(or)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
-19.49952 -1.21788 TD
(display)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
3.42613 0 Td
[(them)-361(on)-361(the)-362(W)80(eb.)-362(All)-361(these)-361(things)-361(are)-374(indeed)-363(mec)27(hanizations)-374(of)-374(mathe-)]TJ
-3.42613 -1.23127 TD
[(matics,)-386(in)-376(a)-374(broader)-374(sense,)-387(and)-376(there)-361(are)-387(man)27(y)-361(in)26(teresting)-386(pro)-53(jects)-387(on)-375(all)-387(these)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(fron)27(ts,)-414(but)-388(w)27(e)-402(shall)-414(limit)-415(the)-401(scop)-26(e)-402(of)-414(our)-401(discussions)-414(to)-414(ev)27(en)26(ts)-387(in)-402(the)-388(spirit)-414(of)]TJ
T*
[(John)-268(Henry)-254(and)-269(Big)-280(Blue.)-281(Moreo)28(v)27(er,)-281(w)27(e)-281(do)-268(not)-267(discuss)-267(past)-280(and)-255(presen)27(t)-268(e\013orts)-279(to)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(enable)-349(computer)-347(programs)-358(to)-347(mak)28(e)-348(conjectures,)-361(or)-360(to)-347(apply)-335(mec)27(hanized)-349(reason-)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(ing)-361(to)-347(other)-361(areas)-359(than)-348(mathematics,)-373(suc)27(h)-348(as)-361(v)27(eri\fcation)-360(of)-361(computer)-360(programs)]TJ
T*
[(or)-347(securit)28(y)-335(proto)-25(cols,)-374(etc.)]TJ
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 136.8 155.16 Tm
(8)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 151.32 Tm
[(The)-322(abacus)-334(do)-27(es)-321(not)-320(coun)26(t)-321(b)-27(ecause)-321(it)-334(is)-321(not)-321(automatic.)-345(With)-308(Leibniz's)-336(mac)27(hine,)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(the)-335(h)27(uman)-335(only)-334(turned)-335(the)-335(crank.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
8 0 obj
<<
/Length 8682
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 134.76 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(6)-3171(Mic)26(hael)-361(Beeson)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(Algebra{y)24(es,)-289(the)-337(same)-314(la)25(ws)-302(of)-325(concern)-313(in)-325(the)-325(Robbins)-326(conjecture.)-313(Lik)24(e)-313(Leib-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(niz,)-421(Bo)-24(ole)-409(seems)-410(to)-422(ha)24(v)24(e)-397(had)-421(a)-410(grandiose)-398(vision)-410(ab)-24(out)-422(the)-422(applicabilit)24(y)-409(of)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
[(his)-314(algebraic)-288(metho)-25(ds)-313(to)-314(practical)-301(problems{)-290(his)-314(b)-24(o)-24(ok)-313(mak)24(es)-301(it)-314(clear)-301(that)-314(he)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(hop)-24(ed)-265(these)-277(la)24(ws)-253(w)24(ould)-265(b)-24(e)-265(used)-265(to)-265(settle)-278(practical)-253(questions.)-254(William)-277(Stanley)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(Jev)25(ons)-278((1835-1882))-253(heard)-277(of)-302(Bo)-23(ole's)-277(w)24(ork,)-277(and)-289(underto)-25(ok)-289(to)-290(build)-301(a)-289(mac)24(hine)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(to)-362(mak)24(e)-349(calculations)-349(in)-361(Bo)-24(olean)-337(algebra.)-337(He)-373(successfully)-350(designed)-349(and)-362(built)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(suc)24(h)-458(a)-445(mac)24(hine,)-458(whic)25(h)-458(he)-457(called)-457(the)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
16.91118 0 Td
[(L)48(o)48(gic)49(al)-494(Piano)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
6.01046 0 Td
[(,)-470(apparen)24(tly)-446(b)-24(ecause)-445(it)]TJ
-22.92163 -1.2045 TD
[(w)24(as)-313(ab)-24(out)-338(the)-325(size)-325(and)-326(shap)-24(e)-325(of)-337(a)-313(small)-326(piano.)-325(This)-326(mac)25(hine)-325(and)-326(its)-338(creator)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(deserv)24(e)-301(m)24(uc)24(h)-325(more)-313(fanfare)-314(than)-325(they)-314(ha)24(v)24(e)-312(so)-314(far)-314(receiv)25(ed:)-313(This)-313(w)24(as)-314(the)-325(\frst)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(mac)24(hine)-337(to)-349(do)-338(mec)25(hanical)-337(inference.)-349(Its)-338(predecessors,)-326(including)-350(the)-349(Stepp)-25(ed)]TJ
T*
[(Rec)25(k)24(oner,)-422(only)-445(did)-446(arithmetic.)-459(The)-445(mac)25(hine)-434(is)-446(on)-446(displa)24(y)-434(at)-446(the)-458(Museum)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(of)-385(Science)-397(at)-386(Oxford.)-385(The)-385(design)-386(of)-398(the)-397(mac)24(hine)-385(w)24(as)-373(describ)-25(ed)-385(in)-398(a)-385(pap)-24(er,)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
0 -1.2045 TD
[(On)-325(the)-349(Me)48(chanic)49(al)-362(Performanc)50(e)-349(of)-349(L)48(o)48(gic)49(al)-361(Infer)48(enc)48(e)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
22.82527 0 Td
[(,)-313(read)-301(b)-25(efore)-301(the)-313(British)]TJ
-22.82528 -1.19245 TD
[(Ro)24(y)25(al)-314(So)-24(ciet)25(y)-325(in)-338(1870.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 231.96 514.44 Tm
(9)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 149.76 496.68 Tm
[(Gottlob)-242(F)84(rege)-228((1848-1925))-205(created)-229(mo)-24(dern)-241(logic)-241(including)-241(\\for)-229(all",)-241(\\there)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(exists",)-374(and)-374(rules)-362(of)-373(pro)-25(of.)-373(Leibniz)-386(and)-373(Bo)-24(ole)-361(had)-373(dealt)-374(only)-373(with)-386(what)-373(w)24(e)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(no)24(w)-361(call)-361(\\prop)-24(ositional)-338(logic")-349(\(that)-375(is,)-362(no)-361(\\for)-362(all")-349(or)-362(\\there)-349(exists"\).)-363(They)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(also)-386(did)-397(not)-386(concern)-385(themselv)23(es)-385(with)-410(rules)-386(of)-386(pro)-24(of,)-398(since)-385(their)-398(aim)-386(w)25(as)-386(to)]TJ
T*
[(reac)24(h)-265(truth)-278(b)24(y)-277(pure)-278(calculation)-264(with)-290(sym)24(b)-24(ols)-266(for)-277(the)-277(prop)-25(ositions.)-266(F)84(rege)-265(to)-25(ok)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(the)-313(opp)-24(osite)-302(tac)24(k:)-301(instead)-314(of)-301(trying)-302(to)-314(reduce)-300(logic)-301(to)-301(calculation,)-301(he)-301(tried)-314(to)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(reduce)-325(mathematics)-326(to)-325(logic,)-313(including)-337(the)-326(concept)-324(of)-338(n)24(um)24(b)-24(er.)-325(F)84(or)-314(example,)]TJ
T*
[(he)-325(de\fned)-337(the)-325(n)24(um)24(b)-24(er)-326(2)-325(to)-325(b)-25(e)-324(the)-338(class)-314(of)-325(all)-325(classes)-314(of)-325(the)-326(form)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
28.47438 0 Td
(f)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.50589 0 Td
[(x;)-169(y)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
1.54176 0 Td
(g)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.81906 0 Td
(with)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
-31.34109 -1.19246 TD
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.89133 0 Td
(6)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.09609 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
[(.)-361(Lo)-25(osely)-349(sp)-25(eaking,)-349(2)-349(is)-362(the)-361(class)-350(of)-361(all)-350(classes)-338(with)-373(t)23(w)25(o)-349(mem)24(b)-24(ers;)-350(but)]TJ
-2.51741 -1.2045 TD
[(put)-326(that)-314(w)25(a)24(y)84(,)-289(the)-325(de\fnition)-314(sounds)-302(circular,)-302(whic)25(h)-313(it)-314(is)-314(not.)-313(His)-314(ma)-60(jor)-289(w)24(ork,)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
(the)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
1.75857 0 Td
[(Be)49(gri\013schrift)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
6.03454 0 Td
[([43],)-361(w)24(as)-362(published)-386(in)-373(1879,)-349(when)-373(F)84(rege)-361(w)24(as)-361(31)-362(y)25(ears)-350(old.)]TJ
-7.79311 -1.2045 TD
[(He)-349(describ)-24(ed)-349(it)-350(as)-338(a)-349(sym)24(b)-25(olic)-336(language)-325(of)-349(pure)-350(though)24(t,)-338(mo)-24(deled)-349(up)-24(on)-362(that)]TJ
T*
[(of)-337(arithmetic.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.40926 TD
[(Bertrand)-266(Russell)-289((1872-1970))-242(found)-289(F)84(rege's)-277(famous)-278(error:)-266(F)84(rege)-265(had)-289(o)24(v)25(er-)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(lo)-24(ok)24(ed)-397(what)-398(is)-410(no)24(w)-385(kno)24(wn)-397(as)-398(the)-409(Russell)-410(parado)23(x.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 360.36 330.72 Tm
(10)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 372.48 327.12 Tm
[(Namely)85(,)-410(F)84(rege's)-385(rules)]TJ
-23.86115 -1.2045 TD
[(allo)24(w)25(ed)-313(one)-325(to)-326(de\fne)-324(the)-338(class)-314(of)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
14.67081 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.90337 0 Td
[(suc)24(h)-313(that)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.40847 0 Td
(P)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.78292 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
[(\))-338(is)-325(true)-326(for)-326(an)24(y)-313(\\concept")]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
-21.71713 -1.19245 TD
(P)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.78292 0 Td
[(.)-422(F)84(rege's)-397(idea)-422(w)25(as)-398(that)-423(suc)24(h)-421(a)-410(class)-398(w)25(as)-410(an)-422(ob)-60(ject)-409(itself,)-423(the)-422(class)-410(of)-421(ob-)]TJ
-0.78293 -1.2045 TD
[(jects)-338(\\falling)-337(under)-337(the)-338(concept)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
14.09265 0 Td
(P)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.78292 0 Td
[(".)-337(Russell)-338(used)-338(this)-338(principle)-337(to)-338(de\fne)-349(the)]TJ
-14.87558 -1.19245 TD
(class)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
2.36082 0 Td
(R)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.10814 0 Td
[(of)-337(concepts)-350(that)-338(do)-349(not)-338(fall)-349(under)-338(themselv)24(es.)-337(This)-350(concept)-337(leads)-337(to)]TJ
-3.46896 -1.2045 TD
[(a)-373(con)24(tradiction)-362(kno)24(wn)-373(as)-362(Russell's)-374(P)24(arado)24(x.)-349(Here)-373(is)-374(the)-374(argumen)24(t:)-374((1))-374(if)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
32.5215 0 Td
(R)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
-32.5215 -1.2045 TD
[(falls)-266(under)-277(itself)-278(then)-277(it)-278(do)-24(es)-265(not)-277(fall)-277(under)-266(itself;)-278((2))-277(this)-278(con)24(tradiction)-254(sho)24(ws)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(that)-362(it)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
3.20397 0 Td
[(do)48(es)-396(not)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
3.98689 0 Td
[(fall)-349(under)-350(itself;)-362((3)therefore)-351(b)24(y)-349(de\fnition)-362(it)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
19.68153 0 Td
[(do)48(es)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
2.20424 0 Td
[(fall)-349(under)]TJ
-29.07663 -1.2045 TD
[(itself)-338(after)-326(all.)]TJ
ET
q
56.76 0 0 -0.48 134.748 216.948 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 136.8 210 Tm
(9)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 206.16 Tm
[(In)-295(Decem)28(b)-27(er)-294(2002,)-333(an)-308(original)-320(cop)27(y)-295(of)-320(this)-308(pap)-27(er)-294(w)27(as)-320(a)27(v)54(ailable)-321(for)-307(purc)26(hase)-307(from)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(a)-348(rare)-346(b)-27(o)-27(ok)-347(dealer)-348(in)-348(New)-348(Y)80(ork)-320(for)-361(a)-347(price)-348(exceeding)-349($2000.)]TJ
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 188.04 Tm
(10)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 184.2 Tm
[(Russell)-307(w)26(as)-320(thirt)28(y)-294(y)27(ears)-307(old)-321(at)-307(the)-294(time{ab)-26(out)-321(the)-307(same)-320(age)-307(that)-307(F)80(rege)-307(had)-308(b)-27(een)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(when)-309(he)-322(made)-320(the)-308(error.)-320(Russell's)-333(resp)-26(ectful)-335(letter)-320(to)-320(F)80(rege)-320(with)-308(the)-321(bad)-309(news)-321(is)]TJ
T*
[(reprin)27(ted)-268(in)-282([102],)-320(p.)-281(124,)-293(along)-294(with)-295(F)81(rege's)-294(reply:)-280(\\Y)80(our)-267(disco)27(v)27(ery)-280(of)-294(the)-281(con)27(tra-)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(diction)-388(caused)-375(me)-388(the)-375(greatest)-398(surprise)-387(and,)-376(I)-388(w)27(ould)-375(almost)-399(sa)27(y)81(,)-388(consternation,)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(since)-348(it)-348(has)-347(shak)27(en)-335(the)-334(basis)-361(on)-334(whic)26(h)-349(I)-334(in)26(tended)-335(to)-347(build)-337(arithmetic.")]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
9 0 obj
<<
/Length 6903
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 290.52 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(The)-335(Mec)27(hanization)-361(of)-361(Mathematics)-3183(7)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 149.76 666.2401 Tm
[(Russell)-302(\(with)-326(co-author)-289(Whitehead\))-314(wrote)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
18.71793 0 Td
[(Principia)-360(Mathematic)48(a)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
10.31052 0 Td
[([91])-301(to)]TJ
-30.53407 -1.2045 TD
[(sa)24(v)24(e)-229(mathematics)-253(from)-254(this)-254(con)25(tradiction.)-242(They)-253(restricted)-242(the)-253(applicabilit)24(y)-253(of)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
[(F)84(rege's)-241(class-de\fnition)-230(principle,)-253(th)23(us)-241(blo)-24(c)24(king)-241(Russell's)-242(parado)24(x,)-229(and)-241(sho)24(w)24(ed)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(\(b)24(y)-410(actually)-409(carrying)-386(out)-410(h)24(undreds)-411(of)-409(pages)-398(of)-409(pro)-25(ofs\))-410(that)-411(the)-421(main)-410(lines)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(of)-410(mathematics)-410(could)-397(still)-411(b)-24(e)-421(dev)24(elop)-23(ed)-398(from)-410(the)-409(restricted)-399(principle.)-410(This)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(w)24(ork)-241(w)25(as)-242(v)24(ery)-241(in\ruen)24(tial)-253(and)-253(b)-24(ecame)-240(the)-265(starting)-243(p)-24(oin)24(t)-253(for)-254(t)24(w)24(en)25(tieth-cen)24(tury)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(logic;)-349(thirt)23(y)-350(y)25(ears)-338(later,)-350(when)-361<477F>506(odel)-361(needed)-360(a)-350(sp)-24(eci\fc)-361(axiom)-337(system)-362(for)-350(use)]TJ
T*
[(in)-349(stating)-339(his)-350(incompleteness)-337(theorem,)-338(the)-350(ob)25(vious)-326(c)24(hoice)-336(w)24(as)-337(the)-350(system)-338(of)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
0 -1.19245 TD
(Principia)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
4.03507 0 Td
(.)Tj
-2.52945 -1.2045 TD
[(Da)24(vid)-277(Hilb)-24(ert)-289((1862-1943))-242(w)25(as)-266(one)-276(of)-289(the)-290(foremost)-266(mathematicians)-277(of)-290(the)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(early)-385(t)23(w)25(en)24(tieth)-398(cen)24(tury)84(.)-398(He)-397(con)25(tributed)-399(to)-398(the)-409(dev)24(elopmen)24(t)-385(of)-398(formal)-398(logic)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(\(rules)-363(for)-349(reasoning\),)-339(and)-361(then)-362(b)-24(ecame)-360(in)24(terested)-362(in)-362(a)-349(t)24(w)24(o-step)-350(reductionist)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(program)-434(that)-447(com)24(bined)-457(those)-446(of)-446(Leibniz)-458(and)-445(F)84(rege:)-446(he)-457(w)24(ould)-446(\frst)-447(reduce)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(mathematics)-326(to)-338(logic,)-312(using)-326(formal)-326(languages,)-313(and)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
22.25916 0 Td
(then)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
2.20424 0 Td
[(reduce)-325(logic)-313(to)-337(com-)]TJ
-24.46339 -1.2045 TD
[(putation.)-471(His)-482(plan)-470(w)25(as)-458(to)-482(consider)-459(the)-481(pro)-25(ofs)-458(in)-482(logic)-457(as)-470(ob)-61(jects)-458(in)-482(their)]TJ
T*
[(o)24(wn)-373(righ)24(t,)-374(and)-386(study)-374(them)-398(as)-374(one)-373(w)25(ould)-374(study)-386(an)24(y)-373(\fnite)-386(structure,)-375(just)-399(as)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(mathematicians)-422(study)-423(groups)-398(or)-410(graphs.)-411(He)-421(hop)-24(ed)-433(that)-423(w)25(e)-409(w)24(ould)-422(then)-422(b)-24(e)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(able)-325(to)-313(giv)24(e)-313(algorithms)-315(for)-313(determining)-326(if)-337(a)-313(giv)24(en)-313(statemen)23(t)-325(could)-325(b)-25(e)-324(pro)23(v)24(ed)]TJ
T*
[(from)-458(giv)24(en)-458(axioms,)-458(or)-446(not.)-470(By)-457(consideration)-447(of)-469(this)-471(researc)24(h)-434(program,)-447(he)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(w)24(as)-397(led)-410(to)-410(form)24(ulate)-398(the)-409(\\decision)-398(problem")-397(for)-398(logic,)-397(b)-25(etter)-410(kno)24(wn)-397(b)24(y)-409(its)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(German)-313(name,)-325(the)-326(\\En)25(tsc)23(heidungsproblem".)-289(This)-326(problem)-313(w)24(as)-313(published)-338(in)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(1928)-349(in)-373(the)-374(in\ruen)24(tial)-374(logic)-360(b)-25(o)-24(ok)-373(b)24(y)-361(Hilb)-24(ert)-386(and)-362(Ac)25(k)24(ermann)-362([51].)-361(This)-373(w)24(as)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(the)-374(problem)-373(whose)-361(negativ)24(e)-361(solution)-363(made)-373(T)85(uring)-362(famous;)-374(the)-374(next)-373(section)]TJ
T*
[(will)-337(explain)-325(the)-337(problem)-326(and)-337(its)-326(solution.)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
11.95517 0 0 11.95517 134.76 360.12 Tm
[(3)-1124(Hilb)-31(ert)-371(and)-392(the)-371(En)30(tsc)31(heidungsproblem)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 337.08 Tm
[(The)-457(En)24(tsc)24(heidungsproblem)-422(asks)-435(whether)-458(there)-446(exists)-446(a)-446(decision)-446(algorithm)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(suc)24(h)-325(that:)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
1.69834 -2.07174 TD
<0F>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.83111 0 Td
[(It)-338(tak)24(es)-326(t)24(w)24(o)-325(inputs:)-338(a)-325(\fnite)-338(set)-338(of)-325(axioms,)-326(and)-325(a)-337(conjecture.)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
-0.83111 -1.18041 TD
<0F>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.97565 0 Td
[(It)-495(computes)-470(for)-470(a)-482(\fnite)-482(time)-482(and)-482(outputs)-483(either)-470(a)-482(pro)-24(of)-470(of)-470(the)]TJ
-0.97565 -1.2045 TD
[(conjecture)-325(from)-338(the)-337(axioms,)-314(or)-325(\\no)-326(pro)-24(of)-325(exists".)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
0 -1.18041 TD
<0F>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.83111 0 Td
[(The)-337(result)-326(is)-338(alw)25(a)24(ys)-302(correct.)]TJ
-1.02382 -2.09583 TD
[(P)25(art)-302(of)-326(the)-325(reason)-302(for)-313(the)-338(historical)-302(imp)-24(ortance)-326(of)-313(this)-326(problem)-325(is)-314(that)-326(it)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(w)24(as)-361(a)-362(signi\fcan)24(t)-361(ac)24(hiev)24(emen)25(t)-362(just)-374(to)-374(state)-362(the)-386(problem)-362(precisely)85(.)-362(What)-373(are)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
0 -1.19245 TD
(axioms)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
3.32442 0 Td
[(?)-301(What)-301(is)-290(a)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
5.31185 0 Td
[(pr)49(o)48(of)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
2.14401 0 Td
[(?)-313(What)-301(is)-302(an)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
5.87796 0 Td
(algorithm)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
4.10735 0 Td
[(?)-325(Progress)-266(on)-289(the)-301(\frst)-303(t)24(w)24(o)-289(of)]TJ
-20.76558 -1.2045 TD
[(those)-290(questions)-290(had)-301(b)-24(een)-301(made)-288(b)24(y)-290(Russell)-301(and)-289(b)24(y)-289(Hilb)-24(ert)-314(himself.)-302(There)-288(w)24(as)]TJ
T*
[(an)-422(imp)-24(ortan)23(t)-422(di\013erence)-421(in)-421(their)-435(approac)25(hes,)-398(ho)24(w)24(ev)25(er.)-398(Russell)-422(w)24(ork)24(ed)-397(with)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(pro)-25(ofs)-241(and)-241(axioms)-241(in)-241(order)-242(to)-241(\fnd)-253(axioms)-241(that)-242(w)24(ere)-240(eviden)24(tly)-241(true,)-254(and)-241(w)25(ould)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(therefore)-350(enable)-361(one)-361(to)-361(deriv)24(e)-361(true)-362(\(and)-362(only)-362(true\))-374(mathematical)-362(theorems.)]TJ
T*
[(He)-240(had)-229(in)-229(mind)-241(one)-229(\fxed)-241(in)24(terpretation)-218(of)-229(his)-241(axioms{that)-218(is,)-230(they)-241(w)25(ere)-217(ab)-24(out)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(the)-398(one)-385(true)-398(mathematical)-386(univ)24(erse)-385(of)-398(classes,)-374(if)-398(they)-397(w)24(ere)-385(ab)-24(out)-398(an)24(ything)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(at)-338(all.)-337(In)-350(the)-349(man)24(y)-325(pages)-337(of)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
12.51475 0 Td
[(Principia)-397(Mathematic)48(a)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
10.00939 0 Td
[(,)-361(Russell)-338(and)-337(Whitehead)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
10 0 obj
<<
/Length 9604
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 134.76 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(8)-3171(Mic)26(hael)-361(Beeson)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(nev)24(er)-301(discussed)-302(the)-313(question)-314(of)-301(what)-314(w)25(e)-301(w)24(ould)-313(to)-24(da)24(y)-301(call)-301(the)-313(in)24(terpretations)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(of)-313(their)-314(formal)-302(theory)84(.)-301(Hilb)-24(ert,)-326(on)-313(the)-313(other)-302(hand,)-313(understo)-26(o)-24(d)-313(v)24(ery)-301(w)24(ell)-313(that)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
[(the)-458(same)-446(axioms)-434(could)-445(ha)24(v)24(e)-433(more)-446(than)-446(one)-445(in)24(terpretation.)-436(Hilb)-24(ert's)-458(most)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(w)24(ell-kno)25(wn)-229(w)24(ork)-241(on)-241(axiomatization)-229(is)-241(his)-254(b)-24(o)-24(ok)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
20.28378 0 Td
[(F)72(oundations)-289(of)-289(Ge)49(ometry)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
11.17776 0 Td
([50].)Tj
-31.46154 -1.2045 TD
[(This)-326(b)-24(o)-24(ok)-313(pro)24(vided)-301(a)-313(careful)-313(axiomatic)-313(rew)24(orking)-289(of)-326(Euclid)-312(from)-314(21)-313(axioms.)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(Hilb)-24(ert)-338(emphasized)-325(the)-337(distinction)-339(b)-24(et)24(w)24(een)-324(correct)-314(reasoning)-301(\(ab)-25(out)-337(p)-25(oin)25(ts,)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(lines,)-434(and)-434(planes\))-422(and)-433(the)-434(facts)-434(ab)-25(out)-434(p)-24(oin)24(ts,)-434(lines,)-434(and)-422(planes,)-434(b)24(y)-421(sa)24(ying)]TJ
T*
[(that)-422(if)-434(y)24(ou)-410(replace)-409(\\p)-24(oin)24(ts,)-410(lines,)-422(and)-422(planes")-409(b)24(y)-410(\\tables,)-422(c)25(hairs,)-399(and)-421(b)-25(eer)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(m)24(ugs",)-374(the)-385(reasoning)-350(should)-386(still)-387(b)-24(e)-385(correct.)-362(This)-385(seems)-374(ob)24(vious)-362(to)-386(to)-24(da)24(y's)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(mathematicians,)-350(b)-24(ecause)-361(the)-362(axiomatic)-337(approac)24(h)-337(to)-362(mathematics)-350(pro)24(v)24(ed)-349(so)]TJ
T*
[(fruitful)-266(in)-265(the)-254(rest)-254(of)-253(the)-253(t)24(w)24(en)25(tieth)-266(cen)25(tury)-242(that)-266(ev)25(ery)-242(studen)24(t)-254(of)-253(mathematics)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(is)-278(to)-24(da)24(y)-277(steep)-24(ed)-289(in)-277(this)-290(basic)-278(idea.)-276(But,)-277(at)-278(the)-289(da)24(wn)-277(of)-277(the)-289(t)24(w)24(en)24(tieth)-277(cen)24(tury)84(,)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(this)-362(idea)-361(seemed)-349(radical.)-350(The)-361(mathematician)-349(P)24(oincar)24<13>470(e)-325(understo)-25(o)-24(d)-349(Hilb)-24(ert's)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(p)-24(oin)24(t)-482(v)24(ery)-470(clearly)84(,)-469(as)-470(one)-482(can)-469(see)-482(in)-482(the)-494(follo)24(wing)-469(quotation)-471([78],)-469(but)-495(he)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(though)24(t)-326(it)-338(an)24(tithetical)-338(to)-325(the)-338(spirit)-338(of)-326(mathematics:)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 151.68 472.56 Tm
[(Th)26(us)-294(it)-294(will)-308(b)-27(e)-295(readily)-307(understo)-26(o)-27(d)-295(that)-280(in)-295(order)-293(to)-294(demonstrate)-305(a)-294(theorem,)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(it)-307(is)-308(not)-294(necessary)-306(or)-307(ev)27(en)-295(useful)-308(to)-293(kno)27(w)-308(what)-294(it)-308(means.)-307(W)80(e)-294(migh)27(t)-307(replace)]TJ
T*
[(geometry)-506(b)26(y)-481(the)-495(reasoning)-521(piano)-495(imagined)-522(b)26(y)-481(Stanley)-495(Jev)27(ons,)-509(or)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
30.9958 0 Td
0.187 Tc
[(::)13(:)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
1.69968 0 Td
0 Tc
(a)Tj
-32.69548 -1.23126 TD
[(mac)28(hine)-323(where)-334(w)26(e)-321(should)-322(put)-308(in)-322(axioms)-332(at)-320(one)-322(end)-309(and)-321(tak)28(e)-308(out)-321(theorems)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(at)-320(the)-295(other,)-320(lik)27(e)-308(that)-307(legendary)-307(mac)28(hine)-323(in)-308(Chicago)-334(where)-308(pigs)-321(go)-320(in)-308(aliv)27(e)]TJ
T*
[(and)-335(come)-361(out)-334(transformed)-359(in)27(to)-347(hams)-347(and)-336(sausages.)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 392.4 Tm
[(The)-445(date)-446(of)-446(that)-446(quotation)-446(is)-447(1908,)-421(almost)-434(a)-446(decade)-432(after)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
26.67967 0 Td
[(F)72(oundations)-470(of)]TJ
-26.67967 -1.19245 TD
[(Ge)49(ometry)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
4.2037 0 Td
[(.)-301(But)-301(the)-302(concept)-288(of)-301(\\pro)-25(of)-72(")-277(w)24(as)-277(still)-302(a)-289(bit)-302(unclear.)-289(The)-300(distinction)]TJ
-4.2037 -1.2045 TD
[(that)-326(w)24(as)-313(still)-326(lac)24(king)-313(w)24(as)-301(what)-326(w)25(e)-325(call)-313(to)-24(da)24(y)-313(the)-338(distinction)-326(b)-24(et)24(w)24(een)-312(a)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
31.20859 0 Td
(\frst-)Tj
-31.2086 -1.2045 TD
[(or)49(der)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
2.67399 0 Td
[(pro)-25(of)-397(and)-398(a)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
5.60093 0 Td
[(se)49(c)48(ond-or)49(der)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
5.84182 0 Td
[(pro)-25(of.)-397(The)-397(axioms)-386(of)-397(geometry)-386(in)-397(Hilb)-24(ert's)]TJ
-14.11674 -1.19245 TD
[(b)-24(o)-24(ok)-229(included)-240(the)-242(\\con)25(tin)24(uit)23(y)-229(axiom",)-216(whic)24(h)-241(sa)24(ys)-217(that)-242(if)-241(y)24(ou)-229(ha)24(v)25(e)-217(t)24(w)24(o)-229(subsets)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
0 -1.2045 TD
(A)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.24063 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
2.09583 0 Td
(B)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.28881 0 Td
[(of)-482(a)-482(line)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.32415 0 Td
(L)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.68657 0 Td
[(,)-470(and)-494(all)-469(the)-494(p)-25(oin)25(ts)-483(of)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
10.708 0 Td
(A)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.24063 0 Td
[(lie)-482(to)-482(the)-494(left)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 411 336.24 Tm
(11)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 424.32 332.64 Tm
[(of)-494(all)-482(the)]TJ
-29.06458 -1.2045 TD
[(p)-24(oin)24(ts)-423(of)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.31211 0 Td
(B)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.80701 0 Td
[(,)-422(then)-433(there)-410(exists)-423(a)-409(p)-25(oin)25(t)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
12.1775 0 Td
(P)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.2045 0 Td
(on)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.46949 0 Td
(L)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.09609 0 Td
[(to)-422(the)-422(righ)24(t)-410(of)-422(all)-409(p)-24(oin)24(ts)-423(of)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
-21.0667 -1.19245 TD
(A)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.18041 0 Td
[(not)-434(equal)-421(to)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
5.92614 0 Td
(P)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.78293 0 Td
[(,)-434(and)-421(to)-434(the)-434(left)-434(of)-434(all)-421(p)-24(oin)24(ts)-435(of)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
14.79126 0 Td
(B)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.24063 0 Td
[(not)-434(equal)-421(to)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
5.92614 0 Td
(P)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.78292 0 Td
[(.)-434(This)]TJ
-30.63043 -1.2045 TD
[(axiom)-409(is)-410(in)24(tended)-422(to)-410(sa)24(y)-410(that)-422(there)-410(are)-398(no)-421(\\holes")-397(in)-410(a)-422(line.)-409(F)84(or)-410(example,)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
(if)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.03587 0 Td
(L)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.14427 0 Td
[(is)-446(the)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
2.97512 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
[(-axis,)-446(and)-446(if)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
5.87796 0 Td
(A)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.2045 0 Td
[(is)-458(the)-458(set)-446(of)-458(p)-24(oin)24(ts)-459(with)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
11.44275 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 381.96 288.48 Tm
(2)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 391.32 284.88 Tm
(<)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.26473 0 Td
[(2,)-446(and)-457(if)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.3362 0 Td
(B)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.26472 0 Td
(is)Tj
-32.61786 -1.2045 TD
[(the)-446(set)-446(of)-446(p)-24(oin)24(ts)-446(with)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
10.26234 0 Td
0.47 Tc
(x>)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
2.28855 0 Td
0 Tc
[(0)-434(and)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
2.99921 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 295.32 276.48 Tm
(2)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 304.44 272.88 Tm
(>)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.24063 0 Td
[(2,)-446(then)-445(the)-458(axiom)-434(guaran)24(tees)-422(the)]TJ
-18.27226 -1.2045 TD
[(existence)-216(of)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
5.17935 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.84315 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
1.05996 0.83111 TD
(p)Tj
ET
q
5.04 0 0 -0.48 213.588 269.628 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 213.6 260.88 Tm
[(2.)-217(But)-229(the)-229(statemen)24(t)-218(of)-229(the)-229(axiom)-204(men)24(tions)-218(not)-229(only)-217(p)-24(oin)24(ts,)]TJ
-7.91356 -1.19245 TD
[(lines,)-289(and)-277(planes)-278(\(the)-289(ob)-61(jects)-277(of)-289(geometry\))-266(but)-289(also)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
22.39165 0 Td
(sets)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.89106 0 Td
[(of)-277(p)-24(oin)24(ts.)-290(Remem)25(b)-25(er)]TJ
-24.28272 -1.2045 TD
(that)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.20423 0 Td
[(F)72(oundations)-385(of)-410(Ge)49(ometry)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
11.50298 0 Td
[(w)24(as)-349(written)-375(b)-24(efore)-361(the)-373(disco)24(v)24(ery)-338(of)-361(Russell's)]TJ
-13.70721 -1.2045 TD
[(parado)24(x)-362(and)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
5.89 0 Td
(Principia)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
4.03507 0 Td
[(,)-422(and)-385(apparen)24(tly)-374(Hilb)-24(ert)-398(did)-398(not)-386(see)-385(the)-385(necessit)23(y)-385(of)]TJ
-9.92508 -1.19246 TD
[(careful)-373(atten)23(tion)-374(to)-385(the)-386(axioms)-362(for)-374(sets)-374(as)-374(w)25(ell)-374(as)-373(to)-386(the)-386(axioms)-361(for)-374(p)-25(oin)25(ts,)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(lines,)-386(and)-397(planes.)-386(A)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
9.1542 0 Td
[(se)49(c)48(ond-or)49(der)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
5.84182 0 Td
[(theory)-374(or)-386(axiomatization)-361(is)-398(one)-385(that,)-387(lik)24(e)]TJ
-14.99603 -1.19245 TD
[(Hilb)-24(ert's)-290(axiomatization)-253(of)-290(geometry)85(,)-265(uses)-278(v)60(ariables)-265(for)-266(sets)-278(of)-289(ob)-60(jects)-278(as)-265(w)24(ell)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(as)-229(v)60(ariables)-217(for)-230(ob)-60(jects.)-229(P)24(eano's)-204(axioms)-230(for)-229(n)24(um)24(b)-24(er)-229(theory)-218(are)-228(another)-218(famous)]TJ
ET
q
56.76 0 0 -0.48 134.748 162.108 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 155.16 Tm
(11)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 151.32 Tm
[(Hilb)-28(ert's)-386(axioms)-386(use)-375(a)-374(primitiv)28(e)-375(relation)-387(\\)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
19.1917 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.9636 0 Td
[(is)-388(b)-27(et)27(w)27(een)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
5.07228 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.91007 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
2.03427 0 Td
(z)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.52195 0 Td
[(".)-388(W)80(e)-374(can)-375(a)27(v)27(oid)]TJ
-28.69386 -1.21788 TD
[(the)-335(informal)-360(term)-346(\\lie)-361(to)-347(the)-335(left")-360(using)-348(this)-334(relation.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
11 0 obj
<<
/Length 10458
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 290.52 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(The)-335(Mec)27(hanization)-361(of)-361(Mathematics)-3183(9)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(example)-240(of)-253(a)-241(second-order)-218(axiomatization.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 315.72 669.84 Tm
(12)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 326.52 666.2401 Tm
[(Inciden)24(tally)84(,)-241(P)25(eano's)-229(publication)]TJ
-19.24791 -1.2045 TD
[([75])-313(w)24(as)-301(a)-313(pamphlet)-326(written)-326(in)-325(Latin,)-314(long)-313(after)-314(Latin)-314(had)-325(b)-24(een)-313(displaced)-325(as)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
[(the)-398(language)-384(of)-398(sc)24(holarship,)-375(so)-397(that)-399(the)-397(publication)-398(has)-398(b)-24(een)-397(view)25(ed)-398(as)-385(an)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(\\act)-253(of)-277(roman)24(ticism".)-242(P)25(eano,)-253(originally)-241(a)-265(go)-24(o)-24(d)-253(teac)25(her,)-254(b)-24(ecame)-264(an)-265(unp)-24(opular)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(teac)24(her)-385(b)-24(ecause)-385(he)-385(insisted)-399(on)-398(using)-386(formal)-386(notation)-386(in)-397(elemen)25(tary)-375(classes;)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(nev)24(ertheless,)-410(his)-422(w)24(ork)-410(ev)25(en)24(tually)-422(b)-24(ecame)-421(in\ruen)24(tial,)-422(and)-421(it)-434(is)-422(his)-423(notation)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(that)-338(is)-326(used)-337(to)-25(da)24(y)-325(in)-337(logic,)-325(not)-326(F)84(rege's.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.21654 TD
[(In)-326(b)-24(oth)-325(these)-326(t)24(w)24(o)-325(famous)-314(examples,)-325(the)-325(theories)-314(ac)24(hiev)25(e)-313(their)-326(aim:)-325(They)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(uniquely)-397(de\fne)-397(the)-410(structures)-388(they)-397(are)-386(trying)-398(to)-398(axiomatize.)-385(Ev)24(ery)-373(system)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(of)-289(ob)-60(jects)-290(satisfying)-278(Hilb)-24(ert's)-302(axioms)-278(for)-289(plane)-289(geometry)-265(is)-290(isomorphic)-278(to)-301(the)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(Euclidean)-385(plane.)-385(Ev)25(en)-385(if)-398(w)24(e)-385(b)-24(egin)-385(b)24(y)-385(assuming)-387(that)-386(the)-398(system)-386(consists)-387(of)]TJ
T*
[(tables,)-302(c)25(hairs,)-302(and)-302(b)-24(eer)-301(m)24(ugs,)-301(it)-314(turns)-315(out)-301(to)-314(b)-24(e)-313(isomorphic)-290(to)-313(the)-313(Euclidean)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(plane.)-445(Ev)24(ery)-434(system)-434(of)-458(ob)-60(jects)-434(satisfying)-447(P)24(eano's)-422(axioms)-434(is)-446(isomorphic)-434(to)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(the)-434(natural)-422(n)24(um)24(b)-24(ers.)-423(But)-434(the)-433(second-order)-411(nature)-422(of)-433(these)-434(axiom)-410(systems)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(is)-338(essen)24(tial)-326(to)-337(this)-339(prop)-24(ert)23(y)85(.)-338(The)-336(tec)24(hnical)-325(term)-338(for)-338(this)-338(prop)-25(ert)24(y)-325(is)-338(that)-350(the)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(theory)-253(is)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
4.01098 0 Td
[(c)48(ate)49(goric)49(al)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
4.51688 0 Td
[(.)-277(These)-253(are)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
4.97458 0 Td
[(se)49(c)48(ond-or)49(der)-300(c)48(ate)48(goric)50(al)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
10.52733 0 Td
[(theories.)-254(The)-264(concept)]TJ
-24.02977 -1.2045 TD
[(of)-385(second-order)-363(theory)-373(v)24(ersus)-375(\frst-order)-364(theory)-386(is)-386(not)-385(easy)-374(to)-386(grasp,)-374(but)-398(is)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(v)24(ery)-361(imp)-25(ortan)24(t)-374(in)-386(understanding)-362(the)-386(theoretical)-362(basis)-374(of)-373(the)-386(mec)25(hanization)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(of)-337(mathematics,)-326(so)-326(here)-325(go)-24(es:)]TJ
1.50563 -1.21654 TD
[(If)-410(w)24(e)-397(require)-398(a)-397(\frst-order)-388(v)24(ersion)-386(of)-409(the)-410(con)24(tin)24(uit)24(y)-398(axiom,)-397(then)-410(instead)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.19245 TD
[(of)-422(sa)24(ying)-409(\\for)-422(all)-422(sets)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
10.04553 0 Td
(A)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.18041 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
2.04765 0 Td
0.205 Tc
[(B:)37(:)36(:)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
2.13197 0 Td
0 Tc
[(",)-421(the)-434(axiom)-422(will)-433(b)-24(ecome)-421(man)24(y)-421(axioms,)]TJ
-15.40555 -1.2045 TD
(where)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
2.8908 0 Td
(A)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.08405 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.93924 0 Td
(B)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.14428 0 Td
[(are)-325(replaced)-325(b)24(y)-325(man)24(y)-325(di\013eren)24(t)-338(\frst-order)-304(form)24(ulas.)-326(In)-325(other)]TJ
-7.05837 -1.2045 TD
[(w)24(ords,)-458(instead)-471(of)-469(b)-25(eing)-469(able)-457(to)-470(state)-471(the)-482(axiom)-458(for)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
23.81296 0 Td
[(al)-48(l)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.54176 0 Td
[(sets)-471(of)-470(p)-24(oin)24(ts,)-470(w)24(e)]TJ
-25.35472 -1.19246 TD
[(will)-409(ha)24(v)24(e)-385(to)-410(settle)-398(for)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
9.97326 0 Td
[(algebr)50(aic)48(al)-48(ly)-469(de\fnable)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.92508 0 Td
[(sets)-399(of)-397(p)-24(oin)24(ts.)-411(W)85(e)-409(will)-410(still)-398(b)-24(e)]TJ
-19.89834 -1.2045 TD
[(able)-349(to)-362(de\fne)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
6.29953 0.83111 TD
(p)Tj
ET
q
5.04 0 0 -0.48 205.788 387.708 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 205.8 378.96 Tm
[(2,)-349(but)-374(w)24(e)-349(will)-361(not)-362(b)-24(e)-361(able)-349(to)-362(de\fne)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
15.8994 0 Td
<19>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
[(,)-361(b)-25(ecause)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.36029 0 Td
<19>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.9636 0 Td
[(cannot)-349(b)-24(e)]TJ
-28.95618 -1.2045 TD
[(de\fned)-277(b)24(y)-277(algebraic)-252(conditions.)-278(Another)-277(w)24(a)24(y)-265(of)-277(lo)-24(oking)-265(at)-277(this)-278(situation)-278(is)-278(to)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(consider)-277(systems)-291(of)-301(\\p)-24(oin)24(ts")-278(that)-302(satisfy)-291(the)-301(axioms.)-277(Suc)24(h)-301(systems)-291(are)-277(called)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(\\mo)-24(dels".)-446(In)-458(the)-470(case)-445(at)-458(hand,)-458(w)24(e)-445(ha)24(v)24(e)-445(the)-458(\\real)-446(plane")-445(consisting)-447(of)-457(all)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(p)-24(oin)24(ts)-338(\()]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
3.39669 0 Td
[(x;)-169(y)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.54176 0 Td
[(\),)-338(and)-325(on)-337(the)-338(other)-325(hand,)-326(w)25(e)-325(ha)24(v)24(e)-325(the)-337(smaller)-314(\\plane")-325(consisting)]TJ
-4.93845 -1.2045 TD
[(only)-373(of)-386(the)-385(n)24(um)23(b)-24(ers)-374(\()]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
9.67213 0 Td
[(x;)-169(y)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.54176 0 Td
[(\))-386(where)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
3.70986 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.95155 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.98742 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.91542 0 Td
[(are)-361(solutions)-375(of)-386(some)-373(p)-24(olynomial)]TJ
-18.77815 -1.2045 TD
[(equation)-398(with)-421(in)24(teger)-398(co)-24(e\016cien)25(ts.)-398(Both)-410(these)-398(satisfy)-411(the)-409(\frst-order)-388(axioms)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(of)-337(geometry)84(,)-325(but)-338(the)-350(smaller)-314(plane)-337(lac)25(ks)-326(the)-337(p)-24(oin)24(t)-338(\()]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
22.57233 0 Td
0.036 Tc
<193B>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.04792 0 Td
0 Tc
[(0\))-350(and)-325(hence)-336(do)-24(es)-338(not)]TJ
-23.62024 -1.2045 TD
[(satisfy)-327(the)-337(second-order)-302(con)25(tin)23(uit)24(y)-338(axiom.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.21654 TD
[(Similarly)84(,)-338(in)-361(arithmetic,)-350(if)-362(w)25(e)-349(do)-338(not)-361(use)-350(v)60(ariables)-337(for)-338(sets)-351(in)-361(stating)-351(the)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(induction)-446(axiom,)-434(w)25(e)-433(will)-446(b)-24(e)-445(able)-446(only)-433(to)-446(\\appro)23(ximate")-409(the)-446(axiom)-433(b)24(y)-434(in-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(cluding)-373(its)-363(sp)-24(eci\fc)-373(instances,)-362(where)-361(the)-373(inductiv)23(e)-361(set)-374(is)-362(de\fned)-373(in)-373(the)-374(\fxed)]TJ
ET
q
56.76 0 0 -0.48 134.748 238.788 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 231.84 Tm
(12)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 228.12 Tm
[(These)-375(famous)-373(axioms)-386(c)27(haracterize)-373(the)-362(natural)-374(n)27(um)26(b)-27(ers)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
25.32126 0 Td
(N)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.29818 0 Td
[(as)-374(follo)28(ws:)-401(0)-375(is)-374(in)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
8.12368 0 Td
(N)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.92345 0 Td
(,)Tj
-35.66658 -1.23127 TD
[(and)-335(if)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
2.91757 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.92345 0 Td
[(is)-348(in)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
2.22163 0 Td
(N)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.25803 0 Td
[(then)-335(the)-321(successor)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
8.5118 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 291.24 220.92 Tm
(+)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 300.24 217.08 Tm
(of)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.16435 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.91007 0 Td
[(is)-348(in)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
2.22163 0 Td
(N)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.92345 0 Td
[(,)-348(and)-335(0)-334(is)-348(not)-334(the)-335(successor)-346(of)]TJ
-22.6446 -1.21788 TD
[(an)27(y)-348(n)26(um)27(b)-27(er,)-361(and)-362(if)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
8.9936 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 229.92 210 Tm
(+)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 238.8 206.16 Tm
(=)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.11082 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 253.68 210 Tm
(+)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 263.04 206.16 Tm
(then)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
2.35547 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.89668 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.1242 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.54872 0 Td
[(.)-361(\(The)-362(successor)-386(of)-374(0)-361(is)-374(1,)-375(the)-348(successor)]TJ
-18.20133 -1.21788 TD
[(of)-361(1)-347(is)-348(2,)-361(etc.\))-347(T)80(o)-347(these)-348(axioms)-359(P)27(eano)-348(added)-349(the)-334(axiom)-360(of)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
26.27148 0 Td
(induction)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
4.18898 0 Td
0.361 Tc
[(:i)361(f)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
1.59262 0 Td
0 Tc
(X)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.27142 0 Td
[(is)-348(an)27(y)]TJ
-33.32449 -1.23127 TD
[(set)-441(satisfying)-452(these)-428(prop)-27(erties)-454(with)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
16.44812 0 Td
(X)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.3651 0 Td
[(instead)-441(of)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
4.8983 0 Td
(N)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.92345 0 Td
[(,)-455(then)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
3.15847 0 Td
(N)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.3651 0 Td
[(is)-455(a)-427(subset)-442(of)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
6.5846 0 Td
(X)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.92345 0 Td
(.)Tj
-35.66658 -1.21788 TD
[(The)-456(induction)-442(axiom)-454(is)-454(equiv)53(alen)27(t)-441(to)-455(the)-441(statemen)28(t)-441(that)-454(ev)27(ery)-441(non-empt)27(y)-428(set)]TJ
T*
[(of)-374(natural)-374(n)26(um)27(b)-27(ers)-361(con)27(tains)-374(a)-374(least)-373(elemen)26(t,)-374(and)-362(is)-374(also)-387(equiv)53(alen)27(t)-361(to)-360(the)-362(usual)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(form)28(ulation)-374(of)-374(mathematical)-372(induction:)-363(for)-360(sets)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
21.69438 0 Td
(X)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.2848 0 Td
[(of)-361(natural)-360(n)26(um)27(b)-27(ers,)-361(if)-361(0)-361(is)-374(in)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
-22.97918 -1.21788 TD
(X)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.92345 0 Td
[(,)-348(and)-335(if)-361(whenev)26(er)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
8.08353 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.9636 0 Td
[(is)-348(in)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
2.23502 0 Td
(X)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.27142 0 Td
[(so)-347(is)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
2.28855 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 290.88 144.24 Tm
(+)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 297 140.4 Tm
[(,)-348(then)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
2.9711 0 Td
(X)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.27142 0 Td
[(con)27(tains)-347(all)-361(natural)-348(n)27(um)27(b)-28(ers.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
12 0 obj
<<
/Length 7477
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 134.76 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(10)-2662(Mic)26(hael)-361(Beeson)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(language)-349(of)-373(arithmetic.)-374(There)-361(are)-362(theorems)-362(that)-374(sa)24(y)-362(a)-361(certain)-362(equation)-361(has)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(no)-325(solution)-314(in)-326(in)24(tegers,)-313(whose)-313(pro)-25(ofs)-326(require)-301(pro)23(ving)-313(a)-313(v)24(ery)-313(complicated)-325(for-)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
[(m)24(ula)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
2.5174 0 Td
(P)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.16837 0 Td
[(b)24(y)-385(induction,)-386(as)-374(a)-373(lemma,)-386(where)-373(the)-397(form)23(ula)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
20.35605 0 Td
(P)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.16837 0 Td
[(is)-386(to)-24(o)-374(complicated)]TJ
-25.21018 -1.19245 TD
[(to)-470(ev)24(en)-469(b)-24(e)-470(stated)-482(in)-470(the)-482(language)-445(of)-470(arithmetic{p)-25(erhaps)-458(it)-483(requires)-458(more)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(adv)60(anced)-276(mathematical)-265(concepts.)-277(Just)-278(as)-266(there)-277(exist)-278(di\013eren)24(t)-277(mo)-24(dels)-278(of)-277(\frst-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(order)-302(geometry)-313(\(in)-326(whic)25(h)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
11.35843 0 Td
<19>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.92746 0 Td
[(do)-24(es)-313(or)-314(do)-24(es)-313(not)-326(exist\),)-326(there)-326(also)-301(exist)-326(di\013eren)24(t)]TJ
-12.2859 -1.2045 TD
[(mo)-24(dels)-410(of)-397(\frst-order)-388(n)24(um)24(b)-24(er)-398(theory)84(,)-398(some)-397(of)-398(whic)25(h)-410(are)-397(\\non-standard",)-375(in)]TJ
T*
[(that)-374(the)-374(\\n)24(um)24(b)-24(ers")-350(of)-361(the)-374(mo)-24(del)-373(are)-361(not)-362(isomorphic)-362(to)-362(the)-373(actual)-362(in)24(tegers.)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(These)-433(non-standard)-423(mo)-25(dels)-445(are)-422(more)-434(di\016cult)-458(to)-434(visualize)-433(and)-434(understand)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(than)-338(a)-325(plane)-337(that)-338(\\simply")-326(omits)-326(n)24(um)24(b)-24(ers)-326(with)-349(complicated)-325(de\fnitions,)-338(b)-24(e-)]TJ
T*
[(cause)-349(these)-362(mo)-24(dels)-349(con)24(tain)-350(\\n)24(um)24(b)-24(ers")-338(that)-362(are)-349(not)-362(really)-337(n)24(um)24(b)-24(ers,)-362(but)-362(are)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
(\\extra".)Tj
1.50563 -1.50563 TD
[(Using)-277(mo)-24(dern)-290(language,)-276(w)24(e)-277(sa)24(y)-277(that)-302(a)-277(\frst-order)-267(theory)84(,)-289(ev)24(en)-289(one)-276(formed)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(b)24(y)-409(restricting)-412(a)-409(second-order)-386(categorical)-397(theory)-410(to)-410(its)-423(\frst-order)-388(instances,)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(generally)-337(has)-338(man)24(y)-349(mo)-24(dels,)-350(not)-349(just)-363(one.)-349(This)-349(situation)-351(w)24(as)-337(not)-350(clearly)-337(un-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(dersto)-25(o)-24(d)-434(in)-434(the)-433(\frst)-435(t)23(w)25(o)-422(decades)-433(of)-434(the)-433(t)23(w)25(en)24(tieth)-434(cen)24(tury)84(,)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 396.84 487.44 Tm
(13)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 409.56 483.84 Tm
[(but)-446(b)24(y)-434(1928,)]TJ
-27.58305 -1.19246 TD
[(when)-409(Hilb)-24(ert)-398(and)-410(Ac)25(k)24(ermann)-386(published)-398(their)-410(monograph)-374(on)-397(mathematical)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(logic)-289([51],)-289(it)-313(had)-301(b)-25(ecome)-300(clear)-288(at)-302(least)-290(to)-301(those)-302(authors.)-290(Clarit)23(y)-289(on)-289(this)-314(p)-24(oin)24(t)]TJ
T*
[(led)-421(directly)-422(to)-422(the)-434(form)23(ulation)-409(of)-422(the)-434(En)25(tsc)23(heidungsproblem:)-398(Since)-433(a)-410(\frst-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(order)-470(theory)-483(generally)-481(has)-482(man)24(y)-482(mo)-24(dels,)-482(can)-494(w)25(e)-482(decide)-493(\(giv)24(en)-482(a)-481(theory\))]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(whic)25(h)-350(form)24(ulas)-338(are)-349(true)-350(in)-350(all)-349(the)-362(mo)-24(dels?)-361(It)-350(also)-338(led)-361(directly)-349(to)-350(the)-362(form)24(u-)]TJ
T*
[(lation)-350(of)-361(the)-362(completeness)-349(problem:)-350(Are)-349(the)-362(form)24(ulas)-338(true)-362(in)-361(all)-350(the)-361(mo)-24(dels)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(exactly)-421(those)-434(that)-435(ha)24(v)24(e)-409(pro)-24(ofs)-422(from)-435(the)-433(axioms?)-422(The)-433(former)-423(problem)-421(w)24(as)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(solv)24(ed)-361(b)24(y)-374(T)85(uring)-374(and)-373(Ch)24(urc)24(h,)-362(the)-385(latter)-375(b)24(y)-373<477F>506(odel,)-373(b)-24(oth)-374(within)-386(a)-373(few)-385(y)24(ears)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(of)-337(the)-350(publication)-337(of)-338(Hilb)-24(ert-Ac)24(k)24(ermann.)-325(These)-325(dev)24(elopmen)25(ts)-338(laid)-338(the)-337(foun-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(dations)-338(of)-349(mo)-25(dern)-337(mathematical)-350(logic,)-336(whic)24(h)-337(in)-350(turn)-350(furnished)-350(the)-350(to)-24(ols)-338(for)]TJ
T*
[(the)-337(mec)24(hanization)-325(of)-325(mathematics.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.49358 TD
[(The)-325(distinction)-350(b)-24(et)24(w)24(een)-337(second-order)-301(and)-338(\frst-order)-315(confuses)-326(p)-24(eople)-337(b)-24(e-)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(cause)-289(it)-301(has)-278(t)24(w)24(o)-289(asp)-24(ects:)-290(syn)24(tax)-290(and)-289(seman)24(tics.)-290(A)-288(theory)-290(whic)25(h)-290(has)-289(v)60(ariables)]TJ
T*
[(for)-446(ob)-60(jects)-434(and)-446(for)-446(sets)-435(of)-458(those)-434(ob)-60(jects)-446(\(for)-447(example)-433(in)24(tegers)-434(and)-446(sets)-446(of)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(in)24(tegers\))-326(is)-338(syn)23(tactically)-325(second-order.)-314(W)85(e)-349(can)-337(write)-338(do)24(wn)-325(mathematical)-337(in-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(duction)-482(using)-482(the)-494(set)-483(v)60(ariables.)-470(But)-494(then,)-494(w)24(e)-481(can)-469(still)-495(consider)-470(this)-495(as)-470(a)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(\frst-order)-267(theory)83(,)-289(in)-301(whic)25(h)-289(case)-289(w)24(e)-289(w)25(ould)-289(allo)24(w)-277(mo)-24(dels)-301(in)-289(whic)24(h)-301(the)-289(set)-302(v)60(ari-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(ables)-325(range)-314(o)25(v)24(er)-314(a)-325(suitable)-338(coun)25(table)-326(collection)-324(of)-325(sets)-339(of)-325(in)24(tegers,)-326(and)-325(there)]TJ
T*
[(w)24(ould)-361(also)-362(b)-24(e)-373(mo)-24(dels)-374(with)-373(non-standard)-351(in)24(tegers)-362(in)-374(whic)25(h)-362(the)-373(set)-374(v)60(ariables)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(range)-289(o)24(v)24(er)-289(a)-301(collection)-301(of)-313(\\subsets)-302(of)-314(in)24(tegers")-289(of)-301(the)-314(mo)-24(del.)-313(Or,)-301(w)24(e)-301(can)-313(con-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(sider)-302(it)-326(as)-301(a)-301(second-order)-290(theory)84(,)-301(in)-326(whic)25(h)-301(case)-301(w)24(e)-312(do)-314(not)-313(allo)24(w)-289(suc)24(h)-313(mo)-24(dels,)]TJ
T*
[(but)-314(only)-301(allo)24(w)-288(mo)-24(dels)-302(in)-301(whic)25(h)-302(the)-313(set)-302(v)61(ariables)-290(range)-289(o)24(v)24(er)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
25.98106 0 Td
[(al)-48(l)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.37313 0 Td
[(subsets)-303(of)-313(the)]TJ
-27.35419 -1.19245 TD
[(in)24(tegers)-290(of)-301(the)-313(mo)-24(del.)-301(Whether)-314(it)-301(is)-302(second-order)-278(or)-289(\frst-order)-291(is)-302(determined)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(b)24(y)-349(what)-362(w)25(e)-349(allo)24(w)-349(as)-350(a)-349(\\mo)-24(del")-349(of)-349(the)-362(theory)84(,)-349(not)-362(b)24(y)-349(the)-362(language)-336(in)-362(whic)25(h)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(w)24(e)-324(express)-327(the)-337(theory)84(.)]TJ
ET
q
56.76 0 0 -0.48 134.748 162.108 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 155.16 Tm
(13)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 151.32 Tm
[(See)-415(for)-428(example)-414([67],)-441(P)27(art)-427(I)-26(I)-27(I)-401(for)-441(more)-413(details)-428(on)-428(the)-401(views)-428(of)-428(Hilb)-27(ert)-428(and)-415(his)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(con)27(temp)-27(oraries.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
13 0 obj
<<
/Length 7993
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 290.52 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(The)-335(Mec)27(hanization)-361(of)-361(Mathematics)-2674(11)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
11.95517 0 0 11.95517 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(4)-1124(T)90(uring's)-572(negativ)29(e)-582(solution)-572(of)-573(the)]TJ
1.6863 -1.17439 TD
[(En)30(tsc)31(heidungsproblem)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 627.48 Tm
[(The)-301(dev)25(elopmen)24(ts)-278(describ)-24(ed)-301(ab)-24(o)24(v)24(e)-276(still)-303(left)-301(the)-301(En)24(tsc)24(heidungsproblem)-278(some-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(what)-301(imprecise,)-302(in)-301(that)-314(the)-301(concept)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
15.71872 0 Td
(algorithm)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
4.43256 0 Td
[(men)24(tioned)-301(in)-313(the)-302(problem)-301(had)]TJ
-20.15129 -1.19245 TD
[(not)-458(b)-24(een)-469(de\fned.)-458(Apparen)24(tly)-446(Hilb)-24(ert)-470(hop)-24(ed)-458(for)-458(a)-446(p)-24(ositiv)24(e)-458(solution)-458(of)-458(the)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(problem,)-446(in)-458(whic)25(h)-458(case)-445(it)-459(w)25(ould)-446(not)-458(ha)24(v)24(e)-433(b)-24(een)-469(necessary)-422(to)-458(de\fne)-458(\\algo-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(rithm",)-435(as)-434(the)-433(solution)-435(w)24(ould)-433(exhibit)-434(a)-434(sp)-24(eci\fc)-445(algorithm.)-423(But)-433(a)-434(negativ)24(e)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(solution)-338(w)24(ould)-337(ha)24(v)24(e)-325(to)-337(pro)23(v)24(e)-324(that)-339(no)-337(algorithm)-326(could)-349(do)-337(the)-338(job,)-349(and)-337(hence)]TJ
T*
[(it)-338(w)25(ould)-326(b)-24(e)-337(necessary)-313(to)-338(ha)24(v)24(e)-312(a)-326(de\fnition)-337(of)-337(\\algorithm".)]TJ
1.50563 -1.21654 TD
[(Alan)-265(T)85(uring)-278((1912-1954),)-229(answ)24(ered)-265(the)-277(question)-266(\\What)-277(is)-277(an)-265(algorithm?")]TJ
-1.50563 -1.19245 TD
[(in)-361(1936)-349([100])-337(b)24(y)-362(de\fning)-361(T)85(uring)-362(mac)24(hines.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 321.6 535.32 Tm
(14)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 333.6 531.72 Tm
[(He)-361(used)-361(his)-362(de\fnition)-374(to)-362(sho)24(w)]TJ
-19.95856 -1.2045 TD
[(that)-326(there)-314(exist)-313(problems)-314(that)-314(cannot)-314(b)-24(e)-325(solv)24(ed)-301(b)24(y)-313(an)24(y)-301(algorithm.)-314(The)-312(most)]TJ
T*
[(w)24(ell-kno)25(wn)-386(of)-397(these)-398(is)-398(the)-410(halting)-398(problem{there)-386(exists)-398(no)-398(T)85(uring)-386(mac)24(hine)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(that)-447(tak)24(es)-421(as)-434(inputs)-447(a)-446(T)85(uring)-434(mac)24(hine)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
17.77842 0 Td
(M)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.51767 0 Td
[(and)-434(an)-445(input)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
6.32363 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.01178 0 Td
[(for)-434(M,)-446(and)-434(de-)]TJ
-26.63149 -1.2045 TD
[(termines)-398(correctly)-386(whether)-398(M)-398(halts)-398(on)-398(input)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
20.27173 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
[(.)-410(Indeed,)-397(w)24(e)-397(don't)-398(need)-409(t)24(w)24(o)]TJ
-20.83785 -1.2045 TD
[(v)60(ariables)-326(here:)-349(no)-337(T)85(uring)-338(mac)24(hine)-337(can)-337(determine)-349(correctly)-326(whether)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
29.75115 0 Td
(M)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.42131 0 Td
(halts)Tj
-31.17246 -1.19245 TD
[(at)-338(input)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
3.89053 0 Td
(M)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.08405 0 Td
(.)Tj
-3.46896 -1.21654 TD
[(In)-302(that)-302(same)-289(remark)60(able)-277(1936)-276(pap)-25(er)-289([100],)-289(T)85(uring)-290(applied)-301(his)-301(new)-289(T)85(uring)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(mac)24(hines)-325(to)-326(giv)25(e)-313(a)-325(negativ)24(e)-313(solution)-326(to)-326(the)-337(En)24(tsc)24(heidungsproblem.)-302(His)-338(solu-)]TJ
T*
[(tion)-338(mak)24(es)-337(use)-337(of)-338(the)-349(result)-339(just)-350(men)24(tioned,)-337(that)-350(the)-350(halting)-338(problem)-337(is)-338(not)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(solv)60(able)-289(b)24(y)-301(a)-301(T)85(uring)-290(mac)24(hine.)-301(W)85(e)-301(shall)-302(describ)-24(e)-289(his)-302(solution)-302(to)-301(the)-301(En)24(tsc)24(hei-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(dungsproblem)-447(no)25(w,)-446(but)-458(not)-458(the)-446(solution)-459(to)-446(the)-458(halting)-446(problem,)-446(whic)25(h)-458(is)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(co)25(v)24(ered)-325(in)-338(an)24(y)-337(mo)-24(dern)-338(textb)-24(o)-24(ok)-337(on)-350(the)-337(theory)-338(of)-337(computation.)-350(\(The)-337(reader)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(who)-289(do)-24(es)-277(not)-289(already)-265(kno)24(w)-277(what)-289(a)-289(T)84(uring)-277(mac)24(hine)-289(is)-277(should)-290(skip)-290(to)-277(the)-301(next)]TJ
T*
[(section.\))-338(The)-325(solution)-326(has)-325(three)-338(steps:)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
1.69834 -2.27651 TD
<0F>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.84315 0 Td
[(W)84(rite)-349(do)24(wn)-325(axioms)-326(A)-349(to)-338(describ)-24(e)-337(the)-350(computations)-326(of)-349(T)84(uring)-325(ma-)]TJ
-0.84315 -1.2045 TD
[(c)24(hines.)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
0 -1.21655 TD
<0F>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.95156 0 Td
[(T)85(uring)-459(mac)25(hine)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
7.41972 0 Td
(M)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.52972 0 Td
[(halts)-459(at)-446(input)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
6.69702 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.03587 0 Td
[(if)-458(and)-446(only)-457(if)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
6.45612 0 Td
(A)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.2045 0 Td
[(pro)24(v)24(es)-422(the)]TJ
-25.2945 -1.2045 TD
[(theorem)-326(\\)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.39643 0 Td
(M)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.40927 0 Td
[(halts)-326(at)-338(input)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
6.33567 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
(".)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
-12.70747 -1.21654 TD
<0F>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.91542 0 Td
[(If)-410(w)24(e)-409(had)-409(an)-410(algorithm)-398(to)-410(determine)-410(the)-422(consequences)-396(of)-410(axioms)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
-0.91542 -1.19245 TD
(A)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.74679 0 Td
[(,)-361(it)-362(w)24(ould)-349(solv)24(e)-349(the)-350(halting)-362(problem,)-349(con)24(tradiction.)-338(Hence)-360(no)-350(suc)24(h)]TJ
-0.74679 -1.2045 TD
[(algorithm)-326(exists.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 224.16 272.88 Tm
(15)Tj
ET
q
56.76 0 0 -0.48 134.748 260.748 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 253.8 Tm
(14)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 249.96 Tm
[(T)80(uring)-375(\\mac)28(hines")-401(are)-387(conceptual)-375(ob)-54(jects)-400(rather)-374(than)-374(ph)25(ysical)-387(mac)28(hines.)-389(They)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
0 -1.21788 TD
[(c)53(ould)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
2.71682 0 Td
[(b)-27(e)-429(built,)-442(but)-429(in)-428(practice)-441(the)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
13.42348 0 Td
[(ide)53(a)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
2.22163 0 Td
[(of)-441(these)-441(mac)27(hines)-442(is)-441(used,)-442(rather)-427(than)]TJ
-18.36193 -1.21788 TD
[(ph)26(ysical)-414(examples.)-427(Suc)26(h)-389(a)-428(mac)28(hine)-416(can)-415(b)-27(e)-402(sp)-27(eci\fed)-416(b)27(y)-402(a)-414(\fnite)-416(list)-427(of)-414(its)-427(parts)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[((\\states"))-263(and)-255(their)-254(connections)-267((\\instructions").)-265(They)-255(w)27(ork)-253(on)-254(\\inputs")-254(that)-254(are)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(represen)27(ted)-401(b)26(y)-401(sym)28(b)-27(ols)-414(on)-415(an)-415(input)-403(device,)-415(usually)-415(called)-415(a)-428(\\tap)-26(e".)-428(Whenev)26(er)]TJ
T*
[(the)-335(tap)-26(e)-335(is)-347(ab)-27(out)-347(to)-334(b)-27(e)-335(used)-335(up,)-336(an)-348(attendan)28(t)-321(will)-362(attac)29(h)-335(more,)-360(so)-347(conceptually)80(,)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(the)-402(tap)-26(e)-415(is)-428(in\fnite,)-416(y)27(et)-401(the)-414(mac)27(hine)-416(could)-415(still)-428(b)-27(e)-415(built.)-415(T)80(uring's)-415(k)27(ey)-401(idea)-428(w)26(as)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(that)-293(the)-295(descriptions)-320(of)-308(the)-294(mac)28(hines)-309(can)-308(b)-27(e)-308(giv)28(en)-295(b)26(y)-294(sym)28(b)-27(ols,)-307(and)-295(hence)-309(T)80(uring)]TJ
T*
[(mac)28(hines)-349(can)-348(accept)-348(\(descriptions)-346(of)-80(\))-347(T)80(uring)-348(mac)27(hines)-348(as)-347(inputs.)]TJ
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 155.16 Tm
(15)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 151.32 Tm
[(In)-415(more)-440(detail)-442(the)-415(argumen)28(t)-441(is)-428(this:)-441(Supp)-29(ose)-414(some)-440(T)80(uring)-442(mac)28(hine)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
31.33038 0 Td
(K)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.3651 0 Td
(accepts)Tj
-32.69548 -1.21788 TD
[(inputs)-429(describing)-455(axiom)-440(sets)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
13.46363 0 Td
(S)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.1242 0 Td
[(and)-429(p)-27(oten)27(tial)-454(theorems)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
11.02787 0 Td
(B)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.82977 0 Td
[(,)-442(and)-442(outputs)-428(1)-441(or)-441(0)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
14 0 obj
<<
/Length 10141
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 134.76 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(12)-2662(Mic)26(hael)-361(Beeson)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 149.76 666.2401 Tm
[(The)-457(\\computations")-447(referred)-446(to)-458(in)-458(the)-470(\frst)-459(step)-458(can)-458(b)-24(e)-457(though)24(t)-459(of)-469(as)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(t)24(w)24(o-dimensional)-290(tables.)-313(Eac)25(h)-290(ro)24(w)-301(of)-313(the)-313(table)-313(corresp)-25(onds)-290(to)-301(the)-326(tap)-24(e)-313(of)-313(the)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
[(T)85(uring)-278(mac)24(hine)-288(at)-278(a)-289(giv)24(en)-264(stage)-278(in)-289(its)-290(computation.)-290(The)-276(next)-289(ro)23(w)-276(is)-290(the)-289(next)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(stage,)-434(after)-434(one)-433(\\mo)24(v)24(e")-409(of)-434(the)-446(mac)25(hine.)-434(There)-433(is)-434(an)-434(extra)-434(mark)-422(\(y)24(ou)-434(can)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(think)-338(of)-325(a)-313(red)-326(color\))-313(in)-325(the)-338(cell)-325(where)-324(the)-326(T)85(uring)-326(mac)25(hine)-313(head)-325(is)-326(lo)-24(cated)-325(at)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(that)-326(stage.)-302(When)-324(w)24(e)-325(refer)-301(to)-326(cell)-313(\()]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
14.99602 0 Td
[(i;)-169(j)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.26473 0 Td
[(\))-326(w)25(e)-313(mean)-313(the)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
6.52839 0 Td
(j)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.46976 0 Td
[(-th)-326(cell)-313(in)-325(the)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
6.22726 0 Td
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.34931 0 Td
[(-th)-314(ro)24(w.)]TJ
-29.83546 -1.2045 TD
[(The)-301(axioms)-277(sa)24(y)-289(that)-302(suc)24(h)-290(a)-289(table)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
14.65876 0 Td
(T)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.02382 0 Td
[(is)-290(a)-301(computation)-289(b)24(y)-289(mac)24(hine)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
12.80383 0 Td
(M)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.37313 0 Td
[(if)-301(for)-290(all)]TJ
-29.85955 -1.2045 TD
[(the)-277(en)24(tries)-254(in)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
5.89 0 Td
(T)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.73475 0 Td
[(,)-265(the)-265(con)24(ten)24(ts)-266(of)-265(cell)-264(\()]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
9.25056 0 Td
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.44567 0 Td
0.096 Tc
(+1)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.38518 0 Td
0.169 Tc
(;j)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.91542 0 Td
0 Tc
[(\))-253(are)-253(related)-254(to)-265(the)-277(con)24(ten)24(ts)-254(of)-277(the)]TJ
-18.62157 -1.19245 TD
[(three)-326(cells)-337(\()]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
5.11912 0 Td
[(i;)-169(j)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
1.48153 0 Td
<00>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
[(1\),)-326(\()]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
1.87902 0 Td
[(i;)-169(j)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.26472 0 Td
[(\),)-338(and)-337(\()]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
3.33646 0 Td
[(i;)-169(j)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.48153 0 Td
[(+)-217(1\))-325(according)-313(to)-326(the)-337(program)-314(of)-325(T)84(uring)]TJ
-15.56214 -1.2045 TD
[(mac)24(hine)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
3.90258 0 Td
(M)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.08405 0 Td
[(.)-313(Although)-326(this)-326(uses)-314(natural)-314(n)24(um)24(b)-24(ers)-314(\()]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
16.94732 0 Td
[(i;)-169(j)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.26472 0 Td
[(\))-314(to)-325(refer)-302(to)-325(the)-326(cells)-313(of)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
-23.19867 -1.2045 TD
(T)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.73474 0 Td
[(,)-373(only)-386(a)-373(few)-385(basic)-374(and)-385(easily)-374(axiomatizable)-373(prop)-24(erties)-362(of)-386(the)-397(n)24(um)24(b)-25(ers)-374(are)]TJ
-0.73475 -1.19245 TD
[(needed)-361(for)-337(suc)24(h)-350(an)-349(indexing.)-361(Of)-350(course,)-337(it)-362(tak)24(es)-338(some)-349(pages)-337(to)-350(\fll)-361(in)-350(all)-361(the)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(details)-350(of)-349(the)-350(\frst)-351(t)24(w)25(o)-338(steps,)-350(but)-350(the)-362(basic)-337(idea)-349(is)-338(not)-349(complicated)-349(once)-337(one)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(understands)-327(the)-337(concepts)-326(in)24(v)24(olv)25(ed.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(T)85(uring's)-315(result)-314(sho)24(w)24(ed)-313(conclusiv)24(ely)-313(that)-326(it)-337(will)-325(nev)24(er)-313(b)-24(e)-325(p)-24(ossible)-326(to)-326(com-)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(pletely)-313(mec)25(hanize)-301(mathematics.)-302(W)85(e)-313(shall)-302(nev)25(er)-290(b)-24(e)-313(able)-300(to)-302(tak)24(e)-301(all)-301(our)-302(math-)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(ematical)-469(questions)-471(to)-482(a)-482(computer)-470(and)-482(get)-470(a)-470(correct)-470(y)25(es-or-no)-447(answ)24(er.)-458(T)85(o)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(understand)-302(the)-302(de\fnitiv)24(eness)-302(of)-301(T)85(uring's)-302(result,)-303(one)-288(needs)-301<477F>506(odel's)-302(complete-)]TJ
T*
[(ness)-290(theorem.)-289(The)-301(completeness)-289(theorem)-289(iden)24(ti\fes)-290(the)-301(t)23(w)25(o)-289(natural)-290(meanings)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(of)-373(\\logical)-337(consequence":)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
11.27412 0 Td
(P)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.15632 0 Td
[(is)-362(a)-373(logical)-349(consequence)-348(of)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
11.91251 0 Td
(A)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.74679 0 Td
0.373 Tc
[(,i)373(f)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
1.60198 0 Td
0 Tc
(P)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.14428 0 Td
[(is)-374(true)-362(in)-373(all)]TJ
-27.83599 -1.2045 TD
[(systems)-327(\(mo)-24(dels\))-326(that)-338(satisfy)-315(axioms)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
16.4896 0 Td
(A)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.74679 0 Td
[(.)-325(On)-325(the)-338(other)-314(hand,)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
9.35896 0 Td
(P)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.10814 0 Td
[(should)-326(hop)-24(e-)]TJ
-27.7035 -1.19246 TD
[(fully)-398(b)-24(e)-397(a)-373(logical)-373(consequence)-384(of)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
14.70694 0 Td
(A)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.74679 0 Td
[(,)-398(if)-385(and)-398(only)-373(if)-398(there)-385(exists)-387(a)-385(pro)-25(of)-385(of)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
17.05572 0 Td
(P)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
-32.50945 -1.2045 TD
(from)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
2.37286 0 Td
(A)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.74679 0 Td
[(.)-349(This)-338(turns)-339(out)-349(to)-338(b)-24(e)-349(the)-350(case,)-325(and)-337(is)-350(exactly)-325(the)-349(con)24(ten)24(t)-337(of)-338<477F>506(odel's)]TJ
-3.11965 -1.2045 TD
[(completeness)-350(theorem.)-349(Therefore,)-349(T)84(uring's)-338(result)-363(means)-349(that)-362(w)24(e)-349(shall)-350(nev)25(er)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(b)-24(e)-277(able)-265(to)-265(tak)24(e)-265(all)-265(questions)-266(of)-265(the)-277(form,)-266(\\do)-24(es)-253(theorem)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
24.07795 0 Td
(P)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.04792 0 Td
[(follo)24(w)-265(from)-265(axioms)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
-25.12587 -1.2045 TD
(A)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.74679 0 Td
[(?")-337(to)-325(a)-326(computer)-337(and)-325(get)-326(a)-337(guaran)24(teed)-301(correct)-325(y)24(es)-314(or)-325(no)-325(answ)23(er.)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
11.95517 0 0 11.95517 134.76 337.56 Tm
[(5)-1124(Ch)29(urc)31(h)-382(and)-382<477F>561(odel)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 315.84 Tm
[(T)85(uring's)-363(negativ)24(e)-349(solution)-362(of)-361(the)-374(En)25(tsc)23(heidungsproblem)-338(w)25(as)-362(follo)24(w)24(ed)-349(in)-373(the)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(1930's)-361(b)24(y)-386(other)-374(\\negativ)24(e")-360(results.)-388(In)-385(1936,)-373(Alonzo)-373(Ch)24(urc)24(h)-373((1903-1995))-350(in-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(v)24(en)24(ted)-373(the)-386(lam)24(b)-24(da-calculus)-361(\(often)-386(written)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
18.91065 0 Td
<15>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.57816 0 Td
[(-calculus\))-386(and)-373(used)-374(it)-386(to)-386(giv)24(e)-361(a)]TJ
-19.48881 -1.2045 TD
[(de\fnition)-314(of)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
5.52865 0 Td
(algorithm)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
4.43256 0 Td
[(di\013eren)24(t)-314(from)-301(T)84(uring's,)-290(and)-301(hence)-312(an)-302(indep)-24(enden)25(t)-314(so-)]TJ
-9.96122 -1.19245 TD
[(lution)-398(of)-398(the)-409(En)24(tsc)24(heidungsproblem)-374([29].)-386(He)-397(also)-385(pro)23(v)24(ed)-385(the)-397(result)-399(w)24(e)-397(no)24(w)]TJ
ET
q
56.76 0 0 -0.48 134.748 260.748 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 249.96 Tm
[(according)-280(as)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
5.74145 0 Td
(S)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.95022 0 Td
[(pro)27(v)27(es)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
3.10493 0 Td
(B)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.09743 0 Td
[(or)-280(do)-27(es)-267(not)-267(pro)27(v)27(e)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
7.88278 0 Td
(B)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.82977 0 Td
[(.)-268(T)80(o)-280(solv)28(e)-268(the)-268(halting)-280(problem,)-281(whic)26(h)]TJ
-19.60658 -1.21788 TD
[(is)-348(whether)-334(a)-334(giv)27(en)-335(T)80(uring)-348(mac)28(hine)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
15.84587 0 Td
(M)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.43202 0 Td
[(halts)-347(at)-334(a)-347(giv)27(en)-335(input)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
10.02412 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.58887 0 Td
[(,)-335(w)27(e)-348(construct)-333(the)]TJ
-27.89087 -1.21788 TD
[(set)-414(of)-428(axioms)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
6.46415 0 Td
(A)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.17773 0 Td
[(\(dep)-27(ending)-416(on)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
6.91918 0 Td
(M)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.09743 0 Td
[(\))-428(as)-427(in)-416(the)-414(\frst)-414(step.)-415(W)80(e)-415(then)-415(construct)-413(the)]TJ
-15.6585 -1.23127 TD
[(sequence)-335(of)-361(sym)28(b)-27(ols)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
9.35495 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.8833 0 Td
[(expressing)-347(\\)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
5.4604 0 Td
(M)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.45878 0 Td
[(halts)-347(at)-347(input)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
6.51768 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.58887 0 Td
[(".)-348(According)-347(to)-348(step)-334(2,)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
10.5996 0 Td
(M)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
-34.86358 -1.21788 TD
[(halts)-294(at)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
3.65365 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.86992 0 Td
[(if)-294(and)-282(only)-281(if)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
5.90205 0 Td
(A)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.05728 0 Td
[(pro)27(v)27(es)-280(the)-281(theorem)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
8.77947 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.54872 0 Td
[(.)-281(By)-281(h)27(yp)-27(othesis,)-293(w)26(e)-281(can)-294(determine)]TJ
-20.81108 -1.21788 TD
[(this)-240(b)26(y)-241(running)-228(T)80(uring)-254(mac)27(hine)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
14.1328 0 Td
(K)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.19112 0 Td
[(at)-240(the)-241(inputs)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
5.87528 0 Td
(A)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.01713 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.90043 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.54872 0 Td
[(.)-241(If)-254(w)27(e)-241(get)-253(1,)-254(then)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
7.77571 0 Td
(M)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.33833 0 Td
(halts)Tj
-33.77953 -1.23127 TD
(at)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.16435 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.58887 0 Td
[(,)-254(and)-242(if)-267(w)26(e)-254(get)-253(0,)-268(it)-253(do)-27(es)-254(not.)-254(If)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
13.50378 0 Td
(K)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.2045 0 Td
[(b)-27(eha)26(v)27(es)-240(as)-267(w)27(e)-254(ha)26(v)27(e)-240(supp)-28(osed,)-254(this)-254(algorithm)]TJ
-16.4615 -1.21788 TD
[(will)-348(solv)28(e)-348(the)-321(halting)-348(problem.)-348(Since)-335(it)-335(in)27(v)27(olv)27(es)-334(only)-321(T)80(uring)-348(mac)28(hines)-335(connected)]TJ
T*
[(b)26(y)-240(simple)-254(steps,)-254(it)-253(can)-255(b)-27(e)-254(done)-255(b)26(y)-227(another)-254(T)81(uring)-255(mac)28(hine,)-269(con)27(tradicting)-253(T)80(uring's)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(result)-307(on)-308(the)-294(unsolv)54(abilit)27(y)-308(of)-321(the)-294(halting)-307(problem.)-321(Hence)-296(no)-307(suc)26(h)-308(mac)28(hine)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
33.17728 0 Td
(K)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.24465 0 Td
(can)Tj
-34.42193 -1.21788 TD
(exist.)Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
15 0 obj
<<
/Length 8803
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 290.52 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(The)-335(Mec)27(hanization)-361(of)-361(Mathematics)-2674(13)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(summarize)-326(in)-325(the)-337(statemen)23(t,)-326(\\Arithmetic)-338(is)-325(undecidable".)-325(Since)-325(P)25(eano's)-313(ax-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(ioms)-398(are)-385(not)-398(\frst-order,)-376(the)-398(En)25(tsc)23(heidungsproblem)-386(do)-24(es)-386(not)-397(directly)-398(apply)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
[(to)-350(them,)-361(and)-350(one)-349(can)-348(ask)-338(whether)-350(there)-349(could)-349(b)-24(e)-361(an)-350(algorithm)-338(that)-350(tak)24(es)-337(a)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(\frst-order)-291(statemen)23(t)-314(ab)-24(out)-313(the)-314(natural)-302(n)24(um)24(b)-24(ers)-314(as)-301(input,)-326(and)-313(correctly)-290(out-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(puts)-278(\\true")-253(or)-254(\\false".)-253(The)-264(En)24(tsc)24(heidungsproblem)-242(do)-24(es)-265(not)-265(apply)84(,)-265(since)-265(there)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(exists)-374(no)-374(\(\fnite)-386(\frst-order\))-364(system)-375(of)-373(axioms)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
20.30787 0 Td
(A)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.12019 0 Td
[(whose)-373(logical)-361(consequences)]TJ
-21.42805 -1.2045 TD
[(are)-398(the)-397(statemen)23(ts)-410(true)-398(in)-410(the)-410(natural)-386(n)24(um)24(b)-24(ers.)-398(Ch)24(urc)24(h)-398(sho)24(w)24(ed)-385(that,)-410(nev-)]TJ
T*
[(ertheless,)-447(there)-458(is)-446(no)-446(suc)24(h)-457(algorithm.)-435(Ch)24(urc)24(h's)-446(studen)23(t)-458(Kleene)-445(pro)24(v)24(ed)-445(the)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(equiv)60(alence)-276(of)-277(the)-277(T)85(uring-mac)23(hine)-264(and)-277(the)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
18.64566 0 Td
<15>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.57816 0 Td
[(-calculus)-277(de\fnitions)-278(of)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
9.93712 0 Td
(algorithm)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
-29.16094 -1.2045 TD
[(in)-337(his)-338(Ph.)-325(D.)-337(thesis,)-339(later)-325(published)-338(in)-326([60].)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 322.68 562.2 Tm
(16)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 149.76 544.8 Tm
[(In)-422(1931,)-397(Kurt)-411<477F>507(odel)-410([45])-421(pro)24(v)24(ed)-398(his)-422(famous)-410(\\incompleteness)-410(theorem",)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(whic)25(h)-277(w)24(e)-265(can)-264(state)-266(as)-266(follo)24(ws:)-265(Whatev)24(er)-265(system)-266(of)-277(axioms)-253(one)-265(writes)-278(do)24(wn)-264(in)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(an)-301(attempt)-314(to)-302(axiomatize)-288(the)-302(truths)-315(ab)-24(out)-301(the)-302(natural)-302(n)24(um)24(b)-24(ers,)-290(either)-301(some)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(false)-337(statemen)23(t)-338(will)-349(b)-24(e)-349(pro)24(v)24(ed)-325(from)-338(the)-338(axioms,)-337(or)-326(some)-337(true)-338(statemen)23(t)-350(will)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(not)-314(b)-24(e)-301(pro)24(v)24(ed.)-289(In)-313(other)-302(w)25(ords,)-291(if)-313(all)-301(the)-313(axioms)-302(are)-289(true,)-302(then)-313(some)-301(true)-314(fact)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(will)-385(b)-24(e)-386(unpro)24(v)60(able)-373(from)-374(those)-386(axioms.)-362<477F>507(odel)-386(used)-385(neither)-374(T)84(uring)-386(mac)25(hines)]TJ
(nor)'
/F9 1 Tf
1.84288 0 Td
<15>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.57816 0 Td
[(-calculus)-374(\(neither)-398(of)-385(whic)24(h)-385(w)24(as)-386(in)24(v)24(en)25(ted)-386(un)24(til)-386(\fv)24(e)-385(y)24(ears)-374(later\),)-386(but)-398(in)]TJ
-2.42105 -1.19245 TD
[(essence)-373(ga)24(v)24(e)-361(a)-373(third)-387(de\fnition)-385(of)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
14.92375 0 Td
(algorithm)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
4.10734 0 Td
(.)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 327.12 464.76 Tm
(17)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 339.48 461.16 Tm
[(The)-385(bulk)-385(of)-386<477F>506(odel's)-373(pap)-25(er)-373(is)]TJ
-20.54877 -1.2045 TD
[(dev)24(oted,)-313(not)-313(to)-314(his)-314(essen)24(tial)-302(ideas,)-313(but)-314(to)-313(the)-326(details)-313(of)-313(co)-24(ding)-301(computations)]TJ
T*
[(as)-410(in)24(tegers;)-398(although)-410(he)-421(did)-422(not)-410(use)-422(T)85(uring)-410(mac)24(hines,)-410(he)-409(still)-423(had)-421(to)-410(co)-24(de)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(a)-397(di\013eren)24(t)-398(kind)-398(of)-397(computation)-387(as)-397(in)24(tegers.)-374(No)24(w)24(ada)25(ys,)-374(when)-397(\\Ascii)-398(co)-23(des")]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(used)-374(b)24(y)-373(computers)-374(routinely)-374(assign)-363(a)-373(n)24(um)24(b)-24(er)-374(to)-373(eac)25(h)-374(alphab)-24(etic)-373(c)24(haracter,)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(and)-313(hence)-325(reduce)-312(a)-313(line)-313(of)-326(text)-325(to)-314(a)-313(v)24(ery)-301(long)-313(n)24(um)24(b)-24(er,)-314(using)-313(three)-326(digits)-314(p)-24(er)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(c)24(haracter,)-362(this)-398(seems)-386(routine.)-386(F)84(or)-374(example,)-385(`a')-385(has)-386(the)-398(Ascii)-385(co)-24(de)-385(97,)-373(`b')-398(is)]TJ
T*
[(assigned)-350(98,)-361(`c')-373(gets)-362(99,)-361(and)-362(so)-361(on.)-374(Th)25(us)-362(\\cat")-361(gets)-362(the)-374(n)24(um)24(b)-24(er)-362(099097116.)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(Suc)24(h)-325(enco)-23(dings)-314(can)-313(also)-301(b)-24(e)-325(used)-326(to)-325(sho)23(w)-301(that)-326(T)85(uring)-314(mac)25(hine)-313(computations)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(can)-325(b)-24(e)-337(enco)-23(ded)-337(in)-338(n)24(um)24(b)-24(ers.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.38518 TD
[(Making)-470(use)-494(of)-482(T)85(uring)-483(mac)25(hines,)-482(it)-495(is)-482(not)-482(v)24(ery)-482(di\016cult)-494(to)-482(understand)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(the)-422(main)-421(idea)-410(of)-421<477F>506(odel's)-410(pro)-24(of.)-410(The)-421(tec)24(hnical)-409(details)-410(ab)-24(out)-422(co)-24(ding)-409(can)-410(b)-24(e)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(used)-301(to)-290(construct)-290(a)-301(n)24(um)24(b)-24(er-theoretical)-278(form)23(ula)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
20.78967 0 Td
(T)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.73475 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
[(e;)-168(x;)-169(y)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
2.45718 0 Td
[(\))-277(that)-302(expresses)-291(that)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
-24.36703 -1.2045 TD
(e)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.91542 0 Td
[(is)-458(a)-446(co)-23(de)-446(for)-446(a)-446(T)85(uring)-446(mac)24(hine)-445(\(a)-446(\fnite)-458(set)-459(of)-445(instructions\),)-448(and)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
29.77524 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.97565 0 Td
[(is)-446(a)]TJ
-31.6663 -1.19245 TD
[(co)-24(de)-301(for)-313(a)-301(complete)-301((halting))-314(computation)-314(b)24(y)-301(mac)24(hine)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
24.00568 0 Td
(e)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.78292 0 Td
[(at)-301(input)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
3.83031 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
[(.)-325(In)-302(other)]TJ
-29.18503 -1.2045 TD
[(w)24(ords,)-458(\\mac)24(hine)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
7.84129 0 Td
(e)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.93951 0 Td
[(halts)-471(at)-470(input)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
6.7452 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
[(")-470(can)-469(b)-24(e)-482(expressed)-446(b)24(y)-470(\\there)-470(exists)-458(a)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
-16.09212 -1.2045 TD
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.9636 0 Td
[(suc)24(h)-446(that)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.64937 0 Td
(T)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.73475 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
[(e;)-168(x;)-169(y)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
2.45718 0 Td
[(\).")-422(No)24(w)-445(supp)-25(ose)-433(that)-447(w)25(e)-434(had)-445(a)-434(correct)-422(and)-446(complete)]TJ
-9.19034 -1.19245 TD
(axiomatization)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
6.84156 0 Td
(A)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.10814 0 Td
[(of)-361(the)-374(true)-362(statemen)23(ts)-362(of)-361(arithmetic.)-375(W)85(e)-361(could)-361(then)-374(solv)24(e)]TJ
-7.9497 -1.2045 TD
[(the)-470(halting)-458(problem)-458(b)24(y)-470(the)-470(follo)24(wing)-445(algorithm:)-459(w)25(e)-458(sim)24(ultaneously)-458(try)-459(to)]TJ
T*
[(pro)24(v)24(e)-337(\\mac)24(hine)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
7.16677 0 Td
(e)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.81906 0 Td
[(do)-24(es)-350(not)-361(halt)-362(at)-350(input)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
10.10575 0 Td
(e)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.46976 0 Td
[(")-337(from)-362(the)-362(axioms)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
8.37127 0 Td
(A)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.74679 0 Td
[(,)-361(and)-362(w)25(e)-349(run)]TJ
ET
q
56.76 0 0 -0.48 134.748 216.948 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 210 Tm
(16)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 206.16 Tm
[(Kleene)-335(w)26(en)27(t)-334(on)-335(to)-334(b)-27(ecome)-347(one)-335(of)-347(the)-335(t)28(w)26(en)27(tieth)-335(cen)27(tury's)-320(luminaries)-361(of)-347(logic;)-361(his)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[([61])-361(is)-347(probably)-335(the)-334(most)-346(in\ruen)25(tial)-334(logic)-361(textb)-26(o)-26(ok)-334(ev)27(er)-334(written,)-361(and)-335(he)-335(laid)-348(the)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(foundations)-347(of)-348(\\recursion)-346(theory",)-347(whic)26(h)-335(includes)-349(the)-335(sub)-54(ject)-347(no)27(w)-335(kno)27(wn)-335(as)-347(the)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(theory)-333(of)-361(computation.)]TJ
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 166.2 Tm
(17)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 162.36 Tm
[<477F>509(odel's)-361(de\fnition)-336(seemed)-347(at)-347(the)-348(time)-347(rather)-347(sp)-27(ecialized,)-361(and)-349(\(unlik)27(e)-335(T)80(uring)-348(\fv)27(e)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(y)27(ears)-507(later\))-507(he)-509(made)-508(no)-509(claim)-521(that)-508(it)-508(corresp)-25(onded)-510(to)-507(the)-509(general)-521(notion)-508(of)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(\\computable",)-360(though)-335(that)-334(turned)-335(out)-347(to)-347(b)-27(e)-335(true.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
16 0 obj
<<
/Length 7444
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 134.76 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(14)-2662(Mic)26(hael)-361(Beeson)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(mac)24(hine)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
3.87849 0 Td
(e)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.75884 0 Td
[(at)-301(input)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
3.81826 0 Td
(e)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.75883 0 Td
[(to)-301(see)-289(if)-302(it)-301(halts.)-290(Here)-289(\\sim)24(ultaneously")-278(can)-289(b)-24(e)-301(tak)24(en)-289(to)]TJ
-9.21443 -1.2045 TD
[(mean)-253(\\in)-253(alternating)-241(steps.")-242(A)24(t)-253(ev)24(en-n)24(um)24(b)-24(ered)-241(stages,)-242(w)25(e)-253(run)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
26.92057 0 Td
(e)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.7227 0 Td
[(at)-253(input)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
3.73395 0 Td
(e)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.71066 0 Td
(for)Tj
-32.08788 -1.20451 TD
[(one)-385(more)-374(step,)-386(and,)-385(at)-374(o)-24(dd-n)24(um)24(b)-25(ered)-385(stages,)-362(w)24(e)-385(mak)24(e)-373(one)-385(more)-373(deduction)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(from)-446(the)-446(axioms)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
7.79311 0 Td
(A)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.74679 0 Td
0.458 Tc
[(.I)458(f)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
1.85493 0 Td
0 Tc
(e)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.90337 0 Td
[(halts)-447(at)-446(input)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
6.68498 0 Td
(e)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.46976 0 Td
[(,)-446(w)25(e)-446(\fnd)-458(that)-446(out)-446(at)-446(some)-446(ev)25(en-)]TJ
-18.45294 -1.2045 TD
[(n)24(um)24(b)-24(ered)-301(stage.)-302(Otherwise,)-301(b)24(y)-301(the)-314(assumed)-314(completeness)-301(and)-301(correctness)-290(of)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(the)-362(axioms)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
5.14321 0 Td
(A)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.74679 0 Td
[(,)-361(w)24(e)-361(succeed)-349(at)-361(some)-350(o)-24(dd-n)24(um)24(b)-24(ered)-350(stage)-349(to)-362(\fnd)-361(a)-350(pro)-24(of)-362(that)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
-5.89001 -1.2045 TD
(e)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.81906 0 Td
[(do)-24(es)-337(not)-350(halt)-350(at)-350(input)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
10.05758 0 Td
(e)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.46976 0 Td
[(.)-349(But)-350(since)-349(the)-350(halting)-349(problem)-338(is)-350(unsolv)60(able,)-349(this)]TJ
-11.34639 -1.2045 TD
[(is)-350(a)-349(con)24(tradiction;)-338(hence)-360(no)-350(suc)24(h)-349(set)-350(of)-349(axioms)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
20.88603 0 Td
(A)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.09609 0 Td
[(can)-349(exist.)-362(That)-349(is)-350<477F>506(odel's)]TJ
-21.98212 -1.19245 TD
[(incompleteness)-326(theorem.)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
11.95517 0 0 11.95517 134.76 538.68 Tm
[(6)-1124(The)-382(P)30(ossible)-381(Lo)-30(opholes)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 514.8 Tm
[(The)-421(results)-411(of)-410(T)85(uring,)-410(Ch)24(urc)24(h,)-410(and)-421<477F>506(odel)-409(are)-410(commonly)-409(called)-409(\\negativ)24(e")]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(results)-291(in)-313(that)-302(they)-301(sho)23(w)-288(the)-302(imp)-24(ossibilit)23(y)-302(of)-301(a)-301(complete)-300(reduction)-290(of)-301(mathe-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(matics)-266(or)-241(logic)-252(to)-266(computation.)-253(Hilb)-24(ert's)-266(program)-242(w)24(as)-253(a)-253(hop)-24(eless)-253(pip)-24(e)-277(dream.)]TJ
T*
[(These)-397(famous)-410(results)-399(seem)-398(to)-410(close)-397(the)-410(do)-24(ors)-398(on)-397(those)-410(who)-398(w)25(ould)-398(hop)-24(e)-409(to)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(mec)25(hanize)-397(mathematics.)-411(But)-409(w)24(e)-397(are)-398(not)-397(completely)-410(trapp)-25(ed;)-397(there)-410(are)-397(the)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(follo)24(wing)-325(p)-24(ossible)-326(\\lo)-24(opholes",)-301(or)-325(a)24(v)24(en)24(ues)-313(that)-338(ma)24(y)-325(still)-339(pro)24(v)24(e)-313(fruitful.)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
1.69834 -2.19219 TD
<0F>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.84315 0 Td
[(Ma)24(yb)-24(e)-337(there)-338(exist)-338(in)24(teresting)-338(axiom)-325(systems)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
19.8622 0 Td
(A)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.0961 0 Td
[(suc)24(h)-337(that,)-351(for)-325(that)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
-21.80145 -1.2045 TD
[(p)48(articular)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
4.4687 0 Td
[(axiom)-253(system,)-254(there)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
8.90125 0 Td
[(do)48(es)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
2.09583 0 Td
[(exist)-254(a)-252(\\decision)-241(pro)-25(cedure",)-228(that)]TJ
-15.46578 -1.19245 TD
[(p)-24(ermits)-363(us)-350(to)-361(compute)-349(whether)-350(a)-349(giv)24(en)-349(statemen)23(t)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
22.31939 0 Td
(P)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.13223 0 Td
[(follo)24(ws)-337(from)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
5.68524 0 Td
(A)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
-29.13685 -1.2045 TD
[(or)-326(not.)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
0 -1.19245 TD
<0F>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.80702 0 Td
[(Ma)24(yb)-24(e)-301(there)-302(exist)-301(in)24(teresting)-303(algorithms)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
17.94705 0 Td
(f)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.90338 0 Td
[(that)-314(tak)24(e)-289(an)-301(axiom)-301(sys-)]TJ
-19.65744 -1.2045 TD
(tem)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.96334 0 Td
(A)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.03587 0 Td
[(and)-289(an)-277(input)-302(form)24(ula)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
9.49146 0 Td
(P)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.072 0 Td
(and,)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
2.18015 0 Td
(sometimes)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
4.51687 0 Td
[(,)-289(tell)-301(us)-290(that)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
5.61297 0 Td
(P)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.072 0 Td
[(follo)24(ws)]TJ
-26.94466 -1.2045 TD
(from)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
2.32469 0 Td
(A)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.74679 0 Td
[(.)-289(Ev)24(en)-276(if)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
3.90258 0 Td
(f)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.89133 0 Td
[(is)-278(not)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
2.68604 0 Td
[(guar)49(ante)48(e)49(d)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
4.90232 0 Td
[(to)-289(w)24(ork)-265(on)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
4.91436 0 Td
[(al)-48(l)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
1.36108 0 Td
(P)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.78292 0 Td
[(,)-289(if)-301(it)-290(w)24(ould)-277(w)25(ork)]TJ
-22.5121 -1.19246 TD
(on)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
1.37313 0 Td
(some)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
2.51741 0 Td
(P)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.10814 0 Td
[(for)-302(whic)25(h)-325(w)24(e)-313(did)-325(not)-314(kno)24(w)-312(the)-314(answ)24(er)-301(b)-24(efore,)-325(that)-314(w)24(ould)]TJ
-4.99867 -1.2045 TD
[(b)-24(e)-337(quite)-338(in)24(teresting.)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
<0F>'
/F1 1 Tf
0.8552 0 Td
[(Ev)25(en)-337(if)-362(suc)24(h)-349(an)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
7.15473 0 Td
(f)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.95156 0 Td
[(w)24(ork)24(ed)-325(only)-349(for)-350(a)-349(particular)-338(axiom)-338(system)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
19.01905 0 Td
(A)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.10814 0 Td
(of)Tj
-29.08867 -1.19245 TD
[(in)24(terest,)-302(it)-314(still)-302(migh)24(t)-302(b)-24(e)-313(able)-301(to)-301(answ)24(er)-289(mathematical)-302(questions)-290(that)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(w)24(e)-324(could)-337(not)-326(answ)24(er)-326(b)-24(efore.)]TJ
-0.19272 -2.19219 TD
[(These)-409(lo)-24(opholes)-422(in)-421(the)-434(negativ)24(e)-409(results)-412(of)-421(the)-434(thirties)-423(allo)24(w)-409(the)-434(partial)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(mec)25(hanization)-446(of)-446(mathematics.)-458(It)-459(is)-458(the)-458(pursuit)-459(of)-446(these)-458(p)-24(ossibilities)-460(that)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(o)-24(ccupies)-325(the)-337(main)-338(business)-326(of)-337(this)-339(pap)-24(er.)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
11.95517 0 0 11.95517 134.76 224.04 Tm
[(7)-1124(The)-382(\frst)-371(theorem-pro)30(v)30(ers)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 200.16 Tm
[(When)-349(the)-337(computer)-338(w)24(as)-337(still)-339(newb)-23(orn,)-338(some)-337(p)-24(eople)-337(tried)-338(to)-338(write)-337(programs)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(exploiting)-253(the)-265(lo)-24(opholes)-253(left)-278(b)24(y)-252(Ch)24(urc)24(h)-253(and)-265<477F>506(odel.)-253(The)-264(\frst)-267(one)-252(exploited)-265(the)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(p)-24(ossibilit)22(y)-361(of)-373(decision)-362(pro)-24(cedures.)-362(There)-361(w)25(as)-362(already)-349(a)-373(kno)24(wn)-361(decision)-362(pro-)]TJ
T*
[(cedure)-289(for)-277(arithmetic)-302(without)-290(m)24(ultiplication.)-302(This)-289(is)-290(essen)24(tially)-277(the)-302(theory)-277(of)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(linear)-289(equations)-302(with)-301(in)24(teger)-290(v)61(ariables,)-290(and)-301(\\for)-290(all")-288(and)-302(\\there)-301(exists".)-290(This)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(theory)-410(go)-24(es)-422(b)24(y)-421(the)-422(name)-421(of)-422(\\Presburger)-386(arithmetic",)-422(after)-423(M.)-422(Presburger,)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
17 0 obj
<<
/Length 7710
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 290.52 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(The)-335(Mec)27(hanization)-361(of)-361(Mathematics)-2674(15)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(who)-349(\frst)-363(ga)25(v)24(e)-337(a)-349(decision)-350(pro)-24(cedure)-349(for)-350(it)-362(in)-361([82].)-349(It)-363(cried)-349(out)-350(for)-361(implemen-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(tation,)-314(no)24(w)-313(that)-314(the)-313(computer)-314(w)25(as)-302(more)-301(than)-326(a)-301(though)24(t)-314(exp)-23(erimen)24(t.)-314(Martin)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
[(Da)24(vis)-374(to)-24(ok)-361(up)-386(this)-374(c)24(hallenge)-360([37],)-374(and)-373(in)-374(1954)-348(his)-374(program)-351(pro)24(v)24(ed)-361(that)-386(the)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(sum)-398(of)-398(t)24(w)24(o)-385(ev)25(en)-398(n)24(um)24(b)-24(ers)-386(is)-398(ev)24(en.)-397(This)-398(w)25(as)-386(p)-24(erhaps)-386(the)-410(\frst)-387(theorem)-398(ev)25(er)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(pro)24(v)24(ed)-253(b)24(y)-265(a)-265(computer)-265(program.)-242(The)-264(computer)-266(on)-265(whic)25(h)-265(the)-277(program)-242(ran)-265(w)24(as)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(a)-361(v)60(acuum)-361(tub)-25(e)-373(computer)-362(kno)25(wn)-362(as)-349(the)-374(\\johnniac",)-349(at)-361(the)-374(Institute)-375(for)-362(Ad-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(v)60(anced)-264(Study)-278(in)-265(Princeton,)-253(whic)25(h)-265(had)-265(a)-265(memory)-253(of)-265(1024)-241(w)25(ords.)-254(The)-265(program)]TJ
T*
[(could)-325(use)-337(a)-326(maxim)24(um)-325(of)-337(96)-325(w)24(ords)-314(to)-325(hold)-338(the)-337(generated)-313(form)23(ulas.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.19245 TD
[(In)-314(1955,)-300(New)25(ell,)-313(Sha)24(w,)-313(and)-313(Simon)-326(wrote)-301(a)-313(program)-302(they)-313(called)-313(the)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
29.5223 0 Td
-0.048 Tc
[(Log)-48(i)-48(c)]TJ
-31.02792 -1.2045 TD
0 Tc
[(The)49(orist)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
3.60145 0 Td
[([74].)-421(This)-422(program)-387(w)25(en)24(t)-422(through)-410(another)-398(lo)-24(ophole:)-409(it)-423(tried)-422(to)-410(\fnd)]TJ
-3.60145 -1.2045 TD
[(pro)-25(ofs,)-422(ev)25(en)-422(though)-422(according)-409(to)-434(T)85(uring)-422(it)-434(m)24(ust)-435(fail)-422(sometimes.)-422(It)-434(pro)23(v)24(ed)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(sev)24(eral)-410(prop)-24(ositional)-411(logic)-409(theorems)-422(in)-434(the)-433(system)-423(of)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
24.05386 0 Td
[(Principia)-469(Mathemat-)]TJ
-24.05387 -1.2045 TD
[(ic)48(a)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.21654 0 Td
[(.)-398(The)-396(authors)-375(w)24(ere)-385(proud)-374(of)-398(the)-385(fact)-398(that)-398(this)-387(program)-374(w)25(as)-374(\\heuristic",)]TJ
-1.21654 -1.19245 TD
[(b)24(y)-409(whic)24(h)-409(they)-422(mean)24(t)-410(not)-410(only)-409(that)-423(it)-422(migh)24(t)-410(fail,)-409(but)-422(that)-423(there)-410(w)25(as)-398(some)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(analogy)-349(b)-24(et)24(w)24(een)-360(ho)24(w)-361(it)-374(solv)23(ed)-361(problems)-362(and)-361(ho)24(w)-361(a)-361(h)24(uman)-374(w)25(ould)-362(solv)24(e)-361(the)]TJ
T*
[(same)-410(problems.)-398(They)-409(felt)-422(that)-422(a)-398(heuristic)-410(approac)24(h)-397(w)24(as)-398(necessary)-386(b)-24(ecause)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(the)-374(approac)25(h)-350(of)-373(systematically)-363(searc)24(hing)-349(for)-374(a)-361(pro)-25(of)-373(of)-374(the)-373(desired)-362(theorem)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(from)-410(the)-422(giv)24(en)-409(axioms)-398(seemed)-421(hop)-24(eless.)-410(They)-409(referred)-398(to)-422(the)-422(latter)-410(as)-410(the)]TJ
T*
[(\\British)-302(Museum")-302(algorithm,)-302(comparing)-289(it)-314(to)-301(searc)24(hing)-290(for)-301(a)-301(desired)-314(item)-313(in)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(the)-422(British)-423(Museum)-410(b)24(y)-421(examining)-410(the)-421(en)24(tire)-410(con)24(ten)24(ts)-410(of)-422(the)-422(m)24(useum.)-422(Ac-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(cording)-361(to)-386([38],)-374(Alan)-373(New)25(ell)-385(said)-374(to)-374(Herb)-385(Simon)-374(on)-373(Christmas)-375(1955,)-361(ab)-24(out)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(their)-254(program,)-229(\\Kind)-253(of)-253(crude,)-241(but)-266(it)-253(w)24(orks,)-242(b)-24(o)25(y)84(,)-253(it)-254(w)25(orks!".)-230(In)-253(one)-253(of)-253(Simon's)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(obituaries)-374([66])-386(\(he)-397(died)-386(in)-397(2001)-361(at)-386(age)-385(84\),)-386(one)-373(\fnds)-398(a)-385(con)24(tin)24(uation)-374(of)-397(this)]TJ
(story:)'
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 151.68 374.04 Tm
[(The)-322(follo)28(wing)-362(Jan)27(uary)81(,)-321(Professor)-345(Simon)-321(celebrated)-335(this)-320(disco)27(v)27(ery)-307(b)26(y)-307(w)26(alk-)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(ing)-321(in)26(to)-320(a)-321(class)-347(and)-308(announcing)-322(to)-321(his)-321(studen)26(ts,)-307(\\Ov)28(er)-321(the)-308(Christmas)-332(holi-)]TJ
T*
[(da)27(y)80(,)-321(Al)-308(New)26(ell)-334(and)-322(I)-321(in)26(v)27(en)27(ted)-295(a)-321(thinking)-321(mac)27(hine.")-335(A)-308(subsequen)26(t)-307(letter)-320(to)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(Lord)-281(Russell)-294(explaining)-281(his)-282(ac)28(hiev)26(emen)27(t)-267(elicited)-295(the)-281(reply)-268(:)-281(\\I)-280(am)-294(deligh)27(ted)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(to)-441(kno)27(w)-428(that)-414(`Principia)-455(Mathematica')-453(can)-428(no)26(w)-441(b)-28(e)-428(done)-429(b)27(y)-415(mac)28(hinery)80(.)-429(I)]TJ
T*
[(wish)-402(Whitehead)-389(and)-388(I)-388(had)-389(kno)27(wn)-388(of)-401(this)-388(p)-27(ossibilit)28(y)-401(b)-28(efore)-400(w)27(e)-402(w)27(asted)-401(10)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(y)27(ears)-347(doing)-348(it)-347(b)26(y)-334(hand.")]TJ
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 252.6 312.12 Tm
(18)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 149.76 289.8 Tm
[(In)-229(1957,)-217(the)-241(y)24(ear)-216(of)-241(publication)-230(of)-240(New)24(ell,)-240(Sha)24(w,)-229(and)-229(Simon's)-241(rep)-24(ort)-218([74],)-229(a)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(\fv)24(e)-289(w)25(eek)-277(Summer)-289(Institute)-303(for)-290(Sym)24(b)-24(olic)-289(Logic)-277(w)25(as)-278(held)-289(at)-289(Cornell,)-289(attended)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(b)24(y)-349(man)24(y)-350(American)-349(logicians)-337(and)-349(some)-350(researc)24(hers)-314(from)-350(IBM.)-361(A)24(t)-350(this)-362(meet-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(ing,)-373(Abraham)-362(Robinson)-374(in)24(tro)-25(duced)-361(the)-385(idea)-361(of)-374(Sk)24(olem)-373(functions)-374([explained)]TJ
T*
[(b)-24(elo)24(w],)-349(and)-349(shortly)-339(after)-350(the)-361(meeting)-349(a)-350(n)25(um)23(b)-24(er)-349(of)-350(imp)-24(ortan)24(t)-350(adv)60(ances)-337(w)24(ere)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(made.)-301(Sev)24(eral)-289(new)-300(programs)-279(w)25(ere)-301(written)-302(that)-314(searc)24(hed)-277(more)-301(systematically)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(for)-278(pro)-24(ofs)-278(than)-289(the)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
8.40741 0 Td
[(L)48(o)48(gic)-325(The)49(orist)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
6.46816 0 Td
[(had)-289(done.)-277(The)-288(problem)-278(w)25(as)-278(clearly)-265(seen)-288(as)]TJ
-14.87558 -1.19245 TD
[(\\pruning")-241(the)-278(searc)24(h,)-241(i.e.)-264(eliminating)-254(fruitless)-266(deductions)-266(as)-253(early)-241(as)-254(p)-24(ossible.)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(Gelern)24(ter's)-326(geometry)-313(pro)23(v)24(er)-313([44])-325(used)-326(a)-337(\\diagram")-301(to)-338(prune)-325(false)-338(goals.)-313(The)]TJ
T*
[(mathematical)-386(logician)-373(Hao)-385(W)85(ang)-385(wrote)-386(a)-385(program)-363([103])-373(based)-385(on)-386(a)-385(logical)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(system)-363(kno)25(wn)-349(as)-350(\\natural)-338(deduction".)-349(W)84(ang's)-362(program)-326(pro)24(v)24(ed)-337(all)-361(400)-337(pure)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(predicate-calculus)-434(theorems)-458(in)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
13.94811 0 Td
[(Principia)-493(Mathematic)48(a)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
10.10575 0 Td
[(.)-482(Da)25(vis)-447(and)-457(Putnam)]TJ
ET
q
56.76 0 0 -0.48 134.748 151.188 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 144.24 Tm
(18)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 140.4 Tm
[(Russell)-347(ma)27(y)-334(ha)27(v)27(e)-335(had)-348(his)-348(tongue)-335(\frmly)-347(in)-335(c)27(heek.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
18 0 obj
<<
/Length 10420
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 134.76 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(16)-2662(Mic)26(hael)-361(Beeson)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[([40])-277(published)-290(a)-276(pap)-25(er)-289(that)-290(coupled)-276(the)-289(use)-290(of)-277(Sk)24(olem)-289(functions)-289(and)-278(conjunc-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(tiv)24(e)-446(normal)-434(form)-434(with)-458(a)-433(b)-25(etter)-458(algorithm)-422(to)-446(determine)-446(satis\fabilit)22(y)84(.)-433(Ov)24(er)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
[(the)-374(next)-373(sev)24(eral)-362(y)25(ears,)-350(these)-374(strands)-363(of)-374(dev)25(elopmen)24(t)-362(led)-373(to)-373(the)-374(in)24(v)24(en)24(tion)-361(of)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(fundamen)24(tal)-362(algorithms)-338(that)-350(are)-350(still)-350(in)-362(use.)-349(W)84(e)-361(shall)-349(discuss)-351(three)-350(of)-361(these)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(to)-24(ols:)-326(Sk)24(olemization,)-325(resolution,)-314(and)-338(uni\fcation.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.58994 TD
[(Sk)24(olem)-313(functions)-338(are)-313(used)-326(to)-325(systematically)-314(eliminate)-338(\\there)-313(exists".)-326(F)84(or)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(instance,)-217(\\for)-217(ev)24(ery)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
8.51581 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.79497 0 Td
[(there)-217(exists)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
5.09503 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.74679 0 Td
[(suc)24(h)-217(that)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.2037 0 Td
(P)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.78292 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
[(x;)-169(y)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.54176 0 Td
[(\)")-217(is)-217(replaced)-217(b)24(y)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
7.1186 0 Td
(P)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.78292 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
[(x;)-169(g)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.52971 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
(\)\),)Tj
-32.83467 -1.19245 TD
(where)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
2.91489 0 Td
(g)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.87929 0 Td
[(is)-362(called)-349(a)-361(\\Sk)24(olem)-349(function".)-361(When)-361(w)24(e)-361(express)-338(the)-374(la)25(w)-349(that)-363(ev)25(ery)]TJ
-3.79417 -1.2045 TD
(nonzero)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
3.66168 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.84315 0 Td
[(has)-253(a)-265(m)24(ultiplicativ)23(e)-265(in)24(v)25(erse)-254(in)-265(the)-277(form)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
17.03163 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.84315 0 Td
(6)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.277 Tc
(=0)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
1.83084 0 Td
0 Tc
(!)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.27677 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.66248 0 Td
<01>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.37339 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F13 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 404.64 570.2401 Tm
<00>Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.89477 0 Td
(1)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 418.2 566.64 Tm
0.265 Tc
[(=1)265(,w)290(ea)265(r)265(e)]TJ
-28.45029 -1.19245 TD
0 Tc
[(using)-314(a)-313(Sk)24(olem)-313(function)-325(\(written)-327(as)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
15.85122 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F13 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 298.32 558.36 Tm
<00>Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.89477 0 Td
(1)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 312.36 554.76 Tm
[(instead)-314(of)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.55301 0 Td
(g)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.51794 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
[(\).)-338(T)85(erms)-314(are)-301(built)-338(up,)]TJ
-23.8491 -1.2045 TD
[(using)-326(function)-337(and)-338(op)-24(eration)-313(sym)23(b)-24(ols,)-326(from)-325(v)60(ariables)-314(and)-337(constan)23(ts;)-314(usually)]TJ
T*
[(letters)-326(near)-326(the)-337(b)-24(eginning)-325(of)-326(the)-337(alphab)-24(et)-337(are)-314(constan)24(ts)-314(and)-337(letters)-327(near)-325(the)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(end)-337(are)-337(v)60(ariables)-314(\(a)-337(con)24(v)24(en)24(tion)-325(in)24(tro)-25(duced)-337(b)24(y)-337(Descartes\).)-326(Certain)-338(terms)-338(are)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(distinguished)-315(as)-289(\\prop)-25(ositions";)-290(in)24(tuitiv)23(ely)-301(these)-313(are)-289(the)-314(ones)-301(that)-302(should)-302(b)-24(e)]TJ
T*
[(either)-265(true)-254(or)-253(false)-265(if)-266(the)-265(v)60(ariables)-253(are)-253(giv)24(en)-253(sp)-24(eci\fc)-264(v)60(alues.)-253(The)-265(use)-265(of)-265(Sk)24(olem)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(functions)-398(and)-386(elemen)25(tary)-374(logical)-373(manipulations)-374(enables)-386(us)-386(to)-386(express)-374(ev)25(ery)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(axiom)-349(and)-362(theorem)-361(in)-362(a)-349(certain)-362(standard)-350(form)-362(called)-349(\\clausal)-349(form",)-350(whic)25(h)]TJ
T*
[(w)24(e)-288(no)24(w)-289(explain.)-289(A)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
8.23878 0 Td
[(liter)49(al)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
2.7824 0 Td
[(is)-302(an)-289(atomic)-289(prop)-24(osition)-278(or)-290(its)-302(negation.)-277(A)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
18.66975 0 Td
(clause)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
2.92693 0 Td
(is)Tj
-32.61786 -1.19245 TD
[(a)-349(\\disjunction)-350(of)-350(literals";)-350(that)-350(is,)-350(a)-349(list)-363(of)-349(literals)-350(separated)-338(b)24(y)-349(\\or".)-326(Giv)24(en)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(some)-325(axioms)-314(and)-337(a)-325(conjectured)-325(theorem,)-326(w)24(e)-324(negate)-325(the)-338(theorem,)-325(and)-325(seek)-325(a)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(pro)-25(of)-385(b)24(y)-373(con)24(tradiction.)-374(W)84(e)-397(use)-386(Sk)24(olem)-373(functions)-398(and)-385(logical)-361(manipulations)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(to)-386(eliminate)-385(\\there)-386(exists",)-374(and)-386(then)-385(w)24(e)-385(use)-386(logical)-373(manipulations)-386(to)-374(bring)]TJ
T*
[(the)-422(axioms)-410(and)-409(negated)-421(goal)-398(to)-422(the)-421(form)-410(of)-422(a)-409(list)-423(of)-422(clauses,)-409(where)-410(\\and")]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(implicitly)-398(joins)-386(the)-386(clauses.)-385(This)-386(pro)-25(cess)-373(is)-386(kno)24(wn)-373(as)-386(\\Sk)24(olemization.")-361(The)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(clausal)-325(form)-338(con)24(tains)-326(no)-325(\\there)-325(exists",)-339(but)-338(it)-337(do)-24(es)-338(con)25(tain)-326(new)-337(sym)24(b)-24(ols)-326(for)]TJ
T*
[(the)-362(\(unkno)24(wn\))-362(Sk)25(olem)-349(functions.)-375(The)-348(original)-350(question)-350(whether)-362(the)-361(axioms)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(imply)-458(the)-458(goal)-433(is)-446(equiv)60(alen)25(t)-447(to)-446(the)-457(more)-446(con)24(v)24(enien)25(t)-434(question)-446(whether)-458(the)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(resulting)-326(list)-339(of)-325(clauses)-325(is)-338(con)24(tradictory)-302(or)-326(not.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.58994 TD
[(In)-350(automated)-337(deduction,)-362(it)-350(is)-349(customary)-339(to)-349(use)-350(the)-349(v)24(ertical)-338(bar)-337(to)-350(mean)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(\\or",)-470(and)-494(the)-506(min)24(us)-494(sign)-483(to)-494(mean)-493(\\not".)-482(An)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
21.18715 0 Td
[(infer)49(enc)48(e)-517(rule)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
6.57657 0 Td
[(is)-494(a)-494(rule)-482(for)]TJ
-27.76373 -1.19245 TD
[(deducing)-289(theorems)-277(from)-278(previously-deduced)-277(theorems)-278(or)-278(axioms.)-277(It)-290(therefore)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(has)-410(\\premisses")-399(and)-409(\\conclusions".)-398(As)-422(an)-409(example)-409(of)-422(an)-409(inference)-421(rule)-410(w)24(e)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(men)24(tion)-313(the)-326(rule)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
7.54017 0 Td
[(mo)48(dus)-336(p)48(onens)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
6.03454 0 Td
[(,)-325(whic)24(h)-313(is)-314(already)-301(o)25(v)24(er)-290(2000)-300(y)24(ears)-290(old:)-313(from)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
19.21177 0 Td
(p)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
-32.78649 -1.2045 TD
[(and)-313(\\if)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
3.32442 0 Td
(p)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.80701 0 Td
(then)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
2.25242 0 Td
(q)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.4818 0 Td
[(")-313(infer)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
3.10761 0 Td
(q)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.4818 0 Td
[(.)-313(In)-314(clausal)-301(notation)-302(that)-314(w)25(ould)-302(b)-24(e,)-325(from)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
18.05545 0 Td
(p)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.81906 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
1.91515 0 Td
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.78292 0 Td
(p)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.50589 0 Td
(j)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.27703 0 Td
(q)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
-32.81058 -1.2045 TD
(infer)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
2.30059 0 Td
(q)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.4818 0 Td
(.)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
0.5902 0 Td
[(R)48(esolution)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
4.89027 0 Td
[(generalizes)-289(this)-326(rule.)-313(In)-326(its)-314(simplest)-327(form)-313(it)-326(sa)24(ys,)-302(from)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
23.76478 0 Td
(p)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.50589 0 Td
(j)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.27703 0 Td
(r)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
-32.81058 -1.19245 TD
(and)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
1.87902 0 Td
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.78293 0 Td
(p)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.50589 0 Td
(j)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.27704 0 Td
(q)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.4818 0 Td
[(,)-265(infer)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
2.79444 0 Td
(r)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.46976 0 Td
(j)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.27703 0 Td
(q)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.4818 0 Td
[(.)-277(Ev)24(en)-264(more)-253(generally)84(,)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
9.82872 0 Td
(r)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.75883 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.87902 0 Td
(q)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.74679 0 Td
[(can)-265(b)-24(e)-276(replaced)-265(with)-277(sev)24(eral)]TJ
-21.16306 -1.2045 TD
[(prop)-25(ositions.)-398(F)83(or)-397(example,)-409(from)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
14.59854 0 Td
(p)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.50589 0 Td
(j)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.27703 0 Td
(r)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.46976 0 Td
(j)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.27703 0 Td
(s)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.89133 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
2.01151 0 Td
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.78292 0 Td
(p)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.50589 0 Td
(j)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.27703 0 Td
(q)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.4818 0 Td
(j)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.27703 0 Td
(t)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.36135 0 Td
[(,)-410(w)25(e)-409(can)-410(infer)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
6.54043 0 Td
(r)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.46976 0 Td
(j)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.27703 0 Td
(s)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.46976 0 Td
(j)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.27703 0 Td
(q)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.4818 0 Td
(j)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.27704 0 Td
(t)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.36135 0 Td
[(.)-422(The)]TJ
-30.87133 -1.2045 TD
[(rule)-325(can)-313(b)-24(e)-325(though)23(t)-325(of)-326(as)-313(\\cancelling")]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
16.863 0 Td
(p)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.83111 0 Td
(with)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
2.26446 0 Td
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.78292 0 Td
(p)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.50589 0 Td
[(.)-313(The)-325(cancelled)-324(term)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
9.29874 0 Td
(p)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.81906 0 Td
[(do)-24(es)]TJ
-31.36518 -1.19245 TD
[(not)-289(ha)24(v)24(e)-289(to)-289(b)-25(e)-300(the)-302(\frst)-290(one)-289(listed.)-302(If)-301(w)24(e)-289(deriv)24(e)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
20.2356 0 Td
(p)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.79497 0 Td
[(and)-301(also)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
3.87849 0 Td
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.78292 0 Td
(p)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.50589 0 Td
[(,)-289(then)-301(resolution)]TJ
-26.19787 -1.2045 TD
[(leads)-325(to)-338(the)-337(\\empt)24(y)-326(clause",)-313(whic)25(h)-337(denotes)-326(a)-325(con)25(tradiction.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.58994 TD
[(The)-421(third)-423(of)-421(the)-422(three)-422(to)-24(ols)-410(w)24(e)-421(men)24(tioned)-422(is)-410(the)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
22.34348 0 Td
[(uni\fc)48(ation)-434(algorithm)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.14215 0 Td
(.)Tj
-32.99125 -1.2045 TD
[(This)-470(w)24(as)-458(published)-482(b)24(y)-458(J.)-470(A.)-481(Robinson[89].)-446(Robinson's)-470(publication)-470(\(whic)24(h)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(con)24(tained)-361(more)-350(than)-373(\\just")-363(uni\fcation\))-362(app)-24(eared)-361(in)-361(1965,)-349(but)-374(at)-362(that)-362(time)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(uni\fcation)-241(w)24(as)-241(already)-229(in)-241(the)-253(air,)-241(ha)24(ving)-229(b)-24(een)-253(implemen)25(ted)-253(b)24(y)-241(others)-230(as)-241(early)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
19 0 obj
<<
/Length 9886
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 290.52 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(The)-335(Mec)27(hanization)-361(of)-361(Mathematics)-2674(17)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(as)-398(1962.)-385(See)-409([38])-397(for)-398(this)-411(history)83(.)-397(The)-409(purp)-25(ose)-398(of)-409(the)-410(uni\fcation)-410(algorithm)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(is)-386(to)-386(\fnd)-397(v)60(alues)-386(of)-385(v)60(ariables)-374(to)-386(mak)24(e)-373(t)24(w)24(o)-373(terms)-387(matc)24(h.)-385(F)84(or)-386(example:)-385(giv)24(en)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
0 -1.20451 TD
(f)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
[(x;)-169(g)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.52971 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
[(\)\))-374(and)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
3.1317 0 Td
(f)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(g)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.51793 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(c)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.43362 0 Td
(\))Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
0.169 Tc
(;z)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.9636 0 Td
0 Tc
[(\),)-350(w)25(e)-361(\fnd)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.55301 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.90337 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.10814 0 Td
(g)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.51793 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(c)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.43362 0 Td
(\),)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.02382 0 Td
(z)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.84315 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.10814 0 Td
(g)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.51793 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(g)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.51793 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(c)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.43362 0 Td
[(\)\))-374(b)24(y)-362(applying)-349(uni\fca-)]TJ
-23.39139 -1.19245 TD
[(tion.)-314(The)-324(input)-326(to)-314(the)-325(algorithm)-302(is)-314(a)-313(pair)-313(of)-314(terms)-314(to)-313(b)-25(e)-325(uni\fed.)-325(The)-312(output)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(is)-374(a)-373(substitution;)-376(that)-386(is,)-374(an)-362(assignmen)24(t)-362(of)-374(terms)-374(to)-374(v)60(ariables.)-361(W)84(e)-373(shall)-374(not)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(giv)24(e)-301(the)-313(details)-314(of)-313(the)-313(uni\fcation)-302(algorithm)-302(here;)-313(they)-313(can)-301(b)-24(e)-313(found)-313(in)-313(man)24(y)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(b)-24(o)-24(oks,)-326(for)-325(example)-325(in)-337([25],)-326(Ch.)-337(17,)-325(or)-313([5],)-337(pp.)-338(453)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
21.87372 0 Td
<0B>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.61429 0 Td
(.)Tj
-20.98239 -2.15605 TD
[(Com)24(bining)-385(resolution)-387(and)-385(uni\fcation,)-398(w)24(e)-397(arriv)24(e)-374(at)-385(the)-410(follo)24(wing)-373(rule)-398(of)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.19245 TD
[(inference:)-409(Supp)-24(ose)-410(that)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
10.79232 0 Td
(p)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.91542 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
2.01151 0 Td
(s)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.87928 0 Td
[(can)-409(b)-24(e)-410(uni\fed.)-409(Let)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
8.84103 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.91542 0 Td
[(denote)-397(the)-422(substitu-)]TJ
-24.35499 -1.2045 TD
[(tion)-350(found)-361(b)24(y)-338(the)-361(uni\fcation)-350(algorithm.)-338(Then)-349(from)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
22.87346 0 Td
(p)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.50589 0 Td
(j)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.27703 0 Td
(q)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.8311 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
1.96334 0 Td
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.78292 0 Td
(s)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.46976 0 Td
(j)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.27703 0 Td
(r)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.81906 0 Td
(infer)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
2.33673 0 Td
(q)Tj
/F13 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 449.76 552.72 Tm
<03>Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 454.32 549.12 Tm
(j)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.27704 0 Td
(r)Tj
/F13 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 461.76 552.72 Tm
<03>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 537.12 Tm
[(pro)24(vided)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.10734 0 Td
(p)Tj
/F13 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 180.72 540.84 Tm
<03>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 188.04 537.12 Tm
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.05996 0 Td
(s)Tj
/F13 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 203.28 540.84 Tm
<03>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 207.84 537.12 Tm
[(.)-337(This)-326(rule)-325(is)-326(also)-326(commonly)-312(kno)24(wn)-325(as)-326(\\resolution"{in)-302(fact,)]TJ
-7.3354 -1.19245 TD
[(resolution)-447(without)-470(uni\fcation)-458(is)-458(only)-458(of)-458(historical)-446(or)-446(p)-25(edagogical)-432(in)24(terest.)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(Resolution)-374(is)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
6.07068 0 Td
(always)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
3.21601 0 Td
[(com)24(bined)-373(with)-386(uni\fcation.)-373(J.)-386(A.)-385(Robinson)-374(pro)24(v)24(ed)-361([89])]TJ
-9.28669 -1.19245 TD
[(that)-398(this)-411(rule)-386(is)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
7.38358 0 Td
[(r)49(efutation)-422(c)48(omplete)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
8.39536 0 Td
[(.)-410(That)-397(means)-386(that)-410(if)-398(a)-397(list)-399(of)-397(clauses)-386(is)]TJ
-15.77895 -1.2045 TD
[(con)24(tradictory)83(,)-301(there)-337(exists)-327(a)-325(pro)-24(of)-326(of)-325(the)-337(empt)24(y)-326(clause)-325(from)-325(the)-338(original)-313(list,)]TJ
T*
[(using)-326(resolution)-326(as)-326(the)-337(sole)-325(rule)-326(of)-325(inference.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 328.2 480.96 Tm
(19)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 149.76 456 Tm
[(The)-361(basic)-349(paradigm)-350(for)-350(automated)-362(deduction)-361(then)-374(w)25(as)-350(b)-24(orn:)-362(Start)-350(with)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(the)-349(axioms)-326(and)-337(negated)-337(goal.)-325(P)24(erform)-314(resolutions)-326(\(using)-339(uni\fcation\))-350(un)24(til)-337(a)]TJ
T*
[(con)24(tradiction)-253(is)-266(reac)24(hed,)-240(or)-266(un)24(til)-265(y)24(ou)-253(run)-266(out)-265(of)-265(time)-277(or)-254(memory)84(.)-253(The)-264(mo)-24(dern)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(era)-289(in)-301(automated)-290(deduction)-301(could)-289(b)-24(e)-301(said)-301(to)-290(ha)24(v)24(e)-288(b)-24(egun)-289(when)-301(this)-302(paradigm)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(w)24(as)-361(in)-386(place.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 191.4 411.72 Tm
(20)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 203.52 408.12 Tm
[(One)-373(v)24(ery)-361(imp)-25(ortan)24(t)-374(strand)-375(of)-373(w)24(ork)-362(in)-373(the)-386(sub)-61(ject)-373(since)-385(the)]TJ
-6.90178 -1.2045 TD
[(sixties)-338(has)-338(b)-24(een)-349(dev)24(oted)-337(to)-337(v)60(arious)-326(attempts)-351(to)-338(prev)24(en)24(t)-337(running)-338(out)-338(of)-337(time)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(or)-398(memory)84(.)-397(These)-409(attempts)-411(will)-410(b)-24(e)-409(discussed)-411(in)-409(the)-410(section)-410(\\Searc)25(hing)-374(for)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(pro)-25(ofs")-313(b)-24(elo)24(w.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 197.4 375.84 Tm
(21)Tj
ET
q
56.76 0 0 -0.48 134.748 326.508 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 319.56 Tm
(19)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 315.72 Tm
[(W)80(e)-348(ha)27(v)27(e)-348(o)27(v)27(ersimpli\fed)-362(in)-361(the)-348(text.)-347(The)-362(resolution)-374(rule)-348(as)-373(w)26(e)-361(ha)27(v)27(e)-348(giv)27(en)-348(it)-361(do)-27(es)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(not)-348(p)-27(ermit)-346(one)-362(to)-347(infer)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
10.72005 0 Td
(p)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.52195 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
0.4015 0 Td
(z)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.52195 0 Td
[(\))-347(from)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
3.18523 0 Td
(p)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.52195 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
0.4015 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.58887 0 Td
(\))Tj
/F11 1 Tf
0.4015 0 Td
(j)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
0.28105 0 Td
(p)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.52195 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
0.4015 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.54872 0 Td
[(\).)-321(Either)-361(the)-348(resolution)-360(rule)-361(has)-348(to)-360(b)-27(e)]TJ
-19.01772 -1.21788 TD
[(stated)-387(a)-374(bit)-388(more)-387(generally)81(,)-388(as)-387(Robinson)-388(did,)-376(or)-387(w)27(e)-388(ha)26(v)27(e)-374(to)-388(supplemen)26(t)-374(it)-375(with)]TJ
0 -1.23126 TD
[(the)-321(rule)-335(called)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
6.70505 0 Td
(factoring)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
3.96147 0 Td
[(,)-348(whic)26(h)-335(sa)28(ys)-334(that)-320(if)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
8.87315 0 Td
(A)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.09743 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.98073 0 Td
(B)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.16435 0 Td
[(can)-335(b)-27(e)-321(uni\fed,)-323(and)]TJ
/F11 1 Tf
8.88653 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.84315 0 Td
[(is)-334(the)]TJ
-33.51186 -1.21788 TD
[(substitution)-334(pro)-26(duced)-336(b)26(y)-334(the)-335(uni\fcation)-348(algorithm,)-360(w)27(e)-361(can)-335(infer)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
29.2292 0 Td
(A)Tj
/F11 1 Tf
0.77623 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.50857 0 Td
(.)Tj
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 264.72 Tm
(20)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 261 Tm
[(There)-576(w)27(ere)-575(sev)28(eral)-588(more)-575(attempts)-573(to)-574(write)-575(programs)-586(that)-561(pro)27(v)27(ed)-562(theorems)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(\\heuristically",)-373(to)-347(some)-347(exten)27(t)-334(trying)-346(to)-347(imitate)-360(h)26(uman)-334(though)26(t,)-334(but)-335(in)-348(the)-335(end)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(these)-348(programs)-345(could)-348(not)-348(comp)-26(ete)-348(with)-348(an)-334(algorithmic)-373(searc)28(h.)]TJ
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 231.84 Tm
(21)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 228.12 Tm
[(It)-294(is)-294(true)-294(that)-293(sev)27(eral)-307(other)-293(approac)28(hes)-308(ha)26(v)27(e)-281(b)-27(een)-295(dev)27(elop)-27(ed,)-295(and)-295(ha)27(v)27(e)-295(succeeded)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(on)-415(some)-413(problems.)-428(W)80(e)-401(note)-415(in)-415(particular)-414(the)-415(successes)-427(of)-414(A)27(CL2)-415([20])-428(and)-415(RRL)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[([59])-387(on)-375(problems)-387(in)26(v)27(olving)-374(mathematical)-386(induction,)-376(and)-375(regret)-373(that)-374(our)-374(limited)]TJ
T*
[(space)-334(and)-335(scop)-27(e)-334(do)-335(not)-321(p)-27(ermit)-333(a)-334(fuller)-348(discussion)-348(of)-347(alternativ)29(e)-335(approac)28(hes.)-348(The)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(author)-414(is)-441(partial)-427(to)-427(approac)27(hes)-428(deriv)27(ed)-416(from)-440(the)-415(branc)27(h)-415(of)-428(mathematical)-439(logic)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(kno)27(wn)-335(as)-347(\\pro)-26(of)-347(theory";)-347(in)-335(the)-335(USSR)-322(this)-347(approac)27(h)-335(w)27(as)-347(follo)28(w)26(ed)-375(early)-333(on,)-348(and)]TJ
T*
[(an)-375(algorithm)-399(closely)-401(related)-387(to)-387(resolution)-400(w)26(as)-387(in)26(v)28(en)26(ted)-362(b)27(y)-375(Maslo)29(v)-402(at)-374(ab)-26(out)-388(the)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(same)-280(time)-266(as)-267(resolution)-280(w)27(as)-280(in)26(v)27(en)26(ted.)-254(A)-268(theorem-pro)28(v)28(er)-254(based)-268(on)-268(these)-267(principles)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(w)27(as)-347(built)-349(in)-335(Leningrad)-349((1971).)-372(See)-335([68])-360(for)-361(further)-333(details)-361(and)-335(references.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
20 0 obj
<<
/Length 7937
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 134.76 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(18)-2662(Mic)26(hael)-361(Beeson)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
11.95517 0 0 11.95517 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(8)-1506(Kinds)-382(of)-372(Mathematical)-391(Reasoning)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 641.4 Tm
[(In)-374(this)-374(section,)-362(w)25(e)-361(abandon)-362(the)-373(historical)-351(approac)24(h)-349(to)-362(the)-373(sub)-61(ject.)-373(Instead,)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(w)24(e)-445(examine)-433(the)-458(mec)25(hanization)-434(of)-446(mathematics)-446(b)24(y)-446(taking)-434(in)24(v)25(en)24(tory)-422(of)-458(the)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(mathematics)-422(to)-422(b)-24(e)-422(mec)25(hanized.)-421(Let)-422(us)-422(mak)24(e)-409(a)-422(rough)-410(taxonom)24(y)-397(of)-422(mathe-)]TJ
T*
[(matics.)-278(Of)-289(course)-265(librarians)-267(and)-289(journal)-265(editors)-278(are)-277(accustomed)-265(to)-290(classifying)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(mathematics)-386(b)24(y)-374(sub)-60(ject)-386(matter,)-386(but)-386(that)-387(is)-386(not)-385(what)-374(w)25(e)-386(ha)25(v)24(e)-373(in)-386(mind.)-386(In-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(stead,)-266(w)25(e)-265(prop)-24(ose)-253(to)-278(classify)-253(mathematics)-278(b)24(y)-265(the)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
21.25942 0 Td
[(kind)-301(of)-313(pr)49(o)48(ofs)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
6.09477 0 Td
[(that)-266(are)-265(used.)]TJ
-27.35419 -1.19245 TD
[(W)84(e)-336(can)-325(distinguish)-339(at)-326(least)-338(the)-337(follo)24(wing)-313(categories:)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
0.69861 -2.28855 TD
<0F>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
[(Purely)-325(logical)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
-0.99974 -1.21654 TD
<0F>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
[(Simple)-337(theory)84(,)-326(as)-325(in)-338(geometry)-313(\(one)-337(kind)-338(of)-325(ob)-60(ject,)-337(few)-337(relations\))]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
-0.99974 -1.21654 TD
<0F>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
[(Equational,)-313(as)-326(in)-337(the)-337(Robbins)-338(problem,)-326(or)-325(in)-326(group)-325(or)-326(ring)-313(theory)83(.)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
-0.99974 -1.21654 TD
<0F>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
[(Uses)-338(calculations,)-313(as)-326(in)-337(algebra)-313(or)-314(calculus)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
-0.99974 -1.21654 TD
<0F>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
[(Uses)-338(natural)-314(n)24(um)24(b)-24(ers)-326(and)-337(mathematical)-326(induction)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
-0.99974 -1.21654 TD
<0F>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
[(Uses)-338(de\fnitions)-326(\(p)-24(erhaps)-338(lots)-326(of)-326(them\))]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
-0.99974 -1.21655 TD
<0F>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
[(Uses)-362(a)-361(little)-386(n)24(um)24(b)-24(er)-362(theory)-362(and)-361(simple)-374(set)-362(theory)-362(\(as)-362(in)-373(undergraduate)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(algebra)-313(courses\))]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
-0.99974 -1.21654 TD
<0F>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
[(Uses)-338(inequalities)-325(hea)24(vily)-313(\(as)-338(in)-337(analysis\))]TJ
-0.19272 -2.26446 TD
[(Purely)-445(logical)-446(theorems)-458(are)-458(more)-458(in)24(teresting)-447(than)-470(ma)24(y)-457(app)-24(ear)-458(at)-458(\frst)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(blush.)-410(One)-385(is)-410(not)-398(restricted)-387(to)-398(logical)-385(systems)-399(based)-398(on)-397(resolution)-387(just)-410(b)-24(e-)]TJ
T*
[(cause)-277(one)-276(is)-278(using)-278(a)-289(theorem-pro)23(v)25(er)-241(that)-290(w)24(orks)-266(that)-278(w)25(a)24(y)84(.)-277(There)-276(are)-265(h)24(undreds)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(of)-410(in)24(teresting)-386(logical)-397(systems,)-399(including)-398(v)61(arious)-399(axiom)-385(systems)-399(for)-398(classical)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(prop)-25(ositional)-386(logic,)-397(m)24(ulti-v)60(alued)-410(logic,)-397(mo)-24(dal)-397(logic,)-397(in)24(tuitionistic)-412(logic,)-397(etc.)]TJ
T*
[(All)-325(of)-325(these)-314(can)-325(b)-24(e)-325(analyzed)-312(using)-314(the)-325(follo)24(wing)-301(metho)-24(d.)-338(W)85(e)-325(use)-313(a)-313(predicate)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
0 -1.19245 TD
(P)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.78292 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56612 0 Td
[(\))-338(to)-313(stand)-326(for)-314(\\)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
6.67293 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.87928 0 Td
[(is)-326(pro)24(v)60(able".)-301(W)85(e)-325(use)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
9.19034 0 Td
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.3493 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
[(x;)-169(y)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.54176 0 Td
[(\))-326(to)-325(mean)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.5771 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.89133 0 Td
(implies)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
3.38465 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
[(.)-325(Then,)]TJ
-30.13659 -1.2045 TD
[(for)-265(example,)-265(w)24(e)-276(can)-265(write)-265(do)24(wn)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
13.86379 0 Td
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.78292 0 Td
(P)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.78293 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
(\))Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
0.096 Tc
<6A00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.25268 0 Td
0 Tc
(P)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.78292 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.3493 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
[(x;)-169(y)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.54176 0 Td
(\)\))Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.77088 0 Td
(j)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.27703 0 Td
(P)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.78292 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
[(\))-290(to)-277(express)-254(\\if)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
6.62475 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.84315 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
-31.67835 -1.19246 TD
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.3493 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
[(x;)-169(y)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.54176 0 Td
[(\))-338(are)-313(pro)24(v)60(able,)-313(so)-325(is)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
8.88921 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
[(.")-313(When)-337(\(a)-326(commonly-used)-325(v)60(arian)24(t)-314(of)-72(\))-338(resolution)]TJ
-11.69569 -1.2045 TD
[(is)-278(used)-277(with)-277(this)-278(axiom,)-265(it)-290(will)-277(ha)25(v)24(e)-253(the)-289(same)-265(e\013ect)-277(as)-265(an)-277(inference)-277(rule)-265(called)]TJ
T*
[(\\condensed)-252(detac)24(hmen)24(t")-265(that)-266(has)-266(long)-264(b)-25(een)-264(used)-265(b)24(y)-265(logicians.)-253(W)84(e)-276(will)-265(return)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(to)-313(this)-327(discussion)-314(near)-301(the)-326(end)-325(of)-313(the)-325(pap)-25(er,)-313(in)-325(the)-326(section)-313(on)-313(\\Searc)24(hing)-289(for)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(pro)-25(ofs".)]TJ
1.50563 -1.21654 TD
[(Euclidean)-300(geometry)-289(can)-313(b)-24(e)-313(form)23(ulated)-313(in)-313(a)-301(\frst-order)-292(theory)-301(with)-326(a)-301(sim-)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(ple,)-433(natural)-423(set)-434(of)-422(axioms.)-422(In)-434(fact,)-433(it)-435(can)-421(b)-24(e)-433(form)23(ulated)-421(in)-434(a)-434(theory)-422(all)-421(of)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(whose)-313(v)60(ariables)-301(stand)-327(for)-313(p)-24(oin)24(ts;)-314(direct)-326(references)-301(to)-314(lines)-325(and)-313(planes)-314(can)-313(b)-24(e)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(eliminated)-410([97].)-409(But)-410(that)-410(is)-410(not)-410(imp)-24(ortan)23(t|w)24(e)-409(could)-409(use)-410(unary)-398(predicates)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(for)-290(p)-24(oin)24(ts,)-302(lines,)-301(and)-289(planes,)-290(or)-289(w)24(e)-288(could)-301(use)-290(three)-301(\\sorts")-267(of)-301(v)61(ariables.)-290(What)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(w)24(e)-337(cannot)-337(do)-337(in)-337(suc)23(h)-337(a)-337(theory)-338(is)-338(men)25(tion)-338(arbitrary)-315(sets)-338(of)-338(p)-24(oin)24(ts;)-350(therefore,)]TJ
T*
[(the)-277(con)24(tin)24(uit)23(y)-265(axiom)-265(\(discussed)-278(ab)-24(o)24(v)24(e\))-253(cannot)-265(b)-24(e)-277(stated)-278(in)-277(suc)24(h)-265(a)-265(theory)84(.)-277(W)84(e)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(can)-409(state)-411(some)-409(instances)-411(of)-409(the)-422(con)25(tin)23(uit)24(y)-410(axiom)-409(\(for)-411(example,)-409(that)-422(a)-410(line)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(segmen)24(t)-265(with)-265(one)-265(end)-277(inside)-265(a)-265(circle)-265(and)-265(one)-252(end)-277(outside)-266(the)-277(circle)-252(m)24(ust)-278(meet)]TJ
T*
[(the)-374(circle\);)-373(or)-362(w)25(e)-373(could)-374(ev)25(en)-361(consider)-362(a)-373(theory)-362(with)-374(an)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
24.63202 0 Td
[(axiom)-397(schema)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
6.55248 0 Td
(\(in\f-)Tj
-31.1845 -1.19245 TD
[(nitely)-337(man)24(y)-338(axioms)-325(of)-326(a)-337(recognizable)-312(form\))-338(stating)-339(the)-337(con)24(tin)24(uit)23(y)-325(axiom)-325(for)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(all)-289(\frst-order)-267(de\fnable)-301(sets.)-290(But)-289(if)-302(w)25(e)-289(are)-289(in)24(terested)-290(in)-289(Euclid's)-289(prop)-25(ositions,)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
21 0 obj
<<
/Length 9430
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 290.52 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(The)-335(Mec)27(hanization)-361(of)-361(Mathematics)-2674(19)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(extremely)-398(complex)-396(forms)-387(of)-397(the)-410(con)24(tin)24(uit)23(y)-397(axiom)-385(will)-410(not)-398(b)-24(e)-409(necessary{w)24(e)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(can)-253(consider)-241(a)-253(simple)-265(theory)-254(of)-252(geometry)-242(instead.)-253(It)-266(will)-265(not)-253(pro)24(v)24(e)-241(all)-253(the)-265(the-)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
[(orems)-350(one)-361(could)-373(pro)24(v)24(e)-337(with)-374(the)-373(full)-374(\frst-order)-352(con)25(tin)23(uit)24(y)-361(axiom,)-350(but)-374(w)25(ould)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(b)-24(e)-409(su\016cien)24(t)-410(for)-398(Euclid.)-409(On)-398(the)-410(other)-398(hand,)-409(if)-410(w)25(e)-410(wish)-397(to)-410(pro)23(v)24(e)-385(a)-397(theorem)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(ab)-24(out)-290(all)-277(regular)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
7.50403 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
[(-gons,)-266(the)-289(concept)-276(of)-289(natural)-266(n)24(um)24(b)-25(er)-289(will)-277(b)-24(e)-289(required,)-277(and)]TJ
-8.10629 -1.19245 TD
[(pro)-25(ofs)-289(b)24(y)-313(mathematical)-290(induction)-313(will)-313(so)-25(on)-289(arise.)-289(In)-314(\frst-order)-279(geometry)84(,)-289(w)24(e)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(w)24(ould)-349(ha)24(v)24(e)-325(one)-349(theorem)-337(for)-350(a)-337(square,)-338(another)-338(for)-337(a)-350(p)-24(en)25(tagon,)-338(another)-338(for)-337(a)]TJ
T*
[(hexagon,)-397(and)-397(so)-398(on.)-410(Of)-409(course)-386(not)-410(only)-410(Euclidean,)-396(but)-410(also)-398(non-Euclidean)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(geometry)84(,)-421(can)-434(b)-24(e)-445(form)23(ulated)-421(in)-446(a)-422(\frst-order)-424(theory)84(.)-421(I)-434(kno)24(w)-434(of)-433(no)-434(w)25(ork)-422(in)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(automated)-434(deduction)-446(in)-458(non-Euclidean)-420(geometry)84(,)-434(but)-446(there)-446(exists)-447(at)-434(least)]TJ
T*
[(one)-385(in)24(teresting)-387(op)-24(en)-397(problem)-386(in)-397(h)24(yp)-24(erb)-25(olic)-385(geometry)-373(whose)-386(solution)-386(migh)24(t)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(b)-24(e)-337(p)-24(ossible)-326(with)-338(automated)-337(deduction.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 303.72 538.32 Tm
(22)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 149.76 520.68 Tm
[(Another)-229(example)-241(of)-240(a)-229(simple)-242(theory)-229(is)-241(ring)-230(theory)84(.)-241(Ring)-228(theory)-230(is)-241(a)-241(sub)-61(ject)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(commonly)-277(taugh)24(t)-290(in)-289(the)-301(\frst)-279(y)25(ear)-278(of)-289(abstract)-278(algebra.)-265(The)-288(\\ring)-278(axioms")-265(use)]TJ
T*
[(the)-229(sym)23(b)-24(ols)-217(+)-217(and)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
8.16651 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.50589 0 Td
[(,)-217(and)-217(include)-228(most)-230(of)-217(the)-229(familiar)-217(la)24(ws)-217(ab)-24(out)-229(them,)-229(except)]TJ
-8.6724 -1.19245 TD
[(the)-253(\\m)24(ultiplicativ)23(e)-228(in)24(v)24(erse")-217(la)24(w)-241(and)-240(the)-254(\\comm)25(utativ)23(e)-228(la)24(w)-229(of)-241(m)24(ultiplication",)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
0 -1.2045 TD
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.84315 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.77088 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.93951 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.18041 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.79497 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.78292 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56612 0 Td
[(.)-410(Man)24(y)-409(sp)-25(eci\fc)-409(systems)-399(of)-409(mathematical)-410(ob)-60(jects)-398(satisfy)-411(these)]TJ
-5.87796 -1.19245 TD
[(la)24(ws,)-385(and)-398(ma)24(y)-397(or)-386(ma)24(y)-398(not)-397(satisfy)-399(additional)-398(la)24(ws)-386(suc)24(h)-397(as)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
26.02924 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.84315 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.77088 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.91542 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.16836 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.79497 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.77088 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
0.41 Tc
(.A)Tj
-31.85902 -1.2045 TD
0 Tc
[(system)-242(of)-241(ob)-60(jects,)-241(with)-254(t)24(w)24(o)-228(giv)24(en)-229(\(but)-254(p)-24(ossibly)-242(arbitrarily)-218(de\fned\))-253(op)-24(erations)]TJ
T*
[(to)-326(b)-24(e)-337(denoted)-337(b)24(y)-325(the)-325(sym)23(b)-24(ols)-326(+)-325(and)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
16.32097 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.50589 0 Td
[(,)-325(is)-338(called)-325(a)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
5.27571 0 Td
(ring)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
2.08379 0 Td
[(if)-325(all)-338(the)-325(ring)-326(axioms)]TJ
-24.18636 -1.19246 TD
[(hold)-289(when)-289(the)-289(v)60(ariables)-277(range)-265(o)24(v)24(er)-277(these)-278(ob)-60(jects)-289(and)-289(+)-277(and)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
26.06538 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.78293 0 Td
[(are)-277(in)24(terpreted)]TJ
-26.8483 -1.2045 TD
[(as)-398(the)-410(giv)25(en)-398(op)-24(erations.)-386(In)-410(ring)-398(theory)84(,)-398(one)-397(tries)-398(to)-410(pro)23(v)24(e)-385(a)-397(theorem)-398(using)]TJ
T*
[(only)-373(the)-398(ring)-374(axioms;)-362(if)-397(one)-373(succeeds,)-374(the)-385(theorem)-386(will)-385(b)-24(e)-385(true)-374(in)-386(all)-385(rings.)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(Ho)24(w)25(ev)24(er,)-313(in)-325(b)-25(o)-24(oks)-325(on)-325(ring)-326(theory)-326(one)-325(\fnds)-326(man)25(y)-326(theorems)-326(ab)-24(out)-325(rings)-327(that)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(are)-229(not)-253(form)23(ulated)-241(purely)-241(in)-241(the)-253(language)-228(of)-241(ring)-242(theory)84(.)-229(These)-240(theorems)-242(ha)24(v)24(e)]TJ
T*
[(a)-253(larger)-229(con)24(text:)-253(they)-265(deal)-253(with)-265(rings)-242(and)-253(subrings,)-243(with)-265(homomorphisms)-242(and)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(isomorphisms)-279(of)-301(rings,)-278(and)-302(with)-301(matrix)-290(rings.)-290(Homomorphisms)-278(are)-290(functions)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(from)-458(one)-458(ring)-446(to)-470(another)-446(that)-459(preserv)24(e)-446(sums)-459(and)-457(pro)-25(ducts;)-458(isomorphisms)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(are)-313(one-to-one)-301(homomorphisms;)-315(subrings)-315(are)-313(subsets)-327(of)-325(a)-313(ring)-326(that)-326(are)-313(rings)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(in)-373(their)-375(o)25(wn)-362(righ)24(t;)-362(matrix)-362(rings)-362(are)-362(rings)-362(whose)-361(elemen)25(ts)-375(are)-349(matrices)-362(with)]TJ
T*
[(co)-24(e\016cien)25(ts)-326(dra)24(wn)-325(from)-326(a)-325(giv)24(en)-325(ring.)-314(Th)25(us)-338(passing)-314(from)-326(a)-325(ring)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
27.52282 0 Td
(R)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.0961 0 Td
[(to)-338(the)-337(ring)]TJ
-28.61892 -1.19245 TD
(of)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.24063 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.03587 0 Td
-0.024 Tc
(by)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.49358 0 Td
0 Tc
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.03587 0 Td
[(matrices)-422(with)-446(co)-24(e\016cien)25(ts)-423(in)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
12.92429 0 Td
(R)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.2045 0 Td
[(is)-434(a)-422(metho)-24(d)-446(of)-433(constructing)-423(one)]TJ
-18.93474 -1.2045 TD
[(ring)-422(from)-422(another.)-410(If,)-434(ho)24(w)24(ev)25(er,)-410(w)24(e)-421(wish)-422(to)-422(consider)-422(suc)24(h)-422(rings)-410(of)-434(matrices)]TJ
T*
[(for)-482(an)24(y)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
3.74599 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
[(,)-482(then)-506(the)-494(concept)-493(of)-494(natural)-483(n)24(um)24(b)-24(er)-494(en)24(ters)-483(again,)-481(and)-482(w)24(e)-493(are)]TJ
-4.34825 -1.19245 TD
[(b)-24(ey)24(ond)-289(the)-301(simple)-290(theory)-289(lev)24(el.)-289(Also,)-289(if)-301(w)24(e)-289(wish)-289(to)-301(form)23(ulate)-277(theorems)-290(ab)-24(out)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(arbitrary)-267(subrings)-290(of)-290(a)-288(ring,)-290(again)-277(w)24(e)-288(ha)24(v)24(e)-277(a)-289(theory)-289(that)-302(\(at)-290(least)-290(on)-289(the)-301(face)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(of)-410(it\))-434(is)-410(second-order.)-386(A)-422(recen)25(t)-410(master's)-399(thesis)-423([54])-397(w)24(en)24(t)-422(through)-398(a)-409(t)23(ypical)]TJ
ET
q
56.76 0 0 -0.48 134.748 216.948 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 210 Tm
(22)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 206.16 Tm
[(The)-415(op)-27(en)-429(problem)-415(is)-427(this:)-428(Giv)27(en)-416(a)-428(line)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
18.3084 0 Td
(L)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.11082 0 Td
[(and)-429(a)-414(p)-27(oin)26(t)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
5.7816 0 Td
(P)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.21788 0 Td
[(not)-414(on)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
3.39937 0 Td
(L)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.69593 0 Td
[(,)-428(pro)27(v)27(e)-415(that)]TJ
-30.514 -1.21788 TD
[(there)-334(exist)-347(a)-361(pair)-347(of)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
9.20773 0 Td
[(limiting)-362(p)53(ar)54(al)-53(lels)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
7.7891 0 Td
(to)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.25803 0 Td
(L)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.0439 0 Td
(through)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
3.89455 0 Td
(P)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.803 0 Td
[(.)-335(The)-348(de\fnition)-349(of)-361(limiting)]TJ
-23.99632 -1.23127 TD
[(parallel)-401(sa)28(ys)-401(that)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
8.1906 0 Td
(K)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.33833 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
2.03427 0 Td
(R)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.17773 0 Td
[(form)-400(a)-388(pair)-401(of)-387(limiting)-414(parallels)-401(to)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
16.03323 0 Td
(L)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.08405 0 Td
(through)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
4.30943 0 Td
(P)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.19112 0 Td
(if)Tj
-35.35876 -1.21788 TD
[(one)-388(of)-414(the)-375(four)-401(angles)-414(formed)-401(at)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
15.10978 0 Td
(P)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.19112 0 Td
-0.026 Tc
(by)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.48555 0 Td
0 Tc
(K)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.32495 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
2.04765 0 Td
(R)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.17773 0 Td
[(do)-27(es)-401(not)-401(con)27(tain)-388(an)27(y)-388(ra)28(y)-388(that)]TJ
-22.33678 -1.21788 TD
[(do)-27(es)-294(not)-294(meet)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
6.5043 0 Td
(L)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.69593 0 Td
[(.)-294(It)-281(is)-307(kno)27(wn)-282(that)-293(limiting)-307(parallels)-307(exist,)-307(but)-268(no)-294(\frst-order)-293(pro)-26(of)]TJ
-7.20023 -1.23127 TD
[(is)-348(kno)27(wn,)-335(and)-335(exp)-27(erts)-333(tell)-348(me)-347(that)-334(pro)-26(ducing)-336(a)-347(\frst-order)-333(pro)-26(of)-361(w)27(ould)-335(b)-28(e)-348(w)27(orth)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(a)-348(Ph.)-348(D.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
22 0 obj
<<
/Length 8693
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 134.76 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(20)-2662(Mic)26(hael)-361(Beeson)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(algebra)-325(textb)-25(o)-24(ok)-337([56],)-325(and)-337(found)-350(that)-350(of)-337(ab)-24(out)-338(150)-325(exercises)-325(on)-337(ring)-338(theory)84(,)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(14)-289(could)-301(b)-24(e)-313(straigh)23(tforw)24(ardly)-266(formalized)-289(in)-301(\frst-order)-280(ring)-301(theory)84(.)-289(One)-301(more)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
[(could)-433(b)-25(e)-445(form)24(ulated)-434(using)-434(a)-434(single)-434(natural-n)23(um)24(b)-24(er)-422(v)61(ariable)-434(in)-446(addition)-434(to)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(the)-410(ring)-386(axioms.)-385(The)-397(rest)-399(w)24(ere)-385(more)-397(complex.)-397(The)-397(14)-386(\frst-order)-375(exercises,)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(ho)24(w)25(ev)24(er,)-277(could)-301(b)-24(e)-301(pro)24(v)24(ed)-277(b)24(y)-301(the)-314(theorem-pro)24(ving)-265(program)-278(Otter.)-302(\(Otter)-291(is)-301(a)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(w)24(ell-kno)25(wn)-362(and)-373(widely)-385(used)-374(mo)-24(dern)-373(theorem)-374(pro)24(v)24(er,)-362(describ)-24(ed)-374(in)-373([70],)-373(and)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(readily)-325(a)24(v)60(ailable)-313(on)-325(the)-337(W)84(eb.\))]TJ
1.50563 -1.58994 TD
[(A)-421(great)-422(man)24(y)-422(mathematical)-422(pro)-24(ofs)-422(seem)-422(to)-422(dep)-24(end)-445(on)-422(calculations)-409(for)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(some)-398(of)-397(the)-410(steps.)-398(In)-410(fact,)-398(t)24(ypically)-398(a)-397(mathematical)-398(pro)-24(of)-398(consists)-387(of)-397(some)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(parts)-435(that)-459(are)-433(calculations,)-434(and)-434(some)-445(parts)-435(that)-447(are)-434(logical)-433(inferences.)-445(Of)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(course,)-410(it)-434(is)-422(p)-24(ossible)-434(to)-422(recast)-411(calculations)-421(as)-410(logical)-409(pro)-25(ofs,)-422(and)-421(it)-434(is)-423(p)-24(os-)]TJ
T*
[(sible)-446(to)-446(recast)-422(logical)-433(pro)-25(ofs)-434(as)-434(calculations.)-434(But)-446(there)-446(is)-446(an)-433(in)24(tuitiv)23(e)-446(dis-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(tinction:)-374(a)-373(calculation)-361(pro)-25(ceeds)-361(in)-373(a)-362(straigh)23(tforw)24(ard)-338(manner,)-374(one)-361(step)-374(after)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(another,)-410(applying)-410(ob)24(vious)-397(rules)-411(at)-410(eac)25(h)-409(step,)-423(un)24(til)-422(the)-421(answ)23(er)-397(is)-410(obtained.)]TJ
T*
[(While)-421(p)-24(erforming)-411(a)-421(calculation,)-409(one)-410(needs)-421(to)-422(b)-24(e)-421(careful,)-410(but)-434(one)-409(do)-24(es)-422(not)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(need)-313(to)-325(b)-24(e)-313(a)-313(genius,)-314(once)-312(one)-313(has)-314(\fgured)-313(out)-314(what)-313(calculation)-313(to)-313(mak)24(e.)-301(It)-326(is)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(\\merely)-313(a)-325(calculation.")-313(When)-337(\fnding)-337(a)-313(pro)-25(of,)-325(one)-325(needs)-325(insigh)23(t,)-325(exp)-24(erience,)]TJ
T*
[(in)24(telligence{ev)25(en)-288(genius{to)-302(succeed,)-300(b)-25(ecause)-312(the)-314(searc)24(h)-289(space)-301(is)-313(to)-25(o)-301(large)-289(for)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(a)-325(systematic)-327(searc)24(h)-313(to)-337(succeed.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.58994 TD
[(It)-302(is)-314(not)-301(surprising)-291(that)-314(a)-301(go)-24(o)-24(d)-301(deal)-301(of)-301(progress)-279(has)-301(b)-25(een)-312(made)-301(in)-313(mec)24(ha-)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(nizing)-289(those)-277(parts)-279(of)-289(pro)-24(of)-278(that)-289(are)-265(calculations.)-278(It)-290(ma)25(y)-277(b)-25(e)-288(sligh)23(tly)-277(surprising)]TJ
T*
[(that)-326(metho)-24(ds)-338(ha)24(v)24(e)-313(b)-24(een)-325(found)-337(for)-314(automatically)-313(disco)24(v)24(ering)-301(new)-325(rules)-326(to)-314(b)-24(e)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(used)-338(for)-325(calculations.)-326(F)84(urthermore,)-326(the)-338(relations)-326(b)-24(et)24(w)24(een)-324(the)-350(computational)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(parts)-266(of)-265(pro)-25(ofs)-265(and)-265(the)-278(logical)-252(parts)-266(ha)24(v)24(e)-253(b)-24(een)-276(explored)-265(to)-265(some)-266(exten)25(t.)-278(Ho)25(w-)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(ev)24(er,)-301(there)-313(is)-314(still)-314(some)-302(w)25(ork)-302(to)-313(b)-24(e)-313(done)-313(b)-24(efore)-301(this)-326(sub)-61(ject)-313(is)-314(\fnished,)-314(as)-301(w)24(e)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(will)-337(discuss)-327(in)-337(more)-325(detail)-326(b)-24(elo)25(w.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.58994 TD
[(One)-337(asp)-24(ect)-350(of)-349(mathematics)-350(that)-350(has)-338(not)-349(b)-25(een)-360(adequately)-337(mec)24(hanized)-336(at)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(the)-470(presen)24(t)-458(time)-470(is)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
9.0217 0 Td
(de\fnitions)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
4.51687 0 Td
[(.)-470(Let)-470(me)-470(giv)25(e)-458(a)-457(few)-470(examples)-457(of)-458(the)-470(use)-470(of)]TJ
-13.53858 -1.19246 TD
[(de\fnitions)-386(in)-374(mathematics.)-374(The)-385(concept)-373(\\)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
18.63361 0 Td
(f)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.97565 0 Td
[(is)-374(con)25(tin)23(uous)-362(at)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
7.37154 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56612 0 Td
[(",)-373(where)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.0953 0 Td
(f)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.97565 0 Td
(is)Tj
-32.61786 -1.2045 TD
[(a)-421(real-v)59(alued)-397(function,)-434(has)-410(a)-409(w)24(ell-kno)24(wn)-409(de\fnition:)-422(\\for)-410(ev)25(ery)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
28.11303 0 Td
0.421 Tc
<0F3E>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
2.0356 0 Td
0 Tc
[(0)-409(there)]TJ
-30.14863 -1.2045 TD
(exists)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
2.77035 0 Td
0.325 Tc
<0E3E>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.84288 0 Td
0 Tc
[(0)-337(suc)24(h)-326(that)-350(for)-337(all)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
8.21469 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.86724 0 Td
(with)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
2.2765 0 Td
(j)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.27704 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.75883 0 Td
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
(j)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.57816 0 Td
0.289 Tc
<3C0E>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.55381 0 Td
-0.024 Tc
[(,)-361(we)-361(h)-24(ave)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
4.40847 0 Td
0 Tc
(j)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.27703 0 Td
(f)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
(\))Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.6143 0 Td
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.01178 0 Td
(f)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
(\))Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(j)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.56612 0 Td
0.289 Tc
<3C0F>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.48153 0 Td
0 Tc
(.")Tj
-32.5215 -1.19245 TD
[(One)-349(imp)-24(ortan)23(t)-350(virtue)-350(of)-349(this)-362(de\fnition)-362(is)-350(that)-362(it)-350(sw)24(eeps)-349(the)-362(quan)24(ti\fers)-338(\\for)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(ev)24(ery")-469(and)-482(\\there)-470(exists")-483(under)-482(the)-482(rug:)-482(W)84(e)-493(are)-470(able)-482(to)-482(w)25(ork)-470(with)-495(con-)]TJ
T*
[(tin)24(uit)23(y)-446(in)-433(a)-434(quan)24(ti\fer-free)-422(con)24(text.)-434(If,)-446(for)-434(example,)-433(w)24(e)-433(wish)-446(to)-434(pro)24(v)24(e)-422(that)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
0 -1.19245 TD
(f)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
0.41 Tc
[(\)=)1(\()]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
2.37286 0 Td
0 Tc
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.84315 0 Td
0.277 Tc
[(+3)277(\))]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 201.72 251.64 Tm
0 Tc
(100)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 218.16 248.04 Tm
[(is)-410(a)-409(con)24(tin)24(uous)-398(function,)-410(the)-422(\\easy)-385(w)24(a)24(y")-397(is)-410(to)-398(recognize)]TJ
-8.37127 -1.2045 TD
(that)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
2.07174 0 Td
(f)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.84315 0 Td
[(is)-229(a)-241(comp)-24(osition)-230(of)-241(t)24(w)24(o)-228(con)24(tin)24(uous)-218(functions)-253(and)-229(app)-24(eal)-241(to)-229(the)-241(theorem)]TJ
-2.91489 -1.19245 TD
[(that)-386(the)-374(comp)-24(osition)-374(of)-385(t)23(w)25(o)-362(con)25(tin)23(uous)-373(functions)-375(is)-386(con)25(tin)23(uous.)-362(That)-373(theo-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(rem,)-301(ho)24(w)24(ev)25(er,)-278(has)-289(to)-302(b)-24(e)-313(pro)24(v)24(ed)-289(b)24(y)-289(expanding)-301(the)-301(de\fnitions)-314(and)-289(using)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
30.96769 0 Td
<0F>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.71066 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
-31.67835 -1.2045 TD
<0E>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.4818 0 Td
[(.)-313(This)-302(kind)-313(of)-301(argumen)24(t)-302(do)-24(es)-301(not)-302(mesh)-313(w)24(ell)-301(with)-313(the)-313(clausal)-289(form)-302(paradigm)]TJ
-0.4818 -1.19246 TD
[(for)-290(automated)-289(reasoning,)-278(b)-24(ecause)-288(when)-289(the)-301(de\fnition)-302(is)-289(expanded,)-289(the)-301(result)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(in)24(v)24(olv)24(es)-313(quan)24(ti\fers.)-326(Theorem-pro)23(ving)-301(programs)-302(usually)-338(require)-313(clausal)-326(form)]TJ
T*
[(at)-410(input,)-422(and)-410(do)-397(not)-422(p)-24(erform)-399(dynamic)-409(Sk)24(olemization.)-397(Theorems)-398(that)-410(ha)24(v)24(e)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(b)-24(een)-409(pro)24(v)24(ed)-398(ab)-24(out)-410(con)25(tin)23(uit)24(y)-397(ha)24(v)24(e,)-397(therefore,)-398(had)-410(the)-410(de\fnition-expansion)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(and)-349(Sk)24(olemization)-337(p)-24(erformed)-350(b)24(y)-337(hand)-362(b)-24(efore)-337(the)-362(automated)-349(deduction)-350(pro-)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
23 0 obj
<<
/Length 10921
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 290.52 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(The)-335(Mec)27(hanization)-361(of)-361(Mathematics)-2674(21)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(gram)-410(b)-24(egan,)-409(or)-410(ha)24(v)24(e)-409(used)-422(another)-410(paradigm)-410(\(Gen)24(tzen)-421(sequen)24(ts)-423(or)-410(natural)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(deduction\),)-350(that)-350(do)-24(es)-337(not)-350(su\013er)-338(from)-338(this)-350(problem,)-338(but)-350(is)-350(not)-337(as)-338(w)24(ell-suited)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
[(to)-362(searc)24(hing)-349(for)-362(pro)-25(ofs.)-349(Merely)-362(recognizing)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
19.17564 0 Td
(f)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
0.338 Tc
[(\)=)13(\()]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
2.21628 0 Td
0 Tc
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.81906 0 Td
0.241 Tc
[(+3)241(\))]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 390.6 645.96 Tm
0 Tc
(100)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 406.68 642.2401 Tm
[(as)-362(a)-361(comp)-24(osi-)]TJ
-27.29397 -1.19245 TD
[(tion)-326(of)-313(t)24(w)24(o)-313(functions)-314(is)-326(b)-24(ey)25(ond)-314(the)-325(reac)24(h)-301(of)-313(curren)24(t)-314(theorem-pro)23(v)24(ers{it)-278(is)-313(an)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(application)-325(of)-338(the)-337(author's)-315(curren)24(t)-326(researc)24(h)-301(in)24(to)-338(\\second-order)-289(uni\fcation".)]TJ
1.50563 -1.19245 TD
[(One)-373(migh)24(t)-374(w)24(ell)-373(lo)-24(ok,)-373(therefore,)-362(for)-374(the)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
17.48934 0 Td
(simplest)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
3.87849 0 Td
[(example)-373(of)-373(a)-373(de\fnition.)]TJ
-22.87346 -1.2045 TD
[(Consider)-446(the)-470(de\fnition)-458(of)-458(a)-457(\\comm)24(utator")-435(in)-470(group)-446(theory)84(.)-446(The)-457(notation)]TJ
T*
[(usually)-302(used)-313(for)-302(a)-301(comm)25(utator)-303(is)-301([)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
14.85148 0 Td
[(x;)-169(y)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.54176 0 Td
[(],)-313(but)-326(to)-301(a)24(v)24(oid)-289(notational)-302(complexities,)]TJ
-16.39324 -1.19245 TD
[(let)-349(us)-350(use)-350(the)-349(notation)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
10.26234 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.80701 0 Td
(\n)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.01178 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
[(.)-337(The)-361(de\fnition)-350(is)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
8.17855 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.80701 0 Td
(\n)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.84315 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.072 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F13 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 384.6 574.2 Tm
<00>Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.89477 0 Td
(1)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 395.4 570.6 Tm
(y)Tj
/F13 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 400.68 574.2 Tm
<00>Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.89477 0 Td
(1)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 411.36 570.6 Tm
(xy)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.09609 0 Td
[(,)-349(where)-349(as)]TJ
-28.85982 -1.2045 TD
[(usual)-350(w)25(e)-349(lea)24(v)24(e)-337(the)-361(sym)23(b)-24(ol)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
11.81614 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.8552 0 Td
[(for)-350(the)-349(group)-350(op)-24(eration)-338(un)24(written,)-350(and)-361(assume)]TJ
-12.67134 -1.2045 TD
[(that)-242(asso)-25(ciation)-216(is)-242(to)-229(the)-241(righ)24(t,)-230(i.e.)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
14.85148 0 Td
(abc)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.66221 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.05996 0 Td
(a)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(bc)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.86724 0 Td
[(\).)-241(W)84(e)-240(can)-229(\fnd)-241(problems)-230(in)-241(group)]TJ
-19.35631 -1.19245 TD
[(theory)-314(that)-338(men)24(tion)-325(comm)24(utators)-315(but)-338(do)-325(not)-325(need)-325(second-order)-302(concepts)-325(or)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(natural)-483(n)24(um)24(b)-24(ers)-482(for)-483(their)-494(form)23(ulation)-470(or)-482(solution.)-483(Here)-493(w)24(e)-481(ha)24(v)24(e)-470(a)-481(single)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(de\fnition)-314(added)-312(to)-314(a)-301(simple)-314(theory)84(.)-313(No)24(w)-300(the)-326(p)-24(oin)24(t)-313(is)-302(that)-326(sometimes)-302(w)24(e)-313(will)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(need)-421(to)-410(recognize)-396(complicated)-409(expressions)-387(as)-410(b)-24(eing)-409(actually)-410(\\nothing)-410(but")]TJ
T*
[(a)-361(comm)24(utator.)-350(Long)-350(expressions)-351(b)-24(ecome)-360(short)-351(ones)-361(when)-361(written)-374(using)-362(the)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(comm)24(utator)-338(notation.)-350(On)-350(the)-361(other)-338(hand,)-361(sometimes)-351(w)25(e)-349(will)-349(not)-350(b)-24(e)-361(able)-349(to)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(solv)24(e)-229(the)-241(problem)-241(without)-254(using)-229(the)-253(de\fnition)-254(of)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
20.99443 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.61429 0 Td
(\n)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.83111 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.75883 0 Td
[(to)-241(eliminate)-241(the)-241(sym)23(b)-24(ol)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
-23.19867 -1.2045 TD
(\n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.78292 0 Td
[(.)-385(That)-398(is,)-398(sometimes)-386(the)-398(de\fnition)-398(of)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
16.95936 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.84315 0 Td
(\n)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.03587 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.91542 0 Td
[(will)-397(b)-24(e)-398(needed)-396(in)-398(the)-398(left-to-)]TJ
-20.53672 -1.19245 TD
[(righ)24(t)-218(direction,)-229(and)-229(sometimes)-229(in)-229(the)-242(righ)24(t-to-left)-218(direction.)-217(Existing)-230(theorem-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(pro)24(v)24(ers)-422(ha)24(v)24(e)-421(no)-446(metho)-24(d)-446(to)-446(con)24(trol)-422(equations)-434(with)-458(this)-447(degree)-433(of)-446(subtlet)23(y)85(.)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
(Either)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
3.16783 0 Td
(\n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.19246 0 Td
(will)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
1.98742 0 Td
(always)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
3.2642 0 Td
[(b)-24(e)-421(eliminated,)-434(or)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
8.02197 0 Td
(never)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
2.36082 0 Td
[(.)-434(This)-422(example)-408(de\fnition)-434(also)]TJ
-19.9947 -1.2045 TD
[(serv)23(es)-204(to)-230(bring)-217(out)-217(another)-218(p)-24(oin)24(t:)-229(de\fnitions)-230(can)-216(b)-24(e)-229(explicit,)-229(lik)25(e)-217(the)-241(de\fnition)]TJ
(of)'
/F9 1 Tf
1.21654 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.84315 0 Td
(\n)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.05996 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.92747 0 Td
[(giv)24(en)-409(ab)-24(o)24(v)24(e,)-385(or)-398(implicit.)-422(Cancellativ)25(e)-397(semigroups)-399(are)-398(systems)-399(lik)24(e)]TJ
-4.04712 -1.19245 TD
[(groups)-218(except)-228(that)-242(in)24(v)24(erse)-205(is)-229(replaced)-229(b)24(y)-228(the)-229(cancellation)-217(la)25(w,)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
26.48695 0 Td
(xy)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.37313 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.05996 0 Td
(xz)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.3129 0 Td
(implies)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
-30.23295 -1.2045 TD
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.8311 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.08405 0 Td
(z)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.51794 0 Td
[(.)-337(W)84(e)-361(can)-337(de\fne)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
7.11859 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.80702 0 Td
(\n)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.01178 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.86724 0 Td
[(in)-361(the)-350(con)25(text)-350(of)-338(cancellativ)25(e)-337(semigroups)-338(b)24(y)-349(the)]TJ
-12.23772 -1.2045 TD
(equation)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
4.08325 0 Td
(xy)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.37313 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.04791 0 Td
0.036 Tc
(yx)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.0961 0 Td
0 Tc
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.79497 0 Td
(\n)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.98769 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
[(\).)-326(This)-337(is)-326(an)-325(\\implicit)-326(de\fnition".)-325(If)-338(the)-325(la)24(w)-325(holds)-326(in)]TJ
-10.29847 -1.19245 TD
[(a)-325(semigroup)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
5.62501 0 Td
(S)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.67452 0 Td
[(,)-325(for)-326(some)-325(op)-24(eration)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
9.11806 0 Td
(\n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.78293 0 Td
0.325 Tc
[(,w)349(es)325(a)349(y\\)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.31211 0 Td
0 Tc
(S)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.98769 0 Td
[(admits)-338(comm)24(utators.")]TJ
-19.9947 -1.2045 TD
[(Consider)-229(the)-253(follo)24(wing)-229(three)-241(form)23(ulas,)-229(tak)24(en)-241(from)-241([41],)-229(and)-253(originally)-217(from)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.19246 TD
([64].)Tj
2.50536 -1.85493 TD
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.79497 0 Td
(\n)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
(\))Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
(\n)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(z)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.80701 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.08405 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.79497 0 Td
(\n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.74679 0 Td
(\n)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(z)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.51793 0 Td
[(\))-3337((1))]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
5.32389 0 Td
[(c)48(ommutator)-361(is)-361(asso)50(ciative)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
-15.69463 -1.49358 TD
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.79497 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.7227 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
(\))Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
(\n)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(z)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.80701 0 Td
0.301 Tc
(=\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.46949 0 Td
0 Tc
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.79497 0 Td
(\n)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(z)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.51793 0 Td
(\))Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.7227 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.74679 0 Td
(\n)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(z)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.51793 0 Td
[(\))-1000((2))]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
2.99921 0 Td
[(c)48(ommutator)-349(distributes)-360(over)-372(pr)49(o)48(duct)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
-15.59827 -1.50563 TD
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.79497 0 Td
(\n)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
(\))Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.7227 0 Td
(z)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.80701 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.08405 0 Td
(z)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.73474 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.7227 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.79497 0 Td
(\n)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
[(\))-3325((3))]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
5.32389 0 Td
[(semigr)49(oup)-373(is)-361(nilp)48(otent)-361(class)-360(2)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
-18.2 -1.84289 TD
[(These)-301(three)-301(prop)-25(erties)-290(are)-289(equiv)61(alen)24(t)-301(in)-302(groups)-290(\(in)-313(fact,)-302(in)-301(cancellativ)25(e)-289(semi-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(groups)-254(that)-290(admit)-277(comm)24(utators\).)-255(One)-277(of)-265(the)-289(p)-24(oin)24(ts)-266(of)-277(considering)-265(this)-279(exam-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(ple)-361(is)-350(that)-362(it)-374(is)-350(not)-362(clear)-349(\(to)-350(the)-361(h)24(uman)-362(mathematician\))-362(whether)-349(one)-361(ough)24(t)]TJ
T*
[(to)-410(eliminate)-409(the)-422(de\fnition)-422(of)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
13.26154 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.84315 0 Td
(\n)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.04792 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.93951 0 Td
[(to)-410(pro)24(v)24(e)-397(these)-410(theorems,)-410(or)-398(not.)-410(Otter)]TJ
-16.09212 -1.19245 TD
[(is)-350(able)-337(to)-349(pro)23(v)24(e)-325((1))-350(implies)-361((2),)-350((2))-351(implies)-349((3),)-350(and)-350((3))-350(implies)-350((1),)-350(in)-349(three)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(separate)-326(runs,)-338(in)-350(spite)-338(of)-349(not)-338(ha)25(ving)-326(a)-337(systematic)-338(w)24(a)24(y)-325(to)-337(handle)-350(de\fnitions;)]TJ
T*
[(but)-314(the)-313(pro)-25(ofs)-289(are)-301(not)-302(found)-313(easily)84(,)-301(and)-301(a)-301(lot)-302(of)-301(useless)-302(clauses)-301(are)-290(generated)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(along)-313(the)-337(w)24(a)24(y)85(.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 197.4 172.8 Tm
(23)Tj
ET
q
56.76 0 0 -0.48 134.748 162.108 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 155.16 Tm
(23)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 151.32 Tm
[(An)-255(example)-267(of)-281(the)-267(use)-268(of)-280(a)-268(de\fnition)-268(to)-267(help)-269(Otter)-253(\fnd)-255(a)-281(pro)-26(of)-281(that)-266(it)-268(cannot)-267(\fnd)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(without)-334(using)-335(a)-347(de\fnition)-323(is)-347(the)-335(pro)-26(of)-348(of)-347(the)-321(\\HCBK-1)-347(problem")-334(found)-335(recen)26(tly)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
24 0 obj
<<
/Length 8637
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 134.76 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(22)-2662(Mic)26(hael)-361(Beeson)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 149.76 666.2401 Tm
[(Another)-241(in)24(teresting)-254(problem)-242(in)24(v)24(olving)-240(comm)24(utators)-231(is)-253(often)-253(an)-253(exercise)-241(in)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(an)-253(elemen)25(tary)-230(abstract)-242(algebra)-229(course:)-241(Sho)24(w)-240(that)-254(in)-253(a)-241(group,)-241(the)-254(comm)25(utator)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
[(subgroup)-338(\(consisting)-351(of)-361(all)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
11.97273 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.80701 0 Td
(\n)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.01178 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
[(\))-362(is)-350(a)-349(normal)-350(subgroup.)-338(F)84(or)-350(the)-361(part)-350(ab)-24(out)]TJ
-14.3215 -1.19245 TD
[(normalit)23(y)84(,)-349(w)25(e)-349(ha)24(v)24(e)-337(to)-362(sho)24(w)-349(that)-350(for)-350(all)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
17.51343 0 Td
(a)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
(,)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.27703 0 Td
(b)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.43362 0 Td
[(,)-349(and)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
2.60172 0 Td
(c)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.43362 0 Td
(,)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.62634 0 Td
(c)Tj
/F13 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 362.4 633.96 Tm
<00>Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.89477 0 Td
(1)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 373.08 630.36 Tm
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(a)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.77088 0 Td
(\n)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.02382 0 Td
(b)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.43362 0 Td
(\))Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(c)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.78292 0 Td
[(has)-350(the)-361(form)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
-27.7035 -1.2045 TD
(u)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.7227 0 Td
(\n)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.92747 0 Td
(v)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.80701 0 Td
[(for)-290(some)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
3.9628 0 Td
(u)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.86724 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.91515 0 Td
(v)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.51793 0 Td
[(.)-301(Otter)-290(can)-289(\fnd)-301(sev)24(eral)-265(pro)-25(ofs)-289(of)-302(this)-290(theorem,)-289(but)-314(the)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
-9.72032 -1.19245 TD
(u)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.8311 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.86697 0 Td
(v)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.78293 0 Td
[(in)-253(the)-265(\frst)-255(few)-264(pro)-25(ofs)-241(are)-253(not)-253(the)-266(ones)-241(a)-252(h)24(uman)-253(w)24(ould)-253(\fnd|although)]TJ
-3.481 -1.2045 TD
[(it)-265(do)-25(es)-265(ev)25(en)24(tually)-241(\fnd)-265(the)-278(h)24(uman)-253(pro)-24(of|and)-253(Otter)-254(do)-24(es)-265(a)-253(fairly)-253(large)-241(searc)24(h,)]TJ
T*
[(while)-337(a)-325(h)24(uman)-325(do)-24(es)-338(v)24(ery)-313(little)-338(searc)24(hing)-313(on)-337(this)-327(problem.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.19245 TD
[(In)-277(mathematics)-278(up)-289(through)-266(calculus,)-277(if)-290(w)25(e)-277(do)-277(not)-277(go)-277(deeply)-277(in)24(to)-277(the)-289(foun-)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(dations)-314(of)-325(the)-326(sub)-61(ject)-325(but)-325(consider)-302(only)-325(what)-313(is)-326(actually)-313(taugh)23(t)-313(to)-326(studen)24(ts,)]TJ
T*
[(there)-374(is)-386(mostly)-374(calculation.)-373(In)-374(abstract)-375(algebra,)-361(most)-374(of)-386(the)-385(w)24(ork)-362(in)-373(a)-386(one-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(semester)-362(course)-350(in)24(v)24(olv)24(es)-349(some)-362(\frst-order)-351(axioms)-362(\(groups,)-351(rings,)-362(etc.\),)-374(along)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(with)-506(the)-506(notions)-495(of)-494(subgroup,)-483(homomorphism,)-495(isomorphism,)-483(and)-494(a)-494(small)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(amoun)24(t)-362(of)-373(the)-374(theory)-362(of)-373(natural)-362(n)24(um)24(b)-24(ers.)-362(The)-373(latter)-363(is)-361(needed)-373(for)-374(the)-374(con-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(cept)-313(of)-313(\\\fnite)-314(group")-301(and)-301(the)-326(concept)-312(of)-301(\\order)-302(of)-313(a)-301(group".)-302(Num)25(b)-25(er)-313(theory)]TJ
T*
[(is)-398(needed)-397(only)-397(\(appro)23(ximately\))-386(up)-410(to)-397(the)-398(concept)-397(of)-398(\\)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
24.1984 0 Td
(a)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.92747 0 Td
(divides)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
3.43283 0 Td
(b)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.43362 0 Td
[(")-385(and)-410(the)]TJ
-28.99232 -1.19246 TD
[(factorization)-290(of)-313(a)-301(n)24(um)24(b)-24(er)-313(in)24(to)-302(a)-313(pro)-24(duct)-314(of)-301(primes.)-314(One)-301(pro)24(v)24(es,)-289(for)-302(example,)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(the)-362(structure)-363(theorem)-349(for)-350(a)-361(\fnite)-362(ab)-24(elian)-349(group,)-350(and)-361(then)-362(one)-361(can)-349(use)-361(it)-362(to)]TJ
T*
[(pro)24(v)24(e)-337(the)-374(b)-24(eautiful)-374(theorem)-361(that)-362(the)-362(m)24(ultiplicativ)23(e)-361(group)-349(of)-362(a)-361(\fnite)-374(\feld)-361(is)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(cyclic.)-360(These)-349(theorems)-350(are)-350(presen)24(tly)-350(b)-24(ey)24(ond)-349(the)-361(reac)24(h)-349(of)-362(automated)-350(deduc-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(tion)-326(in)-325(an)24(y)-313(honest)-326(sense,)-313(although)-326(of)-325(course)-302(one)-324(could)-313(prepare)-314(a)-325(sequence)-312(of)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(lemmas)-325(in)-338(suc)24(h)-325(a)-337(w)24(a)24(y)-313(that)-338(the)-338(pro)-24(of)-325(could)-325(ultimately)-338(b)-24(e)-337(found.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(Ho)24(w)25(ev)24(er,)-349(there)-386(is)-386(a)-373(natural)-375(family)-385(of)-386(mathematical)-373(theories)-374(that)-399(is)-374(just)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(su\016cien)24(t)-410(for)-410(expressing)-386(most)-411(undergraduate)-398(mathematics.)-410(Theories)-398(of)-409(this)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(kind)-253(include)-265(a)-253(simple)-253(theory)-253(as)-242(discussed)-254(ab)-24(o)25(v)24(e)-241(\(simple)-254(axioms)-241(ab)-24(out)-265(a)-241(single)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(kind)-434(of)-421(ob)-61(ject\),)-434(and)-421(in)-434(addition)-434(parameters)-411(for)-422(subsets)-423(\(but)-435(not)-434(arbitrary)]TJ
T*
[(quan)24(ti\fcation)-277(o)24(v)24(er)-253(subsets\),)-279(v)60(ariables)-266(for)-277(natural)-266(n)24(um)24(b)-24(ers)-278(and)-277(mathematical)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(induction,)-302(and)-289(functions)-302(from)-289(natural)-290(n)24(um)24(b)-24(ers)-290(in)24(to)-290(the)-301(ob)-60(jects)-290(of)-301(the)-301(simple)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(theory)84(,)-229(so)-229(that)-242(one)-241(can)-228(sp)-25(eak)-228(ab)-24(out)-241(sequences)-229(of)-241(the)-241(ob)-60(jects.)-230(These)-228(additional)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(features,)-374(plus)-374(de\fnitions,)-387(will)-373(encompass)-361(most)-375(of)-373(the)-386(pro)-24(ofs)-362(encoun)24(tered)-373(in)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(the)-325(\frst)-327(semester)-314(of)-313(abstract)-315(algebra.)-301(If)-326(w)25(e)-313(add)-325(inequalities)-314(and)-325(calculations)]TJ
T*
[(to)-253(this)-266(mix,)-265(w)24(e)-253(will)-264(encompass)-242(undergraduate)-241(analysis,)-254(complex)-253(analysis,)-241(and)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(top)-24(ology)-313(as)-326(w)24(ell.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 207.6 287.28 Tm
(24)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 149.76 271.68 Tm
[(Of)-337(course,)-326(there)-337(exist)-338(branc)24(hes)-326(of)-337(mathematics)-338(that)-350(go)-325(b)-24(ey)24(ond)-337(this)-351(kind)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(of)-289(mathematics)-278(\(e.g.)-289(Galois)-277(theory)-278(or)-277(algebraic)-265(top)-24(ology\).)-278(W)85(e)-289(prop)-24(ose)-278(to)-289(not)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(ev)24(en)-325(think)-337(ab)-24(out)-326(automated)-326(deduction)-337(in)-325(these)-338(areas)-313(of)-326(mathematics.)-326(Deal-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(ing)-458(with)-470(the)-458(c)25(hallenges)-446(of)-457(second-order)-435(v)61(ariables)-435(\(without)-470(quan)24(ti\fcation\),)]TJ
ET
q
56.76 0 0 -0.48 134.748 227.868 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 217.08 Tm
[(b)26(y)-428(Rob)-26(ert)-454(V)80(ero\013.)-441(Although)-456(it)-441(is)-468(to)-26(o)-454(tec)27(hnical)-456(to)-454(discuss)-455(here,)-455(the)-441(problem)-455(is)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(listed)-441(as)-454(an)-442(op)-27(en)-442(problem)-441(\(whic)26(h)-442(previously)-441(had)-428(a)-455(mo)-26(del-theoretic)-441(pro)-26(of,)-468(but)]TJ
T*
[(no)-402(\frst-order)-386(pro)-26(of)-80(\))-414(in)-402(App)-28(endix)-376(3)-401(of)-401([72])-427(\(whic)27(h)-389(also)-427(lists)-413(other)-388(c)27(hallenges)-428(to)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(theorem-pro)29(ving)-335(programs\).)-358(The)-348(solution)-361(can)-335(b)-27(e)-348(found)-335(on)-348(V)80(ero\013)-80('s)-347(w)26(eb)-335(page.)]TJ
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 177.12 Tm
(24)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 173.28 Tm
[(There)-335(is)-334(an)-334(ob)26(vious)-334(ob)-53(jection)-348(to)-333(the)-335(ab)-27(o)27(v)27(e)-321(taxonom)29(y:)-334(F)80(unctions)-335(can)-334(b)-28(e)-321(reduced)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(to)-374(sets,)-386(and)-376(n)27(um)26(b)-27(ers)-374(can)-375(b)-27(e)-375(reduced)-375(to)-374(sets,)-387(so)-387(that)-374(all)-388(of)-387(mathematics)-399(can)-375(b)-27(e)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(formalized)-320(in)-295(set)-307(theory)82(.)-295(This)-308(ob)-53(jection)-307(will)-322(b)-27(e)-295(tak)28(en)-295(up)-295(in)-295(the)-294(last)-307(section)-307(of)-307(the)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(pap)-27(er.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
25 0 obj
<<
/Length 15146
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 290.52 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(The)-335(Mec)27(hanization)-361(of)-361(Mathematics)-2674(23)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(de\fnitions,)-410(calculations,)-386(incorp)-24(orating)-386(natural)-399(n)24(um)24(b)-24(ers,)-398(sequences,)-397(and)-398(in-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(duction,)-289(should)-290(k)24(eep)-288(researc)23(hers)-253(busy)-290(for)-290(at)-289(least)-278(a)-289(generation.)-277(A)25(t)-290(that)-302(p)-24(oin)24(t)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
[(computers)-422(should)-435(ha)24(v)25(e)-410(more)-421(or)-422(less)-423(the)-433(capabilities)-422(of)-434(an)-421(en)24(tering)-422(Ph.)-421(D.)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(studen)23(t)-374(in)-361(mathematics.)-362(No)24(w,)-361(in)-373(2003,)-337(they)-374(are)-349(at)-362(appro)24(ximately)-337(freshman)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(lev)24(el.)-300(I)-314(do)-301(not)-314(mean)-300(that)-314(this)-315(progress)-278(is)-314(inevitable|it)-313(will)-301(require)-302(resources)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(and)-325(e\013ort)-338(that)-338(ma)24(y)-325(not)-326(b)-24(e)-337(forthcoming.)-326(But)-337(it)-338(is)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
21.90985 0 Td
[(p)48(ossible)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
3.25215 0 Td
(.)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
11.95517 0 0 11.95517 134.76 574.56 Tm
[(9)-1124(Computer)-382(Algebra)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 550.56 Tm
[(\\Computer)-301(algebra",)-277(while)-301(a)-301(common)-301(and)-301(descriptiv)23(e)-301(term,)-301(is)-314(a)-301(bit)-314(mislead-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(ing)-265(since)-265(the)-277(sub)-61(ject)-265(encompasses)-253(calculus)-253(and)-277(to)-265(some)-254(exten)25(t)-278(com)25(binatorics,)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(as)-398(w)25(ell)-410(as)-398(algebra.)-385(Originally)-386(computers)-410(w)24(ere)-385(view)25(ed)-410(as)-398(n)25(umerical)-398(calcula-)]TJ
T*
[(tors.)-399(In)-410(fact,)-409(when)-409(the)-422(\frst)-399(c)24(hec)25(k)24(ers-pla)23(ying)-373(program)-386(w)24(as)-386(written)-422(in)-410(1948,)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(there)-362(w)25(as)-338(no)-361(prin)23(ter)-350(at)-349(the)-362(IBM)-362(researc)24(h)-337(lab)-350(that)-362(could)-361(prin)24(t)-350(an)24(ything)-350(but)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(n)24(um)24(b)-24(ers,)-302(so)-302(the)-313(output)-314(of)-313(the)-301(c)24(hec)25(k)24(ers)-290(pla)24(ying)-289(program)-290(had)-301(to)-313(b)-25(e)-312(co)-24(ded)-301(n)24(u-)]TJ
T*
[(merically)84(.)-228(But)-242(b)24(y)-228(the)-241(late)-241(1950s,)-205(realization)-217(w)24(as)-229(spreading)-217(that)-242(there)-241(w)24(as)-217(suc)24(h)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(a)-265(thing)-265(as)-254(\\sym)24(b)-24(olic)-253(computation",)-265(and)-265(algebra)-241(and)-265(calculus)-253(w)24(ere)-264(among)-253(the)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(\frst)-315(areas)-301(attac)24(k)24(ed.)-301(Programs)-278(for)-314(elemen)25(tary)-302(calculus)-313(w)25(ere)-301(so)-25(on)-301(written,)-326(in-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(corp)-24(orating)-374(rules)-399(of)-397(th)24(um)23(b)-409(\(\\heuristic")-399(is)-398(the)-409(ten-dollar)-387(w)25(ord)-386(for)-398(a)-398(rule)-397(of)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(th)24(um)23(b\))-434(for)-410(elemen)25(tary)-422(in)24(tegration.)-398(John)-422(McCarth)23(y)-409(in)24(v)24(en)24(ted)-421(LISP)84(,)-422(a)-421(com-)]TJ
T*
[(puter)-446(language)-421(designed)-434(for)-434(programming)-411(sym)24(b)-24(olic)-445(tasks,)-435(and)-434(the)-446(\feld)-445(of)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(computer)-398(algebra)-385(b)-24(egan)-397(to)-410(dev)24(elop)-397(so)-24(on)-398(afterw)24(ards.)-387(The)-409(sub)-60(ject)-398(had,)-409(and)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(still)-350(has,)-338(t)24(w)24(o)-337(sides.)-338(One)-337(side)-350(is)-337(the)-350(theoretical)-337(dev)24(elopmen)24(t)-325(of)-350(algorithms)-326(to)]TJ
T*
[(solv)24(e)-434(problems)-446(of)-458(sp)-24(eci\fc)-445(classes.)-447(The)-445(other)-446(side)-458(is)-446(the)-458(e\016cien)25(t,)-458(practical)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(implemen)24(tation)-338(of)-325(those)-338(algorithms)-314(in)-338(useful)-337(programs.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(In)-229(the)-241(sixties)-230(and)-241(sev)24(en)24(ties,)-217(there)-242(w)25(ere)-217(sev)24(eral)-217(imp)-24(ortan)23(t)-229(theoretical)-229(dev)24(el-)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(opmen)24(ts)-338(in)-349(the)-350(sub)-61(ject.)-349(Although)-349(w)24(e)-337(cannot)-349(a\013ord)-326(a)-349(thorough)-326(in)24(tro)-25(duction)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(to)-362(computer)-349(algebra,)-338(w)25(e)-361(will)-361(men)24(tion)-362(three)-350(dev)25(elopmen)24(ts.)-350(Consider)-350(the)-361(fol-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(lo)24(wing)-277(Mathematica)-277(input:)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
12.02091 0 Td
[(F)72(actor)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
2.81853 0 Td
([)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.27703 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 291 327 Tm
(119)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 304.68 323.4 Tm
<00>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.91542 0 Td
[(1].)-277(Mathematica)-278(resp)-24(onds)-278(instan)23(tly)]TJ
-17.97114 -1.19245 TD
(with)Tj
3.09556 -2.01151 TD
(\()Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
<00>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.78293 0 Td
0.217 Tc
(1+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.72244 0 Td
0 Tc
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
[(\)\(1)-230(+)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
2.50536 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.79497 0 Td
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 248.52 295.68 Tm
(2)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 255.24 291.48 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 270.84 295.68 Tm
(3)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 277.56 291.48 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.01178 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 293.28 295.68 Tm
(4)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 300 291.48 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 315.6 295.68 Tm
(5)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 322.32 291.48 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 337.92 295.68 Tm
(6)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 342.48 291.48 Tm
[(\)\(1)-218(+)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
2.49331 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.79497 0 Td
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 390.84 295.68 Tm
(2)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 397.56 291.48 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 413.16 295.68 Tm
(3)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 419.88 291.48 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 435.48 295.68 Tm
(4)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 442.2 291.48 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 457.8 295.68 Tm
(5)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 165.6 276.6 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.78293 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 179.04 280.68 Tm
(6)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 185.76 276.6 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 201.36 280.68 Tm
(7)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 208.08 276.6 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 223.68 280.68 Tm
(8)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 230.4 276.6 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 246 280.68 Tm
(9)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 252.84 276.6 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 268.44 280.68 Tm
(10)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 279.12 276.6 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 294.72 280.68 Tm
(11)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 305.4 276.6 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 321 280.68 Tm
(12)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 331.68 276.6 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 347.28 280.68 Tm
(13)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 358.08 276.6 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 373.68 280.68 Tm
(14)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 384.36 276.6 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 399.96 280.68 Tm
(15)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 410.64 276.6 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 426.24 280.68 Tm
(16)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 434.76 276.6 Tm
(\))Tj
-27.01694 -1.50563 TD
(\(1)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
1.12019 0 Td
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.79497 0 Td
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 210.24 265.8 Tm
(7)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 216.96 261.6 Tm
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 232.56 265.8 Tm
(8)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 239.28 261.6 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 254.88 265.8 Tm
(14)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 265.56 261.6 Tm
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 281.16 265.8 Tm
(15)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 291.84 261.6 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 307.44 265.8 Tm
(17)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 318.24 261.6 Tm
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 333.84 265.8 Tm
(18)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 344.52 261.6 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 360.12 265.8 Tm
(21)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 370.8 261.6 Tm
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 386.4 265.8 Tm
(22)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 397.08 261.6 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 412.68 265.8 Tm
(24)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 423.48 261.6 Tm
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 439.08 265.8 Tm
(25)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 165.6 246.72 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.78293 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 179.04 250.8 Tm
(28)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 189.72 246.72 Tm
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 205.32 250.8 Tm
(29)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 216 246.72 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 231.6 250.8 Tm
(31)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 242.4 246.72 Tm
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 258 250.8 Tm
(32)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 268.68 246.72 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 284.28 250.8 Tm
(34)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 294.96 246.72 Tm
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 310.56 250.8 Tm
(36)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 321.36 246.72 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 336.96 250.8 Tm
(38)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 347.64 246.72 Tm
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 363.24 250.8 Tm
(39)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 373.92 246.72 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 389.52 250.8 Tm
(41)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 400.2 246.72 Tm
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 415.8 250.8 Tm
(43)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 426.6 246.72 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 442.2 250.8 Tm
(45)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 165.6 231.72 Tm
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.78293 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 179.04 235.92 Tm
(46)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 189.72 231.72 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 205.32 235.92 Tm
(48)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 216 231.72 Tm
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 231.6 235.92 Tm
(50)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 242.4 231.72 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 258 235.92 Tm
(51)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 268.68 231.72 Tm
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 284.28 235.92 Tm
(53)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 294.96 231.72 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 310.56 235.92 Tm
(55)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 321.36 231.72 Tm
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 336.96 235.92 Tm
(57)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 347.64 231.72 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 363.24 235.92 Tm
(58)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 373.92 231.72 Tm
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 389.52 235.92 Tm
(60)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 400.2 231.72 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 415.8 235.92 Tm
(62)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 426.6 231.72 Tm
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 442.2 235.92 Tm
(64)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 165.6 216.84 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.78293 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 179.04 220.92 Tm
(65)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 189.72 216.84 Tm
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 205.32 220.92 Tm
(67)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 216 216.84 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 231.6 220.92 Tm
(68)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 242.4 216.84 Tm
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 258 220.92 Tm
(71)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 268.68 216.84 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 284.28 220.92 Tm
(72)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 294.96 216.84 Tm
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 310.56 220.92 Tm
(74)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 321.36 216.84 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 336.96 220.92 Tm
(75)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 347.64 216.84 Tm
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 363.24 220.92 Tm
(78)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 373.92 216.84 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 389.52 220.92 Tm
(79)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 400.2 216.84 Tm
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 415.8 220.92 Tm
(81)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 426.6 216.84 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 442.2 220.92 Tm
(82)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 165.6 201.84 Tm
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.78293 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 179.04 206.04 Tm
(88)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 189.72 201.84 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 205.32 206.04 Tm
(89)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 216 201.84 Tm
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 231.6 206.04 Tm
(95)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 242.4 201.84 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 258 206.04 Tm
(96)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 266.52 201.84 Tm
(\))Tj
-13.22541 -1.99947 TD
[(This)-350(w)25(as)-338(not)-350(done)-349(b)24(y)-349(trial)-350(and)-349(error.)-327(It)-362(uses)-338(algorithms)-338(for)-350(p)-24(olynomial)-337(fac-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
(torization)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 177 173.64 Tm
(25)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 188.88 169.92 Tm
[(that)-374(\frst)-363(factor)-350(the)-373(p)-25(olynomial)-349(mo)-24(d)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
16.42938 0 Td
(p)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.86724 0 Td
[(for)-350(v)60(arious)-350(small)-362(primes)]TJ
ET
q
56.76 0 0 -0.48 134.748 162.108 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 155.16 Tm
(25)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 151.32 Tm
[(F)80(or)-307(readers)-320(unfamiliar)-320(with)-321(mo)-26(d)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
14.81535 0 Td
(p)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.52195 0 Td
[(,)-308(this)-307(means)-307(that)-307(n)26(um)27(b)-27(ers)-307(are)-307(alw)27(a)27(ys)-320(replaced)]TJ
-15.3373 -1.21788 TD
[(with)-442(their)-441(remainders)-454(after)-453(division)-442(b)27(y)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
18.3084 0 Td
(p)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.52195 0 Td
[(.)-442(F)80(or)-440(example,)-455(3)-441(times)-454(5)-441(is)-454(1)-442(mo)-26(d)-442(7,)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
26 0 obj
<<
/Length 9173
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 134.76 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(24)-2662(Mic)26(hael)-361(Beeson)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
(p)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.50589 0 Td
[(,)-385(and)-374(then)-386(put)-386(the)-385(results)-375(together)-374(clev)25(erly)84(,)-374(using)-374(a)-373(19th-cen)24(tury)-362(theorem)]TJ
-0.50589 -1.2045 TD
[(kno)24(wn)-241(as)-253(Hensel's)-253(lemma.)-253(The)-252(factorization)-242(mo)-24(d)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
21.33169 0 Td
(p)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.75883 0 Td
[(can)-253(b)-24(e)-264(done)-253(quic)24(kly)85(,)-241(using)]TJ
-22.09053 -1.20451 TD
[(an)-385(algorithm)-363(disco)24(v)24(ered)-361(b)24(y)-373(Berlek)61(amp)-374(in)-385(1967.)-361(The)-385(application)-374(of)-385(Hensel's)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(lemma)-313(to)-326(this)-314(problem)-313(w)24(as)-313(disco)24(v)24(ered)-289(b)24(y)-313(Zassenhaus)-303(in)-313(1969.)-301(F)84(ull)-325(historical)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(and)-325(mathematical)-338(details)-326(can)-324(b)-25(e)-336(found)-338(in)-337([57])-325(and)-326([63].)]TJ
1.50563 -1.19245 TD
[(Our)-265(second)-277(example)-289(concerns)-265(the)-289(in)24(tegration)-266(of)-289(elemen)25(tary)-266(functions.)-290(An)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(elementary)-432(function)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.16624 0 Td
[(is)-410(one)-397(that)-411(y)25(ou)-386(migh)24(t)-410(encoun)25(ter)-398(in)-398(freshman)-398(calculus:)]TJ
-9.16624 -1.2045 TD
[(it)-410(is)-410(de\fned)-409(using)-410(m)24(ultiplication,)-411(addition,)-410(subtraction,)-399(division,)-398(trig)-410(func-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(tions,)-314(exp)-24(onen)24(ts,)-314(and)-313(logarithms.)-302(Muc)24(h)-314(e\013ort)-313(in)-314(freshman)-314(calculus)-313(go)-24(es)-301(in)24(to)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(rules)-422(and)-422(metho)-24(ds)-434(for)-422(computing)-422(elemen)25(tary)-411(in)24(tegrals)-410(of)-422(elemen)25(tary)-422(func-)]TJ
T*
[(tions.)-435(Ho)25(w)24(ev)25(er,)-410(not)-446(ev)24(ery)-409(elemen)25(tary)-435(function)-434(has)-434(an)-433(elemen)24(tary)-422(in)24(tegral.)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(F)84(or)-314(example,)]TJ
/F14 1 Tf
5.97432 0.80702 TD
(R)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.83111 -0.80702 TD
(e)Tj
/F15 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 207.24 538.32 Tm
(x)Tj
/F16 1 Tf
4.98132 0 0 4.98132 211.8 541.32 Tm
(2)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 217.8 534.72 Tm
(dx)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.42131 0 Td
[(cannot)-313(b)-24(e)-325(expressed)-314(in)-325(elemen)25(tary)-314(form.)-326(Risc)24(h)-325([95,96])]TJ
-9.75645 -1.2045 TD
[(disco)24(v)24(ered)-409(in)-422(1969)-409(that)-435(the)-433(trial-and-error)-388(metho)-25(ds)-434(y)24(ou)-409(ma)24(y)-422(ha)25(v)24(e)-409(studied)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(in)-349(freshman)-339(calculus,)-349(suc)24(h)-337(as)-338(in)24(tegration)-326(b)24(y)-349(substitution)-352(and)-349(in)24(tegration)-326(b)24(y)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(parts,)-278(can)-277(b)-24(e)-277(replaced)-277(b)24(y)-277(a)-276(single,)-278(systematic)-266(pro)-24(cedure,)-277(that)-278(alw)24(a)25(ys)-266(w)25(orks)-254(if)]TJ
T*
[(the)-313(in)24(tegral)-302(has)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
7.0945 0 Td
(any)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.86697 0 Td
[(elemen)25(tary)-302(answ)24(er.)-301(A)-313(complete)-313(exp)-24(osition)-302(of)-313(the)-325(theory)]TJ
-8.96148 -1.19246 TD
[(is)-338(in)-325([21].)]TJ
1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(Our)-386(third)-411(example)-408(concerns)-386(sets)-398(of)-410(sim)23(ultaneous)-398(p)-24(olynomial)-397(equations.)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(Sa)24(y)84(,)-325(for)-325(example,)-325(that)-338(y)24(ou)-325(wish)-338(to)-325(solv)23(e)-313(the)-337(equations)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
3.45691 -1.84289 TD
(z)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.73474 0 Td
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 192.12 436.8 Tm
(4)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 198.84 432.6 Tm
<00>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(2)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.50589 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.79497 0 Td
0.289 Tc
[(+)72(1=0)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
-3.44487 -1.49358 TD
0 Tc
(y)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 192.72 421.8 Tm
(2)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 199.32 417.72 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 214.92 421.8 Tm
(2)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 221.76 417.72 Tm
<00>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
0.289 Tc
(1=0)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
-7.227 -1.50563 TD
0 Tc
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 165.36 406.8 Tm
(5)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 172.08 402.72 Tm
<00>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(6)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.50589 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 192.72 406.8 Tm
(3)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 199.32 402.72 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 214.92 406.8 Tm
(2)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 221.76 402.72 Tm
<00>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
0.289 Tc
(1=0)Tj
-9.73236 -1.84289 TD
0 Tc
[(If)-253(y)24(ou)-229(ask)-241(Mathematica)-242(to)-241(solv)24(e)-229(this)-254(set)-241(of)-241(three)-241(equations)-242(in)-241(three)-253(unkno)24(wns,)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(it)-350(answ)24(ers)-314((immediately))-362(with)-337(a)-338(list)-350(of)-337(the)-350(ten)-349(solutions.)-327(Since)-349(the)-349(solutions)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(do)-277(not)-289(ha)24(v)24(e)-265(expressions)-266(in)-277(terms)-279(of)-289(square)-265(ro)-25(ots,)-266(they)-289(ha)24(v)24(e)-264(to)-278(b)-24(e)-288(giv)24(en)-277(in)-289(the)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(form)-290(of)-289(algebraic)-264(n)24(um)24(b)-25(ers.)-289(F)84(or)-278(example,)-288(the)-290(\frst)-290(one)-289(is)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
24.23454 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.84315 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.05996 0 Td
[<0B3B>-169(y)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.89106 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.05996 0 Td
<0B>Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.78292 0 Td
<00>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.91542 0 Td
(1)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.50589 0 Td
0.169 Tc
(;z)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.21654 0 Td
0 Tc
(=)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
-32.50945 -1.19245 TD
<00>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.78292 0 Td
0.289 Tc
[(1+)-12(2)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
2.38491 0 Td
0 Tc
<0B>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.63839 0 Td
[(,)-458(where)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
3.75804 0 Td
<0B>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.0961 0 Td
[(is)-458(the)-458(smallest)-459(ro)-24(ot)-446(of)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
10.47915 0 Td
<00>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.78293 0 Td
0.289 Tc
(1+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.87902 0 Td
0 Tc
<0B>Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 358.32 340.2 Tm
(2)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 365.88 336.6 Tm
<00>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.08405 0 Td
(6)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.50589 0 Td
<0B>Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 388.08 340.2 Tm
(3)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 395.64 336.6 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.08405 0 Td
<0B>Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 412.8 340.2 Tm
(5)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 422.04 336.6 Tm
[(=)-482(0.)-457(This)]TJ
-28.83573 -1.2045 TD
[(problem)-265(has)-278(b)-24(een)-276(solv)23(ed)-264(b)24(y)-265(constructing)-267(what)-277(is)-277(kno)24(wn)-265(as)-265(a)-277(\\Gr\177)506(obner)-254(basis")]TJ
T*
[(of)-397(the)-410(ideal)-397(generated)-386(b)24(y)-397(the)-410(three)-398(p)-24(olynomials)-398(in)-397(the)-410(original)-386(problem.)-398(It)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(tak)24(es)-326(to)-24(o)-325(m)24(uc)24(h)-325(space,)-325(and)-325(demands)-338(to)-24(o)-325(m)24(uc)24(h)-325(mathematical)-326(bac)25(kground,)-314(to)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(explain)-241(this)-242(more)-241(fully;)-241(see)-241([106],)-228(Chapter)-241(8)-229(for)-242(explanations.)-229(\(This)-242(example)-240(is)]TJ
T*
[(Exercise)-265(4,)-289(p.)-289(201\).)-265(Although)-289(metho)-24(ds)-290(\(due)-301(to)-278(Kronec)25(k)24(er\))-266(w)24(ere)-264(kno)24(wn)-277(in)-301(the)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(nineteen)24(th)-373(cen)24(tury)-362(that)-362(in)-374(principle)-361(could)-361(solv)23(e)-349(suc)24(h)-361(problems,)-350(the)-374(concept)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(of)-265(a)-253(Gr\177)506(obner)-253(basis)-254(and)-265(the)-265(algorithm)-254(for)-254(\fnding)-265(one,)-265(kno)25(wn)-253(as)-253(\\Buc)24(h)24(b)-24(erger's)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(algorithm",)-302(ha)24(v)24(e)-300(pla)24(y)24(ed)-313(an)-313(indisp)-25(ensable)-325(role)-313(in)-326(the)-325(dev)24(elopmen)25(t)-314(of)-313(mo)-24(dern)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(computer)-338(algebra.)-313(These)-337(results)-339(w)25(ere)-325(in)-350(Buc)25(h)24(b)-24(erger's)-314(Ph.)-337(D.)-349(thesis)-338(in)-350(1965.)]TJ
T*
[(Th)24(us)-277(the)-290(p)-24(erio)-24(d)-277(1965-70)-240(sa)23(w)-264(the)-290(theoretical)-277(foundations)-266(of)-289(computer)-278(algebra)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
(laid.)Tj
1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(It)-302(to)-24(ok)-301(some)-290(time)-313(for)-290(implemen)25(tation)-302(to)-302(catc)25(h)-301(up)-302(with)-313(theory)84(,)-289(but)-314(as)-302(the)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(t)24(w)24(en)24(t)24(y-\frst)-339(cen)25(tury)-338(op)-25(ened,)-348(there)-350(w)24(ere)-337(sev)24(eral)-325(w)24(ell-kno)25(wn,)-325(widely)-349(a)24(v)60(ailable)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(programs)-290(con)24(taining)-314(implemen)25(tations)-327(of)-313(these)-325(imp)-25(ortan)24(t)-326(algorithms,)-302(as)-314(w)24(ell)]TJ
ET
q
56.76 0 0 -0.48 134.748 162.108 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 151.32 Tm
[(b)-27(ecause)-388(15)-387(has)-388(remainder)-374(1)-388(after)-386(division)-388(b)26(y)-374(7.)-388(So)-375(\()]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
23.71527 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.82977 0 Td
[(+)-254(3\)\()]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
2.36885 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.82977 0 Td
0.254 Tc
[(+5)254(\))-93(=)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
3.46628 0 Td
0 Tc
(x)Tj
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 429.12 155.16 Tm
(2)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 435.48 151.32 Tm
(+)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.0439 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.84315 0 Td
0.241 Tc
(+1)Tj
-34.39516 -1.21788 TD
0 Tc
[(mo)-26(d)-348(7.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
27 0 obj
<<
/Length 7512
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 290.52 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(The)-335(Mec)27(hanization)-361(of)-361(Mathematics)-2674(25)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(as)-241(man)24(y)-241(others.)-242(Sym)24(b)-24(olic)-241(mathematics)-242(up)-253(to)-241(and)-253(including)-241(freshman)-241(calculus)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(can)-481(th)23(us)-482(b)-24(e)-494(regarded)-470(as)-470(completely)-481(mec)24(hanized)-481(at)-482(this)-495(p)-24(oin)24(t.)-482(While)-494(one)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
[(cannot)-289(sa)24(y)-289(that)-302(the)-302(\feld)-301(is)-301(complete{ev)25(ery)-277(y)24(ear)-277(there)-302(is)-289(a)-301(large)-277(in)23(ternational)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(conference)-288(dev)24(oted)-277(to)-301(the)-302(sub)-60(ject)-289(and)-289(man)24(y)-289(more)-290(sp)-24(ecialized)-288(conferences{on)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(the)-458(whole)-445(the)-458(mec)25(hanization)-434(of)-458(computation)-446(has)-446(progressed)-423(m)24(uc)25(h)-446(further)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(than)-338(the)-337(mec)24(hanization)-313(of)-337(pro)-25(of.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.24063 TD
[(In)-265(addition)-266(to)-265(the)-277(w)24(ell-kno)24(wn)-253(general-purp)-24(ose)-241(sym)23(b)-24(olic)-265(computation)-265(pro-)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.19245 TD
[(grams)-326(suc)24(h)-350(as)-337(Maple,)-338(Mathematica,)-337(and)-350(Macsyma,)-325(there)-350(are)-325(also)-338(a)-337(n)24(um)24(b)-24(er)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(of)-337(sp)-25(ecial-purp)-24(ose)-326(programs)-314(dev)24(oted)-325(to)-337(particular)-327(branc)24(hes)-325(of)-338(mathematics.)]TJ
T*
[(These)-313(are)-301(programs)-290(suc)24(h)-302(as)-313(MA)24(GMA,)-326(P)85(ARI-GP)-301(\(algebraic)-301(n)24(um)24(b)-24(er)-301(theory\),)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(SnapP)24(ea)-228(\(top)-25(ology\),)-229(GAP)-240(\(group)-242(theory\),)-230(Surface)-241(Ev)25(olv)24(er)-217(\(di\013eren)24(tial)-242(geom-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(etry\),)-338(etc.)-325(These)-337(are)-313(used)-338(b)24(y)-325(sp)-25(ecialists)-326(in)-337(those)-326(\felds.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.22859 TD
[(What)-422(is)-410(the)-422(place)-420(of)-410(computer)-422(algebra)-397(in)-422(the)-422(mec)25(hanization)-398(of)-421(mathe-)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(matics?)-350(Ob)24(viously)-337(there)-350(are)-337(some)-350(parts)-338(of)-350(mathematics)-350(that)-350(consist)-350(mainly)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(of)-446(computations.)-434(The)-445(fact)-446(is)-446(that)-447(this)-447(part)-446(of)-446(mathematics)-434(includes)-446(high-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(sc)24(ho)-24(ol)-434(mathematics)-446(and)-434(\frst-y)23(ear)-422(calculus)-446(as)-434(it)-446(is)-446(usually)-446(taugh)24(t,)-434(so)-447(that)]TJ
T*
[(p)-24(eople)-457(who)-446(do)-445(not)-458(study)-459(mathematics)-446(b)-25(ey)25(ond)-446(that)-458(p)-25(oin)25(t)-459(ha)24(v)25(e)-446(the)-458((mis)-)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(impression)-314(that)-339(mathematics)-326(consists)-326(of)-326(calculations,)-313(and)-325(they)-338(imagine)-325(that)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(adv)60(anced)-276(mathematics)-290(consists)-279(of)-289(y)24(et)-277(more)-277(complicated)-288(calculations.)-266(That)-289(is)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(not)-265(true.)-278(Beginning)-264(with)-278(the)-265(course)-265(after)-266(calculus,)-265(mathematics)-265(relies)-266(hea)25(vily)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(on)-289(pro)-25(ofs.)-277(Some)-289(of)-289(the)-301(pro)-25(ofs)-277(con)24(tain)-289(some)-278(steps)-290(that)-302(can)-276(b)-25(e)-300(justi\fed)-303(b)24(y)-289(cal-)]TJ
T*
[(culation,)-265(but)-266(more)-265(emphasis)-254(is)-265(placed)-264(on)-265(precisely)-253(de\fned,)-265(abstract)-254(concepts,)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(and)-398(the)-397(study)-399(of)-385(what)-398(prop)-24(erties)-387(follo)25(w)-386(from)-386(more)-385(fundamen)24(tal)-398(prop)-25(erties)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(b)24(y)-325(logical)-325(implication.)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
11.95517 0 0 11.95517 134.76 357.12 Tm
[(10)-1124(Decision)-382(Pro)-30(cedures)-381(in)-372(Algebra)-382(and)-392(Geometry)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 331.68 Tm
[(The)-252(\\\frst)-243(lo)-24(ophole")-240(allo)24(ws)-229(the)-265(p)-24(ossibilit)22(y)-240(that)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
20.15129 0 Td
(some)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
2.45718 0 Td
[(branc)24(hes)-229(of)-253(mathematics)]TJ
-22.60847 -1.19246 TD
[(can)-373(b)-24(e)-385(mec)24(hanized.)-360(An)-386(algorithm)-362(whic)25(h)-386(can)-373(answ)24(er)-349(an)24(y)-374(y)24(es-no)-361(question)-374(in)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(a)-361(giv)24(en)-361(class)-362(of)-373(mathematical)-362(questions)-363(is)-373(called)-361(a)-361(\\decision)-362(pro)-24(cedure")-349(for)]TJ
T*
[(those)-302(questions.)-290(W)85(e)-313(will)-301(giv)24(e)-301(a)-289(simple)-313(example)-289(to)-301(illustrate)-303(the)-313(concept.)-301(Y)85(ou)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(ma)24(y)-421(recall)-422(studying)-434(trigonometry)82(.)-409(In)-434(that)-435(sub)-60(ject,)-434(one)-433(considers)-411(\\trigono-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(metric)-302(iden)25(tities")-302(suc)23(h)-289(as)-301(cos)12(\(2)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
13.51449 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56612 0 Td
[(\))-290(=)-264(cos)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 305.52 275.52 Tm
(2)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 311.64 271.92 Tm
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.7227 0 Td
<00>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.93951 0 Td
(sin)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 340.56 276.12 Tm
(2)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 346.68 271.92 Tm
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56612 0 Td
[(.)-313(The)-301(iden)24(tities)-302(considered)]TJ
-21.83759 -1.2045 TD
[(in)-434(trigonometry)-399(alw)25(a)24(ys)-398(ha)24(v)24(e)-409(only)-421(linear)-422(functions)-423(in)-433(the)-422(argumen)24(ts)-411(of)-433(the)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(trig)-302(functions;)-314(for)-302(example,)-300(they)-302(nev)25(er)-301(consider)-290(sin\()]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
22.45188 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 364.08 251.64 Tm
(2)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 368.64 248.04 Tm
[(\),)-314(although)-301(sin\(2)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
7.23904 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.73475 0 Td
0.169 Tc
[(+3)169(\))]TJ
-31.44949 -1.2045 TD
0 Tc
[(w)24(ould)-337(b)-24(e)-349(allo)24(w)25(ed.)-325(Moreo)23(v)24(er,)-301(the)-349(co)-24(e\016cien)25(ts)-338(of)-338(those)-337(linear)-338(functions)-338(are)-337(al-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(w)24(a)25(ys)-254(in)24(tegers,)-241(or)-266(can)-252(b)-24(e)-277(made)-253(so)-265(b)24(y)-265(a)-253(simple)-265(c)24(hange)-253(of)-265(v)61(ariable.)-253(The)-265(question)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(is,)-386(giv)24(en)-373(suc)24(h)-386(an)-385(equation,)-373(determine)-398(whether)-374(or)-385(not)-386(it)-386(holds)-386(for)-374(all)-385(v)60(alues)]TJ
(of)'
/F9 1 Tf
1.24063 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
[(\(except)-446(p)-24(ossibly)-422(at)-434(the)-446(p)-24(oin)24(ts)-423(where)-433(one)-433(side)-422(or)-434(the)-434(other)-422(is)-434(not)-434(de-)]TJ
-2.24037 -1.19246 TD
[(\fned,)-446(e.g.)-433(b)-24(ecause)-445(a)-434(denominator)-422(is)-446(zero.\))-434(Y)85(ou)-446(ma)24(y)-433(b)-25(e)-445(surprised)-423(to)-446(learn)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(that)-362(there)-350(is)-362(a)-349(decision)-349(metho)-24(d)-362(for)-350(this)-362(class,)-350(whic)25(h)-362(w)25(e)-349(no)24(w)-349(giv)24(e.)-337(First,)-363(use)]TJ
T*
[(kno)24(wn)-349(iden)24(tities)-374(to)-350(express)-350(ev)25(erything)-350(in)-362(terms)-362(of)-362(sin)-362(and)-361(cos)12(.)-361(If)-374(necessary)84(,)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(mak)24(e)-385(a)-397(c)24(hange)-385(of)-397(v)60(ariable)-398(so)-386(that)-410(the)-398(linear)-397(functions)-399(in)-397(the)-410(argumen)24(ts)-386(of)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(sin)-434(and)-434(cos)-434(ha)25(v)24(e)-422(in)24(teger)-421(co)-24(e\016cien)25(ts.)-435(Ev)25(en)-421(though)-434(ev)24(erything)-422(is)-446(in)-434(no)24(w)-433(in)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
28 0 obj
<<
/Length 10572
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 134.76 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(26)-2662(Mic)26(hael)-361(Beeson)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(terms)-423(of)-433(sin)-435(and)-421(cos)12(,)-434(there)-434(could)-421(still)-435(b)-24(e)-433(di\013eren)24(t)-434(argumen)24(ts,)-411(for)-422(example)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
(sin\(2)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
2.11992 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56612 0 Td
(\))Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
<00>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.98769 0 Td
(sin)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.39722 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56612 0 Td
[(.)-325(If)-338(so,)-314(w)25(e)-325(next)-325(use)-326(the)-337(iden)24(tities)-326(for)-326(sin)11(\()]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
17.68206 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.79497 0 Td
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.98769 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
[(\))-326(and)-325(cos)12(\()]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.37234 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.78292 0 Td
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.98769 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
(\))Tj
-32.90694 -1.20451 TD
[(to)-277(express)-254(ev)24(erything)-265(in)-277(terms)-267(of)-277(sin)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
15.7669 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.84315 0 Td
[(and)-277(cos)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
3.39669 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
[(.)-277(The)-277(equation)-265(is)-277(no)24(w)-265(a)-265(ratio-)]TJ
-20.57286 -1.19245 TD
[(nal)-337(function)-338(of)-337(sin)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
8.11833 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.91542 0 Td
[(and)-325(cos)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
3.44487 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
[(.)-337(No)24(w)-337(for)-326(the)-337(k)24(ey)-325(step:)-338(Mak)24(e)-325(the)-337(\\W)84(eierstrass)]TJ
-13.04473 -1.2045 TD
(substitution")Tj
/F9 1 Tf
6.11886 0 Td
(t)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.7227 0 Td
[(=)-361(tan)11(\()]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
2.96307 0 Td
(x=)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.07201 0 Td
[(2\).)-386(Then)-385(sin)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
5.61297 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.9636 0 Td
[(and)-373(cos)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
3.49305 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.95156 0 Td
[(b)-24(ecome)-385(rational)-374(functions)]TJ
-21.89781 -1.19245 TD
(of)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.19245 0 Td
(t)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.36135 0 Td
[(.)-385(Sp)-25(eci\fcally)86(,)-386(w)24(e)-385(ha)25(v)24(e)-361(sin)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
11.40662 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.93951 0 Td
0.361 Tc
(=2)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.65017 0 Td
0 Tc
(t=)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.86724 0 Td
[(\(1)-241(+)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
2.1681 0 Td
(t)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 323.52 610.08 Tm
(2)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 327.96 606.48 Tm
[(\))-398(and)-373(cos)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.27598 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.93951 0 Td
0.361 Tc
[(=\()361(1)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
2.28855 0 Td
0 Tc
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.03587 0 Td
(t)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 416.64 610.08 Tm
(2)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 421.08 606.48 Tm
(\))Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.50589 0 Td
[(\(1)-253(+)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
2.18014 0 Td
(t)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 455.28 610.08 Tm
(2)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 459.72 606.48 Tm
(\).)Tj
-32.61786 -1.2045 TD
[(After)-410(this)-411(substitution,)-424(the)-409(equation)-398(b)-24(ecomes)-397(a)-397(p)-25(olynomial)-397(iden)24(tit)23(y)-409(in)-410(one)]TJ
T*
[(v)60(ariable,)-385(and)-398(w)25(e)-398(just)-398(ha)24(v)24(e)-385(to)-398(simplify)-410(it)-398(to)-398(\\standard)-387(form")-386(and)-397(see)-398(if)-409(the)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(t)24(w)24(o)-409(sides)-411(are)-409(iden)24(tical)-422(or)-410(not.)-409(All)-434(that)-422(su\013ering)-411(that)-422(y)24(ou)-410(w)25(en)24(t)-422(through)-410(in)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(trigonometry)-315(class!)-325(and)-326(a)-325(computer)-325(can)-337(do)-325(the)-338(job)-337(in)-338(an)-325(instan)23(t.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(The)-421(question)-434(is,)-422(then,)-446(exactly)-422(where)-421(the)-434(b)-24(orderline)-422(b)-24(et)24(w)25(een)-433(mec)24(haniz-)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.19245 TD
[(able)-445(theories)-435(and)-433(non-mec)24(hanizable)-433(theories)-434(lies.)-434(It)-459(is)-434(somewhere)-433(b)-24(et)24(w)24(een)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(trig)-362(iden)24(tities)-362(and)-374(n)24(um)24(b)-24(er)-362(theory)84(,)-349(since)-361(b)24(y)-362(T)85(uring)-362(and)-361(Ch)24(urc)24(h's)-350(results,)-363(w)24(e)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(cannot)-470(giv)24(e)-457(a)-470(decision)-469(pro)-25(cedure)-457(for)-458(n)24(um)24(b)-25(er)-469(theory)83(.)-469(The)-470(b)-24(orderline)-470(is)-470(in)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(some)-386(sense)-373(not)-398(v)24(ery)-374(far)-374(b)-24(ey)25(ond)-386(trig)-386(iden)24(tities,)-386(since)-386(a)-385(result)-387(of)-385(Ric)25(hardson)]TJ
T*
[([85])-349(sho)23(ws)-349(that)-362(there)-350(is)-362(no)-361(algorithm)-338(that)-362(can)-361(decide)-349(the)-373(truth)-363(of)-362(iden)25(tities)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(in)24(v)24(olving)-277(p)-24(olynomials,)-290(trig)-289(functions,)-302(logarithms,)-279(and)-289(exp)-24(onen)25(tials)-290(\(with)-314(the)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(constan)24(t)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.05916 0 Td
<19>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.9636 0 Td
[(allo)24(w)25(ed,)-337(and)-350(the)-361(restriction)-351(that)-362(the)-362(argumen)24(ts)-338(of)-362(trig)-350(functions)]TJ
-5.02276 -1.2045 TD
[(b)-24(e)-301(linear)-289(remo)24(v)24(ed\).)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 218.4 454.68 Tm
(26)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 229.68 450.96 Tm
[(Nev)25(ertheless,)-290(there)-290(are)-289(man)24(y)-289(examples)-289(of)-301(decision)-289(pro-)]TJ
-9.52759 -1.19245 TD
[(cedures)-398(for)-386(signi\fcan)24(t)-398(b)-24(o)-24(dies)-409(of)-398(mathematics.)-398(P)24(erhaps)-386(the)-398(most)-398(striking)-399(is)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(one)-337(\frst)-339(explored)-325(b)24(y)-337(Alfred)-337(T)84(arski)-326((1902-1983).)-301(The)-337(branc)24(h)-325(of)-338(mathematics)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(in)-386(question)-386(is,)-386(roughly)-373(sp)-25(eaking,)-373(elemen)25(tary)-374(algebra.)-362(It)-398(is)-386(really)-373(more)-374(than)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(elemen)25(tary)-326(algebra,)-325(b)-24(ecause)-337(\\for)-338(all")-325(and)-337(\\there)-338(exists")-338(are)-325(also)-326(allo)25(w)24(ed,)-337(so)]TJ
T*
[(suc)24(h)-325(questions)-327(as)-325(the)-338(follo)24(wing)-325(are)-313(legal:)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
0.69861 -1.90311 TD
<0F>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
[(Do)-24(es)-337(the)-338(equation)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
8.27492 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 239.76 375.84 Tm
(3)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 246.48 372.24 Tm
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 262.08 375.84 Tm
(2)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 268.8 372.24 Tm
[(+)-217(1)-277(=)-265(0)-325(ha)24(v)25(e)-325(a)-325(solution)-327(b)-24(et)24(w)25(een)-337(0)-325(and)-325(1?)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
-12.75565 -1.19245 TD
<0F>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
[(F)84(or)-326(whic)25(h)-337(v)60(alues)-326(of)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
8.76876 0 Td
(a)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.86724 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.93924 0 Td
(b)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.77088 0 Td
[(do)-24(es)-325(the)-338(equation)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
8.0581 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 360.6 364.08 Tm
(4)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 367.32 360.36 Tm
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
(ax)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 388.2 364.08 Tm
(3)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 394.92 360.36 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(b)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.75883 0 Td
[(tak)24(e)-325(on)-325(only)]TJ
-26.17378 -1.19245 TD
[(p)-24(ositiv)23(e)-325(v)60(alues)-337(as)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
7.91357 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.90338 0 Td
[(v)60(aries?)]TJ
-10.51528 -1.9272 TD
[(The)-313(\frst)-314(question)-302(has)-314(an)-313(implicit)-313(\\there)-314(exists)-302(an)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
21.97008 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
[(",)-313(and)-313(the)-314(second)-313(has)-301(an)]TJ
-22.53619 -1.2045 TD
[(implicit)-338(\\for)-325(all)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
7.08246 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
[(".)-337(W)84(e)-337(will)-337(call)-325(this)-338(part)-326(of)-337(mathematics)-326(\\T)85(arski)-315(algebra.")]TJ
-6.14295 -1.2045 TD
[(\\F)84(or)-362(all")-385(and)-373(\\there)-386(exists")-374(are)-374(called)-373(\\quan)25(ti\fers".)-363(A)-385(form)23(ula)-373(without)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.19245 TD
[(quan)24(ti\fers)-314(is)-314(called)-325(\\quan)25(ti\fer-free".)-290(F)84(or)-314(example,)-313(`)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
22.63256 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 365.88 297 Tm
(2)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 372.48 293.4 Tm
0.193 Tc
[(+2)-72(=)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
2.80648 0 Td
0 Tc
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
[(')-313(is)-326(quan)24(ti\fer-)]TJ
-27.19761 -1.2045 TD
[(free.)-325(A)-337(quan)24(ti\fer-free)-326(form)23(ula)-313(migh)24(t)-338(ha)24(v)25(e)-313(the)-338(form)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
8.26287 -2.10787 TD
(f)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 232.56 258.96 Tm
(1)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 237 260.4 Tm
0.169 Tc
[(;:)1(::;)1(x)]TJ
/F15 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 264.84 258.96 Tm
0 Tc
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 270.24 260.4 Tm
0.29 Tc
[(\)=)26(0)-48(&)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
3.67372 0 Td
0 Tc
(g)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.51794 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 321.48 258.96 Tm
(1)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 325.92 260.4 Tm
0.169 Tc
[(;:)1(::;)1(x)]TJ
/F15 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 353.76 258.96 Tm
0 Tc
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 359.28 260.4 Tm
(\))Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.66248 0 Td
<15>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.05996 0 Td
(0)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.50589 0 Td
(;)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
-24.76452 -2.11992 TD
(where)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
2.93898 0 Td
(f)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.98769 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.99947 0 Td
(g)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.89133 0 Td
[(are)-373(p)-25(olynomials.)-373(More)-374(generally)84(,)-373(y)24(ou)-373(migh)24(t)-386(ha)24(v)24(e)-373(sev)24(eral)-362(in-)]TJ
-6.81747 -1.19245 TD
[(equalities)-313(instead)-314(of)-313(just)-327(one.)-313(Using)-313(simple)-314(iden)25(tities,)-327(one)-313(can)-312(sho)23(w)-301(that)-326(an)25(y)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(quan)24(ti\fer-free)-410(form)23(ula)-421(is)-435(equiv)61(alen)24(t)-422(to)-434(one)-421(in)-434(the)-433(form)-423(indicated.)-433(That)-434(is,)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(if)-362(suc)24(h)-349(form)23(ulas)-337(are)-338(com)25(bined)-349(with)-362(\\not",)-337(\\and",)-338(or)-349(\\or",)-326(the)-361(result)-351(can)-336(b)-25(e)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(equiv)60(alen)25(tly)-266(expressed)-253(in)-265(the)-265(standard)-255(form)-265(men)24(tioned.)-265(T)84(arski's)-254(idea)-253(is)-265(called)]TJ
ET
q
56.76 0 0 -0.48 134.748 184.068 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 177.12 Tm
(26)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 173.28 Tm
[(The)-402(exact)-387(b)-27(orderline)-402(for)-413(classes)-413(of)-401(iden)25(tities)-400(still)-414(is)-401(not)-401(kno)27(wn)-388(v)27(ery)-374(accurately)81(.)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(F)80(or)-307(example,)-320(what)-308(if)-321(w)27(e)-308(k)27(eep)-295(the)-308(restriction)-319(that)-307(the)-307(argumen)27(ts)-307(of)-320(trig)-307(functions)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(should)-349(b)-27(e)-334(linear)-361(with)-349(in)27(teger)-347(co)-26(e\016cien)26(ts,)-360(but)-335(w)27(e)-348(allo)27(w)-375(logarithms)-358(and)-349(exp)-27(onen-)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
(tials?)Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
29 0 obj
<<
/Length 10946
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 290.52 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(The)-335(Mec)27(hanization)-361(of)-361(Mathematics)-2674(27)]TJ
ET
q
331.32001 0 0 -1.08 134.748 676.188 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F4 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 236.4 661.2 Tm
[(Fig.)-187(2.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
3.50643 0 Td
[(What)-348(is)-347(T)80(arski)-346(algebra?)]TJ
-14.84212 -1.88705 TD
[(The)-295(tec)27(hnical)-295(name)-294(of)-307(this)-294(branc)27(h)-282(of)-294(mathematics)-305(is)-307(the)-281(theory)-280(of)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
29.5504 0 Td
[(r)53(e)53(al-close)54(d)-348(\felds)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
7.1467 0 Td
(.)Tj
-36.6971 -1.21788 TD
[(The)-456(language)-467(for)-468(this)-454(branc)26(h)-442(of)-467(mathematics)-466(has)-455(sym)28(b)-27(ols)-454(for)-467(t)27(w)27(o)-455(op)-27(erations)-467(+)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
(and)Tj
/F11 1 Tf
2.02088 0 Td
<01>Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.28105 0 Td
[(,)-361(the)-362(in)26(v)28(erse)-361(op)-27(erations)]TJ
/F11 1 Tf
10.88065 0 Td
<00>Tj
/F10 1 Tf
(x)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.73983 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
2.02088 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F17 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 291.96 626.16 Tm
<00>Tj
/F8 1 Tf
0.9636 -0.00001 TD
(1)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 301.8 622.32 Tm
[(,)-361(the)-362(additiv)27(e)-348(and)-362(m)28(ultiplicativ)27(e)-375(iden)26(tit)27(y)]TJ
-18.6296 -1.21788 TD
[(elemen)27(ts)-321(0)-320(and)-322(1,)-321(the)-321(ordering)-321(relation)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
17.62585 0 Td
(<)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
[(,)-321(and)-309(the)-321(equalit)28(y)-308(relation)-333(=.)-322(The)-321(axioms)]TJ
-17.62585 -1.21788 TD
[(include)-283(the)-281(usual)-281(la)27(ws)-307(for)-293(+)-281(and)]TJ
/F11 1 Tf
14.56107 0 Td
<01>Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.28105 0 Td
[(,)-294(and)-269(axioms)-292(relating)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
9.62262 0 Td
(<)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.08405 0 Td
[(to)-280(the)-281(op)-27(erations)-293(+)-281(and)]TJ
/F11 1 Tf
10.86726 0 Td
<01>Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.28105 0 Td
(.)Tj
-36.6971 -1.23127 TD
[(De\fning)-268(0)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
4.818 0 Td
0.281 Tc
(<x)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.94058 0 Td
0 Tc
(as)Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.17773 0 Td
(P)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.803 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
0.4015 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.58887 0 Td
0.254 Tc
(\)\()Tj
/F10 1 Tf
1.05728 0 Td
0 Tc
(P)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.07067 0 Td
[(for)-280(\\p)-27(ositiv)29(e"\),)-281(those)-266(axioms)-279(sa)27(y)-267(that)-267(the)-267(sum)-254(of)-281(p)-27(ositiv)29(e)]TJ
-11.85763 -1.21788 TD
[(elemen)27(ts)-347(is)-334(p)-28(ositiv)29(e)-348(and)-335(the)-322(pro)-26(duct)-335(of)-347(p)-28(ositiv)29(e)-348(elemen)26(ts)-333(is)-348(p)-27(ositiv)28(e.)-348(These)-334(are)-347(the)]TJ
T*
[(axioms)-279(of)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
4.4968 0 Td
[(or)53(der)53(e)53(d)-321(\felds)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
5.76822 0 Td
[(.)-294(The)-269(axioms)-292(for)-280(real-closed)-293(\felds)-268(sp)-27(ecify)-281(in)-282(addition)-281(that)-266(all)]TJ
-10.26502 -1.23127 TD
[(p)-27(ositiv)28(e)-294(elemen)26(ts)-280(ha)27(v)27(e)-268(a)-294(square)-280(ro)-25(ot,)-294(and)-268(all)-294(p)-27(olynomials)-306(of)-294(o)-27(dd)-268(degree)-294(ha)26(v)28(e)-268(a)-294(ro)-26(ot.)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(One)-282(will,)-321(of)-294(course,)-307(need)-282(in\fnitely)-282(man)27(y)-280(axioms)-293(to)-293(express)-293(this)-294(without)-281(men)27(tioning)]TJ
T*
[(the)-468(concept)-469(of)-495(\\natural)-480(n)26(um)27(b)-27(er",)-468(one)-468(axiom)-481(for)-494(eac)27(h)-468(o)-27(dd)-469(degree.)-495(The)-469(classical)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(theory)-360(of)-388(real-closed)-387(\felds)-361(is)-388(dev)26(elop)-26(ed)-362(in)-376(most)-372(algebra)-387(textb)-26(o)-27(oks,)-373(for)-374(example)-374(in)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[([65],)-361(pp.)-349(273)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
5.87528 0 Td
<0B>Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.62902 0 Td
(.)Tj
-6.5043 -1.21788 TD
[(T)80(arski)-279(algebra)-293(escap)-27(es)-294(the)-267(negativ)27(e)-281(results)-293(of)-280(Ch)26(urc)27(h)-268(and)-268<477F>509(odel)-295(b)-27(ecause)-281(it)-281(do)-26(es)-281(not)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(ha)27(v)27(e)-308(v)54(ariables)-334(for)-320(natural)-320(n)26(um)27(b)-27(ers.)-307(The)-322(v)54(ariables)-333(range)-321(o)27(v)27(er)-320(\\real)-334(n)27(um)26(b)-27(ers"{these)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(are)-374(the)-361(n)26(um)27(b)-27(ers)-347(that)-361(corresp)-25(ond)-375(to)-361(p)-27(oin)27(ts)-361(on)-361(a)-375(line)-375(and)-348(are)-374(used)-362(for)-374(co)-26(ordinates.)]TJ
T*
[(Ev)27(en)-348(though)-348(the)-335(v)54(ariables)-360(of)-361(T)80(arski)-359(algebra)-374(are)-360(mean)27(t)-348(to)-347(stand)-347(for)-361(suc)27(h)-348(n)26(um)27(b)-27(ers,)]TJ
T*
[(not)-361(all)-388(individual)-362(n)26(um)27(b)-28(ers)-360(can)-361(b)-28(e)-375(de\fned)-349(in)-362(T)80(arski)-373(algebra.)-387(In)-362(this)-374(language,)-387(one)]TJ
0 -1.23126 TD
[(cannot)-508(directly)-508(write)-521(in)26(tegers)-520(in)-509(decimal)-522(notation)-507(suc)27(h)-509(as)-521(3.)-509(Instead)-508(of)-521(3,)-521(one)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(o\016cially)-413(has)-415(to)-400(write)-401(1)-415(+)-388(1)-401(+)-401(1.)-415(Aside)-402(from)-399(the)-402(incon)26(v)27(enience,)-402(one)-402(can)-402(in)-402(e\013ect)]TJ
T*
[(write)-387(an)26(y)-361(rational)-399(n)26(um)27(b)-28(er;)-361(for)-387(example)-374(2)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
18.72328 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.50857 0 Td
[(3)-388(is)-387(\(1)-254(+)-241(1\)\(1)-252(+)-254(1)-254(+)-241(1\))]TJ
/F17 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 397.08 428.88 Tm
<00>Tj
/F8 1 Tf
0.96359 0 Td
(1)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 407.04 425.16 Tm
[(.)-375(But)-374(one)-375(do)-27(es)]TJ
-30.36678 -1.23127 TD
[(not,)-348(for)-346(example,)-361(ha)26(v)28(e)-335(a)-348(name)-334(for)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
15.53805 0 Td
<19>Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.62902 0 Td
(.)Tj
ET
q
331.32001 0 0 -1.08 134.748 404.268 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F7 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 367.56 Tm
[(elimination)-362(of)-349(quanti\fers)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
10.99708 0 Td
[(.)-313(He)-325(sho)24(w)24(ed)-301(in)-313([97])-313(that)-314(ev)24(ery)-301(form)24(ula)-301(in)-326(T)85(arski)-302(al-)]TJ
-10.99708 -1.2045 TD
[(gebra)-277(is)-302(equiv)61(alen)24(t)-289(to)-302(one)-288(without)-302(an)24(y)-289(quan)24(ti\fers.)-290(F)84(or)-290(example,)-288(the)-302(question)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
(whether)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
3.78213 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 178.08 347.28 Tm
(2)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 183.84 343.68 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.90337 0 Td
(bx)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.12018 0 Td
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.90337 0 Td
(c)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.71066 0 Td
[(=)-277(0)-277(has)-277(a)-277(solution)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
8.09424 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.8552 0 Td
[(with)-289(0)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
2.9992 0 Td
<14>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.05996 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.8552 0 Td
[(app)-24(ears)-266(to)-289(in)24(v)24(olv)24(e)-264(\\there)]TJ
-22.42779 -1.2045 TD
[(exists)-314(an)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.13143 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56612 0 Td
[(",)-325(but)-326(from)-314(the)-337(quadratic)-302(form)24(ula)-313(w)24(e)-313(\fnd)-337(that)-326(the)-326(answ)24(er)-301(can)-313(b)-24(e)]TJ
-4.69755 -1.19246 TD
[(expressed)-241(b)24(y)-241(a)-241(condition)-241(in)24(v)24(olving)-241(only)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
17.06776 0 Td
(b)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.67452 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.86697 0 Td
(c)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.43362 0 Td
[(,)-241(namely)85(,)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.10735 0 Td
(b)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 379.68 323.4 Tm
(2)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 384.6 319.8 Tm
<00>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.84315 0 Td
(4)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.50589 0 Td
(c)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.69861 0 Td
<15>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.04791 0 Td
[(0)-253(and)-241(either)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
-28.17325 -1.2045 TD
(b)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.74679 0 Td
<14>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.08405 0 Td
0.349 Tc
[(0o)349(r)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
2.10787 0 Td
0 Tc
(c)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.74679 0 Td
<14>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.0961 0 Td
[(0.)-349(The)-349(quan)24(ti\fer)-350(\\there)-337(exists)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
13.58676 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56612 0 Td
[(")-361(has)-350(b)-24(een)-361(eliminated.)-349(Sev)24(eral)]TJ
-19.93447 -1.2045 TD
[(classical)-217(results)-231(of)-228(algebra)-205(ha)24(v)24(e)-216(a)-229(similar)-218(\ra)24(v)24(or.)-217(F)84(or)-217(example,)-229(Sturm's)-230(theorem)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(from)-290(the)-313(1830s)-265([65],)-289(p.)-301(276,)-289(coun)24(ts)-290(the)-301(n)24(um)24(b)-24(er)-301(of)-290(ro)-24(ots)-290(of)-301(a)-289(p)-24(olynomial)-289(in)-301(an)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(in)24(terv)60(al)-241(in)-253(terms)-242(of)-253(the)-253(alternations)-231(of)-253(signs)-241(in)-241(the)-254(co)-23(e\016cien)25(ts.)-254(Another)-242(classi-)]TJ
T*
[(cal)-289(result)-290(is)-290(the)-301(existence)-289(of)-289(the)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
13.91197 0 Td
[(r)49(esultant)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
3.78213 0 Td
[(:)-277(If)-302(w)25(e)-289(are)-277(giv)24(en)-289(p)-24(olynomials)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
12.67134 0 Td
(f)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
[(a;)-169(x)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.54176 0 Td
(\))Tj
-32.89489 -1.19245 TD
(and)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.93924 0 Td
(g)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.51793 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
[(a;)-169(x)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.54176 0 Td
[(\),)-350(w)25(e)-325(can)-325(compute)-337(another)-314(p)-24(olynomial)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
17.20026 0 Td
(R)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.77088 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
[(a;)-169(b)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.40927 0 Td
[(\))-326(called)-336(the)-338(resultan)23(t)]TJ
-24.15022 -1.2045 TD
(of)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.22859 0 Td
(f)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.02383 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
2.02356 0 Td
(g)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.51793 0 Td
[(,)-422(suc)24(h)-421(that)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
5.2998 0 Td
(R)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.77088 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
[(a;)-169(b)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.40926 0 Td
[(\))-422(=)-422(0)-409(if)-434(and)-409(only)-422(if)-422(a)-421(common)-409(solution)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
18.13977 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.98769 0 Td
(can)Tj
-31.78675 -1.19245 TD
[(b)-24(e)-349(found)-362(for)-337(the)-350(equations)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
11.98477 0 Td
(f)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
[(a;)-169(x)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.54176 0 Td
[(\))-302(=)-301(0)-349(and)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.58914 0 Td
(g)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.51793 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
[(a;)-169(x)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.54176 0 Td
[(\))-302(=)-301(0.)-349(Again)-337(the)-361(quan)24(ti\fer)]TJ
-21.5485 -1.2045 TD
[(\\there)-337(exists)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
5.85387 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
[(")-349(has)-338(b)-24(een)-349(eliminated.)-349(T)85(arski)-339(sho)24(w)24(ed)-337(that)-350(algebraic)-325(metho)-24(ds)]TJ
-6.41998 -1.2045 TD
[(can)-421(alw)24(a)24(ys)-397(b)-25(e)-433(applied)-421(to)-422(eliminate)-434(\\there)-410(exists")-422(from)-422(algebraic)-397(form)23(ulas,)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(ev)24(en)-397(ones)-409(in)24(v)24(olving)-386(inequalities.)-410(The)-409(elimination)-409(of)-410(one)-397(quan)24(ti\fer)-398(dep)-24(ends)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(essen)24(tially)-266(on)-277(the)-277(fact)-289(that)-278(a)-277(p)-24(olynomial)-265(has)-277(only)-265(\fnitely)-290(man)24(y)-265(ro)-24(ots,)-266(and)-277(w)24(e)]TJ
T*
[(can)-409(compute)-410(the)-421(n)24(um)24(b)-25(er,)-409(the)-422(maxim)24(um)-410(size,)-409(and)-410(some)-397(information)-411(ab)-24(out)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(the)-422(lo)-24(cation)-409(of)-410(the)-422(ro)-24(ots)-398(from)-423(the)-409(co)-24(e\016cien)25(ts)-422(of)-410(the)-422(p)-24(olynomial.)-409(Applying)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(this)-338(pro)-25(cedure)-325(again)-325(and)-325(again,)-325(w)24(e)-336(can)-325(strip)-339<6F0B>-337(one)-325(quan)24(ti\fer)-326(after)-338(another)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
30 0 obj
<<
/Length 11003
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 134.76 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(28)-2662(Mic)26(hael)-361(Beeson)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(\(from)-302(the)-301(inside)-290(out\),)-302(eliminating)-301(all)-289(the)-302(quan)24(ti\fers)-290(in)-301(a)-289(form)23(ula)-289(with)-301(nested)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(quan)24(ti\fers.)-375(W)85(e)-397(need)-385(only)-386(deal)-385(with)-397(\\there)-386(exists")-374(b)-25(ecause)-384(\\for)-374(all")-385(can)-374(b)-24(e)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
[(expressed)-350(as)-362(\\not)-349(there)-362(exists)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
13.46631 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.93951 0 Td
[(not")-350(.)-373(T)85(arski's)-339(pro)-25(cedure)-361(is)-361(a)-350(decision)-361(pro-)]TJ
-14.40582 -1.19245 TD
[(cedure)-373(for)-386(T)85(arski)-363(algebra,)-373(b)-24(ecause)-373(if)-386(w)25(e)-385(start)-375(with)-386(a)-385(form)23(ula)-373(that)-387(has)-373(only)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(quan)24(ti\fed)-386(v)61(ariables)-374(\(so)-387(it)-386(mak)25(es)-374(an)-385(assertion)-375(that)-386(should)-387(b)-24(e)-397(true)-386(or)-374(false\),)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(after)-422(w)24(e)-433(apply)-422(the)-433(pro)-25(cedure)-421(w)24(e)-421(get)-434(a)-421(purely)-434(n)24(umerical)-422(form)24(ula)-410(in)24(v)24(olving)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(equations)-350(and)-361(inequalities)-350(of)-361(rational)-338(n)24(um)24(b)-25(ers,)-362(and)-349(w)25(e)-361(can)-349(simply)-362(compute)]TJ
T*
[(whether)-337(it)-338(is)-326(true)-338(or)-313(false.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.28882 TD
[(Descartes)-242(sho)24(w)25(ed)-241(sev)24(eral)-241(cen)25(turies)-255(earlier)-241(that)-266(geometry)-241(could)-252(b)-24(e)-265(reduced)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.19245 TD
[(to)-386(algebra,)-361(b)24(y)-373(the)-386(device)-385(of)-373(co)-24(ordinates.)-362(This)-386(reduction,)-386(kno)25(wn)-374(as)-373(analytic)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(geometry)84(,)-265(coupled)-276(with)-278(T)85(arski's)-266(reduction)-278(of)-277(algebra)-253(with)-289(quan)24(ti\fers)-266(to)-277(com-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(putation,)-386(yields)-374(a)-373(reduction)-374(of)-374(geometry)-361(\(with)-386(quan)24(ti\fers\))-375(to)-374(computation.)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(In)-338(more)-325(tec)24(hnical)-325(w)25(ords:)-326(a)-326(decision)-325(pro)-24(cedure)-325(for)-326(Euclidean)-336(geometry)84(.)-313(Th)24(us)]TJ
T*
[(Hilb)-24(ert's)-459(program,)-422(to)-458(reduce)-446(mathematics)-446(to)-446(computation,)-446(migh)24(t)-458(seem)-446(to)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(b)-24(e)-482(ac)25(hiev)24(ed)-469(for)-470(the)-482(mathematics)-471(of)-482(the)-482(classical)-458(era,)-470(algebra)-457(and)-470(geome-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(try)83(.)-361(T)85(arski's)-339(studen)23(t)-362(Szmielew)-360(made)-361(it)-362(w)25(ork)-350(for)-350(non-Euclidean)-348(\(h)23(yp)-24(erb)-24(olic\))]TJ
T*
[(geometry)-241(to)-24(o)-253([27].)-253(Since)-253(the)-265(W)85(eierstrass)-243(substitution)-268(reduces)-241(trigonometry)-242(to)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(algebra,)-289(a)-313(decision)-301(metho)-24(d)-326(for)-301(real-closed)-290(\felds)-313(also)-301(applies)-314(to)-301(trigonometry)83(,)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(as)-326(long)-325(as)-325(the)-338(argumen)24(ts)-314(of)-337(the)-338(trig)-326(functions)-338(are)-313(linear.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.28882 TD
[(T)85(arski's)-207(result)-230(is)-229(regarded)-205(as)-217(v)24(ery)-217(imp)-24(ortan)23(t.)-229(Hundreds)-230(of)-229(researc)24(hers)-193(ha)24(v)24(e)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.19245 TD
[(pursued,)-326(and)-325(con)24(tin)24(ue)-325(to)-326(pursue,)-326(the)-337(lines)-326(of)-325(in)24(v)24(estigation)-314(he)-325(op)-24(ened.)-325(There)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(are)-434(t)24(w)24(o)-433(reasons)-435(for)-434(that:)-458(First,)-448(his)-446(results)-436(con)25(trast)-435(sharply)-435(with)-458(Ch)24(urc)24(h's)]TJ
T*
[(and)-373<477F>506(odel's,)-374(and)-361(sho)23(w)-373(that)-374(the)-374(classical)-361(areas)-350(of)-373(algebra)-349(and)-374(geometry)-361(are)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(not)-494(sub)-61(ject)-494(to)-494(those)-482(limiting)-507(theorems.)-483(Second,)-493(there)-482(are)-482(plen)24(t)24(y)-494(of)-494(op)-24(en)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(and)-325(in)24(teresting)-327(problems)-326(that)-338(can)-325(b)-24(e)-325(form)24(ulated)-326(in)-337(the)-337(theory)-326(of)-325(real-closed)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(\felds,)-314(and)-313(this)-314(has)-301(raised)-302(the)-314(hop)-24(e)-313(that)-326(decision)-301(pro)-24(cedures)-301(implemen)24(ted)-313(on)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(a)-337(computer)-350(migh)24(t)-338(one)-336(da)24(y)-338(routinely)-350(answ)24(er)-325(op)-24(en)-337(questions.)-350(Our)-338(purp)-25(ose)-337(in)]TJ
T*
[(this)-338(section)-326(is)-338(to)-325(in)24(v)24(estigate)-314(this)-338(p)-24(ossibilit)22(y)85(.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.28882 TD
[(First,)-411(let)-434(us)-422(giv)24(e)-397(an)-422(example)-421(of)-409(an)-422(op)-24(en)-421(problem)-410(one)-421(can)-409(form)23(ulate)-422(in)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.19245 TD
[(T)85(arski)-351(algebra.)-349(Here)-361(is)-374(an)-361(example)-361(from)-362(the)-373(theory)-362(of)-374(sphere-pac)24(king.)-337(This)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(example,)-313(and)-313(man)24(y)-301(others,)-314(can)-301(b)-24(e)-325(found)-313(in)-326([32].)-301(The)-312(\\kissing)-302(problem")-302(asks)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(ho)24(w)-337(man)24(y)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.83004 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
[(-dimensional)-326(spheres)-326(can)-337(b)-24(e)-349(pac)24(k)25(ed)-325(disjoin)23(tly)-350(so)-325(that)-350(they)-350(eac)25(h)]TJ
-5.43229 -1.2045 TD
[(touc)24(h)-229(the)-241(unit)-241(sphere)-230(cen)25(tered)-229(at)-242(origin.)-217(F)84(or)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
19.0311 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.87929 0 Td
[(=)-277(2)-229(the)-241(answ)24(er)-217(is)-229(six)-230(\(2-spheres)]TJ
-19.91039 -1.2045 TD
[(are)-301(circles\).)-314(F)84(or)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
7.0945 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.87929 0 Td
[(=)-277(3)-313(the)-325(answ)24(er)-302(is)-313(12.)-301(F)84(or)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
11.25003 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.87928 0 Td
[(=)-277(4)-313(the)-325(answ)24(er)-302(is)-313(either)-314(24,)-313(or)]TJ
-20.1031 -1.19245 TD
[(25,)-337(but)-362(nob)-24(o)-24(dy)-349(kno)24(ws)-338(whic)25(h!)-350(The)-348(problem)-350(can)-349(b)-24(e)-349(form)24(ulated)-350(in)-349(the)-362(theory)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(of)-349(real-closed)-326(\felds,)-349(using)-350(100)-337(v)60(ariables)-338(for)-337(the)-362(co)-24(ordinates)-326(of)-349(the)-362(cen)25(ters)-338(of)]TJ
T*
[(the)-422(spheres.)-410(W)84(e)-433(simply)-410(ha)24(v)24(e)-409(to)-422(sa)24(y)-398(that)-434(eac)25(h)-410(cen)25(ter)-411(is)-422(at)-409(distance)-422(2)-410(from)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(the)-325(origin)-314(and)-325(that)-338(eac)25(h)-314(of)-325(the)-325(300)-313(pairs)-314(of)-326(p)-24(oin)24(ts)-326(are)-313(at)-325(least)-326(2)-313(units)-339(apart.)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(Explicitly)84(,)-373(w)24(e)-361(wish)-373(to)-374(kno)24(w)-361(if)-385(there)-362(exist)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
18.51316 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 324.84 207.84 Tm
(1)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 329.4 209.28 Tm
0.169 Tc
[(;:)1(::)12(;)1(x)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 357.12 207.84 Tm
0 Tc
(25)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 365.64 209.28 Tm
0.169 Tc
(;y)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 375 207.84 Tm
0 Tc
(1)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 379.44 209.28 Tm
0.169 Tc
[(;:)1(::;)1(y)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 406.56 207.84 Tm
0 Tc
(25)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 414.96 209.28 Tm
0.169 Tc
(;z)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 424.08 207.84 Tm
0 Tc
(1)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 428.4 209.28 Tm
0.169 Tc
[(;:)1(::;)1(z)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 455.28 207.84 Tm
0 Tc
(25)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 463.68 209.28 Tm
(,)Tj
-33.01534 -1.19245 TD
(and)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
2.05969 0 Td
(w)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 162.36 195.96 Tm
(1)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 166.92 197.4 Tm
0.169 Tc
[(;:)1(::)12(;)1(w)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 196.08 195.96 Tm
0 Tc
(25)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 209.04 197.4 Tm
[(suc)24(h)-446(that)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.66142 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 261.12 201 Tm
(2)Tj
/F15 1 Tf
0 -0.89477 TD
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 268.56 197.4 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.08405 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 284.64 201 Tm
(2)Tj
/F15 1 Tf
-0.05162 -0.89477 TD
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 292.08 197.4 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.072 0 Td
(z)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 307.92 201 Tm
(2)Tj
/F15 1 Tf
-0.06883 -0.89477 TD
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 315.36 197.4 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.07201 0 Td
(w)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 333.36 201 Tm
(2)Tj
/F15 1 Tf
-0.03441 -0.89477 TD
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 342.6 197.4 Tm
[(=)-470(4)-445(and)-446(\()]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.64937 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F15 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 394.56 195.96 Tm
(i)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 400.92 197.4 Tm
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.07201 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F15 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 417.24 195.96 Tm
(j)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 421.56 197.4 Tm
(\))Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 425.4 201 Tm
(2)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 432.84 197.4 Tm
0.301 Tc
(+\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.46949 0 Td
0 Tc
(y)Tj
/F15 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 452.4 195.96 Tm
(i)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 458.64 197.4 Tm
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
-32.50945 -1.2045 TD
(y)Tj
/F15 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 139.68 183.96 Tm
(j)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 143.88 185.4 Tm
(\))Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 147.72 189 Tm
(2)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 154.08 185.4 Tm
0.193 Tc
(+\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.36109 0 Td
0 Tc
(z)Tj
/F15 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 172.32 183.96 Tm
(i)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 177.48 185.4 Tm
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.97565 0 Td
(z)Tj
/F15 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 191.88 183.96 Tm
(j)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 195.96 185.4 Tm
(\))Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 199.8 189 Tm
(2)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 206.28 185.4 Tm
0.181 Tc
(+\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.34904 0 Td
0 Tc
(w)Tj
/F15 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 226.8 183.96 Tm
(i)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 232.08 185.4 Tm
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.97565 0 Td
(w)Tj
/F15 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 248.88 183.96 Tm
(j)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 253.08 185.4 Tm
(\))Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 256.92 189 Tm
(2)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 264.24 185.4 Tm
<15>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.04792 0 Td
[(4)-313(for)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
2.33673 0 Td
(i)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.62634 0 Td
(6)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.04791 0 Td
(j)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.46976 0 Td
[(.)-325(All)-325(w)24(e)-313(ha)24(v)24(e)-300(to)-314(do)-313(is)-314(run)-313(T)84(arski's)]TJ
-18.52521 -1.2045 TD
[(algorithm)-314(on)-337(that)-338(form)23(ula,)-313(and)-337(the)-338(op)-24(en)-325(problem)-337(will)-325(b)-25(e)-336(answ)23(ered.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 429.24 177 Tm
(27)Tj
ET
q
56.76 0 0 -0.48 134.748 162.108 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 155.16 Tm
(27)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 151.32 Tm
[(Another)-348(in)26(teresting)-372(sphere-pac)26(king)-348(problem)-361(w)27(as)-374(op)-26(en)-362(for)-374(cen)26(turies,)-360(un)26(til)-361(it)-361(w)26(as)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(solv)28(ed)-335(in)-349(1998.)-359(Namely)81(,)-335(what)-347(is)-348(the)-335(densest)-334(pac)27(king)-348(of)-347(spheres)-334(in)26(to)-347(a)-334(large)-360(cub)-28(e)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
31 0 obj
<<
/Length 8259
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 290.52 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(The)-335(Mec)27(hanization)-361(of)-361(Mathematics)-2674(29)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 149.76 666.2401 Tm
[(W)84(ell)-300(then,)-314(wh)25(y)-302(is)-301(this)-302(problem)-302(still)-302(op)-24(en?)-313(The)-300(suspicion)-302(ma)24(y)-289(b)-24(e)-313(da)24(wning)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(on)-458(y)24(ou)-445(that)-459(it)-458(isn't)-471(so)-446(easy)-445(to)-459(run)-458(this)-459(pro)-24(cedure)-445(on)-446(a)-458(form)24(ula)-446(with)-458(100)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
[(quan)24(ti\fed)-289(v)60(ariables!)-278(In)-301(the)-302(half-cen)25(tury)-278(since)-301(T)84(arski's)-278(w)24(ork,)-277(researc)24(hers)-254(ha)24(v)24(e)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(found)-398(more)-373(e\016cien)25(t)-398(algorithms)-375(for)-386(quan)24(ti\fer)-374(elimination,)-398(but)-398(on)-385(the)-386(other)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(hand,)-277(they)-277(ha)24(v)24(e)-253(also)-265(pro)24(v)24(ed)-253(theorems)-254(sho)24(wing)-265(that)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
22.37961 0 Td
(any)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.83084 0 Td
[(algorithm)-254(for)-277(quan)24(ti-)]TJ
-24.21045 -1.19245 TD
[(\fer)-325(elimination)-338(m)24(ust)-326(necessarily)-314(run)-326(slo)24(wly)-325(when)-337(large)-313(n)24(um)24(b)-24(ers)-326(of)-325(v)60(ariables)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(are)-385(in)24(v)24(olv)24(ed.)-385(These)-385(lines)-398(of)-398(researc)24(h)-373(no)24(w)-397(almost)-387(meet:)-397(the)-410(b)-24(est)-398(algorithms)]TJ
T*
[(almost)-338(ac)24(hiev)25(e)-325(the)-350(theoretical)-325(limits.)-351(Ho)25(w)24(ev)25(er,)-326(it)-349(seems)-338(that)-350(the)-338(edge)-336(of)-350(ca-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(pabilit)24(y)-314(of)-301(algorithms)-302(is)-314(close)-301(to)-301(the)-326(edge)-300(of)-313(h)24(uman)-301(capabilit)24(y)-314(as)-301(w)24(ell,)-301(so)-313(the)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(p)-24(ossibilit)22(y)-325(that)-326(decision)-313(pro)-24(cedures)-314(migh)24(t)-325(settle)-326(an)-326(op)-24(en)-312(question)-326(cannot)-313(b)-25(e)]TJ
T*
[(de\fnitiv)24(ely)-337(refuted.)-338(W)84(e)-336(therefore)-314(review)-325(the)-337(situation)-339(carefully)84(.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.52971 TD
[(First)-351(w)24(e)-361(review)-349(the)-361(w)24(orst-case)-326(analyses)-338(that)-362(sho)23(w)-349(quan)25(ti\fer)-350(elimination)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(m)24(ust)-290(run)-290(slo)24(wly)84(.)-265(Fisc)24(her)-277(and)-289(Rabin)-289(sho)23(w)25(ed)-277([42])-277(that)-290(an)24(y)-277(algorithm)-266(for)-289(quan-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(ti\fer)-278(elimination)-277(in)-277(real-closed)-253(\felds)-278(will)-289(necessarily)-253(require)-265(exp)-24(onen)24(tial)-265(time)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(for)-302(w)25(orst-case)-279(input)-313(form)23(ulas;)-289(that)-302(is,)-302(time)-314(of)-301(the)-313(order)-290(of)-301(2)]TJ
/F15 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 392.76 499.08 Tm
(dn)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 405.36 495.48 Tm
(where)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
2.85467 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.90337 0 Td
[(is)-314(the)]TJ
-30.91952 -1.2045 TD
[(length)-253(of)-241(the)-253(input)-266(form)24(ula,)-229(and)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
13.9722 0 Td
(d)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.77088 0 Td
[(is)-241(a)-241(\fxed)-253(constan)24(t.)-242(This)-253(is)-241(true)-254(ev)24(en)-240(for)-242(for-)]TJ
-14.74308 -1.19245 TD
[(m)24(ulas)-326(in)24(v)24(olving)-313(only)-337(addition)-326(\(not)-338(m)24(ultiplication\).)-338(Later)-326([104,36])-301(a)-337(stronger)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(lo)24(w)25(er)-350(b)-24(ound)-386(w)25(as)-362(pro)24(v)24(ed:)-349(sometimes)-375(quan)25(ti\fer)-362(elimination)-374(will)-373(require)-362(time)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(\(and)-362(space\))-337(of)-362(the)-361(order)-338(2)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 249.24 451.32 Tm
(2)Tj
/F18 1 Tf
4.98132 0 0 4.98132 253.2 454.32 Tm
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 262.08 447.72 Tm
[(\(double)-350(exp)-23(onen)24(tial\).)-350(\()-362(See)-349([84])-349(for)-350(a)-349(surv)23(ey)-337(of)]TJ
-12.77975 -1.2045 TD
[(results)-351(on)-361(the)-362(complexit)24(y)-349(of)-349(this)-363(problem.\))-362(T)85(aking)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
22.56028 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.91542 0 Td
[(=)-313(64)-349(w)24(e)-349(get)-361(a)-349(n)24(um)24(b)-25(er)]TJ
-23.4757 -1.2045 TD
[(with)-350(more)-325(than)-338(10)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 215.88 427.32 Tm
(18)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 227.64 423.72 Tm
[(decimal)-337(digits.)-338(No)-337(w)24(onder)-325(the)-349(kissing)-327(n)24(um)24(b)-24(er)-337(problem)]TJ
-9.32283 -1.19245 TD
[(is)-338(still)-326(op)-24(en.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.54176 TD
[(T)85(arski's)-399(original)-398(algorithm,)-398(whic)24(h)-421(w)24(as)-398(nev)24(er)-409(implemen)24(ted,)-422(w)25(as)-410(in)-410(prin-)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.19245 TD
[(ciple)-337(m)24(uc)25(h)-338(slo)24(w)24(er)-313(ev)24(en)-324(than)-350(double)-325(exp)-24(onen)24(tial.)-337(T)84(arski's)-326(metho)-25(d)-337(eliminates)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(one)-337(quan)24(ti\fer)-338(at)-349(a)-338(time,)-349(and)-337(the)-350(form)24(ula)-338(expands)-337(in)-350(length)-337(b)24(y)-349(a)-337(double)-337(ex-)]TJ
T*
[(p)-24(onen)24(tial)-301(eac)25(h)-290(time,)-313(so)-289(the)-314(running)-302(time)-301(cannot)-301(b)-24(e)-301(b)-24(ounded)-313(b)24(y)-301(an)24(y)-289(to)23(w)25(er)-289(of)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(exp)-24(onen)25(ts.)-387(Fisc)24(her)-374(and)-373(Rabin's)-386(result)-387(w)25(as)-362(obtained)-386(in)-385(the)-386(fall)-385(of)-386(1972,)-361(but)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(not)-289(published)-302(un)24(til)-302(1974.)-264(In)-302(the)-289(in)24(terim,)-290(not)-302(kno)25(wing)-277(that)-290(e\016cien)25(t)-302(quan)24(ti\fer)]TJ
T*
[(elimination)-446(is)-446(imp)-24(ossible,)-447(George)-433(Collins)-446(in)24(v)24(en)25(ted)-434(an)-446(impro)24(v)24(ed)-434(quan)25(ti\fer-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(elimination)-362(metho)-24(d)-361(kno)24(wn)-337(as)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
13.34586 0 Td
[(cylindric)-409(algebr)50(aic)-397(de)48(c)49(omp)48(osition)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
14.74308 0 Td
[((CAD))-374([31].)]TJ
-28.08894 -1.2045 TD
[(Actually)84(,)-301(according)-276(to)-290(the)-313(preface)-289(of)-289([28],)-289(Collins)-301(had)-289(b)-25(een)-300(w)24(orking)-277(on)-301(quan-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(ti\fer)-338(elimination)-337(since)-338(1955,)-324(but)-350(the)-338(1973)-313(w)25(ork)-326(generalized)-324(his)-338(metho)-24(d)-350(to)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
32.69013 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
-32.69013 -1.2045 TD
[(v)60(ariables)-229(and)-253(hence)-240(made)-253(it)-253(a)-241(general)-229(quan)24(ti\fer)-241(elimination)-241(metho)-25(d.)-253(Collins's)]TJ
T*
[(metho)-24(d)-326(runs)-302(in)-325(double)-313(exp)-24(onen)25(tial)-302(time,)-326(m)24(uc)25(h)-313(b)-25(etter)-313(than)-326(T)85(arski's)-291(metho)-24(d,)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(and)-241(almost)-230(b)-24(est-p)-25(ossible)-229([36].)-241(W)84(e)-240(knew)-228(from)-242(Fisc)24(her)-230(and)-240(Rabin's)-230(lo)25(w)24(er)-229(b)-24(ound)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(that)-350(there)-350(w)25(as)-338(no)-349(hop)-24(e)-349(of)-350(a)-349(really)-337(e\016cien)25(t)-350(quan)24(ti\fer)-338(elimination)-350(algorithm,)]TJ
T*
[(but)-338(the)-337(CAD)-337(metho)-24(d)-337(is)-338(m)24(uc)24(h)-325(faster)-326(than)-326(T)84(arski's)-314(or)-326(Cohen's)-325(metho)-24(ds.)-338(The)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(w)24(orst)-254(case,)-240(when)-265(the)-277(algorithm)-242(tak)24(es)-253(time)-265(2)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 322.44 220.8 Tm
(2)Tj
/F18 1 Tf
4.98132 0 0 4.98132 326.4 223.8 Tm
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 331.8 217.2 Tm
[(,)-253(arises)-254(only)-253(when)-264(there)-254(are)-253(lots)]TJ
-19.77789 -1.2045 TD
[(of)-313(v)60(ariables.)-290(The)-312(algorithm)-302(is)-314(double)-301(exp)-24(onen)25(tial)-314(in)-313(the)-313(n)24(um)24(b)-25(er)-301(of)-313(v)60(ariables,)]TJ
ET
q
56.76 0 0 -0.48 134.748 184.068 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 173.28 Tm
[(in)-402(3-space?)-414(Kepler)-401(conjectured)-415(that)-401(it)-401(is)-414(the)-402(usual)-415(pac)27(king)-401(used)-402(b)26(y)-388(gro)-25(cers)-428(for)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(stac)28(king)-401(oranges,)-413(but)-389(this)-401(w)27(as)-401(di\016cult)-401(to)-401(pro)27(v)27(e.)-388(It)-387(can,)-402(ho)27(w)26(ev)28(er,)-402(easily)-413(b)-28(e)-388(for-)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(m)27(ulated)-361(in)-375(the)-362(theory)-360(at)-374(hand,)-362(so)-374(in)-362(principle,)-376(\\all)-387(w)26(e)-374(ha)26(v)27(e)-361(to)-374(do")-374(is)-374(quan)26(ti\fer)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
(elimination.)Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
32 0 obj
<<
/Length 8628
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 134.76 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(30)-2662(Mic)26(hael)-361(Beeson)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(but)-314(for)-301(a)-301(\fxed)-313(n)24(um)24(b)-25(er)-301(of)-301(v)60(ariables,)-289(the)-314(time)-313(increases)-290(only)-301(as)-301(some)-302(p)-24(o)24(w)25(er)-289(of)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(the)-337(length)-338(of)-325(the)-338(input.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 236.76 657.84 Tm
(28)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 149.76 639.2401 Tm
[(`Mo)-24(ore's)-423(la)25(w")-434(is)-446(the)-458(observ)60(ation,)-422(made)-445(in)-458(1965)-421(b)24(y)-446(Gordon)-434(Mo)-24(ore,)-434(co-)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(founder)-314(of)-313(In)24(tel,)-313(that)-314(data)-302(densit)23(y)-313(in)-313(computers)-314(\(bits)-315(p)-24(er)-313(square)-302(cen)25(timeter\))]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(has)-314(b)-24(een)-324(gro)23(wing)-288(exp)-24(onen)24(tially)84(,)-313(doubling)-313(ev)24(ery)-301(12-18)-289(mon)24(ths,)-314(ev)24(er)-301(since)-325(the)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(in)24(tegrated)-241(circuit)-254(w)25(as)-242(in)24(v)24(en)25(ted)-241(in)-253(1962.)-229(P)25(erhaps)-230(incorrectly)84(,)-241(man)24(y)-241(p)-24(eople)-252(also)]TJ
T*
[(use)-350(\\Mo)-24(ore's)-326(la)25(w")-337(to)-350(refer)-338(to)-349(the)-350(exp)-24(onen)25(tial)-350(increase)-325(in)-361(computer)-338(sp)-25(eed.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 457.92 594.96 Tm
(29)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 579.48 Tm
[(One)-373(should)-374(clearly)-361(understand)-375(that)-374(Mo)-25(ore's)-361(la)24(w)-373(cannot)-374(help)-373(us)-374(m)24(uc)24(h)-373(with)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(an)-337(algorithm)-338(whose)-337(running)-338(time)-350(is)-338(double)-349(exp)-24(onen)25(tial.)-338(If)-350(the)-349(running)-338(time)]TJ
T*
[(is)-350(2)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 150 559.2 Tm
(2)Tj
/F18 1 Tf
4.98132 0 0 4.98132 153.96 562.2 Tm
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 162.84 555.48 Tm
[(and)-349(w)24(e)-337(w)25(an)24(t)-350(to)-350(increase)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
10.94891 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.95156 0 Td
[(b)24(y)-349(one,)-349(w)24(e)-349(need)-349(a)-349(computer)-337(that)-363(runs)-338(2)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 457.08 559.2 Tm
(2)Tj
/F18 1 Tf
4.98132 0 0 4.98132 461.04 562.2 Tm
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 543.6 Tm
[(times)-374(faster,)-363(as)-361(a)-362(short)-362(calculation)-361(will)-361(sho)23(w)-361(y)24(ou:)-361(tak)24(e)-361(the)-374(ratio)-350(of)-373(the)-374(new)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(running)-326(time,)-325(2)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 202.2 535.2 Tm
(2)Tj
/F18 1 Tf
4.98132 0 0 4.98132 206.16 538.2 Tm
(n)Tj
/F16 1 Tf
0.89133 0 Td
(+1)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 220.08 531.6 Tm
[(,)-325(to)-314(the)-337(old)-325(running)-314(time)-338(2)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 336.48 535.2 Tm
(2)Tj
/F18 1 Tf
4.98132 0 0 4.98132 340.44 538.2 Tm
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 345.72 531.6 Tm
[(.)-325(Y)84(ou)-325(will)-325(get)-325(2)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 412.44 535.2 Tm
(2)Tj
/F18 1 Tf
4.98132 0 0 4.98132 416.4 538.2 Tm
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 425.04 531.6 Tm
[(when)-325(y)24(ou)]TJ
-29.13685 -1.19245 TD
[(simplify)-254(that)-242(ratio.)-241(It)-242(tak)24(es)-241(2)]TJ
/F15 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 257.64 523.32 Tm
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 265.44 519.72 Tm
[(Mo)-24(ore's)-230(la)24(w)-228(doubling)-241(p)-24(erio)-25(ds)-241(just)-254(to)-241(increase)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
19.57312 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
-32.69013 -1.2045 TD
[(b)24(y)-349(one.)-337(The)-349(imp)-24(ort)-350(of)-350(the)-361(double-exp)-24(onen)24(tial)-337(running)-338(time)-362(theorems)-338(ab)-24(out)]TJ
T*
[(quan)24(ti\fer)-410(elimination)-422(is)-410(therefore)-410(almost)-410(as)-410(grim)-410(as)-410(the)-422(imp)-24(ort)-423(of)-409<477F>506(odel's)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(theorem.)-410(It)-422(seems)-422(that)-423(Fisc)24(her,)-410(Rabin,)-409(W)84(eispfenning,)-434(and)-409(Da)24(v)24(enp)-24(ort)-410(ha)24(v)24(e)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(destro)23(y)24(ed)-313(T)85(arski's)-315(dream)-325(as)-326(thoroughly)-314(as)-325<477F>506(odel)-337(destro)23(y)24(ed)-313(Hilb)-24(ert's.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.50563 TD
[(But)-325(p)-25(eople)-324(nev)24(er)-325(giv)24(e)-313(up!)-325(Ma)24(yb)-24(e)-325(there)-326(is)-326(an)-325(escap)-24(e)-325(route.)-325(It)-326(w)24(as)-314(disco)24(v-)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(ered)-385(in)-398(1992)-361(b)24(y)-385(Grigorev)-374([46])-373(that)-399(if)-397(w)24(e)-385(restrict)-387(atten)24(tion)-386(to)-386(form)23(ulas)-386(that)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(only)-385(ha)24(v)24(e)-373(\\there)-386(exists",)-386(and)-386(no)-385(\\for)-386(all",)-385(then)-398(w)24(e)-385(can)-385(escap)-24(e)-385(the)-398(dreaded)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(double-exp)-24(onen)25(tial.)-386(He)-409(ga)24(v)24(e)-385(a)-397(decision)-386(pro)-24(cedure)-397(for)-398(this)-399(class)-398(of)-397(form)23(ulas)]TJ
T*
[(whic)25(h)-434(is)-422(\\only")-421(exp)-24(onen)24(tial)-422(in)-434(the)-433(n)24(um)24(b)-25(er)-421(of)-434(v)60(ariables.)-422(This)-422(is)-434(an)-421(imp)-25(or-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(tan)24(t)-350(di\013erence,)-349(since)-349(with)-350(an)-349(exp)-24(onen)25(tial)-350(algorithm,)-326(if)-362(it)-349(do)-24(esn't)-362(run)-338(to)-25(da)24(y)85(,)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(p)-24(erhaps)-350(our)-350(c)25(hildren)-350(will)-349(b)-24(e)-361(able)-349(to)-362(run)-350(it;)-362(while)-361(with)-361(a)-350(double-exp)-23(onen)24(tial)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(running)-326(time,)-337(our)-326(p)-24(osterit)22(y)-325(is)-326(also)-313(do)-24(omed)-337(to)-326(failure.)-325(F)84(urther)-327(impro)24(v)24(emen)25(ts)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(since)-325(1992)-313(are)-325(describ)-25(ed)-325(in)-337([8].)]TJ
1.50563 -1.50563 TD
[(A)-265(W)85(eb)-277(searc)24(h)-241(sho)24(ws)-254(that)-265(dozens,)-265(if)-278(not)-265(h)24(undreds,)-254(of)-265(researc)24(hers)-242(are)-253(w)25(ork-)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(ing)-385(on)-386(quan)24(ti\fer)-374(elimination)-386(these)-397(da)24(ys.)-374(Although)-386(w)25(e)-386(kno)25(w)-373(that)-399(quan)24(ti\fer)]TJ
T*
[(elimination)-374(will)-361(tak)24(e)-361(\\forev)24(er")-337(on)-374(large)-349(problems,)-362(there)-362(still)-374(migh)24(t)-362(b)-24(e)-373(some)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(in)24(teresting)-363(op)-24(en)-373(problems)-350(within)-386(reac)25(h|a)-337(tan)24(talizing)-362(p)-24(ossibilit)23(y)84(.)-374(Hong)-361([52])]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(made)-241(impro)24(v)24(emen)25(ts)-218(to)-241(the)-241(CAD)-253(algorithm,)-229(calling)-229(his)-241(enhanced)-240(v)24(ersion)-218(\\par-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(tial)-314(CAD",)-312(and)-301(implemen)24(ted)-313(it)-314(in)-313(a)-301(program)-290(called)-300(qep)-24(cad)-313(\(quan)24(ti\fer)-302(elimi-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(nation)-265(b)24(y)-277(partial)-266(CAD\).)-277(This)-277(program)-254(has)-266(subsequen)24(tly)-265(b)-25(een)-276(impro)23(v)25(ed)-265(up)-24(on)]TJ
T*
[(b)24(y)-241(man)24(y)-241(other)-229(p)-24(eople,)-253(and)-241(is)-241(publicly)-253(a)24(v)61(ailable)-229(on)-241(the)-253(W)85(eb)-241([22].)-241(A)25(t)-254(least)-229(some)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(of)-301(its)-302(functionalit)23(y)-301(has)-290(b)-24(een)-300(included)-313(with)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
18.58543 0 Td
[(Mathematic)48(a)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
5.90205 0 Td
[(v)24(ersions)-278(4.1)-289(and)-301(4.2,)]TJ
-24.48748 -1.2045 TD
[(in)-253(the)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
2.72217 0 Td
[(Exp)49(erimental)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
5.98636 0 Td
[(pac)24(k)61(age.)-229(But)-253(to)-241(the)-253(b)-24(est)-266(of)-241(m)24(y)-253(kno)24(wledge,)-227(the)-254(algorithms)]TJ
-8.70854 -1.2045 TD
[(in)-337([46])-325(and)-326([8])-325(ha)24(v)24(e)-324(not)-326(b)-24(een)-337(implemen)24(ted.)]TJ
ET
q
56.76 0 0 -0.48 134.748 205.908 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 199.08 Tm
(28)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 195.24 Tm
[(The)-349(in)27(terested)-360(reader)-361(should)-348(pursue)-349(the)-348(CAD)-348(algorithm)-359(in)-362([28];)-374(w)27(e)-361(cannot)-348(tak)28(e)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(the)-442(space)-454(here)-442(ev)27(en)-429(to)-454(correctly)-453(de\fne)-430(what)-454(a)-455(CAD)-428(is,)-468(let)-441(alone)-455(describ)-27(e)-455(the)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(original)-360(algorithm)-359(and)-349(its)-347(recen)27(t)-334(impro)27(v)27(emen)27(ts)-347(in)-335(full.)]TJ
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 166.2 Tm
(29)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 162.36 Tm
[(Mo)-26(ore's)-387(pap)-27(er)-348(con)27(tains)-360(a)-361(prophetic)-362(carto)-25(on)-361(sho)27(wing)-375(a)-361(\\happ)26(y)-347(home)-361(computer")]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(coun)26(ter)-347(b)-27(et)27(w)27(een)-362(\\notions")-373(and)-349(\\cosmetics".)-385(Bill)-374(Gates)-374(w)27(as)-360(ten)-362(y)27(ears)-346(old)-362(at)-360(the)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
(time.)Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
33 0 obj
<<
/Length 11518
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 290.52 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(The)-335(Mec)27(hanization)-361(of)-361(Mathematics)-2674(31)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 149.76 666.2401 Tm
[(It)-410(seems)-398(fair)-398(to)-410(ask,)-398(then,)-410(what)-409(are)-398(the)-410(presen)24(t-da)23(y)-385(limits)-411(of)-409(quan)24(ti\fer)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(elimination)-325(in)-326(algebra?)-313(The)-324(\frst)-327(in)24(teresting)-314(example,)-325(often)-325(used)-326(as)-313(a)-326(b)-24(enc)25(h-)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
[(mark)-265(for)-278(quan)24(ti\fer)-278(elimination,)-277(is)-278(to)-289(\fnd)-277(the)-289(conditions)-278(on)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
25.72812 0 Td
[(a;)-169(b;)-168(c;)-168(d)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
3.52918 0 Td
[(suc)24(h)-277(that)]TJ
-29.25731 -1.19245 TD
[(the)-410(fourth-degree)-398(p)-24(olynomial)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
13.26154 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 272.52 633.96 Tm
(4)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 279.72 630.36 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.05996 0 Td
(ax)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 301.2 633.96 Tm
(3)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 308.4 630.36 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.04792 0 Td
(bx)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 328.8 633.96 Tm
(2)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 336 630.36 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.04792 0 Td
(cx)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.27677 0 Td
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.05996 0 Td
(d)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.92747 0 Td
[(is)-410(p)-24(ositiv)23(e)-397(for)-410(all)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
7.92561 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
(.)Tj
-33.0033 -1.2045 TD
[(That)-422(is,)-422(to)-434(eliminate)-421(the)-434(quan)24(ti\fer)-410(\\for)-410(all)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
19.71766 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
[(")-434(in)-421(that)-435(statemen)24(t.)-422(The)-433(an-)]TJ
-20.28378 -1.19245 TD
[(sw)24(er)-350(is)-361(a)-362(surprisingly)-339(complex)-361(p)-24(olynomial)-361(in)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
19.9947 0 Td
(a)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
(,)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.27703 0 Td
(b)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.43362 0 Td
(,)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.27703 0 Td
(c)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.43362 0 Td
[(,)-361(and)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
2.61376 0 Td
(d)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.51793 0 Td
[(.)-361(Qep)-24(cad)-361(do)-24(es)-362(this)]TJ
-25.07769 -1.2045 TD
[(\fv)24(e-v)60(ariable)-253(problem)-265(almost)-266(instan)23(taneously)84(.)-265(The)-276(curious)-266(reader)-253(can)-265(\fnd)-289(the)]TJ
T*
[(answ)24(er)-313(at)-338(the)-337(qep)-24(cad)-325(examples)-325(w)24(eb)-325(page)-324([22].)]TJ
1.50563 -1.58994 TD
[(It)-398(w)24(as)-386(fairly)-398(easy)-385(to)-410(create)-385(a)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
13.29768 0 Td
[(Mathematic)48(a)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
5.99841 0 Td
[(noteb)-24(o)-24(ok)-398(with)-409(functions)-399(de-)]TJ
-20.80171 -1.19245 TD
[(\fned)-506(to)-494(facilitate)-506(asking)-482(simple)-506(questions)-495(ab)-24(out)-495(sphere)-494(pac)24(king.I)-494(de\fned)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
0 -1.2045 TD
[(TwoSpher)49(es)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
5.17935 0 Td
([)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.27704 0 Td
(M)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.08405 0 Td
[(],)-482(whic)25(h)-494(uses)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
6.33567 0 Td
[(Ine)48(qualityInstanc)48(e)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
8.37127 0 Td
[(to)-494(ask)-482(whether)-482(there)-494(exist)]TJ
-21.24738 -1.2045 TD
[(t)24(w)24(o)-289(disjoin)23(t)-289(spheres)-290(of)-289(radius)-290(1)-289(in)-301(a)-289(cub)-24(e)-301(of)-289(side)-290(2)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
21.53646 0 Td
(M)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.08405 0 Td
[(.)-289(This)-302(is)-289(a)-289(sev)24(en-v)60(ariable)]TJ
-22.62051 -1.19245 TD
[(problem,)-374(coun)25(ting)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
8.35923 0 Td
(M)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.45745 0 Td
[(and)-385(the)-386(co)-24(ordinates)-374(of)-386(the)-385(cen)24(ters)-374(of)-385(the)-386(spheres.)-374(T)84(o)]TJ
-9.81668 -1.2045 TD
[(mak)24(e)-373(it)-398(a)-385(six-v)59(ariable)-373(problem,)-374(w)24(e)-385(can)-385(put)-398(in)-397(sp)-25(eci\fc)-385(v)61(alues)-386(of)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
28.47438 0 Td
(M)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.08405 0 Td
(:)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
0.66247 0 Td
(Mathe-)Tj
-30.22091 -1.2045 TD
[(matic)48(a)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
3.28828 0 Td
[(answ)24(ers)-386(the)-410(query)84(,)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
8.62422 0 Td
[(TwoSpher)49(es)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
5.16731 0 Td
([7)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.78292 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.50589 0 Td
[(4])-385(with)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
3.51714 0 Td
[(T)73(rue)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
2.05969 0 Td
[(;)-410(and)-397(with)-410(a)-397(suitable)]TJ
-23.94546 -1.19245 TD
[(v)60(arian)24(t)-278(of)-289(the)-289(question,)-290(it)-289(could)-289(ev)24(en)-276(exhibit)-302(an)-277(example)-288(of)-289(t)23(w)25(o)-277(suc)24(h)-289(spheres.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
0 -1.2045 TD
[(TwoSpher)49(es)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
5.17935 0 Td
([3)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.78293 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.50589 0 Td
[(2])-313(returns)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
4.54097 0 Td
[(F)72(alse)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
2.20424 0 Td
[(.)-337(The)-325(time)-337(required)-314(is)-326(less)-326(than)-325(a)-325(second.)-326(The)]TJ
-13.21336 -1.2045 TD
[(sev)24(en-v)60(ariable)-253(problem,)-277(with)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
12.73156 0 Td
(M)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.36108 0 Td
[(v)60(ariable,)-265(seems)-277(to)-290(b)-24(e)-289(to)-24(o)-277(di\016cult)-289(for)-278(Mathe-)]TJ
-14.09265 -1.19245 TD
(matica's)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
3.91462 0 Td
[(Cylindric)49(alA)25(lgebr)49(aicDe)49(c)49(omp)48(osition)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
15.34533 0 Td
[(function.)-314(I)-301(also)-289(tried)-302(these)-302(prob-)]TJ
-19.25995 -1.2045 TD
[(lems)-398(with)-410(the)-397(v)24(ersion)-374(of)-398(qep)-23(cad)-398(a)25(v)60(ailable)-385(from)-398([22];)-386(this)-398(program)-374(w)24(as)-386(able)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(to)-386(express)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
4.4446 0 Td
[(TwoSpher)49(es)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
5.15526 0 Td
([)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.27703 0 Td
(M)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.08405 0 Td
0.385 Tc
[(]a)385(s)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
1.93924 0 Td
0 Tc
(M)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
1.43336 0 Td
<15>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.14427 0 Td
0.373 Tc
[(1&)-13(3)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
2.55354 0 Td
0 Tc
(M)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 325.2 426.84 Tm
(2)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 332.04 423.24 Tm
<00>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.03587 0 Td
(6)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.50589 0 Td
(M)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.33699 0 Td
0.241 Tc
(+2)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
1.89107 0 Td
0 Tc
<15>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.14427 0 Td
[(0.)-373(The)-385(least)-374(suc)24(h)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
-25.71607 -1.2045 TD
(M)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.45744 0 Td
[(is)-374(1)-253(+)-241(1)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
3.33646 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.50589 0.83111 TD
(p)Tj
ET
q
5.04 0 0 -0.48 195.708 419.988 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 195.72 411.24 Tm
[(3,)-373(whic)24(h)-373(is)-386(the)-374(v)61(alue)-374(of)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
10.69596 0 Td
(M)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.4454 0 Td
[(one)-373(\fnds)-386(with)-386(p)-24(encil)-373(and)-385(pap)-24(er)-362(if)]TJ
-18.26022 -1.2045 TD
[(one)-337(assumes)-338(that)-350(the)-350(cen)25(ters)-327(of)-349(the)-349(spheres)-339(are)-325(on)-337(the)-349(main)-350(diagonal)-325(of)-349(the)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(cub)-24(e.)-361(But)-361(the)-362(program)-338(did)-362(not)-361(mak)24(e)-349(that)-362(assumption{it)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
25.31859 0 Td
[(pr)49(ove)49(d)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
3.1317 0 Td
[(that)-362(this)-363(is)]TJ
-28.45029 -1.2045 TD
[(the)-349(b)-25(est)-362(p)-24(ossible)-350(arrangemen)24(t.)-326(Similar)-337(queries)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
20.63308 0 Td
[(Thr)49(e)49(eSpher)49(es)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
5.75751 0 Td
([)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.27703 0 Td
(M)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.08405 0 Td
[(],)-349(for)-338(v)60(arious)]TJ
-27.75168 -1.2045 TD
[(sp)-25(eci\fc)-384(v)60(alues)-373(of)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
7.74493 0 Td
(M)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.08405 0 Td
[(,)-373(nev)24(er)-374(returned)-374(answ)24(ers.)-362(After)-386(sev)24(eral)-361(hours)-375(I)-386(stopp)-25(ed)]TJ
-8.82899 -1.19245 TD
[(Mathematica;)-278(in)-277(the)-289(v)24(ersion)-265(of)-278(qep)-23(cad)-277(from)-278([22],)-265(the)-289(jobs)-277(failed)-277(\(after)-290(sev)24(eral)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(hours\))-327(b)-24(ecause)-324(they)-338(ran)-326(out)-325(of)-337(memory)84(.)-326(Nine)-336(v)60(ariables)-314(is)-338(to)-24(o)-325(man)24(y)-325(in)-338(2003.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.58994 TD
[(Using)-277(a)-277(double-exp)-24(onen)24(tial)-277(algorithm,)-278(w)24(e)-276(could)-289(exp)-24(ect)-289(that)-290(with)-289(running)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(time)-374(v)61(arying)-350(as)-350(2)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 211.08 315.36 Tm
(2)Tj
/F18 1 Tf
4.98132 0 0 4.98132 215.04 318.36 Tm
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 220.32 311.64 Tm
0.373 Tc
[(,i)373(f)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
1.58994 0 Td
0 Tc
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.92747 0 Td
[(=)-325(7)-361(corresp)-25(onds)-338(to)-362(one)-361(second,)-349(then)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
16.45347 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.92746 0 Td
[(=)-313(8)-361(should)]TJ
-28.48642 -1.19245 TD
[(corresp)-25(ond)-337(to)-362(2)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 203.28 303.36 Tm
(128)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 219.36 299.76 Tm
[(seconds,)-350(or)-349(more)-350(than)-362(10)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 329.76 303.36 Tm
(35)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 341.76 299.76 Tm
[(y)24(ears,)-338(so)-361(a)-350(sharp)-362(cuto\013)-362(is)-361(to)]TJ
-20.77762 -1.2045 TD
[(b)-24(e)-458(exp)-23(ected.)-458(As)-446(calculated)-445(ab)-24(o)25(v)24(e,)-446(to)-446(increase)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
20.9583 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.05996 0 Td
[(from)-446(7)-446(to)-446(8,)-445(w)24(e)-445(need)-458(2)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 459.24 291.36 Tm
(7)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 463.68 287.76 Tm
(,)Tj
-33.01534 -1.19245 TD
[(or)-446(128,)-445(doublings)-447(of)-457(computer)-459(sp)-24(eed.)-457(But)-458(the)-470(kissing)-447(problem)-446(needs)-457(only)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(existen)24(tial)-434(quan)24(ti\fers,)-435(so)-434(as)-434(discussed)-435(ab)-24(o)24(v)25(e,)-434(it)-446(sneaks)-422(under)-446(the)-446(w)25(all:)-434(w)24(e)]TJ
T*
[(can)-313(solv)24(e)-301(it)-326(in)-313(\\only")-301(exp)-24(onen)25(tial)-314(time.)-325(In)-326(that)-314(case)-313(if)-325(2)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 377.4 255.48 Tm
(7)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 384.96 251.88 Tm
[(corresp)-25(onds)-289(to)-314(one)]TJ
-25.11382 -1.19245 TD
[(second,)-409(then)-422(2)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 199.08 243.6 Tm
(8)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 207.72 240 Tm
[(is)-410(only)-422(t)24(w)24(o)-409(seconds;)-410(but)-422(to)-410(attac)24(k)-410(the)-421(kissing)-411(problem)-410(w)25(e)]TJ
-7.32336 -1.2045 TD
[(need)-433(100)-409(v)60(ariables,)-410(and)-422(2)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 248.52 231.6 Tm
(100)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 265.2 228 Tm
[(corresp)-25(onds)-398(to)-422(2)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 338.88 231.6 Tm
(93)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 351.6 228 Tm
[(seconds{ab)-24(out)-410(10)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 428.88 231.6 Tm
(24)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 441.48 228 Tm
[(y)24(ears.)]TJ
-30.78702 -1.2045 TD
[([Ph)24(ysicists)-435(kno)24(w)-445(a)-446(con)25(v)24(enien)25(t)-434(coincidence:)-445(that)-446(to)-446(three)-446(signi\fcan)24(t)-446(digits,)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(there)-482(are)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.54096 0 Td
<19>Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.93951 0 Td
<02>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.0961 0 Td
(10)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 210.36 207.72 Tm
(7)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 219.6 204.12 Tm
[(seconds)-482(p)-24(er)-494(y)24(ear.])-470(Ev)25(en)-482(when)-481(the)-494(w)24(ork)-482(of)-482(Grigorev)-470(is)]TJ
-8.51581 -1.2045 TD
[(implemen)24(ted,)-277(it)-277(still)-266(w)24(on't)-265(solv)23(e)-252(the)-278(kissing)-254(problem.)-265(Nev)25(ertheless,)-266(there)-266(ma)25(y)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(w)24(ell)-313(b)-24(e)-337(op)-24(en)-313(questions)-314(with)-337(few)24(er)-313(than)-326(\ffteen)-325(v)60(ariables,)-314(so)-313(it)-326(seems)-313(the)-326(jury)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(is)-338(still)-326(out)-338(on)-325(the)-337(p)-24(oten)24(tial)-338(usefulness)-326(of)-338(quan)24(ti\fer)-326(elimination.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.58994 TD
[(Quan)24(ti\fer)-458(elimination)-482(has)-471(not)-470(b)-24(een)-481(the)-482(only)-470(decision)-469(metho)-25(d)-482(used)-482(in)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(geometry)84(.)-446(In)-458(1978,)-433(W)85(u)-470(W)84(en-Tsen)-445(pioneered)-458(the)-457(reduction)-447(of)-457(geometry)-446(to)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
34 0 obj
<<
/Length 8611
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 134.76 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(32)-2662(Mic)26(hael)-361(Beeson)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(p)-24(olynomial)-349(ideal)-349(theory)83(,)-349(in)24(tro)-25(ducing)-349(\\W)85(u's)-362(metho)-25(d")-361([115].)-337(The)-361(idea)-349(here)-349(is)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(that)-471(an)-457(imp)-25(ortan)24(t)-458(class)-447(of)-457(geometric)-458(theorems)-446(can)-458(b)-24(e)-469(stated)-459(in)-470(algebraic)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
(language)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
4.17961 0 Td
[(without)-386(using)-361(ine)48(qualities)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
11.05731 0 Td
[(.)-373(If)-350(the)-350(theorem)-349(can)-337(b)-24(e)-361(stated)-351(using)-337(only)]TJ
-15.23693 -1.19245 TD
[(conjunctions)-241(of)-229(equations)-230(in)-241(the)-241(h)24(yp)-24(othesis)-230(and)-241(an)-228(equation)-241(in)-241(the)-242(conclusion,)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(then)-386(it)-398(reduces)-373(to)-374(asking)-374(if)-385(a)-373(certain)-386(p)-24(olynomial)-374(lies)-373(in)-386(the)-397(ideal)-374(generated)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(b)24(y)-385(a)-386(\fnite)-385(set)-386(of)-386(other)-386(p)-24(olynomials.)-374(Since)-385(that)-398(time,)-386(other)-386(metho)-24(ds,)-386(based)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(on)-265(Gr\177)506(obner)-266(bases,)-265(ha)24(v)24(e)-265(also)-253(b)-24(een)-276(applied)-277(to)-278(geometric)-252(theorem)-278(pro)24(ving.)-253(This)]TJ
T*
[(w)24(ork)-277(has)-277(reduced)-277(geometric)-277(theorem-pro)23(ving)-265(to)-277(computer)-290(algebra,)-265(and)-289(when)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(it)-241(is)-242(applicable,)-228(it)-241(seems)-230(to)-241(b)-24(e)-241(more)-217(e\016cien)25(t)-241(than)-241(quan)24(ti\fer)-230(elimination.)-241(Man)24(y)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(in)24(teresting)-338(theorems)-351(in)-349(classical)-325(plane)-349(and)-350(solid)-350(geometry)-325(ha)24(v)24(e)-337(b)-24(een)-348(pro)23(v)24(ed)]TJ
T*
[(this)-338(w)24(a)24(y)85(.)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
11.95517 0 0 11.95517 134.76 513.96 Tm
[(11)-1124(Equalit)29(y)-381(Reasoning)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 489.36 Tm
[(The)-337(usual)-325(axioms)-314(for)-338(equalit)24(y)85(,)-326(as)-325(giv)24(en)-313(in)-337(mathematics)-338(textb)-25(o)-24(oks,)-326(are)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
10.23825 -2.04765 TD
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.84315 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.05996 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
3.16784 0 Td
[(re\rexivit)24(y)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
-12.80383 -1.50563 TD
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.84315 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.05996 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.8552 0 Td
(&)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.10814 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.80702 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.05996 0 Td
(z)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.78293 0 Td
(!)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.27677 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.8552 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.04792 0 Td
(z)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
3.10761 0 Td
[(transitivit)22(y)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
-9.00966 -1.49358 TD
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.84315 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.05996 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.80702 0 Td
(!)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.27677 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.79497 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.05996 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
3.16784 0 Td
(symmetry)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
-11.87637 -1.50563 TD
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.85519 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.05996 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.8552 0 Td
(&)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.10814 0 Td
<1E>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.5902 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
(\))Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.68656 0 Td
(!)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.27677 0 Td
<1E>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.5902 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
[(\))-2602(substitutivit)21(y)]TJ
-12.32203 -2.04765 TD
[(In)-326(this)-338(form,)-326(these)-325(axioms)-314(are)-313(useless)-314(in)-338(automated)-325(deduction,)-325(b)-25(ecause)-324(they)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(will)-349(\(in)-350(fact)-349(ev)24(en)-337(just)-362(the)-350(\frst)-339(three)-349(will\))-350(generate)-325(a)-349(nev)24(er-ending)-325(stream)-338(of)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(useless)-290(deductions.)-302(The)-300(\\righ)24(t)-290(metho)-24(d")-289(for)-302(dealing)-289(with)-301(equalit)24(y)-289(w)24(as)-289(disco)24(v-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(ered)-265(three)-253(times)-278(in)-265(the)-265(p)-24(erio)-24(d)-266(1965-1970,)-216(indep)-24(enden)25(tly)-278(in)-265([87],)-253([47],)-265(and)-265([62].)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(The)-397(approac)24(hes)-361(had)-386(sligh)24(tly)-386(di\013eren)24(t)-398(emphases,)-386(although)-386(the)-385(k)24(ernel)-386(of)-397(the)]TJ
T*
[(metho)-24(ds)-338(is)-326(the)-337(same.)-326(W)85(e)-337(will)-337(\frst)-339(explain)-325(the)-337(Kn)24(uth-Bendix)-326(metho)-24(d.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.21654 TD
[(By)-228(an)-241(\\orien)24(ted)-229(equation")]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
11.53911 0 Td
(p)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.77088 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.05996 0 Td
(q)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.7227 0 Td
[(w)24(e)-240(simply)-242(mean)-240(a)-229(pair)-242(of)-228(terms)-242(separated)]TJ
-15.59827 -1.19245 TD
[(b)24(y)-241(an)-229(equalit)24(y)-241(sign,)-229(so)-229(that)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
11.76796 0 Td
(p)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.77088 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.05996 0 Td
(q)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.7227 0 Td
[(is)-241(not)-242(considered)-229(the)-241(same)-229(orien)24(ted)-229(equation)]TJ
-14.3215 -1.2045 TD
(as)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.3129 0 Td
(q)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.90338 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.2045 0 Td
(p)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.50589 0 Td
[(.)-410(The)-421(idea)-421(is)-410(that)-422(an)-422(orien)24(ted)-410(equation)-409(is)-422(to)-410(b)-24(e)-421(used)-422(from)-423(left)-421(to)]TJ
-3.92667 -1.19245 TD
[(righ)24(t)-338(only)84(.)-337(The)-337(orien)24(ted)-325(equation)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
14.85148 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56612 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.75883 0 Td
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.01178 0 Td
(z)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.51793 0 Td
0.29 Tc
(\)=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.73448 0 Td
0 Tc
(xy)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.337 0 Td
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
(xz)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.42131 0 Td
[(can)-337(b)-24(e)-349(used)-338(to)-337(c)24(hange)]TJ
-23.58411 -1.2045 TD
(3)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.7227 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.7227 0 Td
[(\(4)-217(+)-217(5\))-337(to)-326(3)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
5.27571 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.7227 0 Td
0.217 Tc
[(4+)1(3)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
2.44514 0 Td
0 Tc
<03>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.7227 0 Td
[(5,)-325(but)-338(not)-338(vice-v)25(ersa.)-302(The)-337(v)61(ariables)-314(can)-325(b)-24(e)-337(matc)24(hed)]TJ
-10.61164 -1.2045 TD
[(to)-398(complicated)-409(expressions,)-375(although)-397(this)-411(example)-397(sho)24(ws)-398(them)-410(matc)24(hed)-397(to)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(constan)24(ts.)-471(Another)-470(name)-482(for)-470(\\orien)24(ted)-458(equation")-470(is)-482(\\rewrite)-458(rule",)-470(whic)25(h)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(con)24(v)25(eys)-314(an)-325(in)24(tuition)-338(ab)-24(out)-338(ho)24(w)-325(rewrite)-325(rules)-326(are)-314(to)-337(b)-24(e)-337(used.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.21654 TD
[(Supp)-24(ose)-362(one)-349(is)-362(giv)25(en)-361(a)-350(set)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
11.94864 0 Td
(E)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.15632 0 Td
[(of)-361(orien)24(ted)-350(equations.)-362(Giv)24(en)-361(an)-349(expression)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
-14.61058 -1.19245 TD
(t)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.36135 0 Td
[(,)-398(w)25(e)-385(can)-385(rewrite)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
7.54017 0 Td
(t)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.75884 0 Td
[(or)-374(its)-398(subterms)-387(using)-386(\(orien)23(ted\))-386(equations)-386(from)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
21.41601 0 Td
(E)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.18041 0 Td
[(un)24(til)]TJ
-31.25677 -1.2045 TD
[(no)-349(more)-350(rules)-350(can)-349(b)-24(e)-349(applied.)-361(If)-362(this)-350(happ)-24(ens,)-362(the)-362(resulting)-350(term)-350(is)-350(called)-348(a)]TJ
T*
[(\\normal)-301(form")-302(of)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
7.84129 0 Td
(t)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.36135 0 Td
[(.)-313(It)-314(need)-313(not)-313(happ)-25(en:)-325(for)-301(example,)-313(if)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
16.09212 0 Td
(E)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.10814 0 Td
[(includes)-313(the)-326(equa-)]TJ
-25.4029 -1.19246 TD
(tion)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
2.05969 0 Td
(xy)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.37313 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.05996 0 Td
0.036 Tc
(yx)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.0961 0 Td
0 Tc
[(,)-337(then)-338(w)25(e)-337(ha)24(v)24(e)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
6.67293 0 Td
(ab)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.24063 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.05996 0 Td
(ba)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.24063 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.05996 0 Td
(ab)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.24063 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.05996 0 Td
0.169 Tc
[(::)1(:)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
1.49358 0 Td
0 Tc
[(ad)-373(in\fnitum)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
5.38411 0 Td
[(.)-325(If)-338(one)-325(sequence)]TJ
-26.04129 -1.2045 TD
[(of)-337(rewrites)-338(do)-25(es)-337(terminate)-338(in)-337(a)-338(normal)-325(form,)-350(it)-338(still)-350(do)-24(es)-338(not)-337(guaran)23(tee)-325(that)]TJ
T*
[(ev)24(ery)-361(suc)24(h)-374(sequence)-372(terminates)-363(\(di\013eren)24(t)-386(subterms)-376(can)-373(b)-24(e)-385(rewritten)-362(at)-386(dif-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(feren)24(t)-398(stages\).)-399(If,)-410(no)-397(matter)-399(what)-397(subterm)-411(w)24(e)-397(rewrite)-386(and)-409(no)-398(matter)-398(what)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(equation)-325(from)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
6.43203 0 Td
(E)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.13223 0 Td
[(w)24(e)-312(use,)-338(the)-325(result)-327(alw)25(a)24(ys)-302(terminates)-326(in)-325(a)-326(normal)-313(form,)-326(and)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
35 0 obj
<<
/Length 9863
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 290.52 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(The)-335(Mec)27(hanization)-361(of)-361(Mathematics)-2674(33)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(if)-325(this)-339(happ)-24(ens)-325(no)-313(matter)-327(what)-325(term)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
16.29688 0 Td
(t)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.68657 0 Td
[(w)24(e)-312(start)-327(with,)-326(then)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
8.6724 0 Td
(E)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.12018 0 Td
[(is)-314(called)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
3.81827 0 Td
(termi-)Tj
-30.5943 -1.2045 TD
(nating)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
2.73421 0 Td
(.)Tj
-1.22859 -1.22859 TD
[(Ev)25(en)-446(this)-471(do)-24(es)-458(not)-458(guaran)24(tee)-433(the)-470(uniqueness)-458(of)-458(the)-470(normal)-458(form)-447(of)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
31.14837 0 Td
(t)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.36135 0 Td
(.)Tj
-33.01534 -1.19245 TD
[(That)-265(w)24(ould)-253(b)-24(e)-265(guaran)24(teed)-253(b)25(y)-253(the)-266(follo)25(wing)-253(desirable)-253(prop)-25(ert)23(y)-252(of)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
27.95644 0 Td
(E)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.79497 0 Td
[(,)-265(kno)24(wn)-265(as)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
-28.75142 -1.2045 TD
[(c)48(on\ruenc)49(e)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
4.50483 0 Td
(.)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.56612 0 Td
(E)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.08405 0 Td
[(is)-302(called)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
3.75804 0 Td
[(c)48(on\ruent)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
4.26393 0 Td
[(if)-301(whenev)25(er)-278(a)-289(term)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
8.37127 0 Td
(t)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.65043 0 Td
[(can)-289(b)-24(e)-301(rewritten)-290(\(using)]TJ
-23.19867 -1.2045 TD
[(one)-289(or)-277(more)-289(steps\))-291(in)-301(t)23(w)25(o)-289(di\013eren)24(t)-290(w)25(a)24(ys)-278(to)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
18.75406 0 Td
(r)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.77088 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.90311 0 Td
(s)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.46976 0 Td
[(,)-301(then)-302(there)-289(exists)-290(another)]TJ
-21.89781 -1.19245 TD
(term)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
2.43309 0 Td
(q)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.86724 0 Td
[(suc)24(h)-362(that)-386(b)-24(oth)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
6.91383 0 Td
(r)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.8552 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.98743 0 Td
(s)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.84315 0 Td
[(can)-373(b)-24(e)-373(rewritten)-375(to)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
8.92534 0 Td
(q)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.4818 0 Td
[(.)-385(This)-374(prop)-25(ert)24(y)-362(clearly)]TJ
-23.30707 -1.2045 TD
[(ensures)-459(the)-482(uniqueness)-470(of)-470(normal)-458(forms)-471(b)-24(ecause,)-469(if)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
23.58411 0 Td
(r)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.95156 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
2.08379 0 Td
(s)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.93951 0 Td
[(w)24(ere)-457(distinct)]TJ
-27.55896 -1.19245 TD
[(normal)-326(forms)-326(of)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
7.28722 0 Td
(t)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.36135 0 Td
[(,)-337(it)-338(w)24(ould)-325(b)-24(e)-337(imp)-24(ossible)-338(to)-326(rewrite)-325(them)-338(as)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
19.1636 0 Td
(q)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.4818 0 Td
(.)Tj
-25.78835 -1.22859 TD
[(These)-385(concepts)-373(will)-398(b)-24(e)-397(made)-385(clear)-373(b)24(y)-386(considering)-373(the)-398(example)-385(of)-385(group)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(theory)84(.)-325(Consider)-326(the)-338(usual)-325(three)-326(axioms)-325(of)-326(group)-325(theory:)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.79391 -2.07174 TD
(e)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.68657 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.7227 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.86724 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.08405 0 Td
(x)Tj
-4.58914 -1.50563 TD
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.34931 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56612 0 Td
(\))Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.6143 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.7227 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.86724 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.08405 0 Td
(e)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
-5.64911 -1.49358 TD
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.79497 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.7227 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
(\))Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.7227 0 Td
(z)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.80701 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.08405 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.79497 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.7227 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.74679 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.7227 0 Td
(z)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.51793 0 Td
(\))Tj
-12.045 -2.07174 TD
[(This)-277(set)-266(is)-265(not)-278(con\ruen)25(t.)-266(F)84(or)-265(example,)-277(the)-265(term)-278(\()]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
21.15102 0 Td
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.3493 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(a)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
(\))Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.4818 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
(a)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
(\))Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.4818 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
(b)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.43362 0 Td
[(\))-277(can)-265(b)-24(e)-277(rewritten)]TJ
-25.54745 -1.2045 TD
(to)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.30086 0 Td
(e)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.73475 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.78292 0 Td
(b)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.83111 0 Td
[(and)-410(then)-421(to)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
5.68524 0 Td
(b)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.43362 0 Td
[(,)-410(but)-410(it)-422(can)-397(also)-398(b)-24(e)-421(rewritten)-411(to)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
14.8274 0 Td
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.3493 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(a)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
(\))Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.65043 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.78292 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(a)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.80701 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.77088 0 Td
(b)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.43362 0 Td
[(\),)-410(whic)25(h)]TJ
-29.69092 -1.2045 TD
[(cannot)-361(b)-25(e)-361(rewritten)-362(further.)-363(Do)-23(es)-362(there)-362(exist)-362(a)-349(terminating)-362(con\ruen)24(t)-361(set)-362(of)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
(equations)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
4.55301 0 Td
(E)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.2045 0 Td
[(extending)-409(these)-410(three,)-410(and)-398(suc)24(h)-409(that)-411(eac)25(h)-397(of)-410(the)-422(equations)-398(in)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
-5.75751 -1.2045 TD
(E)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.2045 0 Td
[(is)-410(a)-397(theorem)-410(of)-398(group)-398(theory?)-397(This)-410(is)-410(an)-398(in)24(teresting)-398(question)-411(b)-24(ecause)-397(if)]TJ
-1.2045 -1.2045 TD
[(there)-301(is,)-314(it)-314(w)25(ould)-302(enable)-312(us)-302(to)-313(solv)23(e)-288(the)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
17.33275 0 Td
[(wor)48(d)-349(pr)49(oblem)-349(for)-349(gr)49(oup)-337(the)48(ory)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
13.08087 0 Td
[(:)-325(giv)24(en)]TJ
-30.41362 -1.19245 TD
[(an)-373(equation)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
5.55274 0 Td
(t)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.69861 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.12018 0 Td
(s)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.46975 0 Td
[(,)-373(do)-24(es)-374(it)-374(follo)24(w)-361(from)-362(the)-373(three)-374(axioms)-362(of)-373(group)-350(theory?)-362(If)]TJ
-7.84129 -1.2045 TD
[(w)24(e)-337(had)-337(a)-325(complete)-337(con\ruen)25(t)-338(set)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
14.36968 0 Td
(E)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.79497 0 Td
[(,)-349(w)24(e)-325(could)-337(simply)-350(rewrite)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
11.38252 0 Td
(t)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.69861 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.95129 0 Td
(s)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.80701 0 Td
[(to)-338(their)]TJ
-30.0041 -1.19245 TD
[(resp)-25(ectiv)25(e)-253(unique)-277(normal)-253(forms,)-267(and)-265(see)-264(if)-266(the)-277(results)-266(are)-253(iden)24(tical.)-265(If)-278(so,)-253(then)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(the)-337(equation)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
5.80569 0 Td
(t)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.63839 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.05996 0 Td
(s)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.79497 0 Td
[(is)-338(a)-325(theorem)-325(of)-338(group)-313(theory)84(.)-326(If)-337(not,)-338(it)-338(is)-326(not)-337(a)-325(theorem.)]TJ
-6.79338 -1.22859 TD
[(The)-481(answ)24(er)-458(for)-482(group)-471(theory)-470(is)-482(a)-470(set)-482(of)-482(ten)-494(equations.)-470(These)-482(are)-470(the)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.19245 TD
[(original)-313(three,)-338(plus)-326(the)-337(follo)24(wing)-325(sev)24(en:)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
2.50536 -2.08379 TD
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.3493 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
(\))Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.6143 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.7227 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.79497 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.7227 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
0.302 Tc
(\)=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.75857 0 Td
0 Tc
(y)Tj
-3.36055 -1.49358 TD
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.79497 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.7227 0 Td
(e)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.77088 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.072 0 Td
(x)Tj
-2.96307 -1.50563 TD
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.3493 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(e)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.46976 0 Td
0.302 Tc
(\)=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.75857 0 Td
0 Tc
(e)Tj
-4.19166 -1.49358 TD
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.3493 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.3493 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
[(\)\))-314(=)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
2.15606 0 Td
(x)Tj
-4.58914 -1.50563 TD
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.79497 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.7227 0 Td
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.3493 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
0.314 Tc
(\)=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.77062 0 Td
0 Tc
(e)Tj
-6.82952 -1.49358 TD
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.78292 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.7227 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.34931 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
(\))Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.62634 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.7227 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
0.302 Tc
(\)=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.75857 0 Td
0 Tc
(y)Tj
-4.54097 -1.50563 TD
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.34931 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.79497 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.7227 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
0.302 Tc
(\)=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.75857 0 Td
0 Tc
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.3493 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
(\))Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.7227 0 Td
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.3493 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
(\))Tj
-13.22541 -2.07174 TD
[(W)84(e)-505(call)-494(this)-494(set)-495(of)-506(ten)-494(equations)-494(\\complete")-481(b)-24(ecause)-494(it)-494(pro)24(v)24(es)-482(the)-494(same)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(equations)-302(as)-313(the)-314(original)-301(three)-313(axioms,)-302(i.e.,)-313(all)-313(the)-313(theorems)-314(of)-314(group)-301(theory)84(,)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(but)-241(it)-242(can)-228(do)-229(so)-217(b)24(y)-229(using)-230(the)-241(ten)-241(equations)-217(only)-229(left-to-righ)23(t,)-218(while)-240(the)-229(original)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(three)-229(m)24(ust)-230(b)-24(e)-241(used)-229(in)-241(b)-24(oth)-241(directions)-218(to)-229(pro)23(v)25(e)-217(the)-241(same)-217(theorems.)-230(In)-229(tec)24(hnical)]TJ
T*
[(language:)-445(the)-470(ten)-470(equations)-458(constitute)-471(a)-458(complete)-457(con\ruen)25(t)-471(set.)-458(That)-470(set)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(happ)-24(ens)-482(to)-470(con)24(tain)-470(the)-470(original)-458(three)-482(axioms,)-458(but)-483(that)-482(can)-470(b)-24(e)-481(view)24(ed)-469(as)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(acciden)25(tal.)-386(W)85(e)-397(w)24(ould)-386(not)-397(ha)24(v)24(e)-385(cared)-386(if)-397(the)-398(original)-374(axioms)-385(had)-386(themselv)24(es)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
36 0 obj
<<
/Length 9107
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 134.76 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(34)-2662(Mic)26(hael)-361(Beeson)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(simpli\fed)-302(somewhat)-277(in)-301(the)-289(\fnal)-290(ten.)-301(\(Of)-302(course,)-277(the)-289(original)-278(axioms)-277(of)-289(group)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(theory)-350(w)25(ere)-338(c)25(hosen)-350(to)-349(b)-24(e)-361(as)-350(simple)-362(as)-337(p)-25(ossible,)-362(so)-349(it)-350(is)-362(not)-350(really)-349(acciden)25(tal)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
[(that)-338(they)-338(are)-313(among)-325(the)-337(ten.\))]TJ
1.50563 -1.58994 TD
[(This)-374(solution)-374(of)-385(the)-386(w)24(ord)-361(problem)-374(for)-374(groups)-374(can)-373(b)-25(e)-385(v)61(astly)-375(generalized.)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.19245 TD
[(Donald)-289(Kn)24(uth)-277(in)24(v)24(en)24(ted)-289(an)-277(algorithm,)-278(whic)25(h)-278(w)25(as)-278(implemen)25(ted)-290(b)25(y)-290(his)-289(studen)23(t)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(Bendix)-469(\(in)-471(F)24(OR)85(TRAN)-469(IV)-470(for)-458(the)-470(IBM)-458(7094\),)-458(and)-458(has)-458(b)-24(ecome)-469(kno)24(wn)-457(as)]TJ
T*
[(the)-386(Kn)24(uth-Bendix)-373(algorithm)-374(since)-374(they)-385(w)24(ere)-361(the)-386(join)24(t)-386(authors)-374(of)-374([62].)-373(This)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(algorithm)-266(w)25(as)-278(published)-289(in)-278(1970,)-264(but)-290(the)-289(w)24(ork)-265(w)24(as)-265(done)-277(considerably)-265(earlier.)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(The)-409(input)-422(is)-410(a)-398(set)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
8.50377 0 Td
(E)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.2045 0 Td
[(of)-410(\(unorien)24(ted)-410(or)-398(orien)24(ted\))-398(equations.)-410(The)-409(output)-410(\(if)]TJ
-9.70827 -1.19245 TD
[(the)-470(algorithm)-446(terminates\))-460(is)-470(a)-446(set)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
15.80304 0 Td
(Q)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.25268 0 Td
[(of)-458(orien)24(ted)-458(equations)-446(\(rewrite)-458(rules\))]TJ
-17.05572 -1.2045 TD
[(that)-362(is)-362(con\ruen)25(t)-362(and)-362(terminating,)-362(and)-349(has)-362(the)-362(same)-361(\(unorien)23(ted\))-362(equations)]TJ
T*
[(as)-314(logical)-300(consequences)-313(as)-301(the)-326(original)-301(set)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
18.4168 0 Td
(E)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.79497 0 Td
[(.)-325(Ho)24(w)25(ev)24(er,)-289(in)-326(general)-300(there)-326(is)-314(no)]TJ
-19.21177 -1.19245 TD
[(guaran)24(tee)-301(of)-337(termination.)-327(One)-325(can)-324(run)-326(this)-327(algorithm)-314(with)-337(the)-337(three)-326(axioms)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(of)-337(group)-326(theory)-326(as)-325(input)-350(and)-325(obtain)-338(the)-338(ten-equation)-325(system)-339(giv)25(en)-325(ab)-24(o)24(v)24(e)-325(as)]TJ
(output.)'
1.50563 -1.58994 TD
[(The)-445(Kn)24(uth-Bendix)-446(metho)-24(d)-458(is)-446(\(or)-447(can)-445(b)-24(e)-458(with)-457(appropriate)-423(commands\))]TJ
-1.50563 -1.19246 TD
[(used)-326(b)25(y)-314(most)-314(mo)-24(dern)-313(theorem-pro)23(v)24(ers.)-290(It)-326(is)-314(in)24(tegrated)-313(with)-326(the)-325(other)-314(meth-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(o)-24(ds)-314(used)-313(in)-313(suc)23(h)-313(theorem-pro)23(v)24(ers.)-265(Here)-313(is)-314(an)-313(example)-300(of)-314(an)-313(in)24(teresting)-302(theo-)]TJ
T*
[(rem)-289(pro)23(v)24(ed)-276(b)24(y)-301(this)-303(metho)-24(d:)-301(In)-290(a)-301(ring)-289(supp)-25(ose)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
20.09106 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 340.56 446.76 Tm
(3)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 347.88 443.16 Tm
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.04792 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.86724 0 Td
[(for)-290(all)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
2.85467 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
[(.)-301(Then)-301(the)-301(ring)]TJ
-26.72785 -1.19245 TD
[(is)-302(comm)25(utativ)23(e.)-301(This)-301(is)-314(pro)24(v)24(ed)-277(b)24(y)-313(starting)-291(out)-314(with)-301(the)-313(set)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
25.96902 0 Td
(E)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.0961 0 Td
[(con)24(taining)-301(the)]TJ
-27.06511 -1.2045 TD
[(ring)-241(axioms)-230(and)-241(the)-253(axiom)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
11.63547 0 Td
(xxx)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.98742 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.05996 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
[(.)-253(Then)-252(the)-242(Kn)25(uth-Bendix)-242(algorithm)-241(is)-242(run)]TJ
-15.24897 -1.2045 TD
[(un)24(til)-350(it)-350(deduces)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
7.11859 0 Td
(xy)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.38518 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.072 0 Td
0.036 Tc
(yx)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.0961 0 Td
0 Tc
[(.)-349(When)-349(that)-350(happ)-25(ens,)-337(a)-337(con)24(tradiction)-326(will)-349(b)-24(e)-349(found)]TJ
-10.67187 -1.19245 TD
[(b)24(y)-313(resolution)-314(with)-326(the)-325(negated)-313(goal)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
15.7669 0 Td
(ab)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
1.22859 0 Td
(6)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.05996 0 Td
(ba)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.9636 0 Td
[(,)-313(so)-314(the)-325(Kn)24(uth-Bendix)-314(algorithm)]TJ
-19.01905 -1.2045 TD
[(will)-277(not)-277(go)-265<6F0B>]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
6.19113 0 Td
[(ad)-313(in\fnitum)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
5.58888 0 Td
[(using)-278(the)-277(comm)25(utativ)23(e)-265(la)24(w)-264(\(as)-278(it)-278(w)25(ould)-277(if)-278(running)]TJ
-11.78001 -1.19246 TD
[(b)24(y)-265(itself.\))-278(The)-265(resulting)-254(pro)-24(of)-265(is)-266(52)-253(steps)-266(long.)-253(Up)-276(un)23(til)-265(1988)-240(it)-278(to)-24(ok)-253(ten)-277(hours)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(to)-350(\fnd)-361(this)-351(pro)-24(of;)-349(then)-350(the)-361(pro)23(v)24(er)-325(RRL)-349([59])-337(w)24(as)-350(able)-337(to)-349(reduce)-349(this)-350(time)-362(to)]TJ
T*
[(t)24(w)24(o)-325(min)24(utes.)-350(Actually)84(,)-337(the)-350(h)24(yp)-24(othesis)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
16.863 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 308.4 351.12 Tm
(3)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 315.72 347.52 Tm
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.07201 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.91542 0 Td
[(can)-337(b)-24(e)-337(replaced)-325(b)24(y)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
8.55195 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F15 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 426.36 351.12 Tm
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 434.76 347.52 Tm
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.072 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.90338 0 Td
(for)Tj
-32.08788 -1.19245 TD
[(an)24(y)-361(natural)-350(n)24(um)24(b)-25(er)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
9.14215 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.92746 0 Td
<15>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.12018 0 Td
[(2,)-361(and)-362(RRL)-373(could)-361(also)-350(do)-361(the)-373(cases)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
16.05598 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.92747 0 Td
0.337 Tc
(=4)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.62608 0 Td
0 Tc
(;)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.44566 0 Td
(6)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.50589 0 Td
(;)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.44567 0 Td
(8)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.67452 0 Td
0.169 Tc
[(::)1(:)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.14427 0 Td
0 Tc
(,)Tj
-33.01534 -1.2045 TD
[(and)-398(man)25(y)-386(other)-386(ev)25(en)-398(v)61(alues)-386(of)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
14.05651 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.99973 0 Td
[([117],)-373(but)-410(it)-398(still)-399(tak)24(es)-386(a)-385(h)24(uman)-397(b)-25(eing)-397(to)]TJ
-15.05625 -1.2045 TD
[(pro)24(v)24(e)-253(it)-277(for)-266(all)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
6.3718 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
[(,)-277(b)-24(ecause)-265(the)-277(\(only)-265(kno)24(wn\))-277(pro)-25(of)-265(in)24(v)24(olv)24(es)-241(induction)-277(on)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
23.83706 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.86724 0 Td
(and)Tj
-31.67835 -1.19245 TD
[(the)-374(theory)-361(of)-374(the)-385(Jacobsen)-349(radical)-362(\(a)-362(second-order)-350(concept\).)-373(The)-373(o)-24(dd)-373(cases)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(are)-325(still)-339(quite)-325(hard)-326(for)-325(theorem)-338(pro)24(v)24(ers.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.58994 TD
[(The)-289(use)-289(of)-289(a)-289(set)-290(of)-301(orien)24(ted)-277(equations)-290(to)-289(rewrite)-277(subterms)-291(of)-302(a)-276(giv)24(en)-289(term)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(is)-302(called)-300(\\demo)-24(dulation")-289(in)-314(the)-313(automated)-289(theorem)-302(pro)24(ving)-289(comm)24(unit)23(y)85(,)-301(and)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(\\rewriting")-205(in)-229(an)-229(almost)-230(separate)-205(group)-217(of)-229(researc)23(hers)-193(who)-228(study)-230(rewrite)-218(rules)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(for)-326(other)-325(reasons.)-303(A)-337(set)-325(of)-338(orien)24(ted)-313(equations)-326(can)-325(b)-24(e)-337(sp)-24(eci\fed)-325(b)24(y)-325(the)-337(user)-326(of)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(Otter)-290(as)-277(\\demo)-24(dulators".)-266(They)-289(will)-289(b)-24(e)-289(used)-289(to)-290(\\reduce")-276(\(rep)-25(eatedly)-276(rewrite\))]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(all)-349(newly-generated)-325(clauses.)-338(What)-349(the)-362(Kn)24(uth-Bendix)-337(algorithm)-338(do)-24(es,)-338(in)-361(ad-)]TJ
T*
[(dition)-362(to)-362(this,)-374(is)-362(to)-362(use)-361(the)-362(existing)-362(demo)-23(dulators)-351(at)-362(eac)25(h)-349(stage)-350(to)-362(generate)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(new)-276(demo)-24(dulators)-255(dynamically)85(.)-265(The)-277(metho)-24(d)-277(is)-265(simple:)-278(Find)-278(a)-264(subterm)-279(of)-265(one)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(of)-385(the)-386(left-hand)-386(sides)-386(that)-387(can)-385(b)-24(e)-385(rewritten)-386(in)-386(t)24(w)24(o)-373(di\013eren)24(t)-386(w)24(a)25(ys)-362(b)24(y)-386(di\013er-)]TJ
T*
[(en)24(t)-337(demo)-24(dulators.)-327(Reduce)-336(the)-349(left-hand)-338(side)-338(as)-325(far)-338(as)-326(p)-24(ossible)-338(after)-338(starting)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(in)-398(these)-385(t)23(w)25(o)-374(di\013eren)24(t)-398(w)25(a)24(ys.)-362(Y)85(ou)-398(will)-385(obtain)-386(t)24(w)24(o)-373(terms)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
24.54771 0 Td
(p)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.89133 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.99947 0 Td
(q)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.4818 0 Td
[(.)-398(If)-385(they)-398(are)]TJ
-27.92031 -1.2045 TD
[(di\013eren)24(t,)-386(then)-398(the)-385(set)-386(of)-386(existing)-386(demo)-24(dulators)-374(is)-386(manifestly)-387(not)-385(con\ruen)24(t,)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
37 0 obj
<<
/Length 8491
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 290.52 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(The)-335(Mec)27(hanization)-361(of)-361(Mathematics)-2674(35)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(and)-349(the)-350(equation)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
7.79311 0 Td
(p)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.79497 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.08405 0 Td
(q)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.81906 0 Td
[(is)-350(a)-337(candidate)-337(for)-350(a)-337(new)-349(demo)-24(dulator.)-338(The)-336(pair)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
21.18715 0 Td
(p)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.50589 0 Td
(,)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.62634 0 Td
(q)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
-32.81058 -1.2045 TD
[(is)-374(called)-373(a)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
4.79391 0 Td
[(critic)49(al)-410(p)49(air)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
5.08299 0 Td
[(.)-398(Also)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
2.96307 0 Td
(q)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.83111 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.13223 0 Td
(p)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.87928 0 Td
[(is)-362(a)-373(candidate,)-373(so)-362(the)-386(di\016cult)24(y)-373(is)-374(whic)24(h)]TJ
-15.68259 -1.20451 TD
[(w)24(a)25(y)-314(the)-337(new)-337(equation)-325(should)-326(b)-24(e)-337(orien)24(ted.)-325(The)-337(solution)-326(is)-326(to)-325(put)-350(the)-338(\\hea)25(vi-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(est")-350(term)-350(on)-337(the)-362(left.)-361(In)-350(the)-361(simplest)-351(case,)-337(\\hea)25(viest")-326(just)-363(means)-349(\\longest",)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(but)-458(if)-458(the)-458(algorithm)-435(do)-24(es)-445(not)-446(halt)-459(with)-458(that)-458(de\fnition)-446(of)-458(\\w)25(eigh)24(t",)-422(other)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(more)-386(complicated)-385(de\fnitions)-386(migh)24(t)-386(mak)24(e)-385(the)-397(algorithm)-375(con)25(v)24(erge.)-361(In)-398(short,)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(the)-386(Kn)24(uth-Bendix)-385(algorithm)-375(dep)-23(ends)-386(on)-386(a)-385(w)25(a)24(y)-374(of)-385(orien)24(ting)-374(new)-385(equations,)]TJ
T*
[(and)-325(man)24(y)-325(pap)-25(ers)-325(ha)24(v)24(e)-325(b)-24(een)-337(written)-338(ab)-24(out)-326(the)-337(p)-24(ossible)-326(metho)-24(ds.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.46949 TD
[(Because)-409(comm)25(utativit)22(y)-409(is)-422(imp)-24(ortan)23(t)-422(in)-422(man)24(y)-409(examples,)-422(but)-434(mak)24(es)-410(the)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(Kn)24(uth-Bendix)-362(algorithm)-338(fail)-361(to)-362(con)25(v)24(erge,)-337(some)-350(e\013ort)-362(has)-349(b)-25(een)-372(exp)-24(ended)-361(to)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(generalize)-204(the)-229(algorithm.)-205(If)-230(the)-217(matc)24(hing)-217(for)-217(rewrites)-206(is)-229(done)-217(using)-217(\\asso)-25(ciativ)24(e-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(comm)24(utativ)24(e)-301(uni\fcation")-301(instead)-302(of)-313(ordinary)-290(uni\fcation,)-302(then)-313(the)-314(algorithm)]TJ
T*
[(still)-435(w)25(orks,)-411(and)-433(one)-434(can)-421(simply)-434(omit)-434(the)-434(comm)24(utativ)24(e)-422(and)-433(asso)-25(ciativ)24(e)-409(ax-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(ioms)-362([5].)-373(This)-362(w)24(as)-361(the)-374(metho)-24(d)-374(emplo)25(y)24(ed)-361(in)-374(McCune's)-373(theorem-pro)23(v)24(er)-325(EQP)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(to)-338(settle)-326(the)-337(Robbins)-338(Conjecture)-325([71].)]TJ
1.50563 -1.46949 TD
[(Returning)-338(to)-337(the)-350(late)-337(1960s,)-313(w)24(e)-349(no)24(w)-325(describ)-24(e)-337(the)-350(con)25(tribution)-339(of)-337(George)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(Robinson)-217(and)-217(Larry)-206(W)85(os.)-218(They)-216(de\fned)-228(the)-229(inference)-217(rule)-217(they)-229(called)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
29.3898 0 Td
[(p)48(ar)49(amo)48(d-)]TJ
-29.3898 -1.19246 TD
(ulation)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
3.01125 0 Td
[(.)-289(This)-289(is)-278(essen)24(tially)-278(the)-289(rule)-277(used)-278(to)-289(generate)-265(new)-288(critical)-278(pairs)-266(at)-289(eac)25(h)]TJ
-3.01125 -1.2045 TD
[(step)-254(of)-265(the)-253(Kn)24(uth-Bendix)-253(algorithm.)-242(But)-265(in)-265([87],)-241(it)-265(w)24(as)-241(not)-265(restricted)-243(to)-253(theo-)]TJ
T*
[(ries)-254(whose)-240(only)-253(relation)-254(sym)24(b)-24(ol)-253(is)-254(equalit)24(y)85(.)-253(Instead,)-254(it)-254(w)25(as)-254(view)25(ed)-253(as)-241(a)-253(general)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(adjunct)-386(to)-373(resolution.)-363(One)-361(retains)-374(the)-374(re\rexivit)24(y)-362(axiom)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
24.86088 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.91542 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.13223 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.93951 0 Td
[(and)-373(replaces)]TJ
-27.84804 -1.2045 TD
[(transitivit)22(y)84(,)-337(symmetry)83(,)-337(and)-338(substitutivit)21(y)-349(with)-349(the)-350(new)-349(inference)-336(rule.)-338(They)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(used)-301(this)-315(metho)-24(d)-301(to)-302(\fnd)-313(pro)-24(ofs)-290(of)-301(theorems)-290(that)-314(w)24(ere)-289(previously)-289(b)-24(ey)24(ond)-301(the)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(reac)24(h)-241(of)-253(computer)-253(programs.)-218(F)84(or)-253(example,)-253(with)-253(\()]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
21.00648 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.62634 0 Td
(\n)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.84315 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
[(\))-265(de\fned)-265(as)-241(the)-265(comm)24(u-)]TJ
-23.00595 -1.2045 TD
[(tator)-302(of)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
3.60145 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.87929 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.9272 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
[(,)-313(they)-314(pro)24(v)24(ed)-289(that)-314(in)-313(a)-313(group,)-301(if)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
14.14083 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 350.4 377.4 Tm
(3)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 357.72 373.8 Tm
[(=)-265(1)-313(then)-313(\()]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.50483 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.75884 0 Td
(\n)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.95155 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
(\))Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
(\n)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.9636 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.80702 0 Td
0.265 Tc
[(=1)265(.)]TJ
-31.46154 -1.19246 TD
0 Tc
[(Although)-434(this)-435(example)-421(is)-434(purely)-422(equational,)-421(the)-434(rule)-434(of)-433(paramo)-25(dulation)-410(is)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(generally)-469(applicable,)-482(whatev)25(er)-482(relation)-471(sym)24(b)-24(ols)-482(ma)24(y)-482(o)-24(ccur)-482(in)-494(addition)-482(to)]TJ
T*
[(equalit)24(y)84(.)-385(Robinson)-374(and)-385(W)84(os)-386(pro)24(v)24(ed)-373([88])-373(the)-398(refutation-completeness)-375(of)-385(this)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(metho)-24(d,)-350(i.e.,)-349(an)24(y)-337(theorem)-337(has)-350(a)-337(pro)-25(of)-337(b)24(y)-349(con)24(tradiction)-326(using)-338(resolution)-338(and)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(paramo)-24(dulation,)-386(with)-410(the)-398(axiom)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
14.76717 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.9636 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.16836 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56612 0 Td
[(.)-410(On)-397(the)-410(other)-386(hand,)-397(Robinson)-398(and)]TJ
-17.46525 -1.19245 TD
[(W)84(os)-361(did)-374(not)-374(in)24(tro)-25(duce)-360(the)-374(concept)-361(of)-361(con\ruence)-372(or)-350(of)-373(a)-362(complete)-361(con\ruen)25(t)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(set)-326(of)-313(rules,)-314(so,)-314(for)-313(example,)-313(the)-325(deduction)-313(of)-326(the)-325(ten)-313(group-theory)-303(theorems)]TJ
T*
[(giv)24(en)-325(ab)-24(o)24(v)24(e)-312(escap)-24(ed)-325(their)-338(notice.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.46949 TD
[(F)84(or)-326(theories)-338(relying)-325(exclusiv)24(ely)-337(on)-337(equalit)24(y)84(,)-337(no)-337(serious)-327(distinction)-350(should)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(made)-325(b)-24(et)24(w)24(een)-324(the)-338(Kn)24(uth-Bendix)-325(metho)-24(d)-326(and)-325(paramo)-24(dulation.)-314(They)-325(are)-313(es-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(sen)24(tially)-278(the)-289(same)-277(thing.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 240.24 243.24 Tm
(30)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 251.52 239.64 Tm
[(Nev)25(ertheless,)-266(as)-278(men)24(tioned)-289(b)-24(efore,)-277(there)-277(is)-278(a)-289(com-)]TJ
-11.71978 -1.2045 TD
[(m)24(unit)23(y)-397(of)-410(researc)24(hers)-362(in)-409(\\rewrite)-386(rules")-386(and)-398(an)-397(almost)-399(disjoin)24(t)-398(comm)24(unit)24(y)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(of)-446(researc)24(hers)-422(in)-458(\\automated)-434(deduction",)-446(eac)25(h)-445(with)-458(their)-447(o)24(wn)-445(conferences)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(and)-410(journals.)-410(The)-421(c)24(hallenge)-397(for)-410(to)-24(da)24(y's)-410(w)24(ork)24(ers)-374(in)-422(equalit)24(y)-409(reasoning)-398(is)-410(to)]TJ
T*
[(connect)-337(the)-337(v)60(ast)-326(b)-24(o)-24(dy)-337(of)-338(existing)-325(w)24(ork)-314(with)-349(the)-338(w)25(ork)-314(that)-338(has)-325(b)-25(een)-336(done)-337(in)]TJ
ET
q
56.76 0 0 -0.48 134.748 173.028 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 166.2 Tm
(30)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 162.36 Tm
[(The)-456(four)-454(di\013erences)-455(listed)-455(on)-455(p.)-442(20)-468(of)-454([72])-468(are)-468(actually)-454(di\013erences)-455(in)-442(the)-455(w)27(a)27(y)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(the)-361(tec)27(hnique)-363(is)-387(used)-376(in)-375(Otter)-360(and)-375(the)-375(w)27(a)27(y)-374(it)-375(w)27(ould)-375(b)-28(e)-374(used)-376(in)-375(a)-374(program)-386(that)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(implemen)27(ted)-335(only)-348(Kn)26(uth-Bendix.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
38 0 obj
<<
/Length 7300
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 134.76 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(36)-2662(Mic)26(hael)-361(Beeson)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(computer)-277(algebra,)-253(so)-266(that)-278(pro)-24(ofs)-266(in)24(v)24(olving)-264(computation)-266(can)-277(b)-24(egin)-276(to)-278(b)-24(e)-277(done)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(b)24(y)-325(computer.)-338(This)-325(task)-326(has)-326(hardly)-326(b)-24(een)-337(b)-24(egun.)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
11.95517 0 0 11.95517 134.76 620.76 Tm
[(12)-1506(Pro)-30(ofs)-371(In)30(v)30(olving)-382(Computations)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 595.32 Tm
[(There)-397(ha)24(v)24(e)-385(alw)25(a)24(ys)-374(b)-24(een)-409(t)23(w)25(o)-386(asp)-24(ects)-398(of)-397(mathematics:)-399(logical)-384(reasoning)-374(and)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(computation.)-350(These)-337(ha)24(v)24(e)-336(historical)-339(ro)-24(ots)-338(as)-338(far)-338(bac)25(k)-337(as)-350(Greece)-336(and)-350(Bab)25(ylo-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(nia,)-277(resp)-25(ectiv)24(ely)85(.)-265(E\013orts)-254(to)-277(mec)24(hanize)-264(mathematics)-278(b)-24(egan)-264(with)-278(computation,)]TJ
T*
[(and)-253(as)-253(discussed)-242(ab)-24(o)24(v)24(e,)-241(the)-265(mac)25(hines)-242(of)-252(P)24(ascal)-241(and)-253(Leibniz)-253(preceded)-252(the)-253(Log-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(ical)-325(Piano.)-312(In)-326(our)-314(time,)-337(the)-326(mec)25(hanization)-313(of)-325(computation)-326(via)-325(computer)-314(has)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(b)-24(een)-325(m)24(uc)25(h)-314(more)-313(successful)-314(than)-326(the)-325(mec)25(hanization)-302(of)-325(logical)-300(reasoning.)-302(The)]TJ
T*
[(mec)25(hanization)-362(of)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
7.80516 0 Td
[(symb)49(olic)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
4.03508 0 Td
[(computation)-374(\(as)-374(opp)-24(osed)-362(to)-373(n)24(umerical)-374(computa-)]TJ
-11.84023 -1.19245 TD
[(tion\))-410(b)-25(egan)-385(in)-409(the)-398(\ffties,)-410(as)-398(did)-410(the)-397(mec)24(hanization)-385(of)-398(logic.)-397(What)-398(is)-410(in)24(ter-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(esting,)-374(and)-361(surprising)-364(to)-362(p)-24(eople)-372(outside)-374(the)-374(\feld,)-373(is)-374(that)-374(the)-374(mec)25(hanization)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(of)-470(logic)-457(and)-470(the)-482(mec)25(hanization)-458(of)-470(computation)-470(ha)24(v)24(e)-457(pro)-25(ceeded)-468(somewhat)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(indep)-24(enden)25(tly)83(.)-481(W)84(e)-481(no)24(w)-470(ha)24(v)25(e)-470(computer)-470(programs)-447(that)-483(can)-469(carry)-458(out)-470(v)24(ery)]TJ
T*
[(elab)-24(orate)-265(computations,)-278(and)-277(these)-290(programs)-254(are)-277(used)-277(b)24(y)-277(mathematicians)-278(\\as)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(required".)-302(W)85(e)-313(also)-301(ha)24(v)24(e)-301(\\theorem-pro)23(v)24(ers",)-265(but)-326(for)-302(the)-325(most)-314(part,)-314(these)-314(t)24(w)24(o)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(capabilities)-386(do)-397(not)-398(o)-24(ccur)-397(in)-398(the)-398(same)-397(program,)-375(and)-385(these)-398(programs)-375(do)-397(not)]TJ
T*
[(ev)24(en)-325(comm)25(unicate)-325(usefully)84(.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.22859 TD
[(P)25(art)-278(of)-301(the)-302(problem)-301(is)-302(that)-302(p)-24(opular)-302(sym)24(b)-24(olic)-289(computation)-302(soft)24(w)24(are)-277(\(suc)23(h)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.19246 TD
[(as)-386(Mathematica,)-398(Maple,)-397(and)-398(Macsyma\))-386(is)-386(logically)-385(incorrect.)-386(F)84(or)-386(example:)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
(Set)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.85493 0 Td
(a)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.02382 0 Td
[(=)-494(0.)-457(Divide)-470(b)-24(oth)-470(sides)-459(b)24(y)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
12.37021 0 Td
(a)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
[(.)-458(Y)85(ou)-470(get)-458(1)-493(=)-494(0,)-458(b)-24(ecause)-457(the)-470(soft)23(w)25(are)]TJ
-15.77895 -1.2045 TD
(thinks)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
3.10761 0 Td
(a=a)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.95129 0 Td
[(=)-385(1)-398(and)-397(0)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.58915 0 Td
(=a)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.42131 0 Td
[(=)-385(0.)-398(This)-410(kind)-397(of)-410(problem)-398(is)-398(p)-24(erv)60(asiv)24(e)-385(and)-410(is)-398(not)]TJ
-11.06936 -1.19245 TD
[(just)-266(an)-241(isolated)-241(\\bug",)-241(b)-24(ecause)-253(computation)-241(soft)23(w)24(are)-228(applies)-254(transformations)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(without)-314(c)25(hec)24(king)-301(the)-313(assumptions)-291(under)-314(whic)25(h)-313(they)-302(are)-301(v)60(alid.)-313(Alternately)84(,)-301(if)]TJ
T*
[(transformations)-292(are)-301(not)-326(applied)-313(unless)-314(the)-313(assumptions)-303(are)-313(all)-301(c)24(hec)25(k)24(ed,)-301(then)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(computations)-218(grind)-229(to)-229(a)-217(halt)-229(b)-25(ecause)-228(the)-229(necessary)-205(assumptions)-219(are)-217(not)-229(v)24(eri\f-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(able.)-289(The)-288(author's)-279(soft)23(w)25(are)-265(MathXp)-25(ert)-290([11],)-289(whic)25(h)-289(w)24(as)-277(written)-290(for)-278(education)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(rather)-411(than)-422(for)-422(adv)61(anced)-409(mathematics,)-423(handles)-410(these)-421(matters)-423(correctly)84(,)-410(as)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(describ)-25(ed)-385(in)-385([10].)-386(Later)-374(v)24(ersions)-374(of)-386(Mathematica)-374(ha)25(v)24(e)-373(b)-25(egun)-397(attac)24(king)-373(this)]TJ
T*
[(problem)-350(b)24(y)-349(restricting)-339(the)-349(applicabilit)23(y)-349(of)-349(transformations)-340(and)-349(allo)24(wing)-337(the)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(user)-338(to)-338(sp)-24(ecify)-349(assumptions)-339(as)-338(extra)-326(argumen)24(ts)-326(to)-349(transformations,)-316(but)-362(this)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(is)-278(not)-289(a)-265(complete)-289(solution.)-265(Buc)24(h)24(b)-24(erger's)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
17.56161 0 Td
[(The)49(or)49(ema)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
4.58915 0 Td
[(pro)-61(ject)-265([23])-276(is)-278(the)-289(b)-24(est)-278(at-)]TJ
-22.15075 -1.2045 TD
[(tempt)-290(so)-277(far)-278(to)-289(com)24(bine)-277(logic)-276(and)-277(computation,)-290(but)-290(it)-289(is)-278(not)-289(in)24(tended)-289(to)-278(b)-24(e)-288(a)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(pro)-25(of-\fnder,)-229(but)-242(rather)-229(a)-241(pro)-25(of-c)24(hec)25(k)24(er,)-205(enabling)-228(a)-241(h)24(uman)-241(to)-229(in)24(teractiv)23(ely)-228(de-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(v)24(elop)-301(a)-313(pro)-24(of.)-313(The)-313(di\016cult)24(y)-314(here)-313(is)-313(that)-314(when)-325(the)-313(underlying)-314(computational)]TJ
T*
[(abilit)24(y)-289(of)-278(Mathematica)-277(is)-290(used,)-289(it)-290(is)-289(hard)-278(to)-289(b)-24(e)-289(certain)-277(that)-290(all)-277(error)-266(has)-278(b)-24(een)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(excluded,)-361(b)-24(ecause)-349(Mathematica)-361(do)-24(es)-350(not)-362(ha)25(v)24(e)-337(a)-362(systematic)-350(w)24(a)25(y)-350(of)-349(trac)24(king)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(or)-326(v)25(erifying)-314(the)-337(pre-conditions)-327(and)-325(p)-24(ost-conditions)-327(for)-326(its)-338(transformations.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.22859 TD
[(Another)-374(program)-362(that)-386(w)24(as)-374(a)-373(pioneer)-373(in)-386(this)-386(area)-374(is)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
23.13844 0 Td
[(A)24(nalytic)49(a)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
4.48074 0 Td
[([30].)-373(This)]TJ
-29.12481 -1.2045 TD
[(w)24(as)-422(a)-421(theorem-pro)23(v)24(er)-397(written)-435(in)-434(the)-446(Mathematica)-422(programming)-410(language.)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(\\W)85(as")-230(is)-241(the)-241(appropriate)-230(tense,)-241(since)-241(this)-242(program)-217(is)-242(no)-241(longer)-229(in)-241(use)-241(or)-229(under)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(dev)24(elopmen)25(t.)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
6.04659 0 Td
[(A)24(nalytic)49(a)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
4.37233 0 Td
[(w)24(as)-277(primarily)-278(useful)-302(for)-277(pro)23(ving)-277(iden)25(tities,)-291(and)-289(made)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
39 0 obj
<<
/Length 6715
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 290.52 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(The)-335(Mec)27(hanization)-361(of)-361(Mathematics)-2674(37)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(a)-421(splash)-423(b)24(y)-434(pro)24(ving)-410(some)-421(di\016cult)-434(iden)24(tities)-435(from)-434(Raman)24(ujan's)-422(noteb)-24(o)-24(oks.)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(It)-362(could)-361(not)-362(deal)-349(with)-374(quan)25(ti\fed)-350(form)23(ulas)-349(and)-362(did)-361(not)-362(ha)24(v)24(e)-349(state-of-the-art)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
[(searc)24(hing)-313(abilities.)]TJ
1.50563 -2.21628 TD
[(On)-313(the)-326(theorem-pro)24(ving)-290(side)-313(of)-325(the)-326(endea)25(v)24(or,)-289(e\013orts)-315(to)-325(incorp)-24(orate)-302(com-)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(putation)-422(in)-410(theorem-pro)23(v)24(ers)-386(ha)24(v)24(e)-397(b)-24(een)-421(restricted)-411(to)-410(t)24(w)24(o)-409(approac)24(hes:)-386(using)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(rewrite)-326(rules)-314(\(or)-326(demo)-23(dulators\),)-315(and)-338(calling)-313(external)-325(decision)-313(pro)-25(cedures)-313(for)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(form)23(ulas)-277(in)-289(certain)-290(sp)-24(ecialized)-288(forms.)-278(The)-289(sub)-61(ject)-288(kno)24(wn)-289(as)-278(\\constrain)24(t)-278(logic)]TJ
T*
[(programming")-302((CLP))-338(can)-337(b)-24(e)-337(considered)-325(in)-337(this)-339(latter)-338(category)85(.)-314(T)85(o)-24(da)24(y)-325(there)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(are)-229(a)-229(few)-252(exp)-24(erimen)24(ts)-230(in)-241(linking)-241(decision-pro)-24(cedure)-217(mo)-24(dules)-241(to)-241(pro)-25(of-c)24(hec)25(k)24(ers)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(\(e.g.)-398(qep)-23(cad)-385(to)-398(PVS\),)-398(but)-398(there)-385(is)-398(little)-399(w)25(ork)-374(in)-398(linking)-397(decision-pro)-25(cedure)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(mo)-24(dules)-338(to)-325(pro)-25(of-\fnding)-325(programs.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 288.84 540.12 Tm
(31)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 149.76 514.32 Tm
[(The)-240(author's)-243(soft)24(w)24(are)-217(MathXp)-25(ert)-253(con)24(tains)-242(computational)-241(co)-24(de)-240(that)-254(prop-)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(erly)-277(trac)23(ks)-265(the)-277(preconditions)-278(for)-266(the)-289(application)-277(of)-277(mathematical)-277(transforma-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(tions.)-254(After)-265(publishing)-254(MathXp)-25(ert)-266(in)-253(1997,)-228(I)-253(then)-266(com)25(bined)-253(some)-253(of)-253(this)-254(co)-24(de)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(with)-362(a)-349(simple)-362(theorem)-349(pro)23(v)25(er)-338(I)-349(had)-362(written)-350(earlier)-350([9],)-349(and)-349(w)24(as)-349(therefore)-350(in)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(a)-458(unique)-457(p)-24(osition)-459(to)-458(exp)-24(erimen)24(t)-458(with)-470(the)-458(automated)-458(generation)-446(of)-457(pro)-25(ofs)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(in)24(v)24(olving)-433(computation.)-459(I)-446(named)-457(the)-458(com)24(bined)-445(theorem-pro)23(v)24(er)-410(W)85(eierstrass)]TJ
T*
[(b)-24(ecause)-325(the)-337(\frst)-327(exp)-24(erimen)24(ts)-338(I)-325(p)-25(erformed)-325(in)24(v)24(olv)24(ed)-325(epsilon{delta)-313(argumen)24(ts.)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(These)-457(are)-458(the)-458(\frst)-471(pro)-25(ofs,)-446(other)-458(than)-470(simple)-458(mathematical)-458(inductions,)-471(to)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(whic)25(h)-326(studen)24(ts)-327(of)-313(mathematics)-326(are)-313(exp)-24(osed.)-313(I)-326(used)-325(W)84(eierstrass)-303(in)-325(1988-1990)]TJ
T*
[(to)-253(\fnd)-265(epsilon-delta)-254(pro)-25(ofs)-253(of)-253(the)-265(con)24(tin)24(uit)23(y)-253(of)-252(sp)-25(eci\fc)-264(functions)-266(suc)24(h)-253(as)-253(p)-25(o)25(w-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(ers)-266(of)-289(x,)-277(square)-265(ro)-25(ot,)-265(log,)-277(sine)-277(and)-277(cosine,)-265(etc.)-289(Before)-265(this,)-278(the)-289(b)-24(est)-290(that)-278(could)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(b)-24(e)-458(done)-445(w)24(as)-433(the)-458(con)24(tin)24(uit)23(y)-445(of)-446(a)-446(linear)-434(function)-458([19].)-445(These)-445(pro)-25(ofs)-434(in)24(v)24(olv)24(e)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(simple)-362(algebraic)-337(la)25(ws)-350(\(or)-350(la)24(ws)-349(in)24(v)24(olving)-337(sine,)-362(cosine,)-349(log,)-349(and)-350(the)-373(lik)24(e\),)-350(but,)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(what)-458(is)-458(more,)-458(they)-458(in)24(v)24(olv)24(e)-445(com)25(bining)-458(those)-459(computations)-458(with)-458(inequalit)24(y)]TJ
(reasoning.)'
1.50563 -2.21628 TD
[(I)-374(then)-385(mo)24(v)24(ed)-361(from)-386(analysis)-363(to)-373(n)24(um)24(b)-25(er)-373(theory)84(,)-374(and)-373(considered)-374(the)-373(pro)-25(of)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(of)-434(the)-445(irrationalit)22(y)-410(of)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
9.9853 0 Td
(e)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.46975 0 Td
[(.)-434(W)85(eierstrass)-412(w)25(as)-434(able,)-434(after)-434(sev)24(eral)-410(impro)24(v)24(emen)25(ts,)]TJ
-10.45506 -1.19245 TD
[(to)-434(automatically)-410(generate)-421(a)-422(pro)-24(of)-422(of)-433(this)-435(theorem)-422([13].)-421(The)-433(pro)-25(of)-422(in)24(v)25(olv)24(es)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(inequalities,)-229(b)-24(ounds)-230(on)-217(in\fnite)-241(series,)-218(t)24(yp)-24(e)-229(distinctions)-218(\(b)-25(et)24(w)25(een)-241(real)-205(n)25(um)23(b)-24(ers)]TJ
T*
[(and)-265(natural)-266(n)24(um)24(b)-24(ers\),)-266(a)-265(subpro)-25(of)-265(b)24(y)-265(mathematical)-265(induction,)-266(and)-277(signi\fcan)24(t)]TJ
ET
q
56.76 0 0 -0.48 134.748 227.868 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 220.92 Tm
(31)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 217.08 Tm
[(P)27(ossible)-428(exceptions:)-414(if)-415(the)-415(set)-414(of)-414(demo)-26(dulators)-427(is)-415(con\ruen)26(t)-401(and)-402(complete,)-414(then)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(demo)-26(dulation)-442(could)-442(b)-28(e)-441(regarded)-455(as)-440(a)-442(decision)-455(pro)-26(cedure)-442(for)-454(equations)-441(in)-442(that)]TJ
T*
[(theory)82(.)-389(Bledso)-26(e's)-428(rules)-401([19],)-414([25])-414(\(Ch.)-402(8\))-400(for)-414(inequalities)-414(could)-389(b)-27(e)-402(regarded)-400(as)-401(a)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(decision)-442(pro)-26(cedure)-442(for)-441(a)-441(certain)-441(class)-454(of)-441(inequalities.)-454(Theorem)-455(pro)28(v)27(ers)-428(suc)27(h)-429(as)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(EQP)-348(and)-348(RRL)-335(that)-347(ha)27(v)27(e)-335(A)27(C-uni\fcation)-349(could)-349(b)-27(e)-348(regarded)-360(as)-361(ha)27(ving)-335(a)-360(decision)]TJ
T*
[(pro)-26(cedure)-269(for)-279(linear)-268(equations.)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
13.78483 0 Td
[(The)53(or)53(ema)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
4.68417 0 Td
[(do)-27(es)-280(con)26(tain)-267(decision)-281(pro)-27(cedures,)-281(but)-254(it)]TJ
-18.469 -1.23127 TD
[(is)-348(primarily)-346(a)-334(pro)-26(of-c)27(hec)26(k)27(er,)-347(not)-334(a)-348(pro)-26(of-\fnder.)-335(An)-336(extension)-333(of)-348(the)-334(pro)27(v)27(er)-334(RRL)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(called)-348(T)80(ecton)-348([1])-361(has)-347(a)-348(decision)-361(pro)-26(cedure)-336(for)-360(Presburger)-346(arithmetic.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
40 0 obj
<<
/Length 8437
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 134.76 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(38)-2662(Mic)26(hael)-361(Beeson)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(mathematical)-337(steps,)-351(including)-337(correct)-338(simpli\fcation)-338(of)-349(expressions)-315(in)24(v)24(olving)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(factorials)-314(and)-337(summing)-326(an)-338(in\fnite)-337(geometrical)-313(series.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 366.84 657.84 Tm
[(32)-533(33)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 149.76 642.2401 Tm
[(Inequalities)-302(pla)24(y)24(ed)-300(a)-314(cen)25(tral)-302(role)-301(in)-313(b)-24(oth)-326(the)-313(epsilon-delta)-302(pro)-25(ofs)-313(and)-314(the)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.19245 TD
[(pro)-25(of)-265(of)-265(the)-277(irrationalit)23(y)-241(of)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
11.86432 0 Td
(e)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.46976 0 Td
[(.)-265(Inequalities)-266(certainly)-265(pla)24(y)-253(a)-265(cen)25(tral)-266(role)-253(in)-277(clas-)]TJ
-12.33408 -1.2045 TD
[(sical)-289(analysis.)-290(Bo)-24(oks)-277(and)-301(journal)-290(articles)-290(ab)-24(out)-301(partial)-290(di\013eren)24(tial)-302(equations,)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(for)-338(example,)-336(are)-338(full)-361(of)-338(inequalities)-349(kno)24(wn)-337(as)-338(\\estimates")-326(or)-338(\\b)-24(ounds",)-338(that)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(pla)24(y)-313(k)24(ey)-313(roles)-313(in)-326(existence)-325(pro)-24(ofs.)-314(Classically)84(,)-301(mathematics)-326(has)-314(b)-24(een)-336(divided)]TJ
T*
[(in)24(to)-301(algebra)-277(and)-290(analysis.)-290(I)-301(w)24(ould)-289(v)24(en)25(ture)-290(to)-301(call)-289(algebra)-277(the)-301(mathematics)-302(of)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(equalit)24(y)84(,)-325(and)-337(analysis)-314(the)-338(mathematics)-326(of)-337(inequalit)24(y)84(.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(The)-240(mec)24(hanization)-241(of)-253(equalit)24(y)-240(reasoning)-230(has)-241(made)-241(more)-241(progress)-230(than)-254(the)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(mec)25(hanization)-253(of)-265(inequalit)24(y)-265(reasoning.)-242(W)85(e)-265(ha)24(v)24(e)-252(discussed)-266(the)-266(\\\frst)-254(lo)-24(ophole")]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(ab)-24(o)24(v)24(e,)-409(whic)25(h)-422(allo)24(ws)-409(for)-423(the)-433(complete)-421(mec)24(hanization)-421(of)-422(certain)-422(sub\felds)-422(of)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(mathematics)-278(b)24(y)-289(a)-277(\\decision)-265(pro)-24(cedure")-265(that)-290(algorithmically)-265(settles)-290(questions)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(in)-265(a)-253(sp)-25(eci\fc)-264(area.)-241(The)-264(mec)25(hanization)-241(of)-265(equalit)24(y)-253(reasoning)-242(has)-253(b)-24(ene\fted)-265(from)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(the)-386(disco)24(v)24(ery)-349(of)-373(decision)-362(pro)-24(cedures)-362(with)-385(surprisingly)-364(wide)-373(applicabilit)24(y)84(.)-373(In)]TJ
T*
[(particular,)-411(a)-409(decision)-422(pro)-24(cedure)-409(has)-410(b)-24(een)-433(found)-422(for)-410(a)-422(class)-410(including)-421(what)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(are)-277(usually)-278(called)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
7.79311 0 Td
[(c)48(ombinatorial)-336(identities)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
10.20212 0 Td
[(.)-301(Com)24(binatorial)-266(iden)25(tities)-291(are)-277(those)]TJ
-17.99523 -1.2045 TD
[(in)24(v)24(olving)-253(sums)-266(and)-277(binomial)-265(co)-24(e\016cien)25(ts,)-266(often)-265(in)-277(quite)-277(complicated)-265(algebraic)]TJ
T*
[(forms.)-326(T)84(o)-325(illustrate)-339(with)-337(a)-325(v)24(ery)-313(simple)-338(example,)]TJ
/F15 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 263.88 438.48 Tm
(n)Tj
/F14 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 259.2 435.48 Tm
(X)Tj
/F15 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 259.44 414.24 Tm
(j)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.51622 0 Td
(=0)Tj
/F14 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 275.16 440.04 Tm
<12>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.74679 -0.73475 TD
(n)Tj
0.06023 -1.36108 TD
(j)Tj
/F14 1 Tf
0.52998 2.09583 TD
<13>Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 295.92 438 Tm
(2)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 303.12 426 Tm
(=)Tj
/F14 1 Tf
1.04791 1.40926 TD
<12>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.74679 -0.73475 TD
(2)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.50589 0 Td
(n)Tj
-0.26499 -1.36108 TD
(n)Tj
/F14 1 Tf
0.85519 2.09583 TD
<13>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.73475 -1.40926 TD
(:)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
-20.52468 -2.77035 TD
[(In)-518(1974)-482(it)-518(w)24(as)-506(recognized)-493(b)24(y)-506(Gosp)-24(er,)-506(who)-518(w)24(as)-494(at)-518(that)-507(time)-518(in)24(v)24(olv)24(ed)-505(in)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(the)-470(creation)-446(of)-457(Macsyma,)-447(that)-470(almost)-447(all)-457(suc)24(h)-458(iden)24(tities)-471(are)-446(sp)-24(ecial)-457(cases)]TJ
T*
[(of)-337(a)-325(few)-337(iden)24(tities)-338(in)24(v)24(olving)]TJ
/F7 1 Tf
12.38226 0 Td
[(hyp)49(er)48(ge)49(ometric)-385(functions)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
10.81641 0 Td
[(,)-337(an)-325(area)-314(of)-337(mathemat-)]TJ
-23.19867 -1.19245 TD
[(ics)-422(initiated,)-434(lik)24(e)-409(so)-422(man)24(y)-410(others,)-422(b)24(y)-422(Gauss.)-410(In)-422(1982,)-409(Doron)-410(Zeilb)-24(erger)-410(re-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(alized)-457(that)-459(recurrence)-433(relations)-447(for)-458(suc)24(h)-446(iden)24(tities)-471(can)-445(b)-24(e)-469(generated)-446(auto-)]TJ
T*
[(matically)84(.)-349(This)-350(realization)-337(is)-350(the)-349(basis)-351(for)-337(\\Zeilb)-24(erger's)-326(paradigm")-338(\(see)-350([81],)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(p.)-470(23\).)-470(This)-470(\\paradigm")-446(is)-470(a)-458(metho)-24(d)-482(for)-458(pro)24(ving)-458(an)-470(iden)24(tit)24(y)-470(of)-470(the)-470(form)]TJ
/F14 1 Tf
0 -0.45771 TD
(P)Tj
/F15 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 145.32 311.64 Tm
(k)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 151.8 314.64 Tm
(summand)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
4.16757 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
[(n;)-169(k)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.60198 0 Td
0.277 Tc
(\)=)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
1.72244 0 Td
0 Tc
(answer)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
3.02329 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
[(\).)-302(Namely:)-288((i))-302(\fnd)-302(a)-289(recurrence)-264(relation)-290(satis-)]TJ
-13.5988 -1.19245 TD
[(\fed)-325(b)24(y)-313(the)-326(sum;)-313((ii))-327(sho)24(w)-313(that)-326(the)-325(prop)-25(osed)-301(answ)24(er)-301(satis\fes)-315(the)-313(same)-314(recur-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(rence;)-385((iii))-411(c)25(hec)25(k)-386(that)-398(\\enough")-385(initial)-398(v)60(alues)-385(of)-398(b)-24(oth)-398(sides)-398(are)-386(equal.)-385(Here)]TJ
T*
[(\\enough")-337(dep)-24(ends)-361(on)-349(the)-362(rational)-338(functions)-362(in)24(v)24(olv)24(ed)-337(in)-361(the)-362(recurrence)-337(rela-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(tion.)-278(The)-288(k)24(ey)-277(to)-277(automating)-266(pro)-24(ofs)-278(of)-277(com)25(binatorial)-254(iden)24(tities)-290(is)-278(to)-289(automate)]TJ
ET
q
56.76 0 0 -0.48 134.748 260.748 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 253.8 Tm
(32)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 249.96 Tm
[(Tw)27(o)-428(things)-415(particularly)-413(am)28(used)-416(me)-401(ab)-27(out)-414(this)-415(piece)-415(of)-428(w)27(ork:)-414(First,)-427(one)-415(of)-414(the)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(referees)-333(said)-321(\\Of)-320(course)-321(it's)-320(a)-321(stun)27(t.")-320(Second,)-309(audiences)-322(to)-320(whom)-321(I)-308(lectured)-308(w)27(ere)]TJ
T*
[(quite)-415(ready)-414(to)-427(accept)-415(that)-427(next)-401(I)-415(migh)27(t)-428(b)-27(e)-415(pro)28(ving)-429(the)-414(irrationalit)29(y)-428(of)-441(Euler's)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(constan)28(t)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
4.1756 0 Td
(\r)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.97698 0 Td
[(or)-374(solving)-400(other)-374(op)-27(en)-389(problems.)-387(P)27(eople)-388(to)-26(da)27(y)-375(are)-387(quite)-375(jaded)-388(ab)-27(out)]TJ
-5.15258 -1.21788 TD
[(the)-361(amazing)-387(latest)-387(accomplishmen)28(ts)-387(of)-388(computers!)-373(What)-375(the)-361(referee)-387(mean)27(t)-374(w)26(as)]TJ
T*
[(that)-347(the)-361(\\stun)27(t")-361(w)27(as)-360(not)-361(going)-374(to)-361(b)-27(e)-361(rep)-27(eated)-361(an)27(y)-348(time)-360(so)-26(on)-375(with)-361(famous)-374(op)-26(en)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(problems)-347(of)-347(n)26(um)27(b)-28(er)-334(theory)82(.)]TJ
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 177.12 Tm
(33)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 173.28 Tm
[(It)-227(w)27(as)-253(di\016cult)-228(for)-253(others)-240(to)-226(build)-243(up)-27(on)-228(this)-227(w)27(ork)-240(in)-242(that)-226(the)-241(co)-26(de)-242(from)-239(MathXp)-27(ert)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(could)-335(not)-348(b)-27(e)-335(shared,)-347(b)-27(ecause)-348(it)-334(is)-348(part)-347(of)-347(a)-348(commercial)-359(pro)-26(duct)-335(no)-335(longer)-360(under)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(the)-241(author's)-239(con)26(trol.)-253(In)-241(the)-241(future,)-241(similar)-265(features)-253(should)-242(b)-27(e)-241(added)-228(to)-254(an)-241(existing,)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(widely-used)-335(theorem)-347(pro)27(v)27(er,)-347(whose)-348(source)-360(co)-27(de)-348(is)-348(accessible,)-374(suc)27(h)-335(as)-347(Otter.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
41 0 obj
<<
/Length 9326
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 290.52 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(The)-335(Mec)27(hanization)-361(of)-361(Mathematics)-2674(39)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(the)-422(disco)24(v)24(ery)-385(of)-422(the)-422(appropriate)-398(recurrence)-397(relation.)-411(In)-410([81],)-409(one)-409(can)-421(learn)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(ho)24(w)-421(this)-423(is)-422(done,)-421(using)-422(metho)-25(ds)-422(whose)-409(ro)-24(ots)-423(lie)-421(in)-422(Gosp)-24(er's)-411(algorithm)-410(for)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
[(the)-446(summation)-435(of)-433(h)24(yp)-24(ergeometric)-410(series,)-422(and)-434(in)-446(y)24(et)-433(earlier)-422(w)24(ork)-410(b)24(y)-433(Sister)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(Mary)-338(Celine)-349(on)-337(recurrence)-325(relations.)-338(The)-349(app)-24(endix)-349(of)-349([81])-338(con)25(tains)-338(p)-24(oin)24(ters)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(to)-398(Mathematica)-386(and)-397(Maple)-398(implemen)24(tations)-386(of)-398(the)-409(algorithms)-375(in)-398(question.)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(In)-434(addition)-422(to)-434(v)24(erifying)-422(prop)-24(osed)-410(iden)24(tities,)-435(some)-433(of)-422(these)-434(algorithms)-411(can,)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(giv)24(en)-301(only)-301(the)-313(left-hand)-314(sum,)-314(determine)-313(whether)-313(there)-302(exists)-314(an)-301(\\answ)24(er")-289(in)]TJ
T*
[(a)-361(certain)-350(form,)-362(and)-349(if)-374(so,)-349(\fnd)-374(it.)-362(The)-361(algorithms)-350(presen)23(ted)-349(in)-362([81])-349(are)-349(note-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(w)24(orth)24(y)-386(b)-24(ecause,)-409(unlik)24(e)-397(either)-398(pro)-25(of-searc)24(h)-373(or)-398(quan)24(ti\fer)-398(elimination)-398(for)-410(the)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(reals,)-290(they)-313(routinely)-290(p)-24(erform)-302(at)-301(h)24(uman)-301(lev)24(el)-301(or)-289(b)-25(etter)-313(in)-302(\fnding)-301(and)-301(pro)24(ving)]TJ
T*
[(com)24(binatorial)-314(iden)25(tities.)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
11.95517 0 0 11.95517 134.76 513.12 Tm
[(13)-1124(Searc)30(hing)-393(for)-371(Pro)-30(ofs)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 487.44 Tm
[(In)-229(essence,)-229(automated)-217(deduction)-241(is)-229(a)-217(searc)24(h)-217(problem.)-229(W)84(e)-228(ha)24(v)24(e)-217(a)-228(list)-230(of)-229(axioms,)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(a)-325(few)-325(\\sp)-24(ecial)-313(h)24(yp)-24(otheses")-314(of)-325(the)-325(theorem)-326(to)-325(b)-25(e)-324(pro)23(v)24(ed,)-313(and)-313(the)-337(negation)-313(of)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(its)-266(conclusion,)-253(and)-253(some)-253(inference)-264(rules.)-254(These)-253(inputs)-266(determine)-265(a)-253(large)-253(space)]TJ
T*
[(of)-325(p)-24(ossible)-326(conclusions)-314(that)-326(can)-313(b)-24(e)-337(dra)24(wn.)-313(W)84(e)-324(m)24(ust)-327(searc)24(h)-313(that)-326(space)-313(to)-326(see)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(if)-422(it)-422(con)25(tains)-411(a)-409(con)24(tradiction.)-410(In)-410(some)-422(approac)24(hes)-386(to)-409(automated)-422(deduction)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(\(that)-387(do)-373(not)-374(use)-373(pro)-25(of)-361(b)24(y)-374(con)25(tradiction\),)-363(w)24(e)-373(migh)24(t)-374(not)-373(put)-386(the)-386(negation)-361(of)]TJ
T*
[(the)-289(conclusion)-277(in,)-289(and)-289(then)-290(searc)24(h)-277(the)-289(p)-24(ossible)-278(deductions)-290(for)-277(the)-302(conclusion,)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(instead)-254(of)-265(a)-252(con)24(tradiction.)-242(Either)-253(w)24(a)24(y)85(,)-253(a)-253(searc)24(h)-241(is)-266(in)24(v)24(olv)25(ed.)-241(T)85(o)-253(the)-265(exten)24(t)-266(that)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(calculation)-397(is)-410(in)24(v)24(olv)24(ed,)-397(the)-410(searc)24(h)-398(can)-397(b)-24(e)-421(limited{when)-409(w)24(e)-409(are)-398(calculating,)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(w)24(e)-409(\\kno)24(w)-409(what)-409(w)24(e)-421(are)-398(doing".)-409(But)-422(the)-422(logical)-397(comp)-23(onen)24(t)-422(of)-410(mathematics)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(in)24(v)24(olv)24(es,)-325(ev)24(en)-337(in)24(tuitiv)23(ely)85(,)-349(a)-337(searc)23(h.)-337(W)85(e)-349(\\\fnd")-338(pro)-24(ofs,)-338(w)24(e)-337(do)-349(not)-337(\\construct")]TJ
(them.)'
1.50563 -1.22859 TD
[(This)-422(searc)24(h)-422(app)-24(ears)-410(to)-434(b)-24(e)-445(fundamen)24(tally)-422(infeasible.)-434(Let)-434(us)-434(see)-434(wh)25(y)-422(b)24(y)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(considering)-326(a)-325(straigh)23(tforw)24(ard)-302(\\breadth-\frst)-328(searc)24(h",)-313(as)-325(a)-325(computer)-338(scien)24(tist)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(w)24(ould)-325(call)-325(it.)-337(Supp)-25(ose)-325(w)24(e)-325(start)-327(with)-337(just)-326(3)-326(axioms)-325(and)-325(one)-325(rule)-326(of)-325(inference.)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(The)-397(three)-398(axioms)-386(w)25(e)-397(call)-385(\\lev)24(el)-385(0".)-397(Lev)24(el)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
18.82633 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.86724 0 Td
[(+)-265(1)-385(is)-398(the)-410(set)-398(of)-398(form)24(ulas)-386(that)]TJ
-19.69357 -1.2045 TD
[(can)-373(b)-24(e)-385(deduced)-385(in)-386(one)-373(step)-386(from)-374(form)24(ulas)-362(of)-385(lev)24(el)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
22.52415 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.97565 0 Td
[(or)-374(less,)-374(at)-386(least)-374(one)-373(of)]TJ
-23.49979 -1.19245 TD
[(whic)25(h)-338(has)-337(lev)24(el)-337(exactly)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
10.40688 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
[(.)-337(The)-337(\\lev)25(el)-337(saturation)-327(strategy")-315(is)-337(to)-338(generate)-337(the)]TJ
-11.00913 -1.2045 TD
[(lev)24(els,)-361(one)-373(b)24(y)-361(one,)-374(b)24(y)-361(applying)-361(the)-374(inference)-373(rule)-373(to)-362(all)-373(pairs)-363(of)-361(form)23(ulas)-361(of)]TJ
T*
[(lo)24(w)25(er)-350(lev)25(els.)-374(It)-374(is)-374(di\016cult)-386(to)-362(coun)25(t)-374(the)-374(size)-373(of)-373(the)-374(lev)24(els)-361(exactly)-373(b)-24(ecause)-361(w)24(e)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(cannot)-301(tell)-326(in)-313(adv)60(ance)-300(ho)24(w)-301(man)24(y)-301(pairs)-302(of)-313(form)23(ulas)-301(can)-301(function)-325(as)-302(premisses)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(of)-397(the)-398(inference)-385(rule.)-386(But)-397(for)-398(a)-386(w)25(orst-case)-363(estimate,)-398(if)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
24.31885 0 Td
(L)Tj
/F15 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 383.88 234.6 Tm
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 393.12 236.04 Tm
[(is)-398(the)-398(n)24(um)24(b)-24(er)-385(of)]TJ
-25.93288 -1.19245 TD
[(form)23(ulas)-337(in)-362(lev)25(el)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
7.5763 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.95156 0 Td
[(or)-338(less,)-350(w)25(e)-349(w)24(ould)-349(ha)24(v)24(e)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
10.14189 0 Td
(L)Tj
/F15 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 327.6 222.72 Tm
(n)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.70549 0 Td
(+1)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 346.2 224.16 Tm
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.09609 0 Td
(L)Tj
/F15 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 363.96 222.72 Tm
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 371.64 224.16 Tm
(+)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.01178 0 Td
(L)Tj
/F15 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 388.56 222.72 Tm
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 393.96 224.16 Tm
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(L)Tj
/F15 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 404.64 222.72 Tm
(n)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 412.44 224.16 Tm
<00>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.01178 0 Td
(L)Tj
/F15 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 429.36 222.72 Tm
(n)Tj
/F13 1 Tf
0.7055 0 Td
<00>Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.89477 0 Td
(1)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 444.84 224.16 Tm
[(\).)-362(T)85(o)]TJ
-31.12428 -1.2045 TD
[(mak)24(e)-361(a)-361(ten)24(tativ)23(e)-361(analysis,)-350(assume)-362(that)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
17.50138 0 Td
(L)Tj
/F15 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 315.96 210.72 Tm
(n)Tj
/F13 1 Tf
0.70549 0 Td
<00>Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.89477 0 Td
(1)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 335.28 212.16 Tm
[(can)-361(b)-24(e)-373(neglected)-361(compared)-349(to)]TJ
-20.1272 -1.2045 TD
[(the)-349(m)24(uc)24(h)-325(larger)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
7.25109 0 Td
(L)Tj
/F15 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 213.84 198.72 Tm
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 219.12 200.16 Tm
[(.)-337(Then)-349(the)-338(recursion)-326(is)-337(appro)23(ximately)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
16.863 0 Td
(L)Tj
/F15 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 393.96 198.72 Tm
(n)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.7055 0 Td
(+1)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 412.32 200.16 Tm
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.05996 0 Td
(L)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 429.72 203.76 Tm
(2)Tj
/F15 1 Tf
0 -0.86036 TD
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 435.12 200.16 Tm
[(,)-337(whic)24(h)]TJ
-30.14863 -1.19246 TD
[(is)-374(solv)24(ed)-361(b)24(y)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
5.51661 0 Td
(L)Tj
/F15 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 196.56 186.84 Tm
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 205.44 188.28 Tm
0.337 Tc
(=2)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 221.64 191.88 Tm
0 Tc
(2)Tj
/F18 1 Tf
4.98132 0 0 4.98132 225.6 194.88 Tm
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 231 188.28 Tm
[(.)-373(When)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
3.60145 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.95156 0 Td
-0.024 Tc
[(=)-361(7)-385(we)-397(h)-24(ave)-385(2)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 339.72 191.88 Tm
0 Tc
(128)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 352.08 188.28 Tm
[(,)-373(a)-362(n)24(um)24(b)-24(er)-373(that)-375(compares)]TJ
-21.81349 -1.2045 TD
[(with)-338(the)-337(n)24(um)24(b)-24(er)-338(of)-325(electrons)-325(in)-338(the)-337(univ)24(erse)-326(\(said)-338(to)-326(b)-24(e)-337(10)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 391.8 179.88 Tm
(44)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 400.2 176.28 Tm
[(\).)-338(Y)85(et)-338(pro)-24(ofs)-326(of)]TJ
-26.64354 -1.2045 TD
[(lev)24(el)-337(30)-337(are)-337(often)-349(found)-362(b)24(y)-337(Otter)-350(\(according)-326(to)-349([109],)-337(p.)-350(225\).)-337(Of)-350(course,)-325(w)24(e)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(ha)24(v)24(e)-409(giv)24(en)-409(a)-409(w)24(orst-case)-387(estimate,)-422(but)-422(in)-422(practice,)-409(lev)24(el)-409(saturation)-411(is)-423(not)-409(a)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(feasible)-325(w)24(a)24(y)-325(to)-325(organize)-313(pro)-25(of)-325(searc)24(h.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
42 0 obj
<<
/Length 6705
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 134.76 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(40)-2662(Mic)26(hael)-361(Beeson)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 149.76 666.2401 Tm
[(In)24(tuitiv)23(ely)84(,)-349(the)-361(di\016cult)23(y)-361(with)-362(lev)25(el)-337(saturation)-351(is)-350(this:)-363(what)-349(w)24(e)-348(are)-338(doing)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(with)-265(lev)24(el)-252(saturation)-255(\(whether)-266(or)-253(not)-253(the)-278(negation)-240(of)-265(the)-266(conclusion)-252(is)-266(thro)23(wn)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
[(in\))-374(is)-362(dev)25(eloping)-361(the)-362(en)24(tire)-362(theory)-361(from)-362(the)-374(axioms.)-350(Naturally)-362(there)-361(will)-362(b)-24(e)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(man)24(y)-397(conclusions)-386(that)-411(are)-385(irrelev)60(an)24(t)-386(to)-398(the)-409(desired)-398(one.)-398(Whole)-397(b)-24(o)-24(oks)-398(ma)25(y)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(exist)-338(\flled)-337(with)-338(in)24(teresting)-326(deductions)-338(from)-337(these)-326(axioms)-326(that)-338(are)-325(irrelev)60(an)24(t)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(to)-24(da)24(y)-277(in)-302(spite)-289(of)-289(b)-25(eing)-288(in)24(teresting)-279(on)-289(another)-277(da)24(y)84(,)-289(and)-289(there)-277(will)-301(of)-289(course)-266(b)-24(e)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(ev)24(en)-325(more)-325(unin)24(teresting)-326(conclusions.)-326(What)-338(w)25(e)-325(need,)-337(then,)-337(are)-314(tec)25(hniques)-338(to)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
0.69861 -1.93925 TD
<0F>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
[(prev)24(en)24(t)-325(the)-338(generation)-313(of)-337(un)24(w)24(an)24(ted)-313(deduced)-337(clauses,)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
-0.99974 -1.18041 TD
<0F>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
[(discard)-338(un)24(w)24(an)25(ted)-350(clauses)-338(b)-24(efore)-349(they)-361(are)-338(used)-349(to)-350(generate)-337(y)24(et)-349(more)-350(un-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(w)24(an)25(ted)-326(clauses,)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
-0.99974 -1.18041 TD
<0F>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
[(generate)-313(useful)-338(clauses)-325(so)-25(oner,)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
-0.99974 -1.19245 TD
<0F>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.99974 0 Td
[(use)-337(useful)-338(clauses)-314(so)-24(oner)-325(than)-326(they)-338(w)25(ould)-325(otherwise)-326(b)-24(e)-337(used.)]TJ
-1.69834 -1.95129 TD
[(Metho)-25(ds)-337(directed)-326(to)24(w)24(ards)-314(these)-337(ob)-60(jectiv)24(es)-314(are)-325(called)-324(\\strategies".)]TJ
1.50563 -1.19245 TD
[(In)-302(1962,)-288(when)-313(none)-301(of)-313(the)-313(strategies)-291(kno)24(wn)-301(to)-24(da)24(y)-301(had)-313(y)24(et)-301(b)-24(een)-313(in)24(v)24(en)24(ted,)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(the)-337(follo)24(wing)-325(problem)-338(w)25(as)-326(to)-24(o)-326(di\016cult)-349(for)-338(automated)-326(theorem)-337(pro)23(ving:)-313(In)-337(a)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(group,)-265(if)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
3.92667 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.67452 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.6143 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.8552 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.04791 0 Td
(e)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.74679 0 Td
[(for)-278(ev)25(ery)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.07121 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56612 0 Td
[(,)-277(then)-289(the)-278(group)-265(is)-278(comm)25(utativ)23(e,)-265(i.e.)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
15.93553 0 Td
(z)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.62634 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.61429 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.79497 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.05996 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.63839 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.61429 0 Td
(z)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
-32.78649 -1.2045 TD
[(for)-326(ev)25(ery)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.17961 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.8552 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.95129 0 Td
(z)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.51793 0 Td
[(.)-325(T)84(o)-24(da)25(y)-326(this)-338(is)-326(trivial)-338(\(for)-326(b)-24(oth)-338(h)24(umans)-338(and)-325(computers\).)-339(It)]TJ
-7.50404 -1.2045 TD
[(w)24(as)-373(consideration)-374(of)-386(this)-386(example)-385(that)-387(led)-397(Larry)-362(W)84(os)-386(to)-385(in)24(v)24(en)24(t)-386(the)-385(\\set)-386(of)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(supp)-25(ort")-278(strategy)-266([107],)-277(whic)25(h)-277(is)-290(to)-24(da)24(y)-277(basic)-277(to)-278(the)-289(organization)-253(of)-289(a)-277(mo)-24(dern)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(theorem-pro)23(v)24(er.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(Here)-265(is)-277(an)-265(explanation)-265(of)-277(\(one)-265(v)24(ersion)-266(of)-72(\))-277(this)-279(strategy)83(.)-265(Divide)-276(the)-277(axioms)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.19246 TD
[(in)24(to)-446(t)24(w)24(o)-446(lists,)-447(usable)-446(and)-457(set)-447(of)-445(supp)-25(ort)-459((sos).)-447(Normally)84(,)-446(sos)-434(con)24(tains)-446(the)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(negation)-301(of)-313(the)-314(desired)-301(theorem)-302(\(that)-314(is,)-314(it)-313(con)24(tains)-302(the)-313(\\sp)-25(ecial)-300(h)24(yp)-24(othesis")]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(of)-229(the)-229(theorem)-217(and)-217(the)-241(negation)-205(of)-229(the)-229(conclusion)-216(of)-229(the)-229(theorem\).)-218(The)-228(axioms)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(of)-410(the)-409(theory)-398(go)-398(in)24(to)-409(usable.)-398(T)84(o)-397(generate)-397(new)-409(clauses,)-398(use)-398(resolution)-398(\(or)-398(a)]TJ
T*
[(v)60(arian)24(t)-338(of)-349(resolution\))-351(with)-349(one)-349(paren)24(t)-338(from)-350(sos)-338(and)-349(one)-349(paren)23(t)-337(from)-350(usable.)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(Sp)-24(eci\fcally)85(,)-289(pic)24(k)-289(one)-289(\\giv)25(en)-277(clause")-277(from)-277(sos.)-290(Mo)23(v)25(e)-277(the)-289(giv)24(en)-289(clause)-277(from)-290(sos)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(to)-422(usable.)-422(Then)-433(mak)24(e)-421(all)-422(p)-24(ossible)-422(inferences)-421(using)-423(the)-433(giv)24(en)-421(clause)-410(as)-422(one)]TJ
T*
[(paren)24(t,)-350(with)-374(the)-373(other)-350(paren)24(t)-362(c)25(hosen)-350(from)-362(usable.)-349(Add)-374(the)-373(new)-361(conclusions)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(\(p)-25(ossibly)-446(after)-447(some)-433(p)-24(ost-pro)-26(cessing\))-434(to)-446(the)-446(sos)-447(list.)-446(Con)24(tin)24(ue,)-446(c)25(ho)-25(osing)-421(a)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(new)-337(giv)24(en)-324(clause,)-338(un)24(til)-337(the)-350(set)-338(of)-337(supp)-25(ort)-338(b)-24(ecomes)-325(empt)24(y)-337(or)-338(a)-325(con)25(tradiction)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(is)-338(deriv)24(ed.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(The)-361(follo)24(wing)-349(fragmen)24(t)-362(of)-361(an)-361(Otter)-363(input)-386(\fle)-361(illustrate)-363(the)-373(c)24(hoice)-349(of)-373(sos)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(and)-337(usable)-326(in)-337(the)-338(example)-324(men)24(tioned)-337(ab)-24(o)24(v)24(e.)-325(\(Here)]TJ
/F19 1 Tf
22.54824 0 Td
(f)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.86724 0 Td
[(means)-325(the)-338(group)-325(op)-25(er-)]TJ
-23.41548 -1.19245 TD
[(ation,)-326(and)]TJ
/F19 1 Tf
4.78186 0 Td
(g)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.8552 0 Td
[(is)-326(the)-337(in)24(v)24(erse.\))]TJ
/F19 1 Tf
-5.63706 -2.13196 TD
(list(usable).)Tj
0 -1.2045 TD
[(x)-518(=)-518(x.)-11539(\\%)-518(equality)]TJ
T*
[(f(e,x))-494(=)-518(x.)-8913(\\%)-518(identity)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(f(g(x),x))-482(=)-518(e.)-7335(\\%)-518(inverse)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(f(f(x,y),z))-470(=)-517(f(x,f(y,z)).)-988(\\%associativity)]TJ
(end_of_list.)'
0 -2.39696 TD
(list(sos).)Tj
ET
endstream
endobj
43 0 obj
<<
/Length 7089
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 290.52 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(The)-335(Mec)27(hanization)-361(of)-361(Mathematics)-2674(41)]TJ
/F19 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(f(x,x))-494(=)-518(e.)-8395(\\%)-518(special)-482(hypothesis)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(f(a,b))-494(!=)-518(f(b,a).)-5215(\\%)-518(Denial)-494(of)-505(conclusion)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
(end_of_list.)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0 -2.3006 TD
[(Otter)-374(\fnds)-374(a)-362(6-step)-362(pro)-24(of,)-374(of)-361(lev)24(el)-373(4,)-361(for)-374(this)-374(problem.)-362(W)84(os,)-373(George)-349(Robin-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(son,)-470(and)-470(Carson)-458(pro)23(v)25(ed)-446(\(ac)24(kno)24(wledging)-457(in)24(v)61(aluable)-458(assistance)-459(from)-470(J.)-940(A.)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(Robinson\))-374([107])-361(that)-386(the)-386(appropriate)-350(use)-374(of)-385(this)-375(strategy)-375(still)-374(preserv)23(es)-361(the)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(refutation-completeness)-279(prop)-24(ert)23(y;)-289(that)-302(is,)-289(if)-302(there)-301(exists)-290(a)-289(pro)-25(of)-289(of)-301(con)24(tradic-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(tion)-410(from)-410(the)-410(form)24(ulas)-398(in)-410(usable)-410(and)-409(sos)-399(together,)-398(then)-421(in)-410(principle)-410(it)-410(can)]TJ
T*
[(b)-24(e)-409(found)-410(b)24(y)-410(this)-410(strategy)83(,)-386(if)-409(w)24(e)-397(do)-410(not)-409(run)-399(out)-410(of)-397(space)-397(or)-398(time)-410(\frst.)-411(The)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(h)24(yp)-24(othesis)-411(of)-409(this)-411(theorem)-398(is)-410(that)-410(the)-422(usable)-397(list)-423(m)24(ust)-411(itself)-410(b)-24(e)-421(satis\fable,)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(i.e.)-301(not)-301(con)24(tain)-302(a)-288(con)24(tradiction.)-290(That)-301(will)-313(normally)-290(b)-24(e)-301(so)-289(b)-24(ecause)-301(w)24(e)-300(put)-314(the)]TJ
T*
[(denial)-325(of)-337(the)-338(conclusion)-325(in)24(to)-325(sos.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.21654 TD
[(Another)-458(w)24(a)24(y)-433(of)-458(trying)-458(to)-459(generate)-445(useful)-458(form)23(ulas)-446(so)-24(oner,)-446(or)-446(to)-458(a)24(v)24(oid)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(generating)-265(useless)-278(form)23(ulas,)-265(is)-290(to)-277(in)24(v)24(en)24(t)-277(and)-277(use)-289(new)-277(rules)-278(of)-277(inference.)-288(Quite)]TJ
T*
[(a)-494(n)24(um)24(b)-24(er)-494(of)-494(v)60(ariations)-471(of)-493(resolution)-483(ha)24(v)24(e)-481(b)-25(een)-505(in)24(tro)-25(duced)-493(and)-494(sho)24(wn)-482(to)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(b)-24(e)-361(useful,)-350(and)-361(v)60(arious)-338(theorems)-338(ha)24(v)24(e)-337(b)-24(een)-361(pro)24(v)24(ed)-337(ab)-24(out)-350(whether)-349(refutation)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(completeness)-458(is)-458(preserv)23(ed)-445(using)-459(v)61(arious)-447(com)25(binations)-447(of)-470(the)-470(rules.)-446(F)84(or)-458(an)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(o)24(v)24(erview)-324(of)-362(these)-349(matters,)-351(see)-349([109].)-349(F)83(or)-337(additional)-350(details)-362(and)-349(man)24(y)-350(exam-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(ples,)-338(see)-337([108].)-313(No)25(w)24(ada)24(ys,)-313(the)-350(user)-326(of)-337(a)-337(theorem-pro)23(v)24(er)-301(can)-325(t)24(ypically)-337(sp)-25(ecify)]TJ
T*
[(the)-362(inference)-348(rules)-338(to)-350(b)-24(e)-361(used)-350(on)-349(a)-349(particular)-338(problem,)-350(and)-349(ma)24(y)-338(try)-350(v)60(arious)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(c)24(hoices;)-373(while)-397(there)-386(ma)25(y)-374(b)-24(e)-397(a)-385(default)-398(selection)-386(\(Otter)-386(has)-386(an)-386(\\autonomous)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(mo)-24(de"\),)-337(exp)-24(ertise)-326(in)-338(the)-337(selection)-325(of)-325(inference)-337(rules)-326(is)-326(often)-337(helpful.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.22859 TD
[(Another)-374(common)-373(w)24(a)25(y)-362(of)-385(trying)-374(to)-374(generate)-373(useful)-386(form)23(ulas)-362(so)-24(oner)-374(is)-373(to)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.19245 TD
[(simply)-386(thro)23(w)-361(out)-386(\\useless")-350(form)24(ulas)-362(as)-374(so)-24(on)-374(as)-374(they)-373(are)-373(generated,)-362(instead)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(of)-361(putting)-363(them)-361(in)-362(sos)-350(for)-350(further)-350(pro)-25(cessing.)-338(F)84(or)-361(example,)-349(if)-362(a)-349(form)24(ula)-350(is)-349(a)]TJ
T*
[(substitution)-328(instance)-325(of)-326(a)-313(form)24(ula)-313(already)-301(pro)23(v)24(ed,)-313(there)-313(is)-326(no)-325(use)-313(k)24(eeping)-313(it.)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(If)-350(y)24(ou)-349(feel)-349(\(or)-338(hop)-24(e\))-361(that)-351(the)-361(pro)-25(of)-337(will)-349(not)-350(require)-337(form)23(ulas)-338(longer)-337(than)-350(20)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(sym)24(b)-25(ols,)-337(wh)24(y)-349(not)-350(thro)23(w)-349(out)-350(longer)-325(form)24(ulas)-338(as)-350(so)-24(on)-337(as)-338(they)-362(are)-337(generated?)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(More)-326(generally)85(,)-325(w)24(e)-337(can)-337(assign)-326(\\w)25(eigh)24(ts")-314(to)-350(form)24(ulas.)-326(The)-336(simplest)-351(\\w)24(eigh)25(t")]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(is)-398(just)-399(the)-397(length)-398(\(total)-386(n)24(um)23(b)-24(er)-397(of)-386(sym)24(b)-24(ols\),)-399(but)-398(more)-385(complex)-385(w)24(eigh)24(tings)]TJ
T*
[(are)-434(p)-24(ossible.)-446(Then)-445(w)24(e)-433(can)-446(sp)-24(ecify)-445(the)-446(maxim)24(um)-446(w)24(eigh)25(t)-434(of)-446(form)24(ulas)-435(to)-434(b)-24(e)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(retained.)-422(Of)-422(course,)-409(doing)-422(so)-410(destro)23(ys)-410(refutation)-422(completeness,)-410(but)-434(it)-435(ma)25(y)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(also)-265(enable)-277(us)-277(to)-278(\fnd)-289(a)-277(pro)-24(of)-277(that)-278(w)24(ould)-277(otherwise)-265(nev)24(er)-265(ha)24(v)24(e)-277(b)-24(een)-276(pro)-25(duced)]TJ
T*
[(in)-410(our)-386(lifetimes.)-422(If)-410(w)25(e)-397(do)-398(not)-398(\fnd)-410(a)-397(pro)-24(of,)-398(w)24(e)-397(can)-397(alw)25(a)24(ys)-386(try)-398(again)-386(with)-409(a)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(larger)-314(maxim)24(um)-325(w)24(eigh)25(t.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.22859 TD
[(The)-469(description)-471(of)-482(the)-470(sos)-470(strategy)-459(ab)-24(o)24(v)24(e)-457(lea)24(v)24(es)-458(sev)24(eral)-457(things)-471(impre-)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.19245 TD
[(cise:)-397(ho)24(w)-397(do)-398(w)25(e)-398(\\select")-385(a)-397(form)23(ula)-397(from)-398(sos)-399(to)-397(b)-25(e)-409(the)-397(next)-410(giv)24(en)-397(form)23(ula?)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(What)-350(is)-337(the)-338(nature)-338(of)-337(the)-349(\\p)-24(ost-pro)-26(cessing"?)-301(These)-337(questions)-338(ha)24(v)24(e)-325(in)24(terest-)]TJ
T*
[(ing)-385(answ)24(ers,)-375(and)-397(the)-386(answ)24(ers)-374(are)-385(not)-386(unique.)-397(There)-386(are)-385(di\013eren)24(t)-386(strategies)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(addressing)-242(these)-253(questions.)-254(Otter)-254(has)-254(man)24(y)-241(user-con)24(trollable)-229(parameters)-243(that)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(in\ruence)-361(these)-349(kinds)-362(of)-350(things.)-362(There)-349(are)-337(so)-350(man)24(y)-349(parameters)-326(that)-363(running)]TJ
T*
[(Otter)-302(is)-302(more)-289(of)-313(an)-301(art)-290(than)-314(a)-301(science.)-288(F)84(or)-302(a)-301(more)-289(detailed)-313(description)-290(of)-313(the)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(basic)-349(algorithm)-351(of)-361(Otter,)-362(see)-349([109],)-349(p.)-362(94,)-349(where)-361(the)-362(program's)-338(main)-350(lo)-24(op)-361(is)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(summarized)-326(on)-325(a)-325(single)-338(page.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
44 0 obj
<<
/Length 9665
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 134.76 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(42)-2662(Mic)26(hael)-361(Beeson)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 149.76 666.2401 Tm
[(It)-266(has)-253(no)24(w)-253(b)-24(een)-276(nearly)-241(fort)23(y)-253(y)24(ears)-253(since)-253(the)-265(in)24(v)24(en)24(tion)-253(of)-265(the)-266(set)-265(of)-265(supp)-25(ort)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(strategy)83(,)-349(and)-374(the)-373(general)-349(approac)24(h)-350(to)-373(theorem)-362(pro)24(ving)-350(describ)-24(ed)-361(ab)-24(o)24(v)24(e)-349(has)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
[(not)-446(c)24(hanged,)-433(nor)-434(has)-434(an)24(y)-434(comp)-23(eting)-446(approac)24(h)-422(met)-446(with)-457(as)-434(m)24(uc)24(h)-446(success.)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(Ov)24(er)-337(that)-350(fort)23(y)-350(y)25(ears,)-326(the)-362(approac)24(h)-325(has)-350(b)-24(een)-361(re\fned)-349(b)24(y)-349(the)-350(dev)25(elopmen)24(t)-349(of)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(man)24(y)-422(in)24(teresting)-422(strategies.)-411(The)-421(skillful)-435(application)-421(of)-422(these)-422(strategies)-411(has)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(led)-349(to)-338(the)-349(solution)-338(of)-350(more)-325(and)-349(more)-338(di\016cult)-349(problems,)-339(some)-337(of)-337(whic)24(h)-349(w)24(ere)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(previously)-386(unsolv)23(ed.)-385(An)-409(impressiv)23(e)-386(list)-398(of)-398(suc)24(h)-397(problems)-386(solv)23(ed)-385(just)-411(in)-409(the)]TJ
T*
[(last)-326(couple)-313(of)-325(y)24(ears)-301(is)-326(giv)24(en)-313(in)-325([41].)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 286.92 586.08 Tm
(34)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 298.44 582.48 Tm
[(These)-325(problems)-314(are)-313(in)-325(highly)-314(tec)25(hnical)]TJ
-16.42938 -1.19245 TD
[(areas,)-326(so)-337(it)-350(is)-338(di\016cult)-350(to)-349(list)-338(and)-350(explain)-337(them)-349(in)-350(a)-337(surv)23(ey)-325(article.)-337(T)84(o)-337(giv)24(e)-324(a)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(taste)-314(of)-325(this)-327(kind)-325(of)-313(researc)24(h,)-302(w)25(e)-313(shall)-314(explain)-313(just)-338(one)-313(of)-313(the)-325(areas)-302(in)24(v)24(olv)24(ed:)]TJ
T*
[(prop)-25(ositional)-386(logic.)-397(Y)85(ou)-398(ma)24(y)-397(think)-410(that)-411(prop)-24(ositional)-386(logic)-385(is)-410(trivial.)-387(After)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(all,)-385(y)24(ou)-386(kno)24(w)-373(ho)24(w)-385(to)-397(decide)-385(the)-398(v)60(alidit)24(y)-385(of)-386(an)24(y)-385(prop)-25(osition)-374(b)24(y)-397(the)-386(metho)-24(d)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(of)-337(truth)-327(tables.)-338(Therefore)-313(it)-338(is)-325(\frst)-339(necessary)-302(to)-337(con)24(vince)-312(y)24(ou)-325(that)-338(this)-339(is)-325(an)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(area)-325(with)-350(in)24(teresting)-338(questions.)-339(W)85(e)-349(write)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
18.36862 0 Td
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.34931 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
[(x;)-169(y)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.54176 0 Td
[(\))-350(for)-338(\\)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
2.78239 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.90337 0 Td
(implies)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
3.40874 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.52998 0 Td
[(",)-337(and)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
3.07148 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56612 0 Td
(\))Tj
-32.89489 -1.2045 TD
[(for)-290(\\not)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
3.73395 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
[(".)-301(Since)-301(\\and")-289(and)-289(\\or")-277(can)-289(b)-24(e)-301(de\fned)-300(in)-301(terms)-303(of)-289(implication)-301(and)]TJ
-4.30007 -1.2045 TD
[(negation,)-422(w)25(e)-421(will)-422(restrict)-423(ourselv)23(es)-397(to)-434(the)-434(connectiv)25(es)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
24.36703 0 Td
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.77088 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
2.0356 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
[(.)-434(The)-421(P)25(olish)]TJ
-27.77577 -1.19246 TD
-0.325 Tw
[(logician)-481(Jan)-518( L)-12(uk)60(asiewicz)-481((1878-1956))-446(in)24(tro)-25(duced)-493(the)-494(follo)24(wing)-482(axioms)-470(for)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
0 Tw
[(prop)-25(ositional)-314(logic:)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
3.09556 -1.75857 TD
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.34931 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.3493 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
[(x;)-169(y)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.54176 0 Td
(\))Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
0.169 Tc
(;i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.79497 0 Td
0 Tc
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.3493 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
0.036 Tc
[(y;)-133(z)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.49358 0 Td
0 Tc
(\))Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
0.169 Tc
(;i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.79497 0 Td
0 Tc
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
[(x;)-169(z)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.52971 0 Td
[(\)\)\))-17864((1))]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
-9.90099 -1.49358 TD
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.34931 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.3493 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
(\))Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
0.169 Tc
(;x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.01178 0 Td
0 Tc
(\))Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
0.169 Tc
(;x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.01178 0 Td
0 Tc
[(\))-22717((2))]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
-5.81774 -1.50562 TD
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.34931 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
[(x;)-169(i)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.36108 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
(\))Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
0.169 Tc
(;y)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.97565 0 Td
0 Tc
[(\)\))-22754((3))]TJ
-8.49173 -1.75857 TD
[(T)85(o)-350(w)25(ork)-338(with)-361(these)-362(axioms)-338(in)-361(Otter,)-350(w)24(e)-349(use)-350(the)-361(predicate)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
25.80039 0 Td
(P)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.78293 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
[(\))-362(to)-361(mean)-350(\\)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
5.1914 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
-32.72626 -1.2045 TD
[(is)-338(pro)24(v)60(able".)-301(W)85(e)-337(then)-350(put)-337(in)24(to)-326(the)-337(usable)-326(list,)]TJ
/F19 1 Tf
0 -1.75857 TD
[(P\(i\(i\(x,y\),i\(i\(y)12(,z\))12(,i)13(\(x,)12(z\))12(\)\))12(\).)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(P\(i\(i\(n\(x\),x\),x\))12(\).)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(P\(i\(x,i\(n\(x\),y\)\))12(\).)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(-P(x))-506(|)-518(-P(i(x,y)))-469(|)-518(P(y).)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
0 -1.75857 TD
[(No)24(w)-373(to)-385(ask,)-374(for)-374(example,)-373(whether)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
15.39351 0 Td
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.34931 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
[(x;)-169(x)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.5779 0 Td
[(\))-386(is)-386(a)-373(theorem,)-374(w)25(e)-386(put)]TJ
/F19 1 Tf
10.33461 0 Td
(-P(i(c,c)))Tj
/F1 1 Tf
-28.04076 -1.2045 TD
[(in)24(to)-374(list(sos).)-376(That)-361(is,)-374(w)24(e)-373(put)-386(in)-373(the)-374(negation)-361(of)-374(the)-373(assertion)-363(that)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
29.81137 0 Td
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.3493 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
[(c;)-168(c)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.3129 0 Td
0.374 Tc
[(\)i)374(s)]TJ
-31.85902 -1.2045 TD
0 Tc
[(pro)24(v)60(able.)-397(The)-409(steps)-411(tak)24(en)-397(b)24(y)-398(resolution)-398(corresp)-25(ond)-398(to)-398(the)-421(rule)-398(of)-410(\\detac)25(h-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(men)24(t")-289(used)-290(b)24(y)-289(logicians:)-265(T)85(o)-289(deduce)-288(a)-289(new)-289(form)24(ula)-277(from)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
24.34295 0 Td
(A)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.03587 0 Td
(and)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.90311 0 Td
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.34931 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
0.048 Tc
[(B;)-121(C)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
2.03561 0 Td
0 Tc
[(\),)-302(mak)25(e)]TJ
-30.05227 -1.2045 TD
[(a)-385(substitution)]TJ
/F12 1 Tf
6.51634 0 Td
<03>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.89133 0 Td
[(so)-374(that)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
3.5051 0 Td
(A)Tj
/F13 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 250.92 270.96 Tm
<03>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 259.2 267.36 Tm
(=)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.15632 0 Td
(B)Tj
/F13 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 278.76 270.96 Tm
<03>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 283.32 267.36 Tm
[(.)-385(Then)-397(y)24(ou)-374(can)-385(deduce)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
10.56347 0 Td
(C)Tj
/F13 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 396.36 270.96 Tm
<03>Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 400.92 267.36 Tm
(.)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 403.68 270.96 Tm
(35)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 416.04 267.36 Tm
[(Wh)24(y)-385(do)-386(w)25(e)]TJ
ET
q
56.76 0 0 -0.48 134.748 260.748 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 253.8 Tm
(34)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 249.96 Tm
[(If)-374(the)-375(non-exp)-28(ert)-360(user)-388(lo)-26(oks)-387(at)-374(the)-374(list)-388(giv)28(en)-389(in)-375([41])-401(of)-387(di\016cult)-375(problems)-387(solv)28(ed)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(using)-321(Otter,)-307(he)-308(or)-320(she)-308(will)-335(v)27(ery)-307(lik)27(ely)-308(not)-307(b)-27(e)-321(able)-322(in)-308(a)-321(straigh)29(tforw)28(ard)-334(manner)-321(to)]TJ
T*
[(get)-240(Otter)-226(to)-227(pro)28(v)27(e)-228(these)-240(theorems.)-239(He)-228(or)-240(she)-228(will)-254(ha)26(v)28(e)-228(to)-240(go)-240(to)-240(the)-228(appropriate)-239(w)27(eb)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(site)-307(and)-295(get)-307(the)-294(input)-282(\fles)-308(prepared)-295(b)27(y)-281(the)-295(exp)-27(erts,)-306(sp)-27(ecifying)-307(the)-295(inference)-308(rules)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(and)-389(parameters)-398(con)26(trolling)-413(the)-388(searc)28(h)-402(strategies.)-425(As)-388(the)-388(authors)-400(state,)-400(they)-388(do)]TJ
T*
[(not)-254(ha)27(v)27(e)-241(a)-267(single)-268(uniform)-267(strategy)-264(that)-254(will)-267(enable)-269(Otter)-239(to)-267(solv)28(e)-254(all)-281(these)-254(di\016cult)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(problems,)-401(and)-402(a)-401(lot)-400(of)-401(h)26(uman)-388(trial)-414(and)-388(error)-413(has)-401(gone)-402(in)27(to)-401(the)-388(construction)-400(of)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(those)-347(input)-336(\fles.)]TJ
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 166.2 Tm
(35)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 162.36 Tm
[(T)80(ec)27(hnically)80(,)-308(since)-308(a)-307(theorem)-293(pro)27(v)27(er)-294(alw)27(a)27(ys)-320(uses)-308(the)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
23.0461 0 Td
[(most)-334(gener)51(al)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
5.91543 0 Td
[(uni\fer,)-296(it)-293(corre-)]TJ
-28.96153 -1.23127 TD
[(sp)-27(onds)-267(to)-267(the)-254(rule)-268(kno)27(wn)-268(as)-267(\\condensed)-269(detac)28(hmen)26(t",)-267(in)-268(whic)26(h)-268(only)-254(most)-279(general)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(substitutions)-347(are)-347(allo)28(w)27(ed.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
45 0 obj
<<
/Length 8514
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 290.52 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(The)-335(Mec)27(hanization)-361(of)-361(Mathematics)-2674(43)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(need)-409(the)-398(predicate)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
8.60013 0 Td
(P)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.78293 0 Td
[(?)-409(Because)-385(w)25(e)-398(are)-397(in)24(terested)-399(in)-409(pro)-25(ofs)-386(from)-398(L1{L3)-386(us-)]TJ
-9.38305 -1.2045 TD
[(ing)-337(condensed)-337(detac)24(hmen)24(t;)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
12.14136 0 Td
(P)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.12018 0 Td
[(is)-338(used)-337(to)-338(force)-337(the)-349(theorem)-326(pro)24(v)24(er)-314(to)-349(imitate)]TJ
-13.26155 -1.20451 TD
[(that)-374(rule.)-374(W)85(e)-373(are)-362(not)-374(just)-386(in)24(terested)-363(in)-373(v)24(erifying)-362(tautologies,)-362(but)-386(in)-373(\fnding)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(pro)-25(ofs)-361(from)-374(the)-386(sp)-25(eci\fc)-372(axioms)-362(L1{L3.)-362(No)25(w,)-361(the)-386(reader)-362(is)-373(in)24(vited)-374(to)-374(try)-374(to)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(pro)24(v)24(e)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
2.66194 0 Td
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.3493 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
[(x;)-169(x)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.57789 0 Td
[(\))-326(from)-289(the)-314(axioms)-289(L1{L3.)-290(This)-301(should)-290(b)-24(e)-313(enough)-288(to)-302(con)25(vince)-301(y)24(ou)]TJ
-4.97459 -1.19245 TD
[(that)-314(the)-313(\feld)-325(is)-302(not)-314(trivial.)-302(Other)-313(axiom)-301(systems)-303(for)-302(prop)-24(ositional)-302(logic)-301(w)24(ere)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
-0.325 Tw
[(giv)24(en)-301(b)24(y)-301(F)84(rege,)-301(b)24(y)-301(Hilb)-24(ert,)-314(and)-301(b)24(y)-349( Luk)60(asievic)24(h.)-301(\(See)-313(the)-313(w)24(onderful)-301(app)-25(endix)]TJ
T*
0 Tw
[(in)-325([83],)-301(where)-313(these)-326(and)-313(man)24(y)-313(other)-302(axiom)-313(systems)-315(are)-301(listed.)-326(The)-324(questions)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(then)-350(arise)-337(ab)-24(out)-350(the)-350(equiv)61(alence)-336(of)-350(these)-349(axiom)-325(systems.)-351(W)84(e)-349(w)25(an)24(t)-338(pro)-25(ofs)-337(of)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(eac)25(h)-350(of)-349(these)-361(axiom)-350(systems)-351(from)-350(eac)25(h)-349(of)-349(the)-362(others.)-350(The)-361(app)-24(endix)-361(of)-350([109])]TJ
T*
[(\(pp.)-338(554-55\))-313(lists)-339(Otter)-326(pro)-25(ofs)-325(of)-338(the)-337(some)-325(of)-338(these)-325(systems)-339(from)-326(L1-L3.)-326(F)84(or)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(example,)-373(the)-385(\frst)-375(axiom)-374(in)-373(F)84(rege's)-374(system)-374(is)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
20.16333 0 Td
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.3493 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
[(x;)-169(n)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.61403 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
[(\)\)\).)-411(Go)-373(ahead,)-361(John)]TJ
-24.45135 -1.2045 TD
[(Henry:)-325(try)-338(to)-326(pro)24(v)24(e)-313(it)-338(from)-326(L1-L3)-326(using)-325(p)-24(encil)-337(and)-325(pap)-25(er.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.337 TD
[(One)-265(t)24(yp)-24(e)-277(of)-277(in)24(teresting)-266(question)-266(studied)-290(b)24(y)-265(logicians)-265(in)-277(the)-277(1930s)-253(through)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(1950s{and)-409(resumed)-447(again)-421(to)-24(da)24(y)-446(with)-446(the)-446(aid)-445(of)-446(automated)-434(reasoning{w)24(as)]TJ
T*
[(this:)-399(giv)25(en)-386(a)-385(theory)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
9.05784 0 Td
(T)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.12018 0 Td
[(de\fned)-397(b)24(y)-398(sev)24(eral)-373(axioms,)-386(can)-385(w)24(e)-385(\fnd)-409(a)-386(\\single)-385(ax-)]TJ
-10.17803 -1.19245 TD
[(iom")-325(for)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
3.97485 0 Td
(T)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.73475 0 Td
[(?)-313(That)-337(is,)-326(a)-325(single)-326(form)24(ula)-313(from)-326(whic)25(h)-338(all)-325(the)-325(axioms)-326(of)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
24.66816 0 Td
(T)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.05996 0 Td
[(can)-313(b)-24(e)]TJ
-30.43771 -1.2045 TD
[(deriv)24(ed.)-265(If)-277(so,)-266(what)-265(is)-277(the)-278(shortest)-255(p)-24(ossible)-265(suc)23(h)-277(axiom?)-264(This)-266(t)24(yp)-24(e)-277(of)-265(question)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(has)-265(b)-25(een)-276(attac)24(k)24(ed)-253(using)-265(Otter)-266(for)-266(a)-265(large)-253(n)24(um)24(b)-24(er)-265(of)-265(di\013eren)24(t)-278(systems,)-266(includ-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(ing)-373(v)60(arious)-350(logics,)-362(group)-349(theories,)-363(and)-373(recen)25(tly)83(,)-361(lattice)-373(theory)83(.)-361(F)84(or)-362(example,)]TJ
T*
[(\\equiv)61(alen)24(tial)-434(calculus")-421(is)-447(the)-445(logical)-421(theory)-435(of)-433(bi-implication)-446(\(if)-447(and)-433(only)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(if)-72(\).)-338(It)-338(can)-325(b)-24(e)-325(represen)23(ted)-313(using)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
13.8397 0 Td
(e)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.46976 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
[(x;)-169(y)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.54176 0 Td
[(\))-326(instead)-326(of)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
5.28775 0 Td
(i)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.34931 0 Td
(\()Tj
/F9 1 Tf
0.38544 0 Td
[(x;)-169(y)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.54176 0 Td
[(\),)-338(and)-325(treated)-326(using)-314(a)]TJ
-23.80092 -1.2045 TD
[(\\pro)24(v)60(abilit)24(y)-229(predicate")]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
10.17802 0 Td
(P)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.03587 0 Td
[(as)-241(ab)-24(o)24(v)24(e.)-241(See)-252([113])-241(for)-241(an)-253(example)-240(of)-253(an)-253(Otter)-242(pro)-24(of)]TJ
-11.21389 -1.2045 TD
[(that)-374(settled)-362(a)-362(long-op)-24(en)-361(question)-362(in)-361(equiv)60(alen)25(tial)-362(calculus,)-361(namely)84(,)-361(whether)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(a)-337(certain)-338(form)24(ula)-325(X)24(CB)-337(is)-337(a)-338(single)-337(axiom)-325(for)-338(this)-350(theory)84(.)-326(This)-349(is)-338(p)-24(erhaps)-338(the)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(most)-326(recen)24(t)-313(example)-313(of)-325(a)-313(theorem)-326(that)-326(has)-313(b)-24(een)-325(pro)24(v)24(ed)-313(for)-314(the)-325(\frst)-327(time)-325(b)24(y)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(a)-301(computer.)-302(Before)-300(it)-314(w)25(as)-290(pro)24(v)24(ed)-289(\(in)-314(April,)-313(2002\),)-289(p)-25(eople)-312(w)24(ere)-289(not)-313(willing)-301(to)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(giv)24(e)-325(o)-24(dds)-326(either)-337(w)24(a)24(y)-313(on)-325(the)-337(question.)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
11.95517 0 0 11.95517 134.76 303 Tm
[(14)-1124(Pro)-30(ofs)-382(In)31(v)29(olving)-382(Sets,)-371(F)91(unctions,)-382(and)-393(Num)29(b)-30(ers)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 271.92 Tm
[(If)-482(w)24(e)-469(examine)-457(a)-470(textb)-25(o)-24(ok)-469(for)-471(an)-469(in)24(tro)-25(ductory)-459(course)-458(in)-469(abstract)-472(algebra,)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(suc)24(h)-446(as)-446([56],)-445(w)24(e)-445(\fnd)-446(that)-459(only)-445(ab)-25(out)-458(ten)-445(p)-25(ercen)25(t)-458(of)-446(the)-458(problems)-434(can)-446(b)-24(e)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(form)23(ulated)-301(in)-325(the)-313(\frst-order)-292(languages)-289(of)-325(groups,)-290(rings,)-302(etc.)-325(The)-313(rest)-302(in)24(v)24(olv)24(e)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(subgroups,)-242(subrings,)-255(homomorphisms,)-243(and/or)-241(natural)-254(n)24(um)24(b)-24(ers.)-253(F)83(or)-253(example,)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(one)-481(of)-494(the)-494(\frst)-496(theorems)-482(in)-494(group)-482(theory)-483(is)-494(Lagrange's)-458(theorem:)-483(if)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
31.20859 0 Td
(H)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.40927 0 Td
(is)Tj
-32.61786 -1.2045 TD
[(a)-494(subgroup)-471(of)-493(a)-494(\fnite)-494(group)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
13.50244 0 Td
(G)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.78292 0 Td
[(,)-494(then)-494(the)-506(order)-470(of)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
9.16625 0 Td
(H)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.40927 0 Td
[(\(the)-494(n)24(um)23(b)-24(er)-494(of)-494(its)]TJ
-24.86088 -1.2045 TD
[(elemen)25(ts\))-291(divides)-277(the)-289(order)-266(of)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
13.08087 0 Td
(G)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.78292 0 Td
[(.)-289(Here)-277(w)25(e)-277(need)-289(natural)-265(n)24(um)23(b)-24(ers)-277(to)-290(de\fne)-288(the)]TJ
-13.86379 -1.19246 TD
[(order,)-278(and)-277(a)-289(bit)-289(of)-289(n)24(um)24(b)-25(er)-289(theory)-277(to)-290(de\fne)-288(\\divides";)-278(w)25(e)-289(need)-289(the)-289(concept)-288(of)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(subgroup,)-266(and)-277(the)-289(pro)-25(of)-265(in)24(v)24(olv)24(es)-253(constructing)-278(a)-265(function)-289(to)-278(put)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
27.65532 0 Td
(H)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.19246 0 Td
[(in)-277(one-one)]TJ
-28.84777 -1.2045 TD
[(corresp)-25(ondence)-288(with)-313(the)-314(coset)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
13.39404 0 Td
0.084 Tc
(Ha)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.4454 0 Td
0 Tc
[(,)-301(namely)84(,)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.22779 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F12 1 Tf
0.84315 0 Td
(7!)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.27677 0 Td
(xa)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.09609 0 Td
[(.)-313(A)24(t)-314(presen)24(t,)-301(no)-314(theorem-)]TJ
-22.28325 -1.19245 TD
[(pro)24(ving)-458(program)-459(has)-482(ev)25(er)-470(generated)-470(a)-470(pro)-24(of)-482(of)-470(Lagrange's)-458(theorem,)-470(ev)24(en)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(though)-398(the)-410(pro)-24(of)-398(is)-398(v)24(ery)-397(short)-387(and)-410(simple.)-397(The)-409(obstacle)-398(is)-398(the)-410(mingling)-397(of)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
46 0 obj
<<
/Length 8060
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 134.76 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(44)-2662(Mic)26(hael)-361(Beeson)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(elemen)25(ts,)-387(subgroups,)-362(mappings,)-374(and)-386(natural)-374(n)24(um)24(b)-24(ers.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 372.36 669.84 Tm
(36)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 384.48 666.2401 Tm
[(The)-385(presen)24(t)-374(p)-24(o)24(w)24(er)]TJ
-25.06565 -1.2045 TD
[(of)-373(automated)-374(theorem)-362(pro)24(v)24(ers)-350(has)-374(yielded)-373(results)-363(only)-373(in)-374(theories)-374(based)-361(on)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
[(equalit)24(y)-349(and)-350(a)-349(few)-361(op)-24(erations)-338(or)-338(in)-361(other)-350(v)24(ery)-337(simple)-350(theories.)-350(A)24(t)-361(least)-350(half)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(of)-385(undergraduate)-375(mathematics)-386(should)-386(come)-385(within)-397(the)-398(scop)-24(e)-385(of)-386(automated)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(pro)-25(of)-240(generation,)-241(if)-254(w)25(e)-253(are)-241(able)-252(to)-242(add)-253(in)-253(a)-252(relativ)23(ely)-240(small)-242(abilit)24(y)-253(to)-254(deal)-240(with)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(sets,)-375(n)25(um)23(b)-24(ers,)-374(and)-385(functions.)-387(W)85(e)-385(do)-374(not)-373((usually))-387(need)-373(sets)-387(of)-373(sets,)-387(or)-361(sets)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(of)-385(sets)-387(of)-385(sets,)-387(and)-385(the)-386(lik)24(e.)-385(Nor)-374(do)-385(w)24(e)-373(usually)-386(need)-385(functions)-398(of)-385(functions,)]TJ
T*
[(except)-277(sp)-24(ecial)-276(functions)-290(of)-277(functions)-290(lik)24(e)-277(the)-277(deriv)60(ativ)23(e)-276(op)-24(erator.)-254(If)-290(w)25(e)-277(add)-277(to)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(a)-313(\frst-order)-304(theory)-301(some)-313(v)60(ariables)-302(for)-314(sets)-314(\(of)-326(the)-325(ob)-60(jects)-314(of)-313(the)-325(theory\))-314(and)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(functions)-290(\(from)-290(ob)-60(jects)-290(to)-277(ob)-60(jects\),)-290(w)24(e)-289(ha)25(v)24(e)-277(what)-277(is)-290(kno)24(wn)-276(as)-290(a)-277(second-order)]TJ
T*
[(theory)84(.)-289(The)-301(lam)24(b)-24(da-calculus)-289(can)-301(b)-24(e)-301(used)-301(to)-302(de\fne)-300(functions,)-302(and)-302(sets)-302(can)-289(b)-24(e)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(regarded)-265(as)-278(Bo)-23(olean-v)60(alued)-277(functions.)-290(The)-288(author's)-278(curren)23(t)-277(researc)23(h)-265(in)24(v)24(olv)25(es)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(adding)-241(capabilities)-241(to)-253(the)-254(existing,)-241(widely-used)-241(theorem)-241(pro)23(v)25(er)-229(Otter)-242(to)-254(assist)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(it)-398(in)-410(handling)-385(second-order)-374(theories,)-386(without)-399(in)24(terfering)-386(with)-410(its)-398(\frst-order)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
(capabilities.)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 186.36 502.44 Tm
(37)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 198.36 498.84 Tm
[(Sp)-24(eci\fcally)85(,)-349(a)-362(new)-348(second-order)-326(uni\fcation)-362(algorithm)-350([14,15],)]TJ
-6.38385 -1.2045 TD
[(has)-470(b)-24(een)-470(added)-469(to)-470(Otter,)-471(and)-470(will)-481(b)-24(e)-470(impro)24(v)24(ed)-458(and)-469(applied.)-482(Preliminary)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(results,)-327(and)-337(the)-338(direction)-325(of)-325(the)-338(researc)24(h)-313(program,)-302(are)-326(describ)-24(ed)-325(in)-337([16].)]TJ
1.50563 -1.26472 TD
[(One)-301(ma)24(y)-289(ob)-60(ject)-313(to)-301(the)-314(use)-301(of)-301(second-order)-278(logic,)-301(and)-301(indeed)-313(to)-301(the)-313(whole)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(idea)-349(of)-361(a)-350(\\taxonom)24(y")-325(of)-361(mathematics,)-350(on)-361(the)-362(grounds)-338(of)-362(the)-361(univ)24(ersalit)23(y)-337(of)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(set)-290(theory)84(.)-277(Let)-289(us)-290(b)-24(egin)-289(b)24(y)-289(stating)-278(the)-302(ob)-60(jection)-277(clearly)85(.)-277(Set)-290(theory)-277(is)-290(a)-289(\\sim-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(ple)-301(theory",)-277(with)-302(one)-288(relation)-290(sym)23(b)-24(ol)-289(for)-289(mem)24(b)-24(ership)-302(and)-289(a)-289(small)-302(n)24(um)24(b)-24(er)-289(of)]TJ
T*
[(axioms.)-253(T)84(rue,)-253(one)-265(of)-253(the)-277(\\axioms")-229(of)-265(ZF)-265(set)-266(theory)-254(is)-253(an)-265(in\fnite)-265(sc)24(hema,)-253(with)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(one)-337(instance)-337(for)-326(eac)25(h)-326(form)24(ula)-337(of)-338(the)-337(language;)-313(but)-350(there)-337(is)-338(another)-326(form)24(ula-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(tion)-374(of)-361(set)-362(theory)84(,)-362<477F>506(odel{Berna)25(ys)-338(set)-362(theory)-361((GB),)-374(whic)24(h)-361(has)-362(a)-361(small)-362(\fnite)]TJ
T*
[(n)24(um)24(b)-24(er)-265(of)-265(axioms.)-254(In)-265(GB,)-265(v)60(ariables)-253(range)-241(o)24(v)24(er)-253(classes,)-253(and)-253(sets)-266(are)-253(de\fned)-277(as)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(classes)-326(whic)25(h)-338(b)-24(elong)-337(to)-337(some)-338(other)-337(class.)-326(\(The)-349(idea)-337(is)-338(that)-338(prop)-25(erties)-338(de\fne)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(classes,)-386(but)-410(not)-410(ev)24(ery)-385(class)-386(is)-410(a)-398(set|w)24(e)-397(escap)-24(e)-397(the)-410(Russell)-398(parado)24(x)-373(in)-410(GB)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(b)-24(ecause)-313(the)-337(Russell)-314(class)-314(is)-325(a)-313(class,)-314(but)-326(not)-326(a)-313(set.\))-338(Because)-300(of)-325(the)-326(p)-24(ossibilit)23(y)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(of)-313(form)23(ulating)-301(set)-314(theory)-314(in)-313(this)-314(w)24(a)24(y)-301(as)-301(a)-313(simple)-314(theory)84(,)-313(the)-314(taxonom)24(y)-301(giv)24(en)]TJ
T*
[(ab)-24(o)24(v)24(e)-313(collapses{all)-301(of)-325(mathematics)-326(is)-338(con)25(tained)-314(in)-337(a)-325(single)-313(simple)-338(\frst-order)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(theory)84(.)-386(No)25(w)-397(for)-386(some)-398(relev)60(an)24(t)-385(history:)-387(a)-398(cen)25(tury)-386(ago,)-385(this)-399(program)-374(for)-398(the)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(foundations)-242(of)-241(mathematics)-242(w)25(as)-229(laid)-241(out,)-242(but)-253(in)-253(the)-241(middle)-253(t)23(w)25(en)24(tieth)-241(cen)24(tury)84(,)]TJ
T*
[(the)-398(Bourbaki)-361(sc)24(ho)-24(ol)-374(prev)61(ailed,)-386(at)-385(least)-386(in)-386(practice,)-385(organizing)-362(mathematics)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(according)-361(to)-386(the)-385(\\man)24(y)-374(small)-374(theories")-374(program.)-350(A)25(t)-386(presen)23(t,)-386(most)-374(w)24(ork)-373(in)]TJ
ET
q
56.76 0 0 -0.48 134.748 260.748 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 253.8 Tm
(36)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 249.96 Tm
[(A)-375(pro)-26(of)-388(of)-401(Lagrange's)-399(theorem)-387(dev)26(elop)-27(ed)-375(b)27(y)-375(a)-374(h)26(uman)-375(has)-387(b)-28(een)-375(c)27(hec)26(k)27(ed)-375(b)26(y)-361(the)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(computer)-427(program)-440(A)27(CL2,)-442(see)-441([116].)-454(That)-441(pro)-27(of)-441(is)-441(not)-428(the)-428(ordinary)-427(pro)-26(of,)-455(but)]TJ
T*
[(instead)-307(pro)-27(ceeds)-308(b)27(y)-281(mathematical)-332(induction)-296(on)-294(the)-308(order)-294(of)-320(the)-295(group.)-307(The)-308(ordi-)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(nary)-347(pro)-27(of)-360(has)-361(b)-27(een)-349(pro)-26(of-c)27(hec)26(k)27(ed)-361(using)-349(HOL)-348([58].)-374(That)-361(pap)-27(er)-361(also)-360(presen)26(ts)-360(an)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(in)26(teresting)-373(\\theory)-373(hierarc)28(h)26(y")-361(sho)28(wing)-389(exactly)-360(what)-374(is)-388(needed.)-363(It)-360(has)-374(also)-387(b)-27(een)]TJ
T*
[(c)27(hec)26(k)27(ed)-322(in)-348(Mizar)-361([99].)]TJ
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 188.04 Tm
(37)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 184.2 Tm
[(Of)-375(course,)-387(second-order)-374(and)-375(\(wh)27(y)-361(not?\))-374(higher-order)-387(theorem)-374(pro)28(ving)-375(has)-374(b)-27(een)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(in)-308(existence)-321(for)-320(a)-321(long)-321(time,)-320(and)-322(there)-307(are)-320(ev)27(en)-309(whole)-321(conferences)-334(dev)26(oted)-294(to)-320(the)]TJ
T*
[(sub)-54(ject,)-428(e.g.)-428(TPHOL)-429(\(Theorem)-427(Pro)28(ving)-415(in)-428(Higher-Order)-401(Logic\).)-441(It)-414(seems)-427(that)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(most)-306(of)-320(this)-321(researc)28(h)-308(is)-321(not)-307(directed)-308(to)28(w)26(ards)-320(pro)27(ving)-307(new)-309(theorems,)-319(so)-320(it)-308(has)-320(not)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(b)-27(een)-335(discussed)-348(in)-349(this)-347(pap)-28(er.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
47 0 obj
<<
/Length 7601
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 290.52 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(The)-335(Mec)27(hanization)-361(of)-361(Mathematics)-2674(45)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(automated)-434(deduction)-458(is)-434(based)-446(on)-445(the)-446(\\small)-434(theories")-422(approac)24(h,)-434(although)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(one)-397(bra)24(v)24(e)-373(man,)-398(Belinfan)25(te,)-398(has)-398(b)-24(een)-397(pro)-25(ceeding)-384(for)-398(man)24(y)-385(y)24(ears)-386(to)-398(dev)24(elop)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
[(computerized)-253(pro)-24(ofs)-254(based)-253(on)-253(GB)-264(set)-266(theory)-241([17,18].)-241(F)84(ollo)24(wing)-252(this)-266(approac)24(h,)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(he)-409(has)-398(enabled)-397(Otter)-411(to)-397(pro)23(v)24(e)-385(more)-397(than)-410(1000)-373(theorems)-399(in)-409(set)-410(theory{but)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(he)-409(still)-411(is)-410(not)-410(up)-409(to)-410(Lagrange's)-374(theorem,)-398(or)-398(ev)24(en)-409(close.)-397(Belinfan)24(te)-409(built)-410(on)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(the)-434(pioneering)-409(w)24(ork)-398(of)-421(Quaife)-422([94].)-421(Finally:)-422(the)-422(answ)24(er)-410(to)-421(the)-422(ob)-60(jection)-422(is)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(simply)-374(that)-386(it)-374(is)-374(to)-25(o)-373(complex)-373(to)-373(regard)-350(n)24(um)24(b)-24(ers)-374(and)-374(functions)-374(as)-374(built)-386(out)]TJ
T*
[(of)-373(sets.)-363(No)-373(mathematician)-362(do)-24(es)-373(so)-362(in)-373(ev)24(eryda)24(y)-349(practice,)-362(and)-361(neither)-374(should)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(automated)-326(deduction)-337(when)-337(the)-337(aim)-325(is)-338(to)-326(someda)24(y)-313(pro)24(v)24(e)-313(new)-337(theorems.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 445.32 574.2 Tm
(38)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 149.76 558.2401 Tm
[(On)-277(the)-289(other)-278(hand,)-277(one)-277(ma)24(y)-277(tak)24(e)-277(the)-277(opp)-24(osite)-289(view)-277(and)-277(sa)24(y)-265(that,)-290(b)-24(ecause)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.19245 TD
[(of)-265(the)-265(di\016culties)-278(of)-265(dev)25(eloping)-253(mathematics)-266(within)-265(set)-266(theory)84(,)-265(one)-253(should)-265(use)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(\\higher-order)-254(logic".)-276(This)-290(has)-277(b)-24(een)-289(the)-301(view)-289(of)-277(man)24(y)-289(of)-289(the)-289(\\pro)-24(of-c)24(hec)24(king")]TJ
T*
[(pro)-61(jects,)-458(and)-458(they)-469(ha)24(v)24(e)-446(b)-24(een)-469(successful)-458(in)-470(c)24(hec)25(king)-446(pro)-24(ofs)-458(of)-470(man)24(y)-446(fairly)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(complicated)-289(theorems.)-302(A)-300(prop)-25(er)-277(review)-289(of)-301(this)-302(w)24(ork)-289(w)24(ould)-289(double)-301(the)-301(length)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(of)-361(this)-363(article,)-361(so)-350(w)24(e)-361(m)24(ust)-362(forego)-349(it.)-362(The)-361(in)24(terested)-362(reader)-350(can)-349(consult)-362([105])]TJ
T*
[(for)-362(a)-373(list)-375(of)-373(\ffteen)-373(pro)-25(of)-361(c)24(hec)25(k)24(ers)-350(and)-373(pro)-25(of)-361(\fnders,)-363(as)-373(w)24(ell)-361(as)-362(references)-361(to)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(further)-339(information.)]TJ
/F6 1 Tf
11.95517 0 0 11.95517 134.76 441 Tm
[(15)-1124(Conclusion)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 415.44 Tm
[(Alan)-470(T)85(uring)-446(wrote)-458(a)-458(seminal)-458(pap)-24(er)-458([101])-445(in)-470(whic)25(h)-470(he)-458(raised)-446(the)-470(question)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(\\Can)-361(mac)25(hines)-362(think?".)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 239.88 407.04 Tm
(39)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 252.12 403.44 Tm
[(After)-374(discussing)-363(v)61(arious)-363(examples,)-361(suc)24(h)-361(as)-374(c)24(hess,)]TJ
-11.78001 -1.2045 TD
[(m)24(usical)-362(comp)-23(osition,)-363(and)-361(theorem)-350(pro)24(ving,)-349(he)-373(then)-374(form)23(ulated)-349(the)-374(\\T)85(uring)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(test")-290(as)-277(a)-289(replacemen)24(t)-277(for)-290(that)-290(imprecise)-289(question.)-278(In)-301(the)-289(T)84(uring)-277(test,)-303(a)-288(com-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(puter)-350(tries)-338(to)-338(deceiv)25(e)-337(a)-337(h)24(uman)-349(in)24(to)-338(thinking)-350(that)-350(the)-350(computer)-337(is)-350(h)24(uman.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 458.04 371.16 Tm
(40)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 355.56 Tm
[(Of)-398(course)-397(in)-398(the)-410(foreseeable)-385(future)-410(it)-410(will)-397(b)-24(e)-410(to)-24(o)-397(di\016cult)-422(for)-398(a)-398(single)-397(com-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(puter)-338(to)-326(b)-24(e)-337(able)-324(to)-326(reac)24(h)-325(h)24(uman)-325(lev)24(el)-325(in)-337(man)24(y)-325(areas)-314(sim)24(ultaneously;)-314(but)-338(w)24(e)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(migh)24(t)-350(consider)-337(restricted)-339(v)24(ersions)-326(of)-338(the)-361(T)85(uring)-338(test)-351(for)-337(sp)-25(eci\fc)-348(areas)-326(of)-349(en-)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(dea)24(v)25(or.)-338(As)-362(men)25(tioned)-362(in)-361(the)-374(in)24(tro)-25(duction,)-350(the)-373(T)85(uring)-350(test)-375(has)-349(already)-338(b)-24(een)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(passed)-242(for)-229(m)24(usical)-241(comp)-24(osition:)-242(Da)25(vid)-229(Cop)-24(e)-253(has)-229(written)-254(a)-240(program)-218(EMI)-241(\(pro-)]TJ
T*
[(nounced)-325(\\Emm)25(y",)-301(for)-326(Exp)-24(erimen)24(ts)-314(in)-325(Musical)-326(In)24(telligence\))-650(whic)24(h)-325(pro)-24(duces)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(m)24(usic)-325(that)-327(regularly)-301(fo)-24(ols)-314(sophisticated)-326(audiences{at)-301(least,)-326(it)-326(did)-337(un)24(til)-326(Cop)-24(e)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(stopp)-25(ed)-277(conducting)-265(\\The)-276(T)85(est")-266(at)-265(his)-278(concerts|stopp)-25(ed)-265(b)-24(ecause)-264(the)-278(exp)-23(erts)]TJ
T*
[(w)24(ere)-301(to)-24(o)-301(em)24(barrassed.)-278(Since)-313(Cop)-24(e)-313(is)-301(a)-301(comp)-24(oser)-302(rather)-290(than)-313(a)-301(computer)-302(sci-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(en)24(tist,)-362(he)-362(presen)24(ts)-350(his)-362(results)-363(primarily)-338(at)-362(concerts)-350(rather)-350(than)-362(conferences.)]TJ
ET
q
56.76 0 0 -0.48 134.748 238.788 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 231.84 Tm
(38)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 228.12 Tm
[(F)80(or)-334(the)-321(record,)-347(Belinfan)27(te)-348(agrees)-346(with)-335(this)-334(statemen)29(t.)-334(His)-335(aim,)-347(ho)27(w)27(ev)27(er,)-335(is)-334(foun-)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(dational.)-468(As)-441(a)-455(b)-27(o)27(y)81(,)-455(he)-442(to)-26(ok)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
13.18258 0 Td
[(Principia)-457(Mathematic)53(a)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
10.8405 0 Td
[(from)-453(his)-456(ph)26(ysicist)-453(father's)]TJ
-24.02308 -1.21788 TD
[(b)-27(o)-27(okshelf)-307(and)-281(said)-294(to)-294(himself,)-320(\\Someda)27(y)-281(I'm)-293(going)-307(to)-294(c)27(hec)26(k)-281(if)-307(all)-295(these)-294(pro)-26(ofs)-307(are)]TJ
T*
[(really)-347(righ)27(t!".)-360(That)-348(spirit)-347(still)-360(animates)-360(his)-335(w)27(ork.)]TJ
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 188.04 Tm
(39)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 184.2 Tm
[(Lik)27(e)-335(Stanley)-334(Jev)27(on's)-348(pap)-27(er,)-348(an)-334(original)-374(cop)27(y)-321(of)-361(this)-334(journal)-347(article)-361(no)27(w)-348(is)-347(priced)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(at)-347($2000.)]TJ
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 166.2 Tm
(40)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 162.36 Tm
[(A)-308(more)-320(detailed)-335(discussion)-321(of)-333(the)-308(T)80(uring)-321(test)-320(can)-321(b)-28(e)-307(found)-323(in)-321(T)80(uring's)-321(pap)-27(er)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
34.59591 0 Td
(op.)Tj
-34.59591 -1.23127 TD
(cit.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.80675 0 Td
[(or)-387(in)-375(an)26(y)-361(mo)-26(dern)-375(textb)-26(o)-26(ok)-361(on)-375(arti\fcial)-387(in)27(telligence;)-402(the)-374(idea)-375(of)-388(a)-374(computer)]TJ
-1.80675 -1.21788 TD
[(trying)-333(to)-347(app)-28(ear)-347(h)26(uman)-334(is)-348(enough)-348(for)-347(our)-348(purp)-27(oses.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
48 0 obj
<<
/Length 9182
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 134.76 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(46)-2662(Mic)26(hael)-361(Beeson)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(I)-446(heard)-434(a)-445(sev)24(en-piece)-421(c)24(ham)24(b)-24(er)-434(orc)24(hestra)-422(p)-24(erform)-435(the)-445(Eigh)24(th)-446(Branden)24(burg)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(Concerto)-325(\(comp)-24(osed)-338(b)24(y)-325(EMI\).)-338(\(Bac)25(h)-338(comp)-24(osed)-325(the)-349(\frst)-327(sev)24(en)-337(Branden)24(burg)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
(Concertos.\))Tj
1.50563 -1.37313 TD
[(In)-326(theorem-pro)23(ving,)-301(as)-325(in)-326(arti\fcial)-313(in)24(telligence,)-325(there)-337(w)24(as)-313(initially)-326(a)-325(divi-)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.19245 TD
[(sion)-241(b)-25(et)24(w)25(een)-253(those)-241(who)-241(though)24(t)-241(computers)-242(should)-241(b)-25(e)-252(programmed)-230(to)-241(\\think")]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(lik)24(e)-337(h)24(umans)-326(and)-337(those)-338(who)-325(fa)24(v)25(ored)-326(a)-325(more)-325(computational)-338(approac)24(h.)-313(Should)]TJ
T*
[(w)24(e)-349(try)-350(to)-349(\fnd)-350(\\heuristics")-338(\(rules)-351(of)-349(th)23(um)24(b\))-362(to)-349(guide)-349(a)-349(computer's)-339(e\013orts)-350(to)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(\fnd)-301(a)-289(pro)-25(of,)-289(or)-289(pla)24(y)-289(a)-289(game)-289(of)-289(c)24(hess,)-289(or)-290(comp)-24(ose)-289(a)-289(piece)-288(of)-301(m)24(usic?)-289(Or)-290(should)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(w)24(e)-349(just)-374(giv)24(e)-337(the)-361(computer)-362(the)-362(rules)-350(and)-349(a)-349(simple)-362(algorithm)-350(and)-349(rely)-350(on)-361(the)]TJ
T*
[(p)-24(o)24(w)24(er)-373(of)-386(silicon)-385(c)24(hips?)-386(It)-386(is)-398(in)24(teresting)-374(to)-386(compare)-373(computerized)-386(c)25(hess)-374(and)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(computerized)-313(theorem-pro)23(ving)-301(in)-325(this)-327(resp)-24(ect.)-325(Both)-314(can)-324(b)-25(e)-325(view)25(ed)-313(as)-313(searc)24(h)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(problems:)-386(c)24(hess)-374(is)-398(a)-385(searc)24(h)-374(organized)-361(b)24(y)-385(\\if)-398(I)-386(mak)25(e)-386(mo)25(v)24(e)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
25.81243 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 397.56 531.48 Tm
(1)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 405.96 532.92 Tm
[(and)-385(he)-398(mak)24(es)]TJ
-27.2217 -1.19245 TD
-0.024 Tc
[(m)-24(ove)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
2.60172 0 Td
0 Tc
(y)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 165.6 519.6 Tm
(1)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 173.4 521.04 Tm
[(and)-349(then)-350(I)-337(mak)24(e)-337(mo)24(v)24(e)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
10.17803 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 280.44 519.6 Tm
(2)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 288.36 521.04 Tm
[(and)-337(he)-349(mak)24(es)-338(mo)24(v)25(e)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
8.9133 0 Td
(y)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 382.08 519.6 Tm
(2)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 390 521.04 Tm
[(and)-337(then)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.23984 0 Td
0.169 Tc
[(::)1(:)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
1.16836 0 Td
0 Tc
[(";)-337(w)24(e)]TJ
-31.02792 -1.2045 TD
[(searc)24(h)-301(the)-326(v)61(arious)-302(p)-25(ossibilities,)-314(up)-326(to)-313(a)-325(certain)-302(\\lev)25(el")-301(or)-314(\\depth",)-313(and)-313(then,)]TJ
T*
[(for)-278(eac)25(h)-277(sequence)-288(of)-289(p)-24(ossible)-278(mo)24(v)24(es,)-277(w)24(e)-276(score)-278(the)-289(situation.)-290(Then)-289(w)24(e)-276(pic)24(k)-289(our)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(mo)24(v)24(e,)-313(using)-325(a)-326(\\max-min")-313(algorithm.)-314(As)-338(in)-325(theorem)-325(pro)23(ving,)-313(the)-325(di\016cult)23(y)-337(is)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(to)-422(\\prune)-410(the)-433(searc)23(h)-397(tree")-410(to)-422(a)24(v)25(oid)-410(getting)-422(sw)24(amp)-24(ed)-409(b)24(y)-422(the)-422(consideration)]TJ
T*
[(of)-446(useless)-434(mo)24(v)24(es.)-422(In)-446(b)-24(oth)-446(endea)25(v)24(ors,)-423(theorem)-434(pro)24(ving)-422(and)-445(c)24(hess,)-434(one)-433(feels)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(that)-350(exp)-24(ert)-350(h)24(uman)-349(b)-24(eings)-350(ha)24(v)24(e)-337(subtle)-350(and)-349(p)-24(o)24(w)24(erful)-337(metho)-24(ds.)-350(Chess)-350(pla)24(y)24(ers)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
(analyze)Tj
/F7 1 Tf
3.55327 0 Td
(far)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.5538 0 Td
[(few)25(er)-302(p)-24(ossibilities)-303(than)-313(c)24(hess)-290(programs)-278(do,)-313(and)-301(those)-302(go)-24(o)-24(d)-301(p)-24(ossi-)]TJ
-5.10708 -1.19245 TD
[(bilities)-362(are)-337(analyzed)-337(deep)-24(er.)-349(One)-349(feels)-349(that)-350(the)-362(same)-337(ma)24(y)-350(b)-24(e)-349(true)-350(of)-349(mathe-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(maticians.)-302(In)-301(c)24(hess)-290(programs,)-278(\\kno)24(wledge")-264(ab)-24(out)-301(op)-24(enings)-302(and)-301(end)-301(games)-289(is)]TJ
T*
[(stored)-326(in)-338(a)-325(database)-313(and)-338(consulted)-325(when)-337(appropriate.)-314(But)-338(in)-337(the)-337(mid-game,)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(ev)24(ery)-385(e\013ort)-398(in)-398(c)25(hess)-387(programming)-374(to)-398(use)-397(more)-386(sp)-25(ecialized)-396(c)25(hess)-387(kno)25(wledge)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(and)-361(less)-362(searc)24(h)-350(has)-362(failed.)-373(The)-361(computer)-361(time)-374(is)-362(b)-24(etter)-374(sp)-25(en)25(t)-374(searc)24(hing)-338(one)]TJ
T*
[(mo)24(v)24(e)-385(deep)-23(er.)-398(On)-398(the)-397(other)-386(hand,)-398(the)-410(game)-385(of)-397(go)-385(is)-398(pla)24(y)24(ed)-385(at)-398(only)-385(sligh)23(tly)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(ab)-24(o)24(v)24(e)-276(the)-302(b)-24(eginner)-289(lev)25(el)-277(b)24(y)-289(computers.)-290(The)-289(b)-24(oard)-289(is)-290(19)-289(b)24(y)-289(19)-277(instead)-289(of)-289(8)-289(b)24(y)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(8,)-397(and)-398(there)-386(are)-385(more)-398(pieces;)-397(the)-398(com)25(binatorial)-374(explosion)-386(is)-398(to)-24(o)-398(deadly)-385(for)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(computers)-326(to)-326(adv)61(ance)-325(m)24(uc)24(h)-337(b)-24(ey)24(ond)-325(this)-338(lev)24(el)-325(at)-337(presen)23(t.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 382.8 333.36 Tm
(41)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 149.76 315.96 Tm
[(Similarly)84(,)-458(in)-470(mathematics,)-471(so)-458(far)-470(at)-458(least,)-470(searc)24(h)-446(has)-458(pro)23(v)25(ed)-458(the)-470(most)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.19245 TD
[(fruitful)-315(general)-276(tec)24(hnique.)-301(One)-289(can)-301(view)-288(computer)-301(algebra)-277(and)-290(computerized)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(decision)-385(pro)-25(cedures,)-385(suc)23(h)-385(as)-386(quan)24(ti\fer)-386(elimination)-398(or)-374(Wilf)-409(and)-386(Zeilb)-24(erger's)]TJ
T*
[(decision)-289(pro)-25(cedure)-276(for)-278(com)25(binatorial)-266(sums,)-290(as)-290(w)25(a)24(ys)-266(of)-289(em)25(b)-25(edding)-289(mathemat-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(ical)-337(kno)24(wledge)-336(in)-349(computer)-338(programs.)-315(Where)-349(they)-349(are)-337(applicable,)-337(they)-350(pla)25(y)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(an)-337(indisp)-25(ensable)-349(role,)-338(analogous)-313(to)-350(the)-349(role)-325(of)-350(op)-24(ening)-337(b)-24(o)-24(oks)-337(and)-350(end)-349(game)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(databases)-374(in)-386(c)25(hess.)-375(In)-385(areas)-374(of)-374(mathematics)-386(in)-397(whic)24(h)-373(it)-398(is)-386(di\016cult)-398(to)-374(bring)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(kno)24(wledge)-348(to)-374(b)-24(ear)-361(\(suc)23(h)-373(as)-362(elemen)25(tary)-350(group)-362(theory)-362(or)-350(prop)-24(ositional)-350(logic\))]TJ
ET
q
56.76 0 0 -0.48 134.748 216.948 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 210 Tm
(41)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 206.16 Tm
[(The)-402(game)-414(tree,)-400(searc)28(hing)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
11.85763 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.01713 0 Td
[(mo)28(v)27(es)-401(in)-402(the)-402(future,)-401(has)-401(ab)-27(out)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
14.49415 0 Td
(b)Tj
/F20 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 393.36 210 Tm
(n)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 402.12 206.16 Tm
[(no)-27(des,)-401(where)-415(at)]TJ
-28.78755 -1.21788 TD
[(a)-361(crude)-348(appro)27(ximation)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
10.55945 0 Td
(b)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.74947 0 Td
0.308 Tc
(=8)Tj
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 259.92 199.08 Tm
0 Tc
(2)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 267.36 195.24 Tm
[(for)-360(c)27(hess)-375(and)-348(19)]TJ
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 332.28 199.08 Tm
(2)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 339.72 195.24 Tm
[(for)-374(go.)-374(So)-361(the)-348(ratio)-373(is)-361(\(19)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
11.42937 0 Td
(=)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.50857 0 Td
(8\))Tj
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 454.92 199.08 Tm
(2)Tj
/F20 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 463.8 195.24 Tm
(.)Tj
-35.66658 -1.23127 TD
[(T)80(aking)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
3.31907 0 Td
(n)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.91007 0 Td
[(=)-281(10)-253(w)26(e)-241(get)-253(more)-253(than)-228(2)]TJ
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 277.44 188.04 Tm
(20)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 285.36 184.2 Tm
[(,)-241(whic)26(h)-241(is)-254(ab)-27(out)-240(a)-254(million:)-268(go)-253(is)-241(a)-253(million)-254(times)]TJ
-15.76557 -1.21788 TD
[(harder)-361(than)-348(c)27(hess.)-374(On)-349(the)-361(other)-361(hand,)-362(computer)-361(sp)-26(eeds)-362(and)-362(memory)-359(sizes)-374(ha)27(v)27(e)]TJ
T*
[(historically)-346(increased)-334(exp)-27(onen)26(tially)81(,)-321(doubling)-336(ev)27(ery)-307(18)-347(mon)27(ths;)-320(so)-334(if)-335(Mo)-26(ore's)-360(la)27(w)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(con)27(tin)26(ues)-374(to)-374(hold,)-389(w)27(e)-375(migh)27(t)-374(hop)-27(e)-375(that)-374(go)-387(programs)-385(w)26(ould)-389(p)-27(erform)-386(w)27(ell)-388(enough)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(in)-335(30)-361(y)27(ears,)-346(ev)27(en)-335(without)-348(impro)28(v)27(emen)26(ts)-333(in)-349(the)-334(programs.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
49 0 obj
<<
/Length 7957
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 290.52 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(The)-335(Mec)27(hanization)-361(of)-361(Mathematics)-2674(47)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(b)-24(ecause)-349(the)-361(axioms)-350(are)-349(v)24(ery)-338(simple)-361(and)-350(to)-24(ols)-362(from)-350(outside)-362(the)-361(sub)-61(ject)-349(area)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(are)-265(not)-277(applicable,)-265(theorem-pro)23(ving)-241(programs)-254(can)-265(outp)-24(erform)-266(h)24(uman)-277(b)-24(eings,)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
[(at)-338(least)-325(sometimes,)-326(just)-339(as)-325(in)-338(c)25(hess.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.58994 TD
[(Ho)24(w)-409(did)-422(the)-433(trade-o\013)-411(b)-24(et)24(w)24(een)-421(high-sp)-24(eed)-421(but)-423(simple)-422(computation)-422(and)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.19245 TD
[(heuristics)-399(pla)24(y)-397(out)-398(in)-410(the)-397(area)-386(of)-397(m)24(usical)-398(comp)-24(osition?)-398(The)-397(answ)24(er)-385(to)-410(this)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(question)-326(is)-338(quite)-337(in)24(teresting,)-327(and)-325(ma)24(y)-325(ha)24(v)24(e)-325(implications)-325(for)-326(the)-338(future)-338(of)-337(re-)]TJ
T*
[(searc)24(h)-277(in)-301(theorem)-290(pro)24(ving.)-277(EMI)-290(do)-24(es)-289(not)-301(comp)-24(ose)-277(from)-290(a)-301(blank)-289(slate.)-290(T)85(o)-289(use)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(EMI,)-410(y)24(ou)-397(\frst)-411(decide)-409(on)-409(a)-398(comp)-24(oser)-398(to)-409(b)-25(e)-421(imitated;)-410(let's)-422(sa)23(y)-385(Bac)25(h.)-410(Then,)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(y)24(ou)-373(feed)-397(EMI)-386(sev)24(eral)-361(comp)-24(ositions)-375(b)24(y)-385(Bac)24(h.)-373(EMI)-386(extracts)-374(from)-386(these)-386(data)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(a)-385(\\grammar")-362(of)-398(m)24(usical)-385(structures.)-376(EMI)-398(then)-398(uses)-386(this)-398(grammar)-375(to)-385(gener-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(ate)-434(a)-421(new)-433(comp)-24(osition,)-422(whic)24(h)-433(will)-434(b)-24(e)-433(p)-25(erceiv)25(ed)-421(as)-422(\\in)-434(the)-434(st)24(yle)-422(of)-433(Bac)25(h".)]TJ
T*
[(The)-289(selection)-289(of)-277(the)-301(initial)-290(database)-277(calls)-277(for)-278(m)24(usical)-289(exp)-24(ertise)-278(and)-289(for)-289(exp)-24(er-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(tise)-350(with)-349(EMI.)-338(F)84(or)-338(example,)-349(to)-337(comp)-24(ose)-337(the)-350(Eigh)25(th)-338(Branden)24(burg)-326(Concerto,)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(Cop)-24(e)-349(c)25(hose)-326(some)-349(of)-337(the)-362(original)-325(sev)24(en)-337(Branden)24(burg)-326(Concertos)-325(and)-350(a)-337(couple)]TJ
T*
[(of)-410(violin)-397(concertos.)-398(When)-409(the)-410(database)-398(con)25(tained)-398(only)-409(the)-410(sev)24(en)-397(Branden-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(burg)-278(Concertos,)-277(the)-301(resulting)-278(comp)-24(osition)-290(seemed)-277(to)-24(o)-289(\\deriv)60(ativ)24(e",)-265(and)-289(ev)24(en)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(con)24(tained)-433(recognizable)-433(phrases.)-435(Y)85(et,)-458(once)-433(the)-458(data)-434(has)-446(b)-24(een)-457(digested,)-446(the)]TJ
T*
[(program)-302(w)24(orks)-314(according)-312(to)-326(sp)-25(eci\fc,)-336(precise)-325(rules.)-326(There)-325(is)-326(nothing)-325(\\heuris-)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(tic")-398(ab)-24(out)-409(the)-410(pro)-25(cess.)-386(A)-409(result)-411(that)-410(\\lo)-24(oks)-386(h)24(uman")-397(has)-398(b)-24(een)-409(ac)24(hiev)25(ed)-385(b)24(y)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(computational)-326(means.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.58994 TD
[(This)-434(is)-422(at)-434(presen)24(t)-434(not)-434(true)-435(of)-433(most)-423(pro)-24(ofs)-422(pro)-25(duced)-433(b)24(y)-434(most)-434(theorem-)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(pro)24(v)24(ers.)-447(T)85(o)-470(exhibit)-470(a)-469(simple)-482(example,)-458(consider)-458(the)-482(theorem)-470(that)-470(a)-470(group)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(in)-434(whic)25(h)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.22779 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 182.52 399 Tm
(2)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 191.52 395.4 Tm
[(=)-446(1)-433(for)-434(all)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
5.28775 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.01178 0 Td
[(is)-434(comm)24(utativ)23(e.)-433(A)-433(h)24(uman)-434(pro)-25(of)-433(migh)24(t)-434(start)-424(b)24(y)]TJ
-11.99682 -1.2045 TD
(substituting)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
5.58888 0 Td
(uv)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.4454 0 Td
(for)Tj
/F9 1 Tf
1.54176 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56612 0 Td
[(,)-361(to)-350(get)-349(\()]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
3.95076 0 Td
(uv)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1.0961 0 Td
(\))Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 279.96 387 Tm
(2)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 287.52 383.4 Tm
[(=)-313(1.)-349(Multiplying)-351(on)-349(the)-361(left)-350(b)24(y)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
14.00834 0 Td
(u)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.92746 0 Td
[(and)-349(on)]TJ
-30.26908 -1.19246 TD
[(the)-434(righ)24(t)-422(b)24(y)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
5.81773 0 Td
(v)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.95155 0 Td
[(the)-446(desired)-422(result)-423(is)-434(immediate.)-433(The)-421(pro)-25(of)-422(that)-434(a)-434(theorem-)]TJ
-6.76929 -1.2045 TD
[(pro)24(v)24(er)-398(\fnds)-422(is)-422(m)24(uc)24(h)-422(less)-422(clev)25(er.)-410(In)-422(longer)-409(pro)-25(ofs,)-410(the)-422(computer's)-422(inh)24(uman)]TJ
T*
[(st)23(yle)-349(stands)-363(out)-349(ev)24(en)-349(more.)-349(The)-361(most)-362(notable)-350(feature)-349(of)-362(suc)24(h)-349(pro)-25(ofs)-350(is)-362(that)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(theorem)-277(pro)23(v)24(ers)-253(nev)24(er)-277(in)24(v)24(en)24(t)-265(concepts)-277(or)-277(form)23(ulate)-277(lemmas.)-277(A)-289(pap)-24(er)-278(written)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(b)24(y)-494(a)-494(mathematician)-494(ma)24(y)-481(ha)24(v)24(e)-482(a)-493(\\main)-494(theorem")-482(and)-494(t)24(w)24(en)24(t)24(y)-482(supp)-25(orting)]TJ
T*
[(lemmas.)-338(The)-336(pro)-25(of)-337(of)-349(the)-338(main)-337(theorem)-338(ma)24(y)-337(b)-24(e)-349(quite)-338(short,)-338(but)-350(it)-350(relies)-325(on)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(the)-241(preceding)-229(lemmas.)-229(Not)-241(only)-241(do)-24(es)-229(this)-242(help)-240(understanding,)-231(but)-241(the)-241(lemmas)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(ma)24(y)-470(b)-24(e)-469(useful)-482(in)-470(other)-471(con)25(texts.)-459(The)-481(most)-471(p)-24(o)24(w)25(erful)-458(presen)23(t-da)24(y)-446(theorem)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(pro)24(v)24(ers)-266(nev)25(er)-290(\fnd,)-301(organize,)-277(or)-289(presen)23(t)-289(their)-290(pro)-24(ofs)-290(in)-301(this)-302(w)24(a)24(y)-277(\(unless)-302(led)-301(to)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(do)-325(so)-326(b)24(y)-337(a)-325(h)24(uman)-325(after)-326(a)-337(failure)-326(to)-325(\fnd)-338(the)-337(pro)-25(of)-325(in)-337(one)-325(go\).)]TJ
1.50563 -1.58994 TD
[(Theorem-pro)24(v)24(ers)-314(of)-349(the)-362(future)-362(should)-350(b)-24(e)-361(able)-349(to)-362(in)24(v)24(en)25(t)-350(terminology)-338(and)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(form)-290(de\fnitions.)-302(The)-300(basis)-290(of)-289(their)-302(abilit)23(y)-289(to)-301(do)-289(this)-302(should)-290(b)-24(e)-301(an)-289(underlying)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(abilit)24(y)-434(to)-434(monitor)-434(and)-434(reason)-410(ab)-24(out)-446(their)-435(o)25(wn)-422(deduction)-445(pro)-25(cess.)-422(As)-434(it)-446(is)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(no)24(w,)-373(h)24(umans)-374(using)-386(a)-373(theorem)-374(pro)24(v)24(er)-362(monitor)-374(the)-386(output,)-386(and)-386(then)-385(c)24(hange)]TJ
T*
[(parameters)-375(and)-397(restart)-375(the)-410(job.)-398(In)-398(the)-397(future,)-399(this)-398(kind)-398(of)-397(feedbac)25(k)-386(should)]TJ
0 -1.19246 TD
[(b)-24(e)-361(automated)-362(and)-361(dynamic,)-362(so)-349(that)-362(the)-374(parameters)-338(of)-362(a)-361(run)-350(can)-361(b)-24(e)-373(altered)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(\(b)24(y)-362(the)-373(program)-338(itself)-73(\))-374(while)-361(the)-374(run)-362(is)-362(in)-361(progress.)-339(With)-374(this)-362(capabilit)24(y)-361(in)]TJ
T*
[(hand,)-277(one)-277(should)-277(then)-290(b)-24(e)-277(able)-276(to)-278(detect)-289(candidates)-277(for)-266(\\lemma")-276(status:)-279(short)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(form)23(ulas)-265(that)-278(are)-253(used)-277(sev)24(eral)-253(times.)-278(It)-278(is)-277(then)-278(a)-265(go)-23(o)-24(d)-265(idea)-277(to)-265(k)24(eep)-265(an)-277(ey)25(e)-265(out)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(for)-362(further)-375(deductions)-373(similar)-363(in)-373(form)-374(to)-374(the)-374(form)24(ulas)-362(in)24(v)24(olv)24(ed)-349(in)-373(the)-374(pro)-24(of)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
50 0 obj
<<
/Length 7634
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 134.76 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(48)-2662(Mic)26(hael)-361(Beeson)]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 134.76 666.2401 Tm
[(of)-349(the)-362(lemmas.)]TJ
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 199.2 669.84 Tm
(42)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 211.2 666.2401 Tm
[(Giving)-349(a)-349(program)-339(the)-361(abilit)24(y)-350(to)-349(form)23(ulate)-349(its)-351(o)25(wn)-349(lemmas)]TJ
-7.67266 -1.2045 TD
[(dynamically)-313(migh)24(t,)-326(in)-325(conjunction)-325(with)-326(the)-325(abilit)24(y)-326(to)-313(mo)-24(dify)-338(the)-325(criteria)-302(for)]TJ
0 -1.20451 TD
[(k)24(eeping)-385(or)-386(using)-398(deduced)-396(form)23(ulas,)-386(enable)-385(the)-409(program)-363(to)-397(\fnd)-410(pro)-25(ofs)-386(that)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(migh)24(t)-338(otherwise)-313(b)-24(e)-337(b)-25(ey)25(ond)-337(reac)24(h.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.25268 TD
[(Suc)24(h)-397(a)-410(pro)24(v)24(er)-373(migh)24(t)-410(pro)-25(duce)-409(pro)-25(ofs)-385(that)-423(lo)-24(ok)-397(more)-398(h)24(uman.)-398(The)-408(in)24(v)24(es-)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(tigation,)-483(the)-494(st)24(yle)-494(of)-494(though)24(t,)-482(and)-494(the)-494(dev)24(elopmen)25(t)-483(of)-493(the)-494(theory)-483(should)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(eac)25(h)-301(lo)-24(ok)-301(more)-290(lik)24(e)-300(pro)-25(ofs)-301(p)-25(eople)-312(pro)-25(duce.)-300(Searc)24(hing)-289(w)24(ould)-301(still)-314(b)-24(e)-313(the)-313(basis)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(\(not)-350(heuristics\),)-351(but)-350(the)-350(result)-338(w)24(ould)-349(lo)-24(ok)-337(less)-338(lik)24(e)-337(it)-350(had)-349(b)-24(een)-349(pro)-25(duced)-336(b)24(y)]TJ
T*
[(P)25(oincar)24<13>469(e's)-373(famous)-410(mac)24(hine)-409(that)-423(tak)24(es)-409(in)-410(pigs)-410(and)-422(pro)-24(duces)-398(sausages.)-398(This)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(t)24(yp)-24(e)-301(of)-301(pro)23(v)24(er)-265(w)25(ould)-302(b)-24(e)-301(a)-289(little)-313(more)-278(lik)25(e)-301(EMI)-290(than)-301(to)-25(da)24(y's)-289(theorem)-290(pro)24(v)24(ers.)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(One)-265(migh)24(t)-265(ev)24(en)-252(b)-24(e)-277(able)-265(to)-265(prime)-266(it)-265(with)-277(sev)24(eral)-241(pro)-25(ofs)-253(b)24(y)-265(the)-265(famous)-266(logician)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(Meredith)-338(in)-337(order)-326(to)-338(ha)24(v)24(e)-325(it)-337(pro)-25(duce)-337(pro)-24(ofs)-326(in)-349(prop)-25(ositional)-314(logic)-324(in)-350(Mered-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(ith's)-338(st)23(yle,)-325(m)24(uc)24(h)-325(as)-326(EMI)-325(can)-325(pro)-25(duce)-324(m)24(usic)-326(in)-337(the)-338(st)24(yle)-325(of)-325(Bac)24(h)-325(or)-313(the)-338(st)23(yle)]TJ
T*
[(of)-373(Scott)-374(Joplin.)-362(A)25(t)-374(presen)23(t)-361(this)-375(is)-374(rather)-350(farfetc)24(hed,)-374(as)-361(there)-362(is)-374(nothing)-362(lik)24(e)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(the)-410(\\grammar")-362(of)-397(Meredith's)-399(pro)-25(ofs.)-386(The)-409(closest)-386(appro)24(ximation)-374(at)-410(presen)24(t)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(w)24(ould)-301(b)-24(e)-301(to)-301(tell)-302(the)-313(program)-278(to)-301(retain)-290(deduced)-300(clauses)-290(similar)-302(in)-301(form)-302(to)-301(the)]TJ
T*
[(lines)-338(of)-325(the)-337(pro)-25(ofs)-325(used)-326(to)-338(prime)-325(the)-338(program.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.25268 TD
[(W)84(e)-336(do)-338(not)-337(exp)-24(ect,)-349(ho)24(w)24(ev)25(er,)-314(that)-350(all)-337(mac)24(hine-generated)-313(pro)-24(ofs)-338(will)-337(\\lo)-24(ok)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.19246 TD
[(h)24(uman".)-325(F)84(or)-326(example,)-325(there)-325(exists)-326(a)-326(mac)25(hine-generated)-301(pro)-25(of)-325(that)-338(a)-325(certain)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
[(form)23(ula)-361(is)-362(a)-361(single)-361(axiom)-350(for)-362(groups)-350(satisfying)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
20.75353 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
6.97385 0 0 6.97385 347.16 441.6 Tm
(19)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
9.96264 0 0 9.96264 359.04 438 Tm
[(=)-325(1)-361(for)-362(all)]TJ
/F9 1 Tf
4.96254 0 Td
(x)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
0.56611 0 Td
[(.)-373(This)-362(pro)-25(of)]TJ
-28.04076 -1.19245 TD
[(con)24(tains)-326(a)-325(form)24(ula)-326(715)-312(sym)23(b)-24(ols)-326(long.)-325(No)-325(h)24(uman)-325(will)-337(\fnd)-337(that)-339(pro)-24(of.)]TJ
1.50563 -1.25268 TD
[(Remem)25(b)-24(er:)-458(the)-482(question)-459(whether)-469(mac)24(hines)-458(can)-469(think)-471(is)-470(lik)24(e)-457(the)-482(ques-)]TJ
-1.50563 -1.2045 TD
[(tion)-386(whether)-385(submarines)-375(can)-385(swim.)-386(W)84(e)-397(exp)-23(ect)-386(mac)25(hine)-386(mathematics)-386(to)-374(b)-24(e)]TJ
T*
[(di\013eren)24(t)-422(from)-410(h)24(uman)-410(mathematics{but)-423(it)-422(seems)-410(a)-409(safe)-410(prediction)-422(that)-422(the)]TJ
0 -1.19245 TD
[(t)24(w)24(en)24(t)24(y-\frst)-339(cen)25(tury)-351(will)-361(see)-349(some)-349(amazing)-337(ac)24(hiev)25(emen)24(ts)-338(in)-361(mac)24(hine)-349(mathe-)]TJ
0 -1.2045 TD
(matics.)Tj
/F6 1 Tf
11.95517 0 0 11.95517 134.76 331.32 Tm
(References)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 134.76 305.88 Tm
[(1.)-562(Agarw)28(al,)-428(R.,)-401(Kapur,)-388(D.,)-402(Musser,)-413(D.)-402(R.,)-401(and)-389(Nie,)-402(X.,)-401(T)80(ecton)-401(pro)-27(of)-414(system.)-399(In:)]TJ
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(Bo)-26(ok,)-387(R.)-375((ed.))]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
6.87903 0 Td
[(Pr)53(o)54(c.)-402(F)80(ourth)-414(International)-416(Confer)52(enc)53(e)-416(on)-388(R)53(ewriting)-403(T)80(e)53(chniques)]TJ
-6.87903 -1.23127 TD
[(and)-375(Applic)53(ations,)-375(Milan,)-349(Italy,)-360(1991.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
16.92992 0 Td
(LNCS)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
3.07817 0 Td
(488)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.7666 0 Td
[(,)-348(Springer-V)80(erlag)-347((1991).)]TJ
-23.1264 -1.27142 TD
[(2.)-562(App)-28(el,)-294(K.,)-295(and)-295(Hak)28(en,)-295(W.,)-295(Ev)27(ery)-280(planar)-308(map)-294(is)-294(four)-307(colorable.)-320(P)27(art)-293(I.)-295(Disc)28(harg-)]TJ
1.35172 -1.23127 TD
(ing,)Tj
/F5 1 Tf
2.0075 0 Td
[(Il)-53(linois)-335(J.)-375(Math.)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
7.66865 0 Td
(21)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.53908 0 Td
[(429{490,)-372(1977.)]TJ
-12.56695 -1.27142 TD
[(3.)-562(App)-28(el,)-321(K.,)-321(Hak)27(en,)-322(W.)-321(Hak)27(en,)-309(and)-321(Ko)-27(c)27(h,)-322(J.,)-334(Ev)27(ery)-307(planar)-334(map)-321(is)-321(four)-334(colorable.)]TJ
1.35172 -1.23127 TD
[(P)27(art)-347(I)-26(I.)-348(Reducibilit)26(y)80(,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
9.7163 0 Td
[(Il)-53(linois)-348(J.)-362(Math.)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
7.68203 0 Td
(21)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.17773 0 Td
[(491{567,)-385(1977.)]TJ
-19.92778 -1.27142 TD
[(4.)-562(Arnon,)-375(D.,)-374(and)-362(Buc)26(h)27(b)-28(erger,)-373(B.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
16.01985 0 Td
[(A)27(lgorithms)-402(in)-388(R)53(e)53(al)-388(A)27(lgebr)52(aic)-402(Ge)54(ometry)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
17.62585 0 Td
[(,)-402(Acad-)]TJ
-32.29398 -1.23127 TD
[(emic)-267(Press,)-280(London)-269((1988).)-278(Reprin)26(ted)-254(from)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
19.33892 0 Td
[(J.)-295(Symb)52(olic)-294(Computation)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
11.41598 0 Td
(5)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.84315 0 Td
[(Num)27(b)-28(ers)]TJ
-31.59805 -1.21788 TD
[(1)-348(and)-348(2,)-348(1988.)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.27142 TD
[(5.)-562(Baader,)-360(F.,)-362(and)-335(Sn)26(yder,)-321(W.,)-362(Uni\fcation)-335(theory)82(,)-335(in)-348([90],)-361(pp.)-349(435-534.)]TJ
ET
q
56.76 0 0 -0.48 134.748 184.068 cm
/Im1 Do
Q
BT
/F8 1 Tf
5.97758 0 0 5.97758 133.08 177.12 Tm
(42)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 144 173.28 Tm
[(There)-375(are)-374(v)54(arious)-387(p)-27(ossible)-387(notions)-374(of)-388(\\similar)-399(in)-362(form")-399(that)-361(migh)27(t)-374(b)-27(e)-375(used.)-375(F)80(or)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(example,)-401(one)-415(idea)-402(is)-414(to)-401(call)-414(form)28(ulas)-414(similar)-427(if)-415(they)-387(b)-28(ecome)-400(the)-402(same)-413(when)-403(all)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(v)54(ariables)-441(are)-440(replaced)-429(with)-442(the)-428(same)-427(letter.)-440(This)-442(notion)-441(is)-428(b)-27(ehind)-430(a)-428(successful)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(strategy)-345(called)-361(\\resonance".)-360([109],)-374(p.)-348(457.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
51 0 obj
<<
/Length 8541
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 290.52 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(The)-335(Mec)27(hanization)-361(of)-361(Mathematics)-2674(49)]TJ
-17.37156 -2.8908 TD
(6.)Tj
1.35172 -0.00001 TD
[(Barendregt,)-507(H.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
7.64188 0 Td
[(The)-509(L)53(amb)53(da)-522(Calculus:)-494(Its)-521(Syntax)-523(and)-522(Semantics)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
22.59107 0 Td
[(,)-509(Studies)-495(in)]TJ
-30.23295 -1.23126 TD
[(Logic)-401(and)-375(the)-375(F)80(oundations)-374(of)-388(Mathematics)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
19.90102 0 Td
(103)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.7666 0 Td
[(,)-388(Elsevier)-400(Science)-376(Ltd.)-376(Revised)]TJ
-21.66762 -1.21788 TD
[(edition)-348(\(Octob)-26(er)-347(1984\).)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.29818 TD
[(7.)-562(Barendregt,)-373(H.,)-362(and)-348(Geuv)26(ers,)-347(H.,)-361(Pro)-26(of-Assistan)29(ts)-387(Using)-348(Dep)-27(enden)26(t)-335(T)27(yp)-27(e)-361(Sys-)]TJ
1.35172 -1.23127 TD
(tems,)Tj
2.79712 -0.00001 TD
[(in:)-389(Robinson,)-388(A.,)-388(and)-389(V)80(oronk)28(o)27(v,)-374(A.)-389((eds.),)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
19.68688 0 Td
[(Handb)53(o)53(ok)-428(of)-402(A)27(utomate)54(d)-441(R)53(e)53(a-)]TJ
-22.484 -1.21788 TD
[(soning,)-376(vol.)-362(II)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.31693 0 Td
[(,)-335(pp.)-335(1151-1238.)-385(Elsevier)-360(Science)-336((2001).)]TJ
-7.66865 -1.29818 TD
[(8.)-562(Basu,)-508(S.,)-495(P)26(ollac)28(k,)-508(R.,)-495(and)-483(Ro)28(y)80(,)-482(M.)-508(F.,)-496(On)-482(the)-495(Com)27(binatorial)-507(and)-496(Algebraic)]TJ
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(Complexit)28(y)-415(of)-427(Quan)26(ti\fer)-401(Elimination,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
17.73292 0 Td
[(Journal)-442(of)-428(the)-442(A)27(CM)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
9.67615 0 Td
(43)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.59262 0 Td
[((6))-413(1002{1046,)]TJ
-29.00168 -1.23127 TD
(1996.)Tj
-1.35172 -1.29818 TD
[(9.)-562(Beeson,)-401(M.,)-401(Some)-374(applications)-401(of)-401(Gen)26(tzen's)-388(pro)-26(of)-387(theory)-374(to)-387(automated)-386(deduc-)]TJ
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(tion,)-441(in)-416(P)81(.)-429(Sc)27(hro)-27(eder-Heister)-427((ed.),)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
16.26075 0 Td
[(Extensions)-470(of)-441(L)53(o)53(gic)-456(Pr)54(o)53(gr)53(amming)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
15.27038 0 Td
[(,)-442(Lecture)]TJ
-31.53113 -1.23127 TD
[(Notes)-347(in)-348(Computer)-347(Science)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
12.54018 0 Td
(475)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
2.12795 0 Td
[(101-156,)-372(Springer-V)80(erlag)-333((1991).)]TJ
-16.01985 -1.29818 TD
[(10.)-575(Beeson,)-414(M.,)]TJ
/F21 1 Tf
7.60173 0 Td
[(Mathp)-27(ert)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
4.30943 0 Td
[(:)-402(Computer)-400(supp)-28(ort)-387(for)-413(learning)-415(algebra,)-414(trigonometry)84(,)]TJ
-10.55945 -1.21788 TD
[(and)-402(calculus,)-415(in:)-402(A.)-402(V)80(oronk)28(o)27(v)-388((ed.),)-401(Logic)-414(Programming)-425(and)-402(Automated)-387(Rea-)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(soning,)-361(Lecture)-348(Notes)-333(in)-349(Arti\fcial)-347(In)26(telligence)-361(624,)-360(Springer-V)80(erlag)-333((1992).)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.29818 TD
[(11.)-575(Beeson,)-320(M.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
7.41437 0 Td
[(Mathp)54(ert)-375(Calculus)-334(Assistant)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12.58033 0 Td
[(.)-348(This)-321(soft)28(w)27(are)-321(pro)-26(duct)-308(w)26(as)-320(published)]TJ
-18.64298 -1.21788 TD
[(in)-335(July)80(,)-348(1997)-346(b)26(y)-321(Mathp)-27(ert)-347(Systems,)-332(San)26(ta)-334(Clara,)-360(CA.)-348(See)-335(www.mathxp)-27(ert.com)]TJ
0 -1.23126 TD
[(to)-347(do)27(wnload)-362(a)-347(trial)-347(cop)27(y)80(.)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.29818 TD
[(12.)-575(Beeson,)-307(M.,)-308(Automatic)-292(generation)-307(of)-307(epsilon-delta)-308(pro)-26(ofs)-307(of)-307(con)27(tin)26(uit)27(y)81(,)-281(in:)-295(Cal-)]TJ
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(met,)-427(Jacques,)-428(and)-415(Plaza,)-441(Jan)-429((eds.))]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
16.82285 0 Td
[(A)27(rti\fcial)-429(Intel)-53(ligenc)52(e)-456(and)-442(Symb)52(olic)-441(Com-)]TJ
-16.82285 -1.23126 TD
[(putation:)-334(International)-349(Confer)52(enc)53(e)-349(AISC-98,)-321(Plattsbur)54(gh,)-348(New)-335(Y)81(ork,)-336(USA,)-321(Sep-)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(temb)53(er)-389(1998)-374(Pr)53(o)54(c)53(e)53(e)53(dings)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
10.89403 0 Td
[(,)-388(pp.)-336(67-83.)-359(Springer-V)80(erlag)-347((1998).)]TJ
-12.24575 -1.29818 TD
[(13.)-575(Beeson,)-387(M.,)-375(Automatic)-373(generation)-387(of)-387(a)-375(pro)-26(of)-374(of)-388(the)-361(irrationalit)29(y)-387(of)-388(e,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
33.57878 0 Td
(Journal)Tj
-32.22707 -1.21788 TD
[(of)-362(Symb)53(olic)-375(Computation)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
11.63012 0 Td
(32)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.17773 0 Td
[(,)-348(No.)-348(4)-347((2001),)-359(pp.)-349(333-349.)]TJ
-14.15957 -1.31157 TD
[(14.)-575(Beeson,)-494(M.,)-509(Uni\fcation)-482(in)-496(Lam)28(b)-28(da)-482(Calculus)-508(with)-482(if-then-else,)-495(in:)-496(Kirc)27(hner,)]TJ
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(C.,)-308(and)-295(Kirc)27(hner,)-295(H.)-294((eds.),)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
12.51342 0 Td
[(A)27(utomate)54(d)-348(De)53(duction-CADE-15.)-349(15th)-348(International)]TJ
-12.51342 -1.21788 TD
[(Confer)52(enc)52(e)-361(on)-349(A)27(utomate)54(d)-361(De)53(duction,)-349(Lindau,)-335(Germany,)-349(July)-348(1998)-348(Pr)53(o)54(c)53(e)53(e)53(dings)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
35.31861 0 Td
(,)Tj
-35.31861 -1.23127 TD
[(pp.)-269(96-111,)-292(Lecture)-268(Notes)-266(in)-268(Arti\fcial)-267(In)26(telligence)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
22.33678 0 Td
(1421)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
2.35547 0 Td
[(,)-281(Springer-V)80(erlag)-266((1998).)]TJ
-26.04396 -1.29818 TD
[(15.)-575(Beeson,)-293(M.,)-281(A)-268(second-order)-281(theorem)-279(pro)27(v)27(er)-267(applied)-269(to)-280(circumscription,)-293(in:)-282(Gor,)]TJ
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(R.,)-268(Leitsc)28(h,)-255(A.,)-268(and)-255(Nipk)26(o)27(w,)-254(T.)-268((eds.),)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
17.09052 0 Td
[(A)27(utomate)54(d)-308(R)53(e)54(asoning,)-296(First)-308(International)]TJ
-17.09052 -1.23127 TD
[(Joint)-456(Confer)53(enc)52(e,)-469(IJCAR)-442(2001,)-455(Siena,)-444(Italy,)-454(June)-456(2001,)-455(Pr)54(o)53(c)53(e)53(e)54(dings)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
31.50437 0 Td
[(,)-468(Lecture)]TJ
-31.50437 -1.21788 TD
[(Notes)-347(in)-348(Arti\fcial)-348(In)27(telligence)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
13.82498 0 Td
(2083)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
2.35547 0 Td
[(,)-361(Springer-V)80(erlag)-347((2001).)]TJ
-17.53217 -1.29818 TD
[(16.)-575(Beeson,)-360(M.,)-362(Solving)-361(for)-360(functions,)-348(to)-361(app)-27(ear)-347(in)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
23.30038 0 Td
[(Journal)-388(of)-375(Symb)52(olic)-362(Computa-)]TJ
-21.94867 -1.23127 TD
(tion)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.75322 0 Td
[(.)-375(A)-361(preliminary)-361(v)27(ersion)-360(app)-27(eared)-375(in:)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
16.7827 0 Td
[(LMCS)-390(2002,)-388(L)53(o)54(gic,)-376(Mathematics,)-402(and)]TJ
-18.53592 -1.21788 TD
[(Computer)-509(Scienc)51(e:)-495(Inter)53(actions,)-496(Symp)53(osium)-495(in)-483(Honor)-495(of)-482(Bruno)-496(Buchb)54(er)53(ger's)]TJ
T*
[(60th)-454(Birthday)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.22325 0 Td
[(,)-442(pp.)-416(24{38,)-439(RISC-Linz)-416(Rep)-27(ort)-414(Series)-428(No.)-414(02-60,)-440(Researc)28(h)-415(Insti-)]TJ
-6.22325 -1.23127 TD
[(tute)-334(for)-360(Sym)27(b)-28(olic)-347(Computation,)-347(Linz)-349((2002).)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.29818 TD
[(17.)-575(Belinfan)27(te,)-348(J.,)-348(Computer)-333(pro)-27(ofs)-360(in)-335<477F>509(odel's)-348(class)-346(theory)-334(with)-334(equational)-347(de\fni-)]TJ
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(tions)-374(for)-387(comp)-26(osite)-374(and)-375(cross,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
13.86513 0 Td
[(J.)-389(A)27(utomate)54(d)-414(R)53(e)53(asoning)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
11.3223 0 Td
(22)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.17773 0 Td
[(,)-375(No.)-374(3,)-375(pp.)-375(311-339,)]TJ
-26.36517 -1.21788 TD
(1988.)Tj
-1.35172 -1.31157 TD
[(18.)-575(Belinfan)27(te,)-334(J.,)-335(On)-308(computer-assisted)-319(pro)-26(ofs)-333(in)-322(ordinal)-321(n)26(um)27(b)-27(er)-308(theory)82(,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
33.27097 0 Td
[(J.)-335(A)27(uto-)]TJ
-31.91925 -1.21788 TD
[(mate)53(d)-388(R)53(e)54(asoning)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
7.89617 0 Td
(22)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.17773 0 Td
[(,)-348(No.)-348(3,)-347(pp.)-336(341-378,)-372(1988.)]TJ
-10.42562 -1.29818 TD
[(19.)-575(Bledso)-26(e,)-522(W.)-509(W.,)-509(and)-509(Hines,)-509(L.)-509(M.,)-508(V)80(ariable)-508(elimination)-521(and)-509(c)26(haining)-509(in)-496(a)]TJ
1.35172 -1.23126 TD
[(resolution-based)-360(pro)27(v)27(er)-334(for)-347(inequalities)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.29818 TD
[(20.)-575(Bo)28(y)27(er,)-428(R.)-415(S.,)-429(and)-428(Mo)-27(ore,)-440(J.)-429(S.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
16.63548 0 Td
[(A)-441(Computational)-455(L)53(o)54(gic)-456(Handb)53(o)53(ok)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
[(,)-442(Academic)]TJ
-15.28377 -1.21788 TD
[(Press,)-360(Boston)-360((1988).)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.31156 TD
[(21.)-575(Bronstein,)-574(M.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
9.14082 0 Td
[(Symb)52(olic)-575(Inte)53(gr)53(ation)-589(I:)-562(T)80(r)54(ansc)52(endental)-616(F)80(unctions)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
22.85873 0 Td
[(,)-589(Springer-)]TJ
-30.64783 -1.21788 TD
[(V)80(erlag,)-360(Berlin/)-361(Heidelb)-28(erg/)-347(New)-348(Y)80(ork)-333((1997).)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
52 0 obj
<<
/Length 8172
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 134.76 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(50)-2662(Mic)26(hael)-361(Beeson)]TJ
0 -2.8908 TD
(22.)Tj
1.87367 -0.00001 TD
[(Bro)28(wn,)-1285(C.,)-1272(QEPCAD-B,)-1271(a)-1271(program)-1282(for)-1284(computing)-1258(with)-1271(semi-)]TJ
-0.52195 -1.23126 TD
[(algebraic)-1511(sets)-1484(using)-1472(CADs,)-1486(to)-1484(app)-27(ear.)-1485(Preprin)27(t)-1472(a)27(v)54(ailable)-1499(at)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(h)26(ttp://www.cs.usna.edu/)-762(w)27(cbro)27(wn/researc)29(h/MOTS2002.2.p)-26(df.)-790(The)-737(program)]TJ
T*
[(itself)-360(is)-361(a)27(v)54(ailable)-348(from)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(h)26(ttp://www.cs.usna.edu/)-293(qep)-27(cad/B/QEPCAD.h)27(tml,)-280(and)-255(\fv)27(e)-255(example)-253(problems)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(can)-348(b)-27(e)-348(view)27(ed)-336(at)]TJ
T*
[(h)26(ttp://www.cs.usna.edu/)-387(qep)-27(cad/B/examples/Examples.h)30(tml.)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(23.)-575(Buc)27(h)26(b)-27(erger,)-333(B.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
9.22112 0 Td
[(et.)-375(al.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
2.93095 0 Td
[(Theorema:)-360(An)-322(In)26(tegrated)-332(System)-320(for)-347(Computation)-347(and)]TJ
-10.80035 -1.23127 TD
[(Deduction)-375(in)-375(Natural)-374(St)27(yle,)-375(in:)-375(Kirc)27(hner,)-375(C.,)-388(and)-376(Kirc)28(hner,)-376(H.)-375((eds.),)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
31.93263 0 Td
-0.053 Tc
[(P)-53(ro)1(ceed)-53(-)]TJ
-31.93263 -1.21788 TD
0 Tc
[(ings)-322(of)-322(the)-321(Workshop)-334(on)-322(Inte)54(gr)53(ation)-349(of)-307(De)52(ductive)-335(Systems)-348(at)-321(CADE-15,)-322(Lindau,)]TJ
T*
[(Germany,)-389(July)-362(1998)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
9.12743 0 Td
[(,)-361(LNAI)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
3.5332 0 Td
(1421)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
2.35547 0 Td
[(,)-361(Springer,)-349(Berlin)-361((1998).)]TJ
-16.36782 -1.23127 TD
[(24.)-575(Buc)27(h)26(b)-27(erger,)-293(B.,)-308(Collins,)-321(G.,)-308(and)-295(Lo)-26(os,)-307(R.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
20.74417 0 Td
[(Computer)-335(A)27(lgebr)53(a:)-335(Symb)52(olic)-321(and)-335(A)27(l-)]TJ
-19.39245 -1.21788 TD
[(gebr)52(aic)-389(Manipulation)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
9.43525 0 Td
[(,)-348(second)-348(edition,)-348(Springer-V)80(erlag)-347(Wien/)-348(New)-349(Y)80(ork)-333((1983).)]TJ
-10.78697 -1.21788 TD
[(25.)-575(Bundy)80(,)-482(A.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
7.40098 0 Td
[(The)-522(Computer)-536(Mo)53(del)-53(ling)-510(of)-508(Mathematic)53(al)-522(R)53(e)53(asoning)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
24.4112 0 Td
[(,)-522(Academic)]TJ
-30.46046 -1.21788 TD
[(Press,)-360(London)-349((1983).)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.23127 TD
[(26.)-575(Bo)-26(ole,)-468(G.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
6.95933 0 Td
[(The)-469(L)53(aws)-468(of)-455(Thought)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
9.82337 0 Td
[(,)-482(Do)28(v)27(er,)-441(New)-456(Y)80(ork)-427((1958).)-466(Original)-467(edition,)]TJ
-15.43098 -1.21788 TD
[(MacMillan)-374((1854).)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(27.)-575(Borsuk,)-360(K.,)-348(and)-348(Szmielew,)-375(W.)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
15.84587 0 Td
[(F)80(oundations)-402(of)-374(Ge)53(ometry)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
11.36245 0 Td
[(,)-375(North-Holland,)-361(Am-)]TJ
-25.8566 -1.21788 TD
[(sterdam,)-360((1960).)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.23127 TD
[(28.)-575(Ca)27(viness,)-267(B.F.,)-267(and)-242(Johnson,)-254(J.R.)-268((eds.))]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
19.78057 0 Td
[(Quanti\fer)-309(Elimination)-268(and)-281(Cylindric)52(al)]TJ
-18.42885 -1.21788 TD
[(A)27(lgebr)52(aic)-388(De)52(c)54(omp)53(osition)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
10.93418 0 Td
[(,)-361(Springer,)-349(Wien/New)-348(Y)80(ork)-334((1998).)]TJ
-12.2859 -1.21788 TD
[(29.)-575(Ch)27(urc)26(h,)-442(A.,)-455(An)-429(unsolv)53(able)-455(problem)-454(of)-455(elemen)27(tary)-453(n)26(um)27(b)-28(er)-428(theory)82(,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
32.66872 0 Td
[(A)27(meric)52(an)]TJ
-31.317 -1.23127 TD
[(Journal)-388(of)-362(Mathematics)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
11.02787 0 Td
(58)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.5257 0 Td
[(345{363,)-385(1936.)]TJ
-13.90528 -1.21788 TD
[(30.)-575(Clark)28(e,)-428(E.,)-428(and)-416(Zhao,)-428(X.:)-415(Analytica:)-428(A)-415(Theorem)-427(Pro)28(v)27(er)-415(in)-415(Mathematica,)-440(in:)]TJ
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(Kapur,)-562(D.)-562((ed.),)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
8.31105 0 Td
[(A)27(utomate)54(d)-589(De)53(duction:)-589(CADE-11:)-576(Pr)53(o)54(c.)-576(of)-563(the)-588(11th)-589(Inter-)]TJ
-8.31105 -1.21788 TD
[(national)-549(Confer)52(enc)52(e)-576(on)-549(A)27(utomate)54(d)-562(De)53(duction)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
21.15905 0 Td
[(,)-562(pp.)-523(761{765,)-573(Springer-V)80(erlag,)]TJ
-21.15905 -1.23126 TD
[(Berlin/Heidelb)-28(erg)-373((1992).)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(31.)-575(Collins,)-535(G.E.,)-522(Quan)26(ti\fer)-494(elimination)-535(for)-508(real)-521(closed)-521(\felds)-509(b)26(y)-495(cylindrical)-509(al-)]TJ
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(gebraic)-481(decomp)-27(osition,)-481(in:)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
12.4465 0 Td
[(Pr)53(o)54(c.)-482(2nd)-483(Conf.)-469(on)-482(A)27(utomata)-494(The)53(ory)-496(and)-495(F)80(ormal)]TJ
-12.4465 -1.23127 TD
[(L)53(anguages)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
4.5771 0 Td
[(,)-375(Springer)-348(LNCS)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
7.84263 0 Td
(33)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.5257 0 Td
[(134{183.)-385(Reprin)26(ted)-321(in)-348([28],)-361(pp.)-349(85-121.)]TJ
-15.29715 -1.21788 TD
[(32.)-575(Con)27(w)27(a)27(y)80(,)-254(J.,)-268(and)-254(Sloane,)-268(N.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
14.17295 0 Td
[(Spher)52(e)-308(Packings,)-296(L)53(attic)54(es)-322(and)-281(Gr)54(oups)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
16.58195 0 Td
[(,)-294(Grundlehren)]TJ
-29.40318 -1.21788 TD
[(Der)-320(Mathematisc)29(hen)-322(Wissensc)27(haften)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
16.80947 0 Td
(290)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.7666 0 Td
[(,)-335(Springer-V)80(erlag,)-320(Berlin/)-334(Heidelb)-28(erg/)]TJ
-18.57607 -1.23127 TD
[(New)-348(Y)80(ork)-334((1998).)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(33.)-575(Cop)-27(e,)-348(D.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
6.5043 0 Td
[(Computers)-388(and)-375(Music)53(al)-375(Style)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
13.12905 0 Td
[(,)-361(A-R)-322(Editions,)-361(Madison)-347((1991).)]TJ
-19.63335 -1.21788 TD
[(34.)-575(Cop)-27(e,)-348(D.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
6.5043 0 Td
[(Exp)53(eriments)-389(in)-362(Music)53(al)-375(Intel)-53(ligenc)52(e)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
16.00647 0 Td
[(,)-348(A-R)-321(Editions,)-361(Madison)-348((1996).)]TJ
-22.51077 -1.21788 TD
[(35.)-575(Cop)-27(e,)-348(D.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
6.5043 0 Td
[(The)-375(A)27(lgorithmic)-376(Comp)54(oser)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12.11192 0 Td
[(,)-361(A-R)-322(Editions,)-361(Madison)-360((2000).)]TJ
-18.61621 -1.21788 TD
[(36.)-575(Da)28(v)27(enp)-28(ort,)-239(J.,)-268(and)-255(Hein)26(tz,)-254(J.,)-267(Real)-254(quan)26(ti\fer)-240(elimination)-281(is)-253(doubly)-242(exp)-27(onen)26(tial,)]TJ
1.35172 -1.23127 TD
[(in)-349([4],)-361(pp.)-335(29{35.)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(37.)-575(Da)28(vis,)-388(M.,)-414(A)-389(computer)-387(program)-399(for)-414(Presburger's)-399(algorithm,)-413(in)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
30.76828 0 Td
[(Summaries)-416(of)]TJ
-29.41656 -1.21788 TD
[(T)80(alks)-281(Pr)54(esente)52(d)-308(at)-267(the)-294(Summer)-269(Institute)-294(for)-268(Symb)53(olic)-268(L)53(o)53(gic,)-269(1957)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
28.89462 0 Td
[(Second)-229(edition,)]TJ
-28.89462 -1.23127 TD
[(published)-337(b)27(y)-335(Institute)-333(for)-347(Defense)-361(Analysis,)-347(1960.)-373(Reprin)26(ted)-321(in)-348([92],)-361(pp.)-335(41-48.)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(38.)-575(Da)28(vis,)-428(M.)-441(The)-442(prehistory)-427(and)-429(early)-440(history)-440(of)-441(automated)-440(deduction,)-430(in)-428([92],)]TJ
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(pp.)-349(1{28.)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(39.)-575(Da)28(vis,)-280(M.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
7.01287 0 Td
[(The)-322(Universal)-322(Computer:)-322(The)-321(R)53(o)54(ad)-308(fr)53(om)-321(L)53(eibniz)-310(to)-320(T)80(uring)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
26.23133 0 Td
[(,)-294(Norton)]TJ
-31.89248 -1.23127 TD
[((2000).)-372(Reprin)26(ted)-321(in)-348(2001)-360(under)-336(the)-334(title)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
18.72328 0 Td
[(Engines)-377(of)-361(L)53(o)54(gic)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
7.41437 0 Td
(.)Tj
-27.48936 -1.21788 TD
[(40.)-575(Da)28(vis,)-347(M.,)-362(and)-348(Putnam,)-361(H.,)-348(A)-349(computing)-347(pro)-27(cedure)-348(for)-360(quan)26(ti\fcation)-347(theory)82(,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(JA)27(CM)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
3.27892 0 Td
(7)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.93683 0 Td
[(201-215,)-372(1960.)]TJ
-5.56747 -1.23127 TD
[(41.)-575(Ernst,)-266(Z.,)-268(Fitelson,)-281(B.,)-280(Harris,)-266(K.,)-268(McCune,)-282(W.,)-268(V)80(ero\013,)-267(R.,)-255(W)80(os,)-280(L.,)-268(More)-280(First-)]TJ
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(order)-240(T)80(est)-226(Problems)-253(in)-228(Math)-241(and)-228(Logic,)-240(in:)-242(Sutcli\013e,)-228(G.,)-254(P)26(elletier,)-253(J.)-241(and)-228(Suttner,)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
53 0 obj
<<
/Length 9069
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 290.52 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(The)-335(Mec)27(hanization)-361(of)-361(Mathematics)-2674(51)]TJ
-16.01985 -2.8908 TD
(C.)Tj
1.39187 -0.00001 TD
[((eds.))-735(Pro)-26(ceedings)-375(of)-374(the)-361(CADE-18)-374(W)80(orkshop{Problems)-372(and)-362(Problem)-373(Sets)]TJ
-1.39187 -1.23126 TD
[(for)-333(A)80(TP,)-335(T)80(ec)27(hnical)-335(Rep)-28(ort)-319(02/10,)-346(Departmen)28(t)-321(of)-334(Computer)-320(Science,)-336(Univ)26(ersit)29(y)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(of)-428(Cop)-27(enhagen,)-429(Cop)-26(enhagen)-416((2002).)-439(The)-415(pap)-28(er)-414(and)-402(asso)-25(ciated)-441(Otter)-400(\fles)-429(can)]TJ
T*
[(b)-27(e)-348(accessed)-361(from)-346(h)26(ttp://www.mcs.anl.go)30(v/)-401(mccune/pap)-28(ers/paps-2002.)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.15097 TD
[(42.)-575(Fisc)27(her,)-348(M.)-334(J.,)-362(and)-321(Rabin,)-335(M.)-348(O.,)-335(Sup)-28(er-exp)-27(onen)27(tial)-321(complexit)28(y)-334(of)-348(Presburger)]TJ
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
(arithmetic,)Tj
/F5 1 Tf
5.32657 0 Td
[(SIAM-AMS)-430(Pr)54(o)53(c)53(e)53(e)54(dings)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
10.80035 0 Td
[(,)-455(V)80(olume)-401(VI)-27(I,)-401(pp.)-416(27{41;)-440(reprin)27(ted)-401(in)-416([28],)]TJ
-16.12691 -1.23127 TD
[(pp.)-349(122{135.)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.15096 TD
[(43.)-575(F)80(rege,)-400(G.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
6.7452 0 Td
[(Be)53(gri\013shrift,)-429(a)-415(formula)-415(language,)-429(mo)53(dele)53(d)-428(up)54(on)-429(that)-427(of)-415(arithmetic,)]TJ
-5.39348 -1.21788 TD
[(for)-375(pur)53(e)-375(thought.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
7.50805 0 Td
[(,)-375(English)-348(translation)-359(in)-348([102],)-374(pp.)-336(1{82.)-359(Original)-361(date)-347(1879.)]TJ
-8.85977 -1.15097 TD
[(44.)-575(Gelern)27(ter,)-414(H.,)-429(Realization)-427(of)-427(a)-415(geometry-theorem)-424(pro)27(ving)-401(mac)28(hine,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
32.88285 0 Td
[(Pr)53(o)54(c.)-442(In-)]TJ
-31.53113 -1.21788 TD
[(ternational)-522(Confer)52(enc)52(e)-509(on)-496(Information)-496(Pr)54(o)53(c)53(essing,)-510(UNESCO)-495(House)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
31.75865 0 Td
(273{282,)Tj
-31.75865 -1.21788 TD
[((1959).)-359(Reprin)27(ted)-335(in)-335(F)80(eigen)27(baum)-348(and)-335(F)80(eldman)-335((eds.),)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
24.47812 0 Td
[(Computers)-388(and)-375(Thought)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
10.85388 0 Td
(,)Tj
-35.33199 -1.23127 TD
[(McGra)28(w-Hill,)-375(New)-349(Y)80(ork)-320((1963).)-372(Reprin)27(ted)-322(again)-360(in)-349([92],)-360(pp.)-336(99-124.)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.15097 TD
(45.)Tj
1.99412 0.25428 TD
<7F>Tj
-0.12045 -0.25428 TD
[(Ub)-27(er)-281(formal)-306(unen)25(tsc)28(heidbare)-282<537F>509(atze)-294(der)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
17.5857 0 Td
[(Principia)-323(Mathematic)53(a)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
10.53268 0 Td
[(und)-269(v)27(erw)27(andter)]TJ
-28.64033 -1.21788 TD
[(Systems)-239(I,)-241(in:)-241(F)80(eferman,)-253(S.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
12.23237 0 Td
[(et.)-268(al.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
2.74358 0 Td
((eds.),)Tj
/F5 1 Tf
3.03802 0 Td
[(Kurt)-280<477F>522(odel:)-281(Col)-53(le)53(cte)53(d)-281(Works,)-281(V)80(olume)-281(I,)]TJ
-18.01397 -1.21788 TD
[(Public)53(ations)-348(1929-1936)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
10.29178 0 Td
[(,)-348(pp.)-309(144-195.)-332(\(The)-321(translation,)-333(On)-294(formally)-333(undecidable)]TJ
-10.29178 -1.23127 TD
[(prop)-27(ositions)-359(of)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
6.95933 0 Td
[(Principia)-363(Mathematic)53(a)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
10.61298 0 Td
[(and)-322(related)-347(systems)-332(I,)-334(app)-27(ears)-347(on)-321(facing)]TJ
-17.57232 -1.21788 TD
[(pages.\))-266(Oxford)-240(Univ)26(ersit)28(y)-240(Press,)-253(New)-255(Y)80(ork,)-240(and)-241(Clarendon)-255(Press,)-266(Oxford)-240((1986).)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.15097 TD
[(46.)-575(Grigor'ev,)-359(D.,)-348(and)-348(V)80(orob)-53(jo)28(v,)-348(N.,)-348(Solving)-348(systems)-346(of)-347(p)-27(olynomial)-360(inequalities)-361(in)]TJ
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(sub)-27(exp)-27(onen)26(tial)-347(time.)-347(J.)-348(Sym)27(b.)-335(Comput.)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
18.29502 0 Td
(5)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.58887 0 Td
[(,)-348(37-64,)-360(1988.)]TJ
-20.2356 -1.15096 TD
[(47.)-575(Guard,)-294(J.,)-321(Oglesb)27(y)80(,)-294(F.,)-308(Bennett,)-294(J.,)-308(and)-295(Settle,)-308(L.,)-308(Semi-automated)-293(mathemat-)]TJ
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
(ics,)Tj
/F5 1 Tf
1.77998 0 Td
[(JA)27(CM)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
3.27892 0 Td
(16)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.17773 0 Td
[((1))-347(49{62,)-372(1969.)]TJ
-7.58835 -1.15096 TD
[(48.)-575(Harrison,)-400(J.,)-401(and)-389(Th)26<13>483(ery)81(,)-389(L.:)-388(Extending)-388(the)-389(HOL)-375(theorem)-387(pro)27(v)28(er)-388(with)-388(a)-401(com-)]TJ
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(puter)-335(algebra)-346(system)-333(to)-347(reason)-346(ab)-27(out)-334(the)-335(reals,)-347(in)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
22.76505 0 Td
[(Higher)-362(Or)53(der)-375(L)53(o)54(gic)-376(The)53(or)53(em)]TJ
-22.76505 -1.23127 TD
[(Pr)53(oving)-443(and)-428(its)-428(Applic)53(ations:)-428(6th)-428(International)-442(Workshop,)-442(HUG)-428('93)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
31.06272 0 Td
[(,)-402(pp.)-402(174{)]TJ
-31.06272 -1.21788 TD
[(184,)-360(Lecture)-348(Notes)-347(in)-335(Computer)-347(Science)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
18.44223 0 Td
(780)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.7666 0 Td
[(,)-361(Springer-V)80(erlag)-334((1993).)]TJ
-21.56055 -1.15097 TD
[(49.)-575(Harrison,)-761(J.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
8.63225 0 Td
[(The)53(or)53(em)-750(Pr)54(oving)-765(with)-748(the)-763(R)53(e)53(al)-736(Numb)54(ers)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
20.03485 0 Td
[(,)-776(Springer-V)80(erlag,)]TJ
-27.31538 -1.21788 TD
[(Berlin/Heidelb)-28(erg/New)-373(Y)80(ork)-334((1998).)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.15097 TD
[(50.)-575(Hilb)-27(ert,)-454(D.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
7.6285 0 Td
[(Grund)-54(lagen)-496(der)-482(Ge)53(ometrie)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12.2056 0 Td
[(,)-482(T)80(eubner)-456((1899).)-465(English)-482(translation)]TJ
-18.48238 -1.21788 TD
[(\(of)-374(the)-348(10th)-360(edition,)-375(whic)26(h)-362(app)-27(eared)-361(in)-348(1962\):)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
21.17243 0 Td
[(F)80(oundations)-402(of)-374(Ge)53(ometry)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
11.36245 0 Td
[(,)-388(Op)-27(en)]TJ
-32.53488 -1.23127 TD
[(Court,)-361(La)-347(Salle,)-349(Illinois)-360((1987).)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.13758 TD
[(51.)-575(Hilb)-27(ert,)-321(D.,)-334(and)-322(Ac)27(k)27(ermann,)-321(W.,)-335('Grundzge)-322(der)-334(theoretisc)28(hen)-322(Logik',)-347(2nd)-322(edi-)]TJ
1.35172 -1.23126 TD
[(tion)-414(\(1938;)-427(\frst)-400(edition)-415(1928\).)-440(English)-415(translation:)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
23.4476 0 Td
[(Principles)-430(of)-428(Mathematic)53(al)]TJ
-23.4476 -1.21788 TD
[(L)53(o)54(gic)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
2.31532 0 Td
[(,)-388(translated)-373(b)26(y)-347(Lewis)-389(M.)-374(Hammond,)-361(George)-387(G.)-375(Lec)27(kie)-362(and)-361(F.)-375(Steinhardt;)]TJ
-2.31532 -1.21788 TD
[(edited)-389(with)-401(notes)-388(b)27(y)-375(Rob)-26(ert)-387(E.)-402(Luce,)-389(Chelsea)-415((1950).)-412(The)-389(translation)-412(is)-388(to)-401(b)-27(e)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(reprin)27(ted)-335(b)26(y)-334(the)-335(A.)-348(M.)-348(S.)-348(in)-335(2003.)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.15096 TD
[(52.)-575(Hong,)-522(H.,)-522(Simple)-522(solution)-535(form)28(ula)-535(construction)-534(in)-523(cylindrical)-535(algebraic)-534(de-)]TJ
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(comp)-26(osition)-347(based)-321(quan)26(ti\fer)-307(elimination,)-348(in:)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
20.26237 0 Td
[(Pr)53(o)54(c.)-349(International)-362(Symp)53(osium)-348(on)]TJ
-20.26237 -1.21788 TD
[(Symb)52(olic)-508(and)-509(A)26(lgebr)53(aic)-509(Computation)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
16.92992 0 Td
[(,)-509(pp.)-482(177-188,)-506(A)26(CM,)-495(1992.)-520(Reprin)26(ted)-468(in)]TJ
-16.92992 -1.23127 TD
[([28],)-374(pp.)-336(210{210.)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.13758 TD
[(53.)-575(Horgan,)-347(J.,)-361(The)-349(death)-334(of)-348(pro)-26(of,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
16.34105 0 Td
[(Scienti\fc)-377(A)27(meric)52(an)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
8.79285 0 Td
[(,)-348(Octob)-26(er)-348(1993,)-373(74{82.)]TJ
-25.1339 -1.15096 TD
[(54.)-575(Huang,)-442(T.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
7.29392 0 Td
[(A)27(utomate)54(d)-482(De)53(duction)-482(in)-456(R)27(ing)-456(The)53(ory)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
17.23773 0 Td
[(,)-468(Master's)-466(W)80(riting)-441(Pro)-53(ject,)]TJ
-23.17993 -1.23126 TD
[(Departmen)28(t)-334(of)-361(Computer)-347(Science,)-349(San)-335(Jose)-361(State)-333(Univ)26(ersit)28(y)-334((2002).)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.13758 TD
[(55.)-575(G.)-388(Huet.)-549(A)-375(uni\fcation)-389(algorithm)-399(for)-387(t)27(yp)-27(ed)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
21.90852 0 Td
<15>Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
(-calculus.)Tj
/F5 1 Tf
4.7377 0 Td
[(The)53(or)53(etic)53(al)-428(Computer)]TJ
-25.89675 -1.23127 TD
[(Scienc)51(e)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
3.65365 0 Td
(1)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.93683 0 Td
[((1975))-359(27{52.)]TJ
-5.9422 -1.15096 TD
[(56.)-575(Jacobsen,)-361(N.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
8.20398 0 Td
[(Basic)-361(A)26(lgebr)53(a)-388(I)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.9058 0 Td
[(,)-335((1985).)]TJ
-15.10978 -1.13758 TD
[(57.)-575(Kaltofen,)-360(E.,)-348(F)80(actorization)-359(of)-360(p)-28(olynomials,)-359(in)-349([24],)-360(pp.)-336(95{114.)]TJ
0 -1.15097 TD
[(58.)-575(Kamm)-25<7F>]TJ
4.88492 0 Td
[(uller,)-348(F.,)-335(and)-322(P)27(aulson,)-348(L.,)-335(A)-308(formal)-346(pro)-26(of)-347(of)-334(Sylo)27(w's)-335(theorem:)-333(an)-334(exp)-27(er-)]TJ
-3.5332 -1.23127 TD
[(imen)27(t)-401(in)-389(abstract)-399(algebra)-414(with)-388(Isab)-26(elle)-415(HOL,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
20.94492 0 Td
[(J.)-415(A)27(utomate)54(d)-429(R)54(e)53(asoning)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
11.4026 0 Td
(23)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.17773 0 Td
[(,)-402(pp.)]TJ
-33.52525 -1.21788 TD
[(235{264,)-385(1999.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
54 0 obj
<<
/Length 8750
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 134.76 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(52)-2662(Mic)26(hael)-361(Beeson)]TJ
0 -2.8908 TD
(59.)Tj
1.87367 -0.00001 TD
[(Kapur,)-308(D.,)-321(and)-308(Zhang,)-322(H.,)-321(An)-309(o)28(v)27(erview)-308(of)-334(Rewrite)-320(Rule)-308(Lab)-27(oratory)-318((RRL),)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
34.26133 0 Td
(J.)Tj
-34.78328 -1.23126 TD
[(of)-362(Computer)-388(and)-375(Mathematics)-388(with)-375(Applic)54(ations)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
21.78806 0 Td
(,)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
0.6424 0 Td
(29)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.5257 0 Td
[(2,)-348(91{114,1995.)]TJ
-25.30788 -1.21788 TD
[(60.)-575(Kleene,)-348(S.)-362(C.,)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
8.40473 0 Td
<15>Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.60225 0 Td
[(-de\fnabilit)26(y)-335(and)-348(recursiv)28(eness,)-361(Duk)27(e)-335(Mathematical)-372(Journal)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
27.10125 0 Td
(2)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.58887 0 Td
(,)Tj
-35.34538 -1.21788 TD
[(pp.)-349(340{353,)-372(1936.)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(61.)-575(Kleene,)-603(S.)-589(C.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
9.14082 0 Td
[(Intr)54(o)53(duction)-629(to)-602(Metamathematics)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
15.37745 0 Td
[(,)-642(v)53(an)-575(Nostrand,)-601(Princeton)]TJ
-23.16655 -1.23127 TD
((1952).)Tj
-1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(62.)-575(Kn)27(uth,)-335(D.)-348(E.,)-361(and)-349(Bendix,)-348(P)80(.)-362(B.,)-361(Simple)-362(w)27(ord)-347(problems)-361(in)-348(univ)26(ersal)-360(algebras,)]TJ
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(in:)-415(Leec)26(h,)-416(J.)-415((ed).,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
8.833 0 Td
[(Computational)-441(Pr)53(oblems)-442(in)-415(A)27(bstr)53(act)-468(A)27(lgebr)52(as)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
21.09213 0 Td
[(pp.)-403(263{297,)]TJ
-29.92513 -1.23127 TD
[(P)27(ergamon)-360(Press)-360((1970).)-358(Reprin)26(ted)-321(in)-349([93],)-360(pp.)-349(342{376.)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(63.)-575(Kn)27(uth,)-295(D.)-321(E.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
8.33782 0 Td
[(Seminumeric)51(al)-348(A)27(lgorithms:)-348(The)-362(A)27(rt)-348(of)-348(Computer)-362(Pr)54(o)53(gr)53(amming,)]TJ
-6.9861 -1.21788 TD
[(V)80(olume)-374(2)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
4.22913 0 Td
[(,)-348(second)-348(edition,)-348(Addison-W)79(esley)81(,)-335(Reading,)-348(MA)-348((1981).)]TJ
-5.58085 -1.21788 TD
[(64.)-575(Kurosh,)-334(A.)-348(G.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
8.87315 0 Td
[(The)-375(The)53(ory)-389(of)-361(Gr)54(oups,)-388(volume)-362(1)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
14.6949 0 Td
[(,)-361(Chelsea,)-362(New)-348(Y)80(ork)-333((1955).)]TJ
-23.56805 -1.23127 TD
[(65.)-575(Lang,)-348(S.)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
5.9422 0 Td
[(A)27(lgebr)52(a)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
3.30568 0 Td
[(,)-361(Addison-W)79(esley)81(,)-321(Reading,)-348(MA.)-349((1965).)]TJ
-9.24788 -1.21788 TD
[(66.)-575(Lewis,)-361(P)27(aul,)-348(obituary)-347(of)-348(Herb)-334(Simon,)-349(h)27(ttp://www.cs.osw)29(ego.edu/)-415(blue/hx/)]TJ
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(courses/cogsci1/s2001/s)-6(ectio)-13(n04/s)-12(ubsection01)-13(/mai)-12(n.h)26(tml.)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(67.)-575(Mancuso,)-280(P)80(.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
7.84263 0 Td
[(F)80(r)53(om)-294(Br)53(ouwer)-321(to)-307(Hilb)53(ert)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
10.85388 0 Td
[(,)-268(Oxford)-266(Univ)26(ersit)28(y)-254(Press,)-280(Oxford)-253((1998).)]TJ
-18.69652 -1.23127 TD
[(68.)-575(Maslo)29(v,)-268(S.,)-268(Min)26(ts,)-253(G.,)-268(and)-255(Orevk)28(o)27(v,)-240(V.,)-255(Mec)27(hanical)-281(pro)-27(of-searc)29(h)-268(and)-241(the)-255(theory)]TJ
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(of)-361(logical)-373(deduction)-336(in)-335(the)-348(USSR,)-322(in:)-349([92],)-361(pp.)-349(29{37.)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(69.)-575(Mo)-26(ore,)-1190(G.)-1164(E.,)-1178(Cramming)-1190(more)-1176(comp)-26(onen)26(ts)-1164(on)27(to)-1163(in)26(tegrated)-1176(cir-)]TJ
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
(cuits,)Tj
/F5 1 Tf
3.39937 0 Td
[(Ele)54(ctr)53(onics)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
5.88867 0 Td
(38)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.17773 0 Td
[(,)-1004(Num)27(b)-28(er)-989(8,)-1004(pp.)-991(April)-991(18,)-1016(1965.)-1029(Av)54(ailable)-1004(at)]TJ
-10.46577 -1.23127 TD
[(h)26(ttp://www.in)28(tel.com/researc)30(h/silicon/)-13(mo)-26(or)-12(espap)-27(er.p)-27(df.)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(70.)-575(McCune,)-482(W.,)-483(Otter)-467(2.0,)-481(in:)-482(Stic)27(k)27(el,)-469(M.)-481(E.)-482((ed.),)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
24.8127 0 Td
[(10th)-495(International)-509(Confer-)]TJ
-23.46098 -1.21788 TD
[(enc)52(e)-415(on)-402(A)27(utomate)54(d)-415(De)53(duction)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
13.90528 0 Td
[(pp.)-376(663{664,)-412(Springer-V)80(erlag,)-373(Berlin/Heidelb)-28(erg)]TJ
-13.90528 -1.23127 TD
((1990).)Tj
-1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(71.)-575(McCune,)-362(W.,Solution)-362(of)-361(the)-348(Robbins)-335(problem,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
23.2067 0 Td
[(J.)-375(A)27(utomate)54(d)-402(R)53(e)54(asoning)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
11.28215 0 Td
(19)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.17773 0 Td
((3))Tj
-34.31486 -1.21788 TD
[(263{276,)-385(1997.)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(72.)-575(McCune,)-268(W.,)-268(and)-255(P)27(admanabhan,)-255(R.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
18.52253 0 Td
[(A)27(utomate)54(d)-308(De)53(duction)-308(in)-295(Equational)-294(L)53(o)53(gic)]TJ
-17.17082 -1.23126 TD
[(and)-375(Cubic)-376(Curves)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
7.97647 0 Td
[(,)-361(LNAI)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
3.54658 0 Td
(1095)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
2.35547 0 Td
[(,)-348(Springer,)-348(Berlin/)-361(Heidelb)-28(erg)-347((1996).)]TJ
-15.23023 -1.21788 TD
[(73.)-575(Monk,)-347(J.)-348(D.,)-348(The)-348(mathematics)-359(of)-347(Bo)-27(olean)-374(algebra,)-360(in)-349(the)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
28.07823 0 Td
[(Stanfor)53(d)-388(Dictionary)]TJ
-26.72651 -1.21788 TD
[(of)-362(Philosophy)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
6.00912 0 Td
[(,)-361(h)26(ttp://plato.stanford.edu/en)29(tries/b)-25(o)-27(olalg-math.)]TJ
-7.36083 -1.23127 TD
[(74.)-575(New)27(ell,)-308(A.,)-295(Sha)26(w,)-308(J.)-308(C.,)-308(Simon,)-294(H.,)-308(Empirical)-307(explorations)-306(with)-308(the)-295(Logic)-307(The-)]TJ
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(ory)-333(Mac)27(hine:)-349(a)-334(case)-347(study)-308(in)-335(heuristics,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
18.05412 0 Td
[(Pr)53(o)54(c)53(e)53(e)53(dings)-389(of)-348(the)-375(Western)-375(Joint)-375(Com-)]TJ
-18.05412 -1.21788 TD
[(puter)-361(Confer)52(enc)52(e,)-349(Institute)-360(of)-335(R)54(adio)-348(Engine)51(ers)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
21.15905 0 Td
[(218-230,)-332(1957.)-333(Reprin)26(ted)-307(in)-309([92],)]TJ
-21.15905 -1.23127 TD
[(pp.)-349(49{74.)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(75.)-575(P)27(eano,)-240(G.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
6.73182 0 Td
[(A)27(rithmetic)53(es)-295(principia,)-256(nova)-282(metho)53(do)-294(exp)53(osita)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
20.34267 0 Td
[(,)-268(Bo)-26(cca,)-254(T)80(urin,)-241((1889).)]TJ
-27.07448 -1.21788 TD
[(76.)-575(Pietrzyk)29(o)27(wski,)-374(T.,)-389(and)-361(Jensen,)-376(D.,)-374(A)-362(complete)-374(mec)27(hanization)-374(of)-388(second)-374(order)]TJ
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
(logic,)Tj
/F5 1 Tf
2.69005 0 Td
[(J.)-362(Asso)54(c.)-375(Comp.)-362(Mach.)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
10.85388 0 Td
(20)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.5257 0 Td
[((2),)-347(1971,)-359(pp.)-349(333-364.)]TJ
-16.42135 -1.23127 TD
[(77.)-575(Pietrzyk)29(o)27(wski,)-374(T.,)-375(and)-375(Jensen,)-376(D.,)-361(A)-361(complete)-374(mec)27(hanization)-388(of)]TJ
/F10 1 Tf
31.29023 0 Td
(!)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.68255 0 Td
[(-order)-360(t)27(yp)-27(e)]TJ
-30.62107 -1.21788 TD
[(theory)82(,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
3.42613 0 Td
[(Asso)54(c.)-389(Comp.)-361(Math.)-362(Nat.)-374(Conf.)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
14.65475 0 Td
[(1972,)-360(V)80(ol.)-347(1,)-361(82-92.)]TJ
-19.4326 -1.21788 TD
[(78.)-575(P)27(oincar)28<13>]TJ
5.27303 0 Td
[(e,)-469(H.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
2.99787 0 Td
[(Scienc)51(e)-495(and)-469(Metho)53(d)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
9.11405 0 Td
[(,)-482(translated)-453(b)26(y)-441(Maitland)-468(from)-467(the)-455(original)]TJ
-16.03323 -1.21788 TD
[(F)80(renc)27(h)-335(edition)-348(of)-361(1908,)-360(Do)28(v)27(er)-334((1952).)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.23127 TD
[(79.)-575(P)27(enrose,)-280(R.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
7.48128 0 Td
[(The)-308(Emp)53(er)53(or's)-308(New)-294(Mind:)-283(Conc)53(erning)-323(Computers,)-308(Minds,)-283(and)-308(the)]TJ
-6.12957 -1.21788 TD
[(L)53(aws)-361(of)-348(Physics)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
7.45452 0 Td
[(,)-321(American)-321(Philological)-374(Asso)-25(ciation)-334((1989).)-345(See)-322(also)-333(the)-321(review)]TJ
-7.45452 -1.21788 TD
[(b)26(y)-428(McCarth)28(y)81(,)-442(J.,)-442(in)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
9.52893 0 Td
[(Bul)-53(letin)-442(of)-455(the)-468(A)27(meric)52(an)-456(Mathematic)53(al)-468(So)53(ciety)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
21.45348 0 Td
[(,)-455(Octob)-26(er,)]TJ
-30.98242 -1.23127 TD
(1990.)Tj
-1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(80.)-575(P)27(enrose,)-641(R.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
8.21737 0 Td
[(Shadows)-642(of)-629(the)-643(Mind:)-630(A)-629(Se)53(ar)53(ch)-656(for)-629(the)-643(Missing)-630(Scienc)51(e)-643(of)]TJ
-6.86565 -1.21788 TD
(Consciousness)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
6.39723 0 Td
[(,)-669(Oxford)-642(Univ)27(ersit)28(y)-616(Press,)-654(Oxford)-628((1996).)-653(See)-643(also)-654(the)-630(crit-)]TJ
-6.39723 -1.23127 TD
[(ical)-803(reviews)-802(b)27(y)-763(McCarth)28(y)80(,)-789(J.,)-803(in)-790(the)-777(electronic)-802(journal)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
28.56003 0 Td
(Psyche)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
3.86778 0 Td
(2)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.37848 0 Td
((11))Tj
-33.80629 -1.21788 TD
[((1995),)-372(h)26(ttp://psyc)29(he.cs.monash.edu.au/v2/psyc)28(he-2-11-mccarth)29(y)80(.h)27(tml,)-374(and)-349(b)27(y)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
55 0 obj
<<
/Length 8175
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 290.52 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(The)-335(Mec)27(hanization)-361(of)-361(Mathematics)-2674(53)]TJ
-16.01985 -2.8908 TD
(F)Tj
0.58887 -0.00001 TD
[(eferman,)-454(S.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
5.87528 0 Td
(Psyche)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
3.51982 0 Td
(2)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.58887 0 Td
[((7))-454((1995),)-452(h)26(ttp://psyc)29(he.cs.monash.edu.au/v2/psyc)28(he-)]TJ
-10.57283 -1.23126 TD
[(2-07-feferman.h)29(tml,)-816(and)-790(P)27(enrose's)-802(replies)-802(to)-789(these)-789(and)-777(other)-789(critics,)-815(at)]TJ
0 -1.21788 TD
[(h)26(ttp://psyc)29(he.cs.monash.edu.au/v2/psyc)28(he-2-23-p)-27(enrose.h)28(tml.)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(81.)-575(P)27(etk)28(o)27(v)54<14>]TJ
4.95183 0 Td
[(sek,)-294(M.,)-321(Wilf,)-321(H.,)-308(and)-309(Zeilb)-27(erger,)-320(D.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
16.67563 0 Td
(A=B)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
2.27517 0 Td
[(,)-308(A.)-308(K.)-308(P)27(eters,)-306(W)80(ellesley)80(,)-321(MA)]TJ
-22.55091 -1.23127 TD
((1996).)Tj
-1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(82.)-575(Presburger,)-493(M.,)]TJ
9.64938 0.25428 TD
<7F>Tj
-0.13383 -0.25428 TD
[(Ub)-27(er)-482(die)-482(V)80(ollst\177)510(andigk)27(eit)-495(eines)-495(gewissen)-508(Systems)-480(der)-482(Arith-)]TJ
-8.16383 -1.21788 TD
[(metik)-320(ganzer)-320(Zahlen,)-322(in)-322(w)27(elc)26(hem)-321(die)-322(Addition)-308(als)-321(einzige)-335(Op)-27(eration)-320(herv)27(ortritt,)]TJ
T*
[(Sparw)27(ozdanie)-375(z)-362(I)-347(Kongresu)-361(Matemat)29(yk)28(o)-120<13>]TJ
18.25487 0 Td
[(w)-375(Kra)-52(jo)-120<13>]TJ
3.6938 0 Td
[(w)-375(Slo)27(wia)-27<13>]TJ
3.96147 0 Td
[(nskic)27(h)-389(W)80(arsza)29(w)27(a,)-375(pp.)]TJ
-25.91013 -1.23127 TD
[(92-101,)-373(1929.)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(83.)-575(Prior,)-360(A.)-334(N.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
7.88278 0 Td
[(F)80(ormal)-375(L)54(o)53(gic)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
5.8619 0 Td
[(,)-348(second)-348(edition,)-348(Clarendon)-362(Press,)-360(Oxford)-333((1962).)]TJ
-13.74468 -1.21788 TD
[(84.)-575(Renegar,)-320(J.,)-335(Recen)27(t)-308(progress)-332(on)-321(the)-308(complexit)28(y)-321(of)-321(the)-321(decision)-335(problem)-307(for)-334(the)]TJ
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(reals,)-360(in:)-349([28],)-374(pp.)-335(220{241.)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.23127 TD
[(85.)-575(Ric)27(hardson,)-321(D.,)-334(Some)-334(unsolv)54(able)-322(problems)-333(in)26(v)27(olving)-334(elemen)26(tary)-319(functions)-335(of)-334(a)]TJ
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(real)-361(v)54(ariable,)-347(J.)-361(Sym)27(b)-28(olic)-334(Logic)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
14.48077 0 Td
(33)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.5257 0 Td
[(511{520)-385((1968).)]TJ
-17.35818 -1.21788 TD
[(86.)-575(Robinson,)-441(A.,)-456(Pro)28(ving)-455(theorems,)-453(as)-454(done)-456(b)27(y)-428(man,)-455(mac)28(hine,)-457(and)-442(logician,)-481(in)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
1.35172 -1.23127 TD
[(Summaries)-336(of)-321(T)80(alks)-334(Pr)53(esente)52(d)-361(at)-334(the)-348(Summer)-336(Institute)-333(for)-335(Symb)52(olic)-322(L)54(o)53(gic,)-336(1957)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
0 -1.21788 TD
[(Second)-349(edition,)-362(published)-350(b)27(y)-335(Institute)-346(for)-361(Defense)-360(Analysis,)-361(1960.)-373(Reprin)26(ted)-334(in)]TJ
T*
[([92],)-374(pp.)-336(74-76.)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(87.)-575(Robinson,)-294(G.,)-308(and)-295(W)80(os,)-307(L.,)-295(P)27(aramo)-25(dulation)-321(and)-295(theorem-pro)29(ving)-295(in)-294(\frst-order)]TJ
1.35172 -1.23127 TD
[(theories)-333(with)-322(equalit)28(y)80(,)-307(in)-309(Meltzer)-333(and)-309(Mic)27(hie)-322((eds.),)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
23.46098 0 Td
[(Machine)-350(Intel)-53(ligenc)52(e)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
9.5557 0 Td
(4)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.58887 0 Td
[(,)-321(pp.)]TJ
-33.60555 -1.21788 TD
[(135-150,)-372(American)-348(Elsevier,)-360(New)-348(Y)80(ork)-333((1969).)-359(Reprin)26(ted)-321(in)-348([110],)-374(pp.)-336(83{99.)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(88.)-575(Robinson,)-334(G.,)-335(and)-322(W)80(os,)-347(L.,)-335(Completeness)-347(of)-334(paramo)-25(dulation,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
29.75115 0 Td
[(Journal)-362(of)-348(Sym-)]TJ
-28.39943 -1.23127 TD
[(b)53(olic)-375(L)53(o)54(gic)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
5.03213 0 Td
(34)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.17773 0 Td
[(,)-348(p.)-349(160)-360((1969).)-358(Reprin)26(ted)-321(in)-349([110],)-373(pp.)-336(102{103.)]TJ
-7.56158 -1.21788 TD
[(89.)-575(Robinson,)-428(J.)-442(A.,)-442(A)-428(mac)28(hine)-430(orien)27(ted)-428(logic)-454(based)-442(on)-428(the)-429(resolution)-440(principle,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(JA)27(CM)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
3.27892 0 Td
(12)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.17773 0 Td
[(,)-348(23-41,)-360(1965.)-373(Reprin)27(ted)-322(in)-348([92],)-361(pp.)-349(397-415.)]TJ
-5.80837 -1.21788 TD
[(90.)-575(Robinson,)-415(Alan,)-428(and)-416(V)80(oronk)28(o)28(v,)-415(A.)-429((eds.),)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
20.90477 0 Td
[(Handb)53(o)53(ok)-468(of)-429(A)27(utomate)54(d)-468(R)53(e)53(asoning,)]TJ
-19.55305 -1.23126 TD
[(V)80(olume)-374(I)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
4.10868 0 Td
[(,)-335(MIT)-347(Press,)-360(Cam)27(bridge,)-361(and)-349(North-Holland,)-334(Ammsterdam)-345((2001).)]TJ
-5.4604 -1.21788 TD
[(91.)-575(Russell,)-454(B.,)-468(and)-456(Whitehead,)-456(A.)-442(N.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
18.56268 0 Td
[(Principia)-457(Mathematic)53(a)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
10.3587 0 Td
[(,)-482(Cam)28(bridge)-469(Uni-)]TJ
-27.56967 -1.21788 TD
[(v)27(ersit)28(y)-361(Press,)-373(Cam)28(bridge,)-375(England.)-376(First)-360(edition)-361((1910),)-386(second)-361(edition)-362((1927),)]TJ
T*
[(reprin)27(ted)-335(1963.)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.23127 TD
[(92.)-575(Siekmann,)-857(J.,)-883(and)-857(W)80(righ)27(tson,)-869(G.)-870((eds),)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
22.9658 0 Td
[(A)27(utomation)-870(of)-843(R)53(e)53(asoning)-858(1:)]TJ
-21.61408 -1.21788 TD
[(Classic)53(al)-1097(Pap)54(ers)-1125(on)-1098(Computational)-1110(L)54(o)53(gic)-1098(1957-1966)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
26.92727 0 Td
[(,)-1164(Springer-V)80(erlag,)]TJ
-26.92727 -1.21788 TD
[(Berlin/Heidelb)-28(erg/New)-373(Y)80(ork)-334((1983).)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.23127 TD
[(93.)-575(Siekmann,)-857(J.,)-883(and)-857(W)80(righ)27(tson,)-869(G.)-870((eds),)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
22.9658 0 Td
[(A)27(utomation)-870(of)-843(R)53(e)53(asoning)-858(2:)]TJ
-21.61408 -1.21788 TD
[(Classic)53(al)-1097(Pap)54(ers)-1125(on)-1098(Computational)-1110(L)54(o)53(gic)-1098(1967-1970)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
26.92727 0 Td
[(,)-1164(Springer-V)80(erlag,)]TJ
-26.92727 -1.21788 TD
[(Berlin/Heidelb)-28(erg/New)-373(Y)80(ork)-334((1983).)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(94.)-575(Quaife,)-455(A.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
7.33407 0 Td
[(A)27(utomate)54(d)-495(Development)-484(of)-455(F)80(undamental)-482(Mathematic)53(al)-481(The)53(ories,)]TJ
-5.98235 -1.23127 TD
[(A)27(utomate)54(d)-401(R)53(e)53(asoning,)-376(V)80(ol.2)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
12.70078 0 Td
[(,)-335(Klu)27(w)26(er)-347(Academic)-348(Publishers,)-362(Dordrec)28(h)27(t)-334((1992).)]TJ
-14.0525 -1.21788 TD
[(95.)-575(Risc)28(h,)-309(R.,)-307(The)-322(problem)-308(of)-320(in)26(tegration)-319(in)-322(\fnite)-295(terms,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
25.80306 0 Td
[(T)80(r)53(ansactions)-375(of)-335(the)-348(AMS)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
-24.45135 -1.21788 TD
(139)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
2.12795 0 Td
[(167{189,)-372(1969.)]TJ
-3.47967 -1.21788 TD
[(96.)-575(Risc)28(h,)-389(R.,)-375(The)-402(solution)-387(of)-401(the)-375(problem)-387(of)-401(in)26(tegration)-399(in)-376(\fnite)-388(terms,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
33.43156 0 Td
[(Bul)-53(letin)]TJ
-32.07985 -1.23127 TD
[(of)-362(the)-388(AMS)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
5.51393 0 Td
(76)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.5257 0 Td
[(605{608,)-385(1970.)]TJ
-8.39135 -1.21788 TD
[(97.)-575(T)81(arski,A.,)-508(A)-482(decision)-509(metho)-25(d)-496(for)-508(elemen)27(tary)-493(algebra)-508(and)-495(geometry)82(.)-495(Rep)-27(ort)]TJ
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(R-109,)-547(second)-549(revised)-535(edition,)-549(Rand)-522(Corp)-26(oration,)-574(San)26(ta)-534(Monica,)-549(CA,)-549(1951.)]TJ
0 -1.23127 TD
[(Reprin)26(ted)-334(in)-335([28],)-374(pp.)-336(24{84.)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(98.)-575(T)81(arski,)-253(A.,)-255(What)-240(is)-254(elemen)26(tary)-252(geometry?)-252(in:)-255(Henkin,)-242(L.,)-254(Supp)-29(es,)-241(P)81(,)-255(and)-241(T)80(arski,)]TJ
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(A.)-308((eds.),)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
4.47003 0 Td
[(Pr)53(o)54(c)53(e)53(e)53(dings)-362(of)-321(an)-335(International)-349(Symp)53(osium)-335(on)-335(the)-334(Axiomatic)-335(Metho)53(d,)]TJ
-4.47003 -1.23127 TD
[(with)-361(Sp)53(e)54(cial)-375(R)53(efer)52(enc)52(e)-375(to)-374(Ge)53(ometry)-388(and)-376(Physics)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
21.85498 0 Td
[(16-29,)-346(North-Holland,)-335(Amster-)]TJ
-21.85498 -1.21788 TD
[(dam)-348((1959).)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
56 0 obj
<<
/Length 7593
>>
stream
/GS4 gs
BT
/F3 1 Tf
8.96638 0 0 8.96638 134.76 692.16 Tm
0 g
[(54)-2662(Mic)26(hael)-361(Beeson)]TJ
0 -2.8908 TD
(99.)Tj
1.87367 -0.00001 TD
[(T)80(rybulec,)-817(W.)-830(A.,)-830(Subgroup)-817(and)-830(cosets)-828(of)-843(subgroup,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
27.32876 0 Td
[(Journal)-817(of)-816(F)80(or-)]TJ
-27.85071 -1.23126 TD
[(malize)53(d)-669(Mathematics)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
10.34532 0 Td
(2)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.58887 0 Td
[(,)-669(1990.)-694(This)-683(is)-682(an)-669(electronic)-682(journal,)-682(published)-672(at)]TJ
-10.93418 -1.21788 TD
[(h)26(ttp://mizar.u)29(wb.edu.pl/JFM/index.h)24(tml.)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(100.)-574(T)80(uring,)-268(A.,)-254(On)-255(computable)-254(n)26(um)27(b)-27(ers,)-254(with)-268(an)-254(application)-267(to)-267(the)-254(En)26(tsc)28(heidung-)]TJ
1.35172 -1.23127 TD
(sproblem,)Tj
/F5 1 Tf
4.75108 0 Td
[(Pr)53(o)54(c)53(e)53(e)53(dings)-456(of)-415(the)-428(L)53(ondon)-442(Mathematic)53(al)-428(So)53(ciety)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
21.85498 0 Td
[(,)-415(ser.)-414(2)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
3.55997 0 Td
(42)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.59262 0 Td
(230{265,)Tj
-31.75865 -1.21788 TD
[(1936-7;)-373(corrections,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
9.03375 0 Td
(ibid.)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
2.28855 0 Td
(43)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.5257 0 Td
[((1937))-359(pp.)-335(544-546.)]TJ
-14.19972 -1.21788 TD
[(101.)-574(T)80(uring,)-308(A.,)-308(Computing)-321(Mac)27(hines)-308(and)-308(In)26(telligence,)-321(in)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
26.21795 0 Td
[(MIND,)-321(A)-335(Quarterly)-347(R)53(e-)]TJ
-24.86623 -1.23127 TD
[(view)-375(of)-362(Psycholo)54(gy)-389(and)-375(Philosophy)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
15.52467 0 Td
(59)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.17773 0 Td
[(,)-361(No.)-348(236,)-360(Octob)-27(er,)-347(1950,)-373(pp.)-336(433-460.)]TJ
-18.05412 -1.21788 TD
[(102.)-574(v)54(an)-295(Heijeno)-27(ort,)-333(J.)-308((ed.))]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
13.10228 0 Td
[(F)80(r)53(om)-348(F)80(r)54(e)53(ge)-349(to)-347<477F>522(odel:)-335(A)-334(Sour)53(c)53(e)-348(Bo)53(ok)-348(in)-335(Mathematic)53(al)]TJ
-11.75057 -1.21788 TD
[(L)53(o)54(gic,)-376(1879{1931)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
7.7088 0 Td
[(,)-375(Harv)55(ard)-334(Univ)26(ersit)28(y)-321(Press,)-360(Cam)28(bridge,)-362(MA)-348((1967).)]TJ
-9.06052 -1.23127 TD
[(103.)-574(W)80(ang,)-321(H.,)-308(T)80(o)27(w)27(ard)-321(mec)27(hanical)-335(mathematics,)-318(1960.)-346(Reprin)26(ted)-294(in)-309([92],)-334(pp.)-308(244{)]TJ
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
(267.)Tj
-1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(104.)-574(W)80(eispfenning,)-483(V.,)-482(The)-469(complexit)28(y)-482(of)-481(linear)-482(problems)-481(in)-482(\felds,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
31.73188 0 Td
[(J.)-496(Symb)53(olic)]TJ
-30.38017 -1.23127 TD
(Computation)Tj
/F4 1 Tf
6.14295 0 Td
(5)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.93683 0 Td
[(3{27)-360((1988).)]TJ
-8.4315 -1.21788 TD
[(105.)-574(Wiedijk,F.,)-362(The)-349(\ffteen)-348(pro)27(v)27(ers)-334(of)-360(the)-335(w)27(orld,)-361(to)-334(app)-27(ear.)]TJ
T*
[(106.)-574(Winkler,)-482(F.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
8.47165 0 Td
[(Polynomial)-482(A)27(lgorithms)-509(in)-482(Computer)-509(A)27(lgebr)52(a)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
20.4765 0 Td
[(,)-495(Springer-V)80(erlag,)]TJ
-27.59643 -1.23127 TD
[(Wien/)-348(New)-349(Y)80(ork)-333((1996).)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(107.)-574(W)80(os.,)-280(L.,)-295(Robinson,)-268(G.,)-295(and)-268(Carson,)-293(D.,)-281(E\016ciency)-281(and)-268(completeness)-293(of)-280(the)-281(set)]TJ
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(of)-361(supp)-27(ort)-334(strategy)-358(in)-335(theorem)-347(pro)28(ving,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
18.16118 0 Td
[(JA)27(CM)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
3.27892 0 Td
(12)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.17773 0 Td
[((4))-347(536{541,)-385(1965.)-373(Reprin)27(ted)]TJ
-22.61783 -1.21788 TD
[(in)-349([110],)-373(pp.)-336(29{36.)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.23126 TD
[(108.)-574(W)80(os,)-508(L.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
6.78535 0 Td
[(The)-522(A)27(utomation)-535(of)-509(R)53(e)53(asoning:)-523(A)26(n)-522(Exp)53(erimenter's)-551(Noteb)54(o)53(ok)-549(with)]TJ
-5.43363 -1.21788 TD
[(OTTER)-362(T)81(utorial)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
7.66865 0 Td
[(,)-361(Academic)-348(Press,)-360(San)-335(Diego)-360((1996).)]TJ
-9.02037 -1.21788 TD
[(109.)-574(W)80(os,)-361(L.,)-375(and)-348(Piep)-28(er,)-374(G.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
13.77145 0 Td
[(A)-375(F)81(ascinating)-404(Country)-401(in)-376(the)-388(World)-387(of)-375(Computing)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
22.92565 0 Td
(,)Tj
-35.34538 -1.23127 TD
[(W)80(orld)-348(Scien)26(ti\fc,)-348(Singap)-27(ore)-347((1999).)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(110.)-574(W)80(os,)-374(L.,)-375(and)-362(Piep)-27(er,)-375(W.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
14.06588 0 Td
[(The)-402(Col)-53(le)53(cte)53(d)-401(Works)-402(of)-374(L)53(arry)-416(Wos,)-388(V)81(olume)-388(I:)-375(Ex-)]TJ
-12.71417 -1.21788 TD
[(ploring)-376(the)-374(Power)-389(of)-361(A)27(utomate)54(d)-388(R)53(e)53(asoning)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
19.24523 0 Td
[(,)-361(W)80(orld)-348(Scien)26(ti\fc,)-348(Singap)-28(ore)-347((2000).)]TJ
-20.59695 -1.23127 TD
[(111.)-574(W)80(os,)-334(L.,)-335(and)-322(Piep)-27(er,)-334(W.,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
13.86513 0 Td
[(The)-348(Col)-54(le)54(cte)53(d)-375(Works)-361(of)-348(L)53(arry)-362(Wos,)-348(V)81(olume)-348(II:)-334(Ap-)]TJ
-12.51342 -1.21788 TD
[(plying)-389(A)27(utomate)54(d)-415(R)53(e)53(asoning)-416(to)-387(Puzzles,)-402(Pr)54(oblems,)-402(and)-389(Op)54(en)-402(Questions)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
32.22707 0 Td
[(,)-388(W)80(orld)]TJ
-32.22707 -1.21788 TD
[(Scien)26(ti\fc,)-348(Singap)-28(ore)-347((2000).)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.23126 TD
[(112.)-574(W)80(os,)-481(L.,)-482(Re\rections)-468(on)-482(Automated)-468(Reasoning)-480(at)-481(Argonne:)-469(A)-468(P)27(ersonalized)]TJ
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(F)80(ragmen)28(t)-347(of)-348(History)83(,)-348(on)-348(the)-335(CD-R)27(OM)-334(included)-337(with)-348([109].)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(113.)-574(W)80(os,)-240(L.,)-255(Ulric)27(h,)-242(D,)-227(and)-241(Fitelson,)-254(B.,)-254(X)27(CB,)-241(the)-228(last)-253(of)-240(the)-241(shortest)-238(single)-254(axioms)]TJ
1.35172 -1.23126 TD
[(for)-360(the)-335(classical)-373(equiv)54(alen)26(tial)-347(calculus,)-361(to)-348(app)-27(ear)-347(in)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
23.30038 0 Td
[(J.)-362(A)27(utomate)54(d)-388(R)53(e)53(asoning)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
-24.6521 -1.21788 TD
[(114.)-574(W)80(u,)-349(W)80(en-Tsun,)-349(On)-335(the)-348(decision)-375(problem)-347(and)-349(the)-348(mec)27(hanization)-374(of)-361(theorem-)]TJ
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(pro)27(ving)-508(in)-523(elemen)27(tary)-507(geometry)83(,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
15.52467 0 Td
[(Scientia)-537(Sinic)52(a)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
7.36083 0 Td
(21)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
1.69968 0 Td
[((2),)-507(1978.)-534(Reprin)27(ted)-496(in:)]TJ
-24.58518 -1.23127 TD
[(Bledso)-26(e,)-295(W.)-254(W.,)-268(and)-268(Lo)26(v)27(eland,)-255(D.)-267(W.)-255((eds.),)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
19.98132 0 Td
[(A)27(utomate)54(d)-321(The)53(or)53(em)-308(Pr)53(oving:)-296(After)]TJ
-19.98132 -1.21788 TD
[(25)-375(Y)81(e)53(ars)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
3.88117 0 Td
[(,)-361(AMS,)-349(Pro)28(vidence,)-349(RI)-334((1983).)]TJ
-5.23288 -1.21788 TD
[(115.)-574(W)80(u,)-228(W)80(en-Tsun,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
9.60923 0 Td
[(Me)53(chanic)52(al)-267(The)53(or)53(em)-295(Pr)53(oving)-282(in)-269(Ge)54(ometries:)-296(Basic)-267(Principles)]TJ
/F3 1 Tf
27.08786 0 Td
(,)Tj
-35.34538 -1.23127 TD
[(Springer-V)80(erlag,)-347(Wien/)-348(New)-348(Y)80(ork)-334((1994).)]TJ
-1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(116.)-574(Y)80(u,)-375(Y.)-375(Computer)-388(Pro)-26(ofs)-413(in)-376(Group)-388(Theory)81(,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
22.20295 0 Td
[(Journal)-415(of)-402(A)27(utomate)54(d)-428(R)53(e)53(asoning)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
-20.85123 -1.21788 TD
(6)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.58887 0 Td
[((3))-347(251-286,)-372(1990.)]TJ
-1.94058 -1.23127 TD
[(117.)-574(Zhang,)-509(H.,)-495(Automated)-495(pro)-26(of)-508(of)-508(ring)-495(comm)29(utativit)28(y)-495(problems)-508(b)27(y)-482(algebraic)]TJ
1.35172 -1.21788 TD
[(metho)-26(ds,)]TJ
/F5 1 Tf
4.42988 0 Td
[(J.)-375(Symb)52(olic)-362(Computation)]TJ
/F4 1 Tf
11.6435 0 Td
(9)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.93683 0 Td
[(423{427,)-372(1990.)]TJ
ET
endstream
endobj
57 0 obj
<<
/Nums[0<</S/D>>]
>>
endobj
58 0 obj
<<
/Type/Encoding
/Differences[77/M 84/T 97/a 99/c 101/e/f 104/h/i 109/m/n/o 115/s/t 122/z]
/BaseEncoding/MacRomanEncoding
>>
endobj
59 0 obj
<<
/Length1 1778
/Length 1778
/Subtype/Type1C
>>
stream




JYPDTB+cmbx12

F��
���LNA
V��s��
��
�������

IO^1.0Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reservedcmbx12Computer Modern



TNGPU[JOBD.FI5
�
F
�
�>��;��	p�����1���� �
��{��
�?���|����|������o�f�g�m��*����"�u�����������r�a�>0�v�X�L�o�����zv��t�x�����������h��������q�w�b�i�U�K�O�����䋠����E�r�~�����������
����
���
�_�
�_�
8����d��&\Gk{�{G�K+WM[v���=�`ɒ�d��F`��Ӌ��ԋ���F�i�
ܿʰ�u=��F`��Ӌ��ԋ���F�i�
ܿʰ�u=��F`��Ӌ��ԋ���F���������s�
����m�%�����͛������|��zvc�y������g�D0�e�%A`��F`��֋��܋���41����
��������o�/�1�74#���-�1�7�����Q���	ݺ���������įpo��g�W[8����k�����Sw
�
�
��g�%�$��$�Sa�([((�j��!�t�շ���aWImnlO�΢�(����
��9�L�*��������x����@�ꑡ������������w������Za!�uS�0�鋶����$
���s��j�dbliee�i������D�I`ƒ�d��F`��Ћ��ˋ���M�+t���
�
��
�^�
�����b��CMh@i���=�`ɒ�d��F`��Ӌ��ԋ���F�i��˰�s?��F`��Ӌ��ԋ���F!���b��4�
���b�
�`���B�!S�
�7a�y��������z������ϴe9c�2�3_�0�w�ؼ���f�`���������}L�����
�-7ykZb������(����
���G�
�h�	����{���x�pH/�!��,�ƌ���Ɖ��������~|ra�z�������U�FE����/�'�1����9����
�'���
�����������v��i`���u��q��yw�yt`��ً��ڋ���tp���sn�����Œ���������������������!`����󋉦�!���iv��v�� ���S��>�
������X�q�������]��aS�Q�06%�� �0�+�+����|��{��~�JqIv[�%���������������������Yt���
��U�
��
�^�
�����b��&ZDm}����A�`ɒ�d��F`��Ӌ��ԋ���F�i��˰�s?��F`��Ӌ��ԋ���F�����
���d�9�'w����
���$��+`����׋����+����$�7�����B�����_��]��
�
���
�
�
7�	��endstream
endobj
60 0 obj
<<
/FontFile3 59 0 R
/Descent -194
/Flags 262178
/Type/FontDescriptor
/StemH 0
/CapHeight 656
/XHeight 698
/StemV 109
/FontName/JYPDTB+cmbx12
/FontBBox[-53 -251 1139 750]
/ItalicAngle 0
/Ascent 686
>>
endobj
61 0 obj
<<
/Widths[1071 0 0 0 0 0 0 786 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 544 0 502 0 510 343 0 627 309 0 0 0 937 627 560 0 0 0 443 435 0 0 0 0 0 502]
/Encoding 58 0 R
/Subtype/Type1
/Type/Font
/LastChar 122
/Name/F0
/FirstChar 77
/FontDescriptor 60 0 R
/BaseFont/JYPDTB+cmbx12
>>
endobj
62 0 obj
<<
/Type/Encoding
/Differences[11/ff/fi/fl/ffi 19/acute 32/suppress/exclam/quotedblright 38/ampersand/quoteright/parenleft/parenright 43/plus/comma/hyphen/period/slash/zero/one/two/three/four/five/six/seven/eight/nine/colon/semicolon 61/equal 63/question 65/A/B/C/D/E/F/G/H/I/J/K/L/M/N/O/P/Q/R/S/T/U/V/W/X/Y/Z/bracketleft/quotedblleft/bracketright 96/quoteleft/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i/j/k/l/m/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v/w/x/y/z/endash/emdash 127/dieresis]
/BaseEncoding/MacRomanEncoding
>>
endobj
63 0 obj
<<
/Length1 10892
/Length 10892
/Subtype/Type1C
>>
stream





GNGBXW+cmr10

F��
���LNY
�������]
��
����
��*c

	SXgsuppress1.00BCopyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reservedcmr10Computer Modern


Y
�9;A6}�+7-
n'3
	20o�4%:/,( $><R["m&

1)KWYwiH5LXG8CEQN
ZSVU*OPT#MFBIDJ.[
?]

�@��Iv��~�I��'�J��	�	�
f
�
�r���

�� �b�X�-��6|�Q��n}6�7��>��	�Q�f�"� ) �!)!�" "|"�##�#�$�%$%a%�&V&�'0'�(���UV�$�yv�|w
��J�\���������}������B�~������������������v���
���������t9�m싪�
�
��R�&���]�������d\�rc[��cl���ut�������=��U�������������hB�elM��fl�ž�o��L���8��}wm]&�l������‹���]�z��������"�f�2��������uz`�l��ԋ�������xWv��v�u������
�ޱ���ǧ�L�
<�Kj^UW��k���Ϲڲ͠����fU���7��pl��xr�����T*^G`V~��
�_����׋͋�{�D�M�AT�!�a�C�2wub`mk^]qp�U4�L��ƶ��O��{������e��pۈŪ߳��Nj#�I:4sq`;�\�m�M�o�W�fKRM�o�8�t��ܭ���g�����
�������������w�T��u�����8�1���������z����a���r��x-�M�8�����v���Uw
ӡ�T�S�z�gw}���������������������������8?�
O�^������Mv�ͳ��w
���-�z�������x�}�������ww�x}����}x�ww�������}�x������u���
�����{�"*;,\�
��R��������hA�ee@��hl�؍�g�
�!��
������������������g[�ih[��gl�\p�$�v��v�Pw
�b�N��������y�y|������-�y�$�v���
�����_���w�mouuoo�u������U�u�omwqss�q�������v���.�
�-�C�������x�}��}x�ww�����V�����x�|��|x�ww����$u�����t����t��7�]]�����̵���WCRd[Oh�|Ӱ����2�0':A.y�^�\��r�z�Qn5S(!�H������e�x�{�K�'a�z�m�l�x�m�N�A@W9�5�Cɋދū���u���v�
���)���(/YSV�G��g�����o�oui}_A�O����֖������P������_e�\a3��el��~h�v�6�
��[�
������ό��lc�qmQ��ql���qt������K�v�S���������ċ���gF�e[`��gl̞�e��|���x���������s���ww�2�
������r%�}��D9\������������g0�bd=��hl�؍�g��g��>sl���I�����w�笡��g�L�J������$��~b��^��Hl�����������H����d�Z���[������}�
���ɩ��t�b��o{j�~������T�A3Rc|y�ta�Y-�	X�
�<l��^��Hl�����������H�����g��^��Hl�����������H�����I��j���ƣ��o�d��swu�{��+������w����g���$��^��Hl�����������H�����g�܇�����kb��"�
S#�<l��^��Hl�����������H������g��j��׹Ք������{�qy�|�����������
��T��#���<��l�؍�g��g��>sl��ً��拈��j,�������k6���r7�j+5��������*�S����u������������?��z�t�����������������%Fs:�(�~������'��l�؍�g��g��>sl��ҋ��ҋ���s>����������i��g�lHJ�c�eg�…�ٜݧ���~�����D�hyrZ���}~�y�Z�T����yv�|w
�{�����ـ�
T��O5́��������y�(�3�e�?f�D��~�������������������yv�|w
��������z���k�Q�-�B��B������������1G�PX��7=��
����J�������V������
��,��������
���+�`�+�6�J�G�-�4�b�^�+�3�J�����,��/������������U�am`\r��s�X�U���z��� ���5��=�!!=�uk�PXl`bp�x���/�xik�uX���������aQ��u��8�
��_��e���`�+�6�J�G�-�4�b�a�.�0�F�J�+�3�^���+�����&���#D�����7/�$�����
��_��U�Br�m�_�|��I�u��H��0�����1��A/2S��������y�h�����̢����:9;Y<TM�T�j�����s��$�����uw���D��9��4g��Avl�����������vA������'�[���{������i�������	�$�v���
����������u�$u���$��
�ɤ��6�;�?������ݦ����3�+&?O?j�x������\�|��͘���u1�Qq_m[i�r���s����������������ݰG)�Fn_`@��h������p�nsk}_0�I�
�����L�#��������v��w
��T�-�p�qqpyj��[�|�����������0�s�nnssnn�s�������v���
��{�{����{u+u��0�åq���V�����M�d������;��8^�����������]��������hRm�b�2��73!8�B�p����z覄���f�q�j�j�DYC7�n�?�V�Q��ˊ�������~����y�\z�������������i��g��	���I�7��$u��"��泤��d�J��������������i�|c�^l�|������_�8����q����D����2�GfX[w���Lmǚ�y��۝٫�囹�M��f�XZ[�YzgOm]�t�$u���L�����[��x���U�]�9�[`{hg�W�������昑���������wZwHc]��\��������{��y���������������]y��f�dY�h�Osadsfq]BR��z����������z�j}h�]5�*�����
���
�
�����?l�؍�g��g��>sl��<��(�P�R��1�?�� \������������uD��P�5=�xOgZpwRQ&싪�
�
�������ȰƏ���lc�plQ��ql��xw��~���9���I��������������gB�da]��al�ϓ�q��f���Wg��>sl��ҋ��ҋ���t>����U싪�
�
���9��|�2����x�>l����������x��p�\$l�����������$������������,������������������hZ�jjZ��hl�\p�?����
�
���$�7�H�A����܌��qk�pgR��il���t�{����������������hA�ee@��hl�؍�g��g��>sl��Ջ��֋���s>����C���I�����~�md�wl��ы�������Uv��m�u��w����%���6�k�|���u��c������B������fT�mc6��gl�厀fK����oJ�Z������Y���1�'�}������������������YAk�U�(��N�6�2�a�a�4�3�R�ۥƭ�$�v��ثw
�D��p��������������rj�b����ʘ���ً���c�{<�
uj1�j��%���^���������Ž“�������$u���ߢ�$���J�d�����k�~#]QzU��p�����s�u{m�dH�b����k�����2TZy^`b^ta@��)�ȴ�Ţ�>{]��ly����������������i^��k�L]8i*3�����@v�U��o�
��T��s�nnssnn�s�����x�o�=KA���������������Uhypqq�p�������������H���v���ϡ��J���������Ү�������c�)�MGJi�}������a�}��Ś��
�GdP{yyyICu/N^y����������5�s�nnssnn�s������u��-�
��p��-�=��������YAf�X�+��O�5�3�`�c�6�1�N�7�����~������#� 9�
N�X������W��
�0�&�}����������������,�
���3���c�,*c��$u���
�����`��ۆ�h��]9�aOBq.bkF�=;@�1�?:��w��נ��А���g��dP��y�Nj��ˋ͓���֔���y(��S�?L@�G�K,|Rm^�$������w
�p�������tKM3�kl�Ƌ����g�1kl��⋳�⋈��k1�����������,�
�
������*�,��|��V��,��*��w�������G^��Hl�����������H�����ue0�~b�;�"*���&�Ѵ�����l�!kyous}~kp\BN�����۵4V�������o�
��T��s�nnssnn�s��������s�nnssnn�s������`����
��	��%��������y����5�񑞰�����
������}�������Or�
�v_��
�����v�4v�U�
�L��b���s�`hypqq�p�������������}�k�CLM����������
싪�Y��]w
��A�"�L����{{��}��c��yXc|U�l�����������Yr�������������-������mS�pl��ы�������yO}�����������u+�����w�䯡��L�J����$��~b��^��Hl�����������H������{���������}�
���ɩ��t�b��o{j�~������T�A.�X�
�<l��^��Hl�����������H���������Ǫ���
��Z�� ��r�.rtB�@�\�������k6���r5�l*1��������-�T���o�u��l�؍�g��g��>sl��C�������
��f����T�$���
�仺�������y~rt�w������h�SP_e���nS�p,�W��<l��^��Hl�����������H�����f��^��Hl�����������vA���������ݵ̼�x�{�w~o��r���~����������ʪ
����w���=�����(���l�؍�g��g��>sl��Ջ��֋���s>��������������3�!Z\���3싪�ɪ���
��������������hA�ee@��hl�؍�g�~���~�������hA�ee@��hl�؍�g��g��>sl��Ջ��֋���s>���������g��>sl��Ջ��֋���s>�����a���s��
�c��J���f�N�,�lؔ�Z� ^�5K�t��q������y�ooywqW�o�������.�s�nnssnn�s�������v�/�
��}�4������͌��tn�ts]��zl���tx�����%�����������������mS�tpc��mlʏ�l��$���}��������������
��������������������qm�qmV��~l���~{{�~��M==�����������qI�{v\��plь�O��\O��\RQ[P�vl�����������u����������d���Y���{�����|p�l��Í�������Uy��t�$�v�4v�U�
���@��-���s�`hypqq�p�������������}�k�CLM����������
�V�s�`hypqq�p�������������}�k�CLM����������
�$�v���Uw
�,��@����S�z�gw}���������������������������8?�
O�^������V�z�gw}���������������������������8?�
O�^������$�b��R�ߢ�����w�B֮���r�@4�����������'tp�k|r�toc(�o�������ذ{�r���������������z��������dw_�ba�aa�u.FF>_�e�v~|yjh�l�e�wOzk`cC�T��
�ٮ}�X��VQ�Nr`���k�v����������&F����������5UDY)ԋ��Nv�V�
�������.�9��x�u��5����+���������t��i�}"cl����򋈴�c"����������������+�j�5��������q�
�������������Ǖ�ʾ������n~�ogM��}l����~w}���!��t�$�lѓ�Z��^��Hl�����������H�������!�S�yxz�xl��ƍ�������fu��eԕv�/�
��A������������un�un^��xl���yn����~0��(��������������nX�smn��ml���~����m�x5��,��������������mS�t�V��gl���k�����}�������������������������4ߓ�
�����F�$���	�㻻�������y~rt�w������f�VE6V!�<l��^��Hl�����������vA����
�v�6�
��s�!��ĝ�����ml�mnK��qlΊ�jx������*�b�4�~�������ŋ���gG�ee`��blĠ�g��E��A�5���������ŋ���gG�ee`��bl֏�f��\��������������9���:�������������������
��T��s�nnssnn�s�����+���w�8��f�������@�
���$�lѓ�Z��������|t��Y�����)�=`\y{����b�����ò“���qe��b�Rbf�On^lvejU^g��s}�����͠v�O�
������O��Q+��u����f�����|��I�'��E������$�lѓ�Z�l��n`�U�
")���(�˸������ay���z[m^u`^g��sq��Ĵ��Ǩ��������|^��z��y+�V��,���r������C���������3��
E7Ace��p}����T{��U�����*�=a_uw���$�lҒ�_�h^��Hl�����������H����<�I����u���L�e�e�������^��Hl�����������H����L����ʖUR�}^��Hl�����������H����L����ʖUR�}^��Hl�����������Wr����Sዪl��}j�Q7_Oez�}A�^B\`Mo���!�lѓ�Z�����@v�U�
�I��G����}KoN_\�������������s�chypqq�p��������a���u�
���3��ʥ�����tn�ty\��ul���zr����&�����������������qI�zpc��ml���h��*�
�~}j�~TuoFK�t��x������x�twu~m^�g�ʴ�ģ������u������@��.��ג������wqo�|������l�`BgH`}���lѓ�Z��^��Hl�����������vA���+��u�����e�x��1�$��E�������'�lѓ�Z�F4[GB7������'�lً�2�*=�0�,÷�ɨ�����;w����Lw
����A�$�#��#�Lr�9m )�u����ҧ���rTAmefH�����r���
�
���u���������h<�ed<��hl�ڎ�g��g��<ql��ڋ��ڋ���q<���+����u���L�e�������^��Hl�����������H����L����ʖUR�}^��Hl�����������Wr����Sዪl��}j�QB\`Mo���!�lѓ�Z�$���0�
�����k�j�'��
�*�
���+�	�
���q�\`_��pr��ȯ������������u`��`�Qeg�Uu_^u_nY�����6���t��{�t��d�V���{CXhc=7g��x�����~��y�z���������������a�������΋Ӌ�m��j�d�a��S�H�������1l������������������~������e�b�|���eH�S�h�o�u�q���}ȋ��͡�������B���r���������6VKZ7�������/��l�؍�g���g��>sl������9��M���\������P�.HDW9$�������
�
���E�J�$�lѓ�Z��^��Hl�����������H����`����v�W�
������{�����U��/$���*��������������$h1��Yc��tm��ͯ���)�ߤ��d�$��z���v�廡��[�7�Ԥ{����c��a��ș��rSQr��j����\���g��dY�[9F\Im�z��������]��������d2f��X�E�Lm@irW�_�:�rʋ͋������8',Ci^Zb��µ�9�+�����f�
��e��]��ዪl��}j�Q7_Og{����$�lѓ�Z��^��Hl�����������H����L����ʖUR�}^��Hl�����������Wr����`����簤
��W����b��m~q�w������?�>�/����(��������������.nJfV3��5�7ݵ��ʊg����������
��E��E�N� �l̔�Z��^��Hl�����������I�����r�olupqp�q����������
�
� �������)����t�=l�؍�g��p�\$l�����������$����������~������������
���g��>sl��ϋ��΋���s>������������=q��y��o��u��?�����n��b��
���П

7�	��endstream
endobj
64 0 obj
<<
/FontFile3 63 0 R
/Descent -194
/Flags 34
/Type/FontDescriptor
/StemH 0
/CapHeight 666
/XHeight 705
/StemV 69
/FontName/GNGBXW+cmr10
/FontBBox[-251 -250 1009 969]
/ItalicAngle 0
/Ascent 683
>>
endobj
65 0 obj
<<
/Widths[578 554 554 831 0 0 0 0 506 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 277 277 506 0 0 0 783 277 385 385 0 783 277 337 277 506 506 506 506 506 506 506 506 506 506 506 277 277 0 783 0 470 0 747 711 723 759 687 650 783 747 361 518 783 626 915 747 783 687 783 735 554 723 747 747 1024 747 747 614 277 506 277 0 0 277 506 554 446 554 446 301 506 554 277 301 530 277 831 554 506 554 530 397 397 385 554 530 723 530 530 446 506 1000 0 0 506]
/Encoding 62 0 R
/Subtype/Type1
/Type/Font
/LastChar 127
/Name/F1
/FirstChar 11
/FontDescriptor 64 0 R
/BaseFont/GNGBXW+cmr10
>>
endobj
66 0 obj
<<
/Type/Encoding
/Differences[43/plus 48/zero/one/two/three/four/five/six/seven/eight/nine 61/equal]
/BaseEncoding/MacRomanEncoding
>>
endobj
67 0 obj
<<
/Length1 1642
/Length 1642
/Subtype/Type1C
>>
stream




FDJIZZ+cmr7

E��
���LNV
p������
��
������A

IM\1.0Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reservedcmr7Computer Modern




R��
�~����B������x*v���w
�2��c�v�������t�}������sr�t}���~s�sr������~�s������x�v���?�
�t���������s�~�*~s�sr����)�p�����t�|�(|t�rs���9w���
��������~�]��lM�;�|���CC����|�|�����|��]N��w}Ƌ��ԋך�ڠˠ���jQ��U�C4A�A~L0wGuc9w���ܧ��
����6�����eOuV��p������z�mmywnG�a�#���j����	jF�SRijcd1��-�	۶����!Edf��ot����ŋ����������kq��a�Eh�@WL9w���
�������ٱ����&�*�1C,\�i�w�v���hSs(U�"���M�����܋���d�Q�~�h�}��7�q�o���԰���ZD2#^������CF�k���\�|�m�P�@8\5�/�<Ƌ݋���Ӭ9�v���w
�c������������c���gW�����ih�j����͛���܋���nkaXMvo��@�3�P���]����������V��9w����ꮨ
����*��ݒձ���������p�r�vznr�u������a�(�$�'��k���=�����&�	;_V^u���Yd��v|�������۹�yf��e�aQR�apdhskxZ9w���D���
������/��~������嚖���������sVwAoV��J�����~��{��z�������¶ȓ�Ǧ[���j�eQm�Pm_gr`sZJH��r������f�~�[�U1�1�����5�_W�e_9�����nw
������8���R���u��}���`g��9i�:pg��ˍ��ˉ���p:����=�&���9w���!���¨
��o�������U �CfQc3��a������s�loozb-�N�
�����K������0��6U;i�x������w�l������u4a}]qljeo�Y�r������������}����9����
�������Ji�u�P~���>�}��L�讧Ǻ���ɋ�
!����74�/�X��������������W���ϡ���=:4MFkg���������o�09������w
��������oLK0�bg�͋����j�~'eg�����������e'���w��?�����n��a��
���ڛ

7�	��endstream
endobj
68 0 obj
<<
/FontFile3 67 0 R
/Descent -194
/Flags 4
/Type/FontDescriptor
/StemH 0
/CapHeight 664
/XHeight 703
/StemV 79
/FontName/FDJIZZ+cmr7
/FontBBox[-27 -250 1122 750]
/ItalicAngle 0
/Ascent 683
>>
endobj
69 0 obj
<<
/Widths[878 0 0 0 0 568 568 568 568 568 568 568 568 568 568 0 0 0 878]
/Encoding 66 0 R
/Subtype/Type1
/Type/Font
/LastChar 61
/Name/F2
/FirstChar 43
/FontDescriptor 68 0 R
/BaseFont/FDJIZZ+cmr7
>>
endobj
70 0 obj
<<
/Type/Encoding
/Differences[11/ff/fi/fl/ffi 19/acute/caron 33/exclam/quotedblright 36/dollar 39/quoteright/parenleft/parenright 43/plus/comma/hyphen/period/slash/zero/one/two/three/four/five/six/seven/eight/nine/colon/semicolon 61/equal 63/question 65/A/B/C/D/E/F/G/H/I/J/K/L/M/N/O/P/Q/R/S/T/U/V/W/X/Y/Z/bracketleft/quotedblleft/bracketright 96/quoteleft/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i/j/k/l/m/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v/w/x/y/z/endash 127/dieresis]
/BaseEncoding/MacRomanEncoding
>>
endobj
71 0 obj
<<
/Length1 10546
/Length 10546
/Subtype/Type1C
>>
stream




FHMDQW+cmr9

E��
���LNX
d������
��
����
{�)	

IM\1.0Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reservedcmr9Computer Modern


X�;9
7A�(n'o:)2&Y8K-

[31/,wi%*><L
 	R0#.CXHMEmQNDVGI5"$
ZSWJ6UF}TP+OB4Z
+{�
k
��K���_v:�X
n��	�
n
�o��

�,t�5�T�U�&�+��=�	ax�<�G�i/O���)��f�J�+� . � �!`!�"*"}"�#.#�#�$e$�%%%�&(&��̖��!�v��v�w
��������
�{s�'��{�v�����
����������x�a��u�����.�6�%�������y����o���o��x,�P�?�!�yv�|w
�#�W�[��������{�����>������|������������
�
�1��"�^��ی����Xf�tdx��Gl���rx�������<��U�������������bN�`_���7l�Гn��Q���>��]J=�t�l�����������]�}��������)�g�6��������uzc�l�����������z[r��v����v��w
��X�,�m�ssmzh��Z�}�����������0�s�mmssmm�s������c�����ꨤ��j�j����F�{�������}����Ģ��s�d��lm�z������T�;OPzfZ�wc�P&�	T!�<l��]��Il�����������I�����j��]��Il�����������I�����5��~b��]��Il�����������I���������—��n�^��e�{�x�����v�6�
����������hn�i`w��Zl���tq������S�y�\��������������^X�]a|��DlԖ�h������|�����������v���Uw
��X�R�x�h~~������������ͩȻ�����������6@�K�a������!�v���
�����d���t�oottoo�t������[�t�oottoo�t������-u��~��$�
��G��@�Z������J��Vd5��hl��fL��,�~9�P������J����@�6�~���������~��������X@k�R�&��V�8�5�^�`�7�4�X�ӯ��p��h�����@�������
��j��c�Jf��������le�{��O&�<l��]��Il�����������I�����j��]��Il�����������I���������޴Ѡ����}��{{}�{���7��@v�U��k�
�B��X�
�s�mmssmn�r�����u�s�;LC���������������Qlusmp�p���������������
� �Z���<��l�؍�f��f��>tl��ɋ��拈��k0�������k6���o6�k*1��������-�S����!�v���
����������r�!hv���������wĿ����
����6͇�m�E������t�s{�l�p�x����������V���l]��F/1P�^�l�g���y��P�D�v⌋������������w�q�y�n��a�/�2��^��������f�{�^�d�\�l�����ź������q�(vEVI<�����
�
����������ڌ��hn�ihu��Sl��{t����?���P��������������bN�`]���8l�Ǚ�o��p���Vf��>tl�����������t?����W����ɪ���
� ����
���������^S�]]S��^l�؍�f�}��}�������^S�]]S��^l�؍�f��f��>tl��Ë��Ë���t>��������f��>tl��Ë��Ë���t>����-�V�ѧ�
����
��3�����������9�`�/�6�O�O�/�7�_�_�0�2�N�����(��4������~�����4�G�{Uv��t�a�*�A�G������2���c!5Q�wl�JZgd]s�x���5�|ni�qZ���������aT�����Ǫ���
� �_��1��o�/rqC�?� \�������l5���o5l).��������0�U� ��o�u��l�؍�f��f��>tl���-�v���5�
�@�X�������u�|��|u�uv������`�����x�}��~w�vu����-Dv�ն��w
���9�y�������x�{�������uv�v}����}v�vu�������{�x�����&����
��u�������ꓓ����Ȍ��np�ney��cl����w{����K<=�����������eq�^�R��dlЍ�P��uqVIurOYR�vl�����������r����������������&�u�����~s�l������ċ���cm��u�+�v�6�
�;������ƌ��lk�lko��Qlʊ�mt������0�g�8��������ċ���^Y�^T���Ml���z��~�H�������!�<�7�|�������ċ���^Y�^T���Mlğ�e��a���}����������=���>���z����������!�����uw
��������x��}���fl��5f��@ul��ы��Ӌ���u@�����%A������a��ص��
d����n���s�mmssmm�s������0�Mlה�Z�n�'G�q��s������x�pnywpW�o������~���F����
�
� ���o&�}��G4\������������h0�c]M��^l�؍�f��f��>tl���!u���"��
�ɤ
��
�l������E,�GgXx*��^������r�nrm|a2�F������F�+�讷���6�##=P?j�x������s�i��ȟ�ޛI\m�[rel^h�n�r������������~����[�������
��j����c�$�	���廹��������{rq�y������g�Qt]�gc�vc�S#�S"�<l��]��Il�����������I�����j��]��Il�����������wB����������̗��{���s�l��w�������W����
�%�#��������z����8�񑝰�����������{�������Ro��~X��	�u����������"���~�Z�������
�'��l�؍�f��f��>tl�����������t>�������ӫe���f�|DH�_�ef�Nj�ߚ⣑��}~����L�lslk�������υ��ɂ���
�����������������)5_L��������ʪ
�"����|���;� ����$���l�؍�f��f��>tl��Ë��Ë���t>��������������9��^^���:��v�2v�U�
�M��f���q�ahxppp�p���������������ImN[^�������������!u����糤
��m�����Ħ���������g�f{xpq�w������c�0��!��s���H����/�O`hOo���Rj��x��ޛΪ�뛼�M��e�Z[[�ZxfRl_�p����k�
��X�
�s�mmssmn�r��������s�mmsrnm�s���������
�
� ��@����3����x�<l��������p�[%l�™��������%������=�������������������U|�[Z~��Sl�[p�?�-���
�
� ��0�6�O�A��Ɍ����nY��af��^l���~x�����������������^S�]]S��^l�؍�f��f��>tl��Ë��Ë���t>����?���O�����|��nd�yl�����������L}��k�!�v�2v�U�
���C��0���q�ahxppp�p���������������ImN[^�������������\�q�ahxppp�p���������������ImN[^�������������!�v���Uw
�1�����R�x�h~~������������ͩȻ�����������6@�K�a������\�x�h~~������������ͩȻ�����������6@�K�a������ ���
�
�"�#���?l�؍�f��f��>tl��A�"�(�P�R��1�D�� \������������Xg��Q�C(b�"TEGWCvL�����
�
� ��z���������bG�``G��bl�ۍg��g�;rl��ϋ��ϋ���r;��������&�
�
��8���"`�&(`�"�!u���
����m��Έ�h��_?�QO?s+_kF�:?J�*�<6��{��է��Α���l��mC��x�Ƌ��ϋڗ��˝���w.��T�=LM�7�P�vA�r�!u���
һ��������Խ��-�1"9@/e�g�n�x���f3aPN�9�!�H�����݋���A�r���n���'�m�t���Ѳ���UEEO]ct>P�q���a�|�k�N�<;[<�4�Bɋދӽ�ѯ�!�v��۫w
�J��~��������������oj�e����Ø���ڋ���funVAvo��G�7�R���^����������'���������&�
�������(�&�"�|&�����q�
�������๲ώ��h��fmq��Ul����{x{~���!��q�(�lϔ�Z��]��Il�����������I������`�_�_�u�}��ll�����������js��g���xv�{w
��������W��P.�����������W�����#q�[�%�������������
�����<���v���ˤ
��˧��������ֿ������`�,�KHIh�}��������_ĭϒ���IcRyxzz/-��bo����������4�s�mmssmm�s��������xv�{w
�����������
d�H�C�/��P�!����������1C�
U[+s$�C���
���B������ v�M�
������M��M&�V��,��$�
����c�Nre3\�R�h��
�
+���(�	���¶�D]��Il�����������I���D��y��|p`rakVAL�����ٹ8T�-u��1�
��t��y���`�/�6�O�O�/�7�_�_�0�2�N�N�0�2�_���&�����#���#<�����3&ԋ��̤���
�#�����?l�؍�f��f��>tl�$�����4�������+��N����������=O>HF-���\������Q��)N>O?$�����
�
�%�������)����p�<l�؍�f��p�[%l�™��������%�����������~����������������f��>tl��΋��Ջ���t>������������<v��y��t��@���'��f�
�����F�J�(�lϔ�Z���Ȫ_�o������(�G\hps�N������������sa��`�Pk\�VqckublV^e��s}�����v�/�
����ȴ�����c��je}��cl���pw�����/��&��������������]b�{ln��kl���}����c�����9�u,��������������]t�cjn��il���i���������������������������!�b��L�ۦ���
��|ح���G{��|����ڼo�~����������y��x������}�cn^�gh�pd�a,CG<X�g�|��oh]i�g�yX{cf\D�R���شx�f��SQ�,wk���n�x��������2������������*tt�*1��>���:R>^-)A�›������
��X��s�mmsrnm�s���������
�
���L�J�(�lϔ�Z��]��Il�����������I���@���'��f�
�����?lϔ�Z�i��^�=� )���&�Ը���K�+��G�����A��y��|v^l]xc`c��qq��ƫ������������ve��{��x@�����驤
��j���F�{�������}����Ģ��s�d��lm�z������T�;'�U �<l��]��Il�����������I�����5��~b��]��Il�����������I����@�V��,��$�
�������7I����9q��j�����)�
UYube��(�lґ�`�h]��Il����������>��ŭŸ���1��G3:^e��s~�����c������g�g�8����⋧j��vc�]CZaVo�c�7;ZW]v���%�lϔ�Z��]��Il�����������I����J�ٽ�dE�{]��Il�����������I����J�ٽ�dE�{]��Il�����������Xr����W����樧
��_���v�w}nq�w������E�3�+ ���)�
���
��������z�FtSqXK9��(�0ۺǘ��r�@����
��f���Clϔ�Z�E2YKC8������+�l؋�2�*J�a�hw�������Ǩ�8�(��G������ꋪ�����
�����L�$����漸��������{rq�y������e�T=9P'�<l��]��Il�����������wB���@�����f�
��f��j��ދ�o��te�YHZhSl����(�lϔ�Z��]��Il�����������I����J�ֿ�ƘZO�{]��Il�����������Xr���ዪ���
����@�9�w�u��9����*���������r��i�|"dl�����������d"����������������*�n�9���!�����
��k��b�Eo�~�P~{��F�w��F���ʗ��8�"���,����=0�0�Y������������v�l�������ң˫��,F%>8[W�K�Z�����t��!������w
�w������rKM/�ll�ȋ����f�.kl��䋴�勈��k.����!u��
�J��ޫw
������������䘔��������x\]�a`^��]�������z��y����������������.gl�Mo^apaxdPH��s����������u�pvoc0�/��
���
5�
[Z{gh�!u���ߤ�!�
��m�������`RtX��q�������y�ooxymI�`����o����1�%.���+�Գ����D{Z��kx��������������ϦF���f�N`Bj#-����[��[w
�-�K����{{��{��k��jth>�l�����������R�z�������������+������mS�ql�����������zM���������
�����u��-�
���@�;��������X@k�R�&��V�8�5�^�b�:�2�T�:��	���}~�����,��A$6�I������J����@�6�~����������@v�U�
�J��J�j�9?C������������
�q�dhxppp�p�����&�a��ت
���?������ˍ��kl�~ol��ol���g������&�����������������Zw�a�R��dl���p��2��p�~�xVunGJrz���������x�try{p^�f�̶�£������
����F�y���'����{sp�z������m�^OaaMt���"�lϔ�Z��]��Il�����������wB���&�v�/�
�B����������m^��ol��ol���|q�����#�����������������`t�_hn��gl���f��&���{����������������
���O���s�mltrnn�r������'�Ml˔�Z��]��Il�����������J�����u���
� ����z�)6'Q���H��������^S�]]S��^l�؍�f�
�&�
!��'����������U|�[Z~��Sl�[p�������Lw
����H�$�%��%�Lo�7h$*�r���t����oUAlggH���W���h��>�
����$�y�����S��-#���'��������������%i2�|��tj��ǵ���.�囧��a���!�v��v�Rw
�h�S��������w�yz������+�v�����0�
���~���:������~������l�l�i���jB�X�k�q�u�l���������z���x�e�3&�}�%q�����}��y�z���������������b�������Ӌ΋�w�u�i�g�A�q�B��ċ������8�r���������!���*�
����x�i�#��& ���(�����w�XYa��tq������Ĥ������Ĵki��a�Xaf�Qr_]o]wa�u���x�
��
�/���(/WVWc[��r������u�klsvhB�N����������+������I�Uc3��hl��f@����
��f��j��ދ�o��te�Y.`Fo}���%�lϔ�Z��]��Il�����������I����J�ֿ�ƘZO�{]��Il�����������Xr����!���v��鮤
��;�ӧ�+��ċ�^��f[�Y7EaKl�z������_���������e3jU�@�HkChuW�c�9�p΋ދ�™��a�g����ʚ���oT��Ygg���A�*@m_\_�����-�@u��0�
�����x�9�������~y��jWz�W�-��	�70�%�=�[���_���o�x���i���f�P�GZ@0�>���9�����~}��w�Uw�����������~���Oځ��������v�s�`�^�J�3�;�q˷����+&�x��������u��?�����n��b��
���՛

7�	��endstream
endobj
72 0 obj
<<
/FontFile3 71 0 R
/Descent -194
/Flags 34
/Type/FontDescriptor
/StemH 0
/CapHeight 666
/XHeight 705
/StemV 74
/FontName/FHMDQW+cmr9
/FontBBox[-39 -250 1036 750]
/ItalicAngle 0
/Ascent 683
>>
endobj
73 0 obj
<<
/Widths[602 575 575 857 0 0 0 0 509 509 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 281 509 0 509 0 0 281 402 402 0 803 281 348 281 509 509 509 509 509 509 509 509 509 509 509 281 281 0 803 0 482 0 776 723 736 790 696 669 803 776 375 522 803 642 937 776 803 696 803 763 575 736 776 776 1057 776 776 629 281 509 281 0 0 281 509 575 455 575 455 308 509 575 281 308 549 281 857 575 509 575 549 402 402 402 575 549 736 549 549 455 509 0 0 0 509]
/Encoding 70 0 R
/Subtype/Type1
/Type/Font
/LastChar 127
/Name/F3
/FirstChar 11
/FontDescriptor 72 0 R
/BaseFont/FHMDQW+cmr9
>>
endobj
74 0 obj
<<
/Type/Encoding
/Differences[46/period 48/zero/one/two/three/four/five/six/seven/eight/nine 70/F 83/S 97/a 103/g 105/i 109/m 114/r 117/u 121/y]
/BaseEncoding/MacRomanEncoding
>>
endobj
75 0 obj
<<
/Length1 2630
/Length 2630
/Subtype/Type1C
>>
stream





RZWJGE+cmbx9

F��
���LN?
Q�����
��
������


IN]1.0Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reservedcmbx9Computer Modern


HJ'ZSBNV4
�

n��B�P����\�H���pN�����
��#�R��R���������������t�c�~mra�t������b��%�90��Z�*�C?��h��"�����P��XW�MKe]m{���Pp���~��ێ����C'&�B$N�������
��T�!�%��I�Lxaq~cV=�`��l������k�jpezYG�P���1����X��iQ�(�$#;���1�)������h+�����
ʢS���j�Ti]y�	+N�v���
�Z�����������xv� ���w�����Xh��������׋��:%�	��vl9�y��G�E‰�������������ċ���
��N���/���#��
�$�3�1������)Y^�% F��]������j�]`gnX-�O��K����O������@�)�;I:^�o������x�c�������JkSv45��j���{����w���N���
��!�u������������w�#��w������p�����pF��~�����ʋߓ�ۚΖ���{=��[�5R=��{dZu^yjN�� � ��
�
�o�%�<��������ˋ����ż����{�����yXT�WMX��`�~���|�~|��y�}��������“��4<C�(�T[��r������f�kldxV4�8��?��
�:�,]`�qaN��۳
����+�Ӯ����7���$C<)U�Q�fVo@c&��Z��6���9�V��`���e���ٖ��aIWkfbu�+�y�_���m�x�[�.�	�e�2�F��㋹��ҴN�����Zw
���^����ms��~����KZ��!�Z���䋈��'��'������N�����&��
�)�I�#���uX�}�D|�~�A�z��#��Ǻ�������	 �%���*P�/�W�s������������_�������ݿN8C`IVU�s�p�����wx�NN������w
��������n����R> �wwZ���������#Z���
����
�����%N�]��'�ϳ�m�
�����l�k}��z|���������x�����-��̴x�v��������������p�y����������w�]�Z�asx}a�]�[��-�W8�JT�g�|vtim`�i�x?v�`uO�G�U�C��׮~�F��QV�(��1�˷�����K_^�K1�c���OkfT��a���ˋ��ϋ�����1
�������a�g]jdda�f������M�BZŒ�d��GZ�Θ��������N�%������
�*�%�4��+�<�
Z���Z���
�������������`A���XA�`*U���'�5�@����ϋ�1
�1����f�b]jfb]�j�����v�\����
�����	�������or�oml��nZ�����������������Tf�lgw��PZ��T�h9e=>������������o�kkoueU�b����̪�<�����
�
����p�nԦ�����z{_�w������W�PE`XQu��
�;�ZǓ�d��GZ�Ց���ŋ���6���8����Z��'�
��8�	�x���C�.R��/^�v������z��������Ӵg<k�:�<`�(�x�׿���q�[�������{��K�����	�"���Xa�����W��苼����
�	�g�	�g�	8����
D�3#XLlx�u3�_�Z1|����A�ZǓ�d��GZ�՗��������G�a��DZ�w?��GZ�՗��������G�a��DZ�w?��GZ�՗��������G������
�
�	�f�	�
�NZǓ�d�R;WY>>������M�ZǓ�d�{�
�w�ϋ־@�G��O����������
�������Q&��Ι����2��I�{���������J���w����_`S�J�U��4E&'C�]���T���u����������i���p�_�w�+��O��?���0����s�q����s�Iy���������������_�‹�=����:�,���B�����_��]��
�	���	�
�
7�	��endstream
endobj
76 0 obj
<<
/FontFile3 75 0 R
/Descent -194
/Flags 262148
/Type/FontDescriptor
/StemH 0
/CapHeight 656
/XHeight 698
/StemV 117
/FontName/RZWJGE+cmbx9
/FontBBox[-58 -250 1195 750]
/ItalicAngle 0
/Ascent 686
>>
endobj
77 0 obj
<<
/Widths[335 0 589 589 589 589 589 589 589 589 589 589 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 749 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 656 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 575 0 0 0 0 0 589 0 335 0 0 0 990 0 0 0 0 482 0 0 656 0 0 0 629]
/Encoding 74 0 R
/Subtype/Type1
/Type/Font
/LastChar 121
/Name/F4
/FirstChar 46
/FontDescriptor 76 0 R
/BaseFont/RZWJGE+cmbx9
>>
endobj
78 0 obj
<<
/Type/Encoding
/Differences[11/ff/fi 39/quoteright 44/comma/hyphen/period 48/zero/one/two/three 53/five/six/seven/eight/nine/colon 61/equal 65/A/B/C/D/E/F/G/H/I/J/K/L/M/N/O/P/Q/R/S/T/U/V/W 89/Y 97/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i 107/k/l/m/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v/w/x/y/z/endash 127/dieresis]
/BaseEncoding/MacRomanEncoding
>>
endobj
79 0 obj
<<
/Length1 10700
/Length 10700
/Subtype/Type1C
>>
stream





AXWUSV+cmti9

M��
����J�LN{
h��|��
��
����
[�)�

IN]1.0Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reservedcmti9Computer Modern


Co7�,028#%6:/&WY-4(C+
"X3$*'.15

MQZSLEmRHV)TGPU[JOBIDFNE
.n

�
���k@���b�	}
F
�{]�
�
�K�\�f�#�~[�>!�|7Z���R��J&�X� �!O!�"D"�#p$$�%L%�&_&�'����I���v���
�k�����������{�6{��~���� �v���5�
���������u�|��|u�uv������`�����y�|��~w�vu����u����ɤ�`�
�᝭��՝����z��x�����͋7��)YIblWq\\V�և������p��W�JJ�K����c�c������N�3�' :i�k������~��������������ijrpt������mQv�;a[U[U�t��v�6�
�����̬�����������������t�Y�m�j�n���}��y����������o{�|�����{R������Ȍ�������gd��fjg��k�~�y~������t����x�����������v���
������
��y�rmlokr�z������L�{�piokou�w������ ���
�
���3�P�,����ɑ�������������Qhg��j�~�y�������}||�������������������ғ���̋�������~ec��dda��e�~�y~���ŋ������}����h��H�{��y���������������������{Q���������� �(�����}����me����y����������������������f����� u��1�
�*�u����M�/+�
�!�c�h�|�~�3�%��b�h�w���/�E?<�)ԣ�+���ݺ���P��V����O��v�����
�������������|�*�_���������������%�럮���x�q��x������1�&xe?<�3q����v�~���������~�P��=����������������`l^NYw��������dU[kok� �V�ڧ�
����
�*�������V��Y�-�/+�
�!�c�h�|�~�3�%�������s�aua�S�
��P����������Xz_]Xhu���I�7�|�ɣ�'�������V�,3c��=!օn�ZX[YU������*��}g}e~o��������cR��v�6�
�����ѥ�����������������x�W�k�i�l���~��y����������i�{�����gq������Ќ�������~hd��gkh��m�|�y~�����������Z���������Mq������Ό��������he��gkh��l�~�y~������p�����x�����������������w����������u����ܱ�
�
��������� �����f�[��`���t����¸j�G('<$I;��0cY������"�(�s��P\d]k���_n���T���rKcl�taky`NG�ݠv�1v�V�
������|<XMYc������������������
��y�k�g�nl�i�l���������ԋ��̤���
����F�h���H{��y~������%�
���Q�6�������Q���z��y~���ŋ������}������������ܟR_-12%�X��z������������B�m7)5'��u���
�
���������#��D�&dwjF\�?0V���������>���~m[��������ř���tC6C��yU:nZFD�uҐ�������
�9����&��2���Ҳ���.��ʋ���C�0��&�2�S�A�]�x��܋��������~�������������|�}�of#My�����F���s4�6�
@*T�@)q�*�����������������v�u��v��
��@����}��~�Jv]^Uj_��v�Nn��������u��	�Q��׫w
�������������
�ۜ����������yYwMic��d�������}�?�ĉ�������������������ȏBxjx"iNMhRgY`R��������{�wV�Iv>�K��!��2�V�9`a}la����
�
�[��E�h���H{��y~������W�U�i�s�?��"��z��y~���ŋ������}ٌ��������I�Up�;E*BV:Y/�z����������u���
�b������˴���������������m�i�l�k�i�l���~��y��������y�u�����1��m�!)'�VQ�꧐����!����̋�������~ec��dda��e�~�y~���ŋ������},��v�r�v��A����
�����
�
�{���Ҽ�����������������t�X�^�]�����~��y����������}yto���r��%�������������������~fd��eif��j�}�y~������v���䌉�����b�3�x~T��B�|����y����������������������������{�Q�����������݌�������
�
�����ɲ���������������l�j�k�j�h�l���~��y��������y�u�������W�X������u��z��y~���������������{K\�f���z����������������������U�������������r��|����������u���
���Aʖ��)��߱����N�= !+"N�v�_�8Bo&Z9�S�����v�������K�!�|�}�����ֿ�kPCNJBg��L]���&ߙ��q|��Y�}]70=0�.M̋��Ǫ���
�N�y������~������������sQ�dO�0��z������������В{q��~�s�����~����������j�������~��}��y�@xvw;5�����������fH��q�q���~�|����������P����{��n{�y~���ŋ������|����h��H�{��y~����{������J���'�
�2̓�4����	�p�{vpvr������~�u\m[���N�ĥ��ͮ�������i�^,f�%�����������������qr�m�xT�(�sl|�]�mo�����:����J���'�
�������Ϝ��������r�wxw�������`�[Xjbr}�wa�f$T�t��������ա�����njv�t~T^�]^zFmfd�p�z�����������{�y�s�rw�j�^�w��������d��q����~��}��~�1oTifi|��������݋��k�
�����|�mikljp�z�����:���z�ogmimt�v���������
�
�����������������_^��^b`��c�~�y~���ŋ������}����h��H�{��y~����G������e�������~��~��{�0ia��43z���������@u��0�
�]�o���=�������������]Rj�U�]�����"�m���
j���v�C,6,2?=����������������~��y�X�`����������������������J݆������������i�q�y�:�T�����d�u���������DCo���t�����~��������� u��~��$�
�+���=��������@4g�T�J��i�k�v�|�.��-����y��d���������������ё�������������������k�g�j�`�^�a���~��y~�������������~�xD�|*r�uY-4� ɦ�A���䡿�8#i�{�����������J���'��f�
��s���*��������z�#�|����z~������������'�#�s�m�{7�D���)�'�T�EV^`����\~ı������������ҷ���ċ�8���Xk�~lh8Zji��u����
�������������������jf��i_]��`�~�y~�������������~����}��fyCRES�la���Ǝ���w�x�Y�DK�_������u����!�
�:����V��|QyD]HqfSKE�y�^�~�����������n�y�k~�X�[�kԋ��������-����*�����+e���ԼȢ���28P�&}q��yz��������������ы4����������o��w
�f��������������UBQgI������{�������������	�ih���9�{~�y���������������������{�C����������Av�V�
���Z�x7ZR\d����������������������������g�b�rf�o�q�z�����������]��Yw
�X�	^=a�p������{������������������������������p�|�����������ӥ�����>���uS�~~�y���������������������V����Z�����{����w��j�E�S�ޥ������'�
�2͒���l���C���orw�wxpszxuC�ќ�����������i�^,f�%�����������������qr�m�x^�
�cc �y������T�ƃ�سϹ��Ӱ�"��p�{vpvr������~�u\dj�|ik}nOPL�ȡ�������0�������}�|{y�n��u�������������|����������8���z��y~���ŋ������}����h��H�{��y���������������������{Q������������ߚSk~���||S�fp$����~��~���Nxlont��������������i�Y�.� ������������z��r�jzbx?_fe[S�^�u��-�
�+���<��������@4`�L�X��g�m�u�}�2��(�������������������PQ� ]F6/�&ͦ�4������9"i�{���������������
�
����������������da��cba��c�}�y~������z����|����j��I�u��y���������������������{M�����������������
����А{q}�x�}�����~���������o�������~��}��v�Bysx@8�����������bM��r�j��|�����������P����{��a{�y~���ŋ������|����h��H�{��y���������������������{�C���������݋�
���v��z�ogmimt�v����������
�
�!��������������{�u��x���N�Lj���q��z��y~���ŋ������}���{K\�f���z����������������������U���������������y�������������� �Ƃh��H�{��y���������������������{Q���������.M̋�����ʪ
�&�����-�(���
�G���z��y~���ŋ������}����h��H�{��y���������������������{Q�������������������uD��)ZT~�^`0�ዪ���
���������������닮��G�q�]�����{���~������������F��������z��v��y�O�H�����~����������������#���������������|���h���1}{~�y~��������������������{||w��|t������������H�a���y��.ٜ�
r�2�0�-���$��������{<���������������{q��u�z�w�����������V�e�"�q��ju�������������œ��~���k}kw�������Z�L>UmNn�w�u�ut�Gz��y~����C�
f�Xt�s��u��}������{�yupzf_�u��8�����H��U��}U~^�|wtzxsxn�u�u�����������{�y�s�rw�j�Y�z��Ћ�á��Ʀ�"�����v�M�
���M�������������{�Zw��}����v�~��������
����*��������z�#�|����z~�����������|������y�|[�`¸�������Ǝ�~��|��x�/txqrx����������V��,��'�
�X��k���d��y���������������������{\������4��e��z����)�&�U�CVeflk�}_�ojrwey{h}S�~��������۟������lv�q���v������������‹�?�~�Wl�w_rU^[a�u�z�~�|������������/�a��=��'�
�1̔����������}�|zz�o�B���b^ZX�Y�����Э�������i�^,f�%�����������������qr�m�x]��b_!��������)jBTSpp���������{�yzj�YV�i����r�v�@�
�4�������������|�m��sw�������\�UOcgis��h�bjrwey{h}S�~��������۟������lv�q��C���}����y���������J����ۘ��f�
�������*��������z�#�|����z~�����������|�$�ԇ}����|�~������������K„�r�X�����}�z�����K�i�����������Ƌ���~���|��x�S}wM`~{�������������8�W������ё�����������m�~s�x�w�����������r�c�O�`[\WZVy}s�����'��f�
����*��������z�#�|����z~�����������}R�w��q�Y���
�%�+%�T�Ƿ���_��r���������Ď�~��|��x�IzyWjx��������K�i�L>UT�՚�����ʥ���Ȕ7������@�a���դ���$ڥ�
r�������$�]D�����y�|[�`¹�������Ď�~��|��x�IzyWjx�������������������{���ɘڞ�����΋��Nj�r��k�i�v�������������m�A���k�:x'Gz��y~����C�
�P��zJp�~Vh�u��}������{�yupzfa�s��+���J�V��,��'�
�����.����������hmjx�}o�[��
�'�(#�U������l��y}T��L����y����������������������������{�\�������������h�L?UZ�ǩ����������ʒ1�������J�a��H���
�����
������~�{w{|x��q�[����) �[dz����v7Z�wkikol�hlq��~������|�xym}ea�{���Ϝx�[i�MAUT�Ԛ�����ϩ���ʓ6������&���'�
�1̔����������}�|k�l��D���pbLO�X�����Э�������i�^,f�%�����������������qr�m�x]��b_)�w������_��{���������Ď�~��|��x�IzyWjx������������ɪ���
����������������~ec��dda��e�~�y~���ŋ������}N����������̋�������~ec��dda��e�~�y~���ŋ������}����h��H�{��y���������������������{Q������������I���h��H�{��y���������������������{Q�������������.ͼ�
�/����f��l���x������c�C�	_.T=�}������Wns;�
qS��{������t���_�PS�b�-������w�q�t�^�m�g�������⋩���h��a���y��.ٜ�
r������$��������{<�����������������{g��l���w�����������]�d�X�ia��qh}D�u�Gz��y~����E�K��yFp�}Uh�u��}������{�yupzf_�u��*������'�
���������O�/���!�&.�B���%�!����h_�ܲ���Ĭ�����gGhx�^FZk\ka�π����Ww
�����$��������{;��'�������~�{p�uz�d�06z��y~����D�����y�|^�]���%��~��~��}�EoaU[�z������������
�5����������������������������ysb|}x�w�|�|�}�z�l�=`+w�����������������������rmz{JN16��jgif\J����������������������{�uu��}�������~��z�_{[h^y{��x�ut�r������݀��'���
�Ǵ�����vssvro���������t�~��}��v�g�o:U�~���������������������������i�^�,�f�%�����������������Ƌ���qs�wz\l�ll�y{a���v�s�w�U�o��ꋰ�'��@���'�
�Ǚ����}���y������˜���������ё����������������j�k�Q`�
z^j���v�U�o���'��~��}��v�g�o:U�~�������������c�EC[_kq��f�ajrwey{h}S�~��������۟������lv�q������'�
�����
������~�{~u�o���q�Y��
�%�+%�T�Ƿ���_��r���������Ď�~��|��x�IzyWjx��������K�i�L>UT�՚�����ʥ���Ȕ7����������'��f�
��Ǚ���*��������z�#�|����z~�����������|�$�ԇ}����|�~���������������������������������j�k�Q`�
z^j���v�U�o���'��~��}��v�g�o:U�~�������������c�ET_rfh�J����۴�
��h��v�����������BR:u]Yl�͵�����������d�_��e�n��������`�G���"�%3�=���ɱ�J���k��7�
�����|�yֿ���ѧ�à�e�G%�*-�I��I���ɱ����������BR:u]G�׮��������4���mm$�3�J�U���'�
�#Ǚ����}���y������˜���������ё����������������j�k�Q`�
z^j���v�U�o���'��~��}��v�g�o:U�~�������������c�EFZe[hŃ`�QTYsVa��e�bjrwey{h}S�~��������۟������lv�q��C���}����y������˜���������ё����²����������w�]�y�m�~u��?�����t��a��
���
7�	��endstream
endobj
80 0 obj
<<
/FontFile3 79 0 R
/Descent -194
/Flags 98
/Type/FontDescriptor
/StemH 0
/CapHeight 666
/XHeight 705
/StemV 70
/FontName/AXWUSV+cmti9
/FontBBox[-35 -250 1148 750]
/ItalicAngle -14
/Ascent 683
>>
endobj
81 0 obj
<<
/Widths[629 575 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 321 0 0 0 0 321 361 321 0 522 522 522 522 0 522 522 522 522 522 321 0 0 790 0 0 0 763 723 736 776 696 669 790 763 402 535 790 642 923 763 790 696 790 749 575 736 763 763 1031 0 763 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 522 468 468 522 468 321 468 522 321 0 468 268 843 575 522 522 468 428 415 335 549 468 683 468 495 415 522 0 0 0 522]
/Encoding 78 0 R
/Subtype/Type1
/Type/Font
/LastChar 127
/Name/F5
/FirstChar 11
/FontDescriptor 80 0 R
/BaseFont/AXWUSV+cmti9
>>
endobj
82 0 obj
<<
/Type/Encoding
/Differences[12/fi 39/quoteright 44/comma/hyphen 48/zero/one/two/three/four/five/six/seven/eight/nine 65/A/B/C/D/E/F/G/H/I 75/K/L/M/N 80/P 82/R/S/T 97/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i 108/l/m/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v 121/y 127/dieresis]
/BaseEncoding/MacRomanEncoding
>>
endobj
83 0 obj
<<
/Length1 6101
/Length 6101
/Subtype/Type1C
>>
stream




DUOTPK+cmbx12

F��
���LNA
V��s��
��
����
8��

IO^1.0Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reservedcmbx12Computer Modern


4/'
4RZ%"3.,m-1�($WNQT&IBCM)H5GF#JDVEPSUO*6
��
,
�6�o�]����$��%��	z	�
�
�3��
,
�
�b��j
�q�<�
d�&�������}����
�$�������6����w�q`���u��q��yw�yt`��ً��ڋ���tp���sn���������������������������������t=�oo<��t`����������u�6���������
�$��3��
�=��`���!`������䋉�������_B���aB�_+T���#�3�B�
����Av�V�$
�0�c��o�89E���������������ߋ���m�T�_�pj�d�g�g��������o���
�������L(��ә������\��v���������P���|�����`Zr�Y�*��#?1�
H�\�}�W���t�u���v�~�o�X�`v<��3�����&����w�v����t�Px���������������]�~Nj�0������M�
�Q�V��%���
�����
���VfV8h�Z�I��#5�"�#�6�������^F`��Ӌ��ԋ���F#��<aP~jKO��&׺�ٸ:]Q�\��̶
��
����������i��bp���R`���~������	�����¶�sG�onP��q`��M�%�}n�^vkFE����������s�mlsvi\�a��շ��i����
�$�����B`���!`�9�T�(��j�v�,��P�P���*��iW��b�Z��	|Wh\]hHj1�������
���}��������������*+��������|�����ks��wr�{��ы˓��Ӓ���|7��X�:N��|}mmwwp�s�_���0��^w
�^�9����sr��y������{��o��r��uy`��Nj��ԋ���ue��o�����������0-`��싱�񋉤�,��{����}�������
¬���
���h����E��L�0lg��v������p�kqjz_E�X��.��΋���{�);���@����ҫ�V(�����
ˢR���m�MjEn(7�U�v��������$����!|���������"�M�`���!`����􋉨�!������q��i�uHH�b�ih�݊��噜��~x��~�Y�lvoK���������!��	����7�9PT�4�;�2����
�'���
�����������v��i`���u��q��yw�yt`��ً��ڋ���tp���sn�����Œ���������������������!`����󋉦�!���iv��v��}����
�$��i�:���^�������O��^m=��r`�������
������n �gg ��n`���!`�����������!�j��e���������Z�u`��英�鋉��pU�����������
�����
���ð��/��
�D?*U�O�d�YxFW��S��(���
5�X��H�w�o������^Iby`Rj�	5�y�`�y�x�s�X�;;rC�(�S��ڋԸ������v�D�
�����D�/o��������
��d���T��$���
�����w�l�~sqf�s������^�&��,i�
&A`��F`��ҋ��ҋ���F���E���h��F`��ҋ��ҋ���F�.�����v���
�w
�S�
����������g��)��r�����aj������ќ���ދ���I��!~{lPP��1�Z�H������������������-���������
�$����aF�{�2�H ����Z2�Vf���n`���!`�����������
�$����!�����>�;���,�9�,`���!`�����������!����/�9GI�7�/�������������
��
���g��B��Ȏɧ���������r�e�{opg�t������c�"��==��H�������� � *�wK�6c�
��Kr���}��۔�����;'(�;#�����v��
������h�kbphkh�j������n�o�chkod`�r������}��[���
�!�2����zٶ�s �kNI��N`�!%v�ocr~wl�aR(��Md�s��Ѹ����
a�D�����������n���u@CS�H�A����.�%�f�b�)�)���ښ��k��s������7��kw�sv�w�
�!������4���u@CS�H�A����.�%�f�b�)�)���F���
���|������,��W1J3��Sh�k��Ժ����
a�D�����������������-���w
���o��.��������ċ���������������{]Z�SR[��\�������z��x��������������-<C�#�fL��i�����q�fmjy\4�7��.���8�c[�k`Q�v�*�
����������g��bp���R`����������	�����¶�tE�pnQ��q`��D��x�����������v�
v�V�$
�4�g���=jMS^���������������ߋ���j�S�_�pj�d�g�g�����������������^w
��
�E�1�*�A���ry��|��O`����
`�����*�
�o��������
���
�_�
�_�
8����d��&\Gk{�{G�K+WM[v���=�`ɒ�d��F`��Ӌ��ԋ���F�i�
ܿʰ�u=��F`��Ӌ��ԋ���F�i�
ܿʰ�u=��F`��Ӌ��ԋ���Fo�V��%���
�
������+F�Tu��r����&�.�PXwkc��A�`ɒ�d��F`��Ӌ��ԋ��F���������P��%CXK``��l�d��� �
��{��
�?���|����|������o�f�g�m��*����"�u�����������r�a�>0�v�X�L�o�����zv��t�x�����������h��������q�w�b�i�U�K�O�����䋠����E�r�~����������苶������
�$��9��V��a�)vf=�B�0����b?���a@�a+P���0�-�J���n����`���!`�o���
��U�
��
�^�
�����b��&ZDm}����A�`ɒ�d��F`��Ӌ��ԋ���F�i��˰�s?��F`��Ӌ��ԋ���F����b��4�
���b�
�`���B�!S�
�7a�y��������z������ϴe9c�2�3_�0�w�ؼ���f�`���������}L�����
�-7ykZb�����o�����U�
���d�J�A�`ɒ�d���������V€�����ߋ�%��-��P�\xbk�[��������I^�Rsf[l\�kGf��}�狶��
���m�J�A�`ɒ�d��F`��ҋ��ҋ���F�}��������
�$����s����n �gg ��n`���������n �gg ��n`���!`�����������!�����!`�����������!������������
��M�!������#[^�!�vI��[������n�banna/�U��9���r�/������C��9P:Y�{��������\���ϋ��Fmm�]kbqiq�e��w����������z���������]��2�֫�~�
��s�����Jq�Ë����Ѿn�������������~�v�x����������y�a�`�bvvyb�d�X���T>�El�b�izxyhg`�f�{s�MtRP�H�L�:���Q�r��[K�3r_���`����������4�й�����F]]�F4�[��~WhhQ��gñ�ʋ������
���d�9�'w����
���$��+`����׋����+����$�7����ɋ�����s�
����m�%�����͛������|��zvc�y������g�D0�e�%A`��F`��֋��܋���4����S��>�
������X�q�������]��aS�Q�06%�� �0�+�+����|��{��~�JqIv[�%���������������������Y�-��������
�%�����B`���!`�X�9����8�
��$��ݺ�7�4�U�����I�=YEdC�	�)�����[�	��^Li:�������
����
��P����ka�v�P|���=�|��/���ך���Ͼ��
 ����*K�,�V�|����������l�l��������@C=VCb`�m�w�����yz�8�狶����$
���s��j�dbliee�i������D�I`ƒ�d��F`��Ћ��ˋ���M�+�(����
���G�
�h�	����{���x�pH/�!��,�ƌ���Ɖ��������~|ra�z�������U�FE����/�'�1���o����
��
�^�
���N`ɒ�d�X?^N=@������F�`ɒ�d��'�n��Ջܶ�:�A��M����o�����U�
�����
��B`ɒ�d�^�u_�F�"&3� �#�6�º���W�F��M������
��NaX~g���ͺ����êƑ���y_���������
��������o�/�1�74#���-�1�7�����Q���	ݺ���������įpo��g�W[8����P���
�
����d�u���3�	}��zyb�z������W�[<iFa}���8�`ɒ�d��F`��֋��܋���4�d�����Sw
�
�
��g�%�$��$�Sa�([((�j��!�t�շ���aWImnlO�΢o���
�
��
�^�
�����b��CMh@i���=�`ɒ�d��F`��Ӌ��ԋ���F�i��˰�s?��F`��Ӌ��ԋ���F�x����
�#�������g'�aa'��g`���`����������������w
�}������kKA��ux`���������`������������B�����_��]��
�
���
�
�
7�	��endstream
endobj
84 0 obj
<<
/FontFile3 83 0 R
/Descent -194
/Flags 262178
/Type/FontDescriptor
/StemH 0
/CapHeight 656
/XHeight 698
/StemV 109
/FontName/DUOTPK+cmbx12
/FontBBox[-53 -251 1139 750]
/ItalicAngle 0
/Ascent 686
>>
endobj
85 0 obj
<<
/Widths[622 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 311 0 0 0 0 311 371 0 0 562 562 562 562 562 562 562 562 562 562 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 853 803 813 863 743 703 883 883 422 0 883 673 1064 883 0 773 0 843 622 783 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 542 622 502 622 512 341 562 622 311 0 0 311 933 622 562 622 592 462 442 442 622 592 0 0 592 0 0 0 0 0 562]
/Encoding 82 0 R
/Subtype/Type1
/Type/Font
/LastChar 127
/Name/F6
/FirstChar 12
/FontDescriptor 84 0 R
/BaseFont/DUOTPK+cmbx12
>>
endobj
86 0 obj
<<
/Type/Encoding
/Differences[11/ff/fi/fl 45/hyphen 50/two 65/A/B/C/D/E/F/G/H/I/J 76/L/M 79/O/P 82/R/S/T 97/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i/j/k/l/m/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v/w/x/y]
/BaseEncoding/MacRomanEncoding
>>
endobj
87 0 obj
<<
/Length1 8076
/Length 8076
/Subtype/Type1C
>>
stream




SOPMTL+cmti10

N��
����J�LN|
�7��z�]
��
����
6�g

KQ`1.00BCopyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reservedcmti10Computer Modern


.n%&RW('Y

#*0-5L"KC3TX4G1.Q$HMmJDENUVBZSF)OIP+0
�
g@��(_"���[�	*	�
oH�k�
�G�x���
������5�W��LV����2O�a���ԡ���-ڟ�
r����3��������{|v��x��h����d��rk�p�;x'�BkJz��x����E���]�]�^l�~Wg�u��������y�{rrwh\�x��#�"����uC�����{�}V�f���������ō������u�S}xLiq���������e���ʚޚ������������xq�~u�x�u�����������`�D�
���
�
�H��@�i���G{��x������Q�S�i�u�#:���{��x������z����}���������^�Pn�O6'RZDa;$l������������Ǫ���
�?�?������������t��QhJ�3�l�����������ϒ{p��|�n��������������p���������~��v�Dxxu::�����������mDp�~�s���������������E����v��gz��y~���ŋ������|����i��G�{��x����s������T�V��,��-�
�����5����������gho{�q�[��
�,�&6�Eִ����w=��w<�`��K�~����x����������������������������}�X�����������l�N;T\�Ʃ���	��Ȥ������o��{�nx������$uђ�������
�9����#��,���Դ���.��ɋ���=�=��(�9�^�J�w�`��ڋ��������~��������������~nf!N�����P���p8�%47(P^pasaWE7�E�����������������������w�z�y�u������B��������{�b}dHHod��{�gd�l������T���-�
�0ș�	������ntrtt~�����q�kvo\���U���ū��������j�`.h�(������������������qs�p}dl6wO\0�n�<�������v�O�
���O�������������{�Ww��~����x�~����
u��}��%�
�*��H�e�������������li��k`^��`�~�w��������������}����ou2��mo`dTe�,�9͋��ţ�3����؋���+�4�q�k������������������������������LA`�Q�Y��b�k�u��5�!�"�Թ��s��g���������������
�3����̔|pz�{�{��������������p���������~��y�Dy{r8=���������	��lFs�x�t�{������������E����v��[z��y~���ŋ������|����i��G�{��x��������������������{�B���������H����qۙ�
�����n�*c��f�~�x������Q�nTjZx��uZ�r'U�t���������ᦿ����tcsZ�f�b���]{Jv;O���s�z���������v�~�r�rv�j�d�t��������R������������{�5pYdawp����������ɓ����º������}g�a���x��-ء�
r�+�*�&���$��������{>�߆��ߕ����������yt�xx�r�u������������_�`�a�amxfvb�gr��}��D���������������|��n|�l�u������������W�S���k)}Bw$Iz��x����B�
~H~W�}s�}Wh�s��~������y�{rrwh\�x���/����}G��}AzK�s��gNXww��|������y�{ptukX�{���ƴ�����������͡������l����������
ߕGl6>%���k�������P�
��{��x������z����}����i���G{��x������"����H�C�� ���l�����������@�5q*;#��������
�
�P����������������ca��bb`��b��y~������z��~������j��H�v��y���������������������wM���������
u��8�
�(�e����P�8%��a�c���|�+� ��\�f�u���'�L0S���� �������O�3g�V0�J2P@s���
�
�������������������^\��]ba��c�~�x������z����}����i��G�{��x����@������k�����������x�2k`��0:l��������ȋ����
�C������������������}�M��x�P�������~������������G��������{��w��y�P�G�~���������������������!������������������h��3�{z��x��������������������||{l���o����������T����ܘ��f�
�������1��������������(�����x����������~���(�⊉������|��������_���v�Q����}�z���C�r���������Ȏ������u�X~xG_p��������������E�L��������Ʋ���������a��h���~�x����������y�^�V�`aicRI{{hz싪�Z��\w
�
�T�`?`�h����z����������������������������������g���������������x��:�ws`���x��������������������{W����`�����{�{����l�����e��a�������h�h�\�����������m�S(V�'����������ʤ�ɿ��uy{�x�{,�~Vd=M�y}�����������qyl}df�v��������9�u�rsss~�w������T���-��f�
��p���1��������������(�����x����������~��(����b�e7�G��	�*�'�O�Oeivki��rj�ַ�������������������R�k�ap�nKr`EX��u����������y�
��t���������������ˋ틋-���.UUmnYtG�&�O}�"�����?���{��x������z����}����i��G�{��x��������������������wQ��������������{C}��}S�\�}xA�k�ߩ�����~~���Szmklm��������������h�X�������.Ͻ�
�.����k��p���z������b�I�	b+W>�}������Ukp;$uQ��{������~�vtoz^N�g�*����=�b�o�g�����ۦ��d�����-�
�1Ș���C���<�o�v}�l8VE�՘��ժ�������j�`.h�(������������������qs�p}dY��qpi�i�so���������f��p�ǵ�ҩ�ϲ�.���ntrtt~�����q�kvck"zbWukb]Y{���������<���������wn�p��7u��0�
�[�_��
�=��������������^Sd�D�w���
��W�V�p�������}�|���y�}�u�g�0='2�@�@��󋢐�������������������|W�e����������������������U�|������������q�r��,�x�l���i�z���������GAq���u�}�������������a���x��-٠�
r������$��������z=�Վ��ѓ����������{m�}s�w�u������������b�b�)�r��iv�I{��w�����B�	M�b�vi�~Wg�x���������y�{rrwh^�v��f���������ʪ
������/���	�G�
��{��x������z����}����i��G�{��x��������������������wQ�����������������ѾqKw|)e_dhYxO������
�
�<���������������z�u��y����S�ʼn���s��{��x������z����}���}Se^����y���������������������R���������������z����������	�
��!�ʃi��G�{��x��������������������wQ���������$�V��,��-�
�O���l��d�����x����������������������������}�X������������&�z�b���
��(�)�O�OZ`gin�^�rgwtm{xc~P����������ѝ�����n���{�o�t�������Rkap�nKr`EXQ�������u��-�
�*����=��������������LA`�Q�Y��b�k�u��8�$��W�
�j�����������=X�K873�"ɤ�1�������+4q�k������������T�a���������p���v7Y�voi\cc�|~l��p��������qyl}dc�y����מ�
�J�������z��t�n��}p�`���(�!6�G־������^�J�kN=T�U�ז���	�������ǔ7��!����
����1��������������(�����x����������~��������w�|V�f���������ˎ����������rzExao�q��������7�a���ԡ���#ۨ�
r��ǿ����$�\C�����{�}V�f���������ō������u�S}xLiq���������Č��������z�����������������r_��d���~�x����������
�r���Adp�!y-Jz��x����F���Z�ZZq�~Vg�s��~������y�{rrwh\�x��&�%���-����ú�a����#����~��|�n�p+Q�}��������ĠĠĕ�������e�f�-�i�)������������������ŋ�����ts�n�x�l�n�t~jjj}e���w�d�b��鋬�*���t�w�}vpwor��������T����ڸ�
��a��G�
Y��b�{�{������`�K���"�&(�I����������-A2�zUr����̯������b��$���-��f�
�����1��������������(�����x����������~��Q�~|�p�a���
�,�&6�E֯����Z��v���������ō������u�S}xLiq��������P�l�N;T\�Ʃ���	��Ȥ������o��{�nx������=���-�
�Ý��z�C����������������Ћ���X�|�p�n��J���������|��������4����������������Ћ���X�|�M_�}c~i���v�_�g��苭�)��������~��|�p�p)Qv��������������Q�\EY__mЃW�^OZj]i��i�`gwtm{xc~P����������ѝ�����n�{�x�{@����������|�������̀����Ww
�����$��������{;��(�������z��r�v|�d�36z��x����C�����{�}Y�c��)�������y�[yc@Rp������������-�
�/Ț������������wm�n��B���y���~oxnm_^���Ȭ��������j�`.h�(������������������qs�p}dqEqAW4�n������U������������ō������u�S}xLiq���������$���-�
���w�������z��k�i���xk�k��
�,�&6�E֯����Z��v���������ō������u�S}xLiq��������P�k�M:T\�Ʃ���	��Ȥ�����Wa������<�a��۹��8w����nȚ������9eA_Y[}�������������{�yd�SW�i���������������wm�n��B���n�cOP^���Ȭ��������j�`.h�(������������������qs�p}dqEqAW4�n�������x�v��ښ�
�)�������������}�h��k�~�x������J�jFgYu{��d�jgwtm{xc~P����������ѝ�����n�{�x�{@����������|�������T���p��;�
�������{�Ύ��ګ�̒�f�K"�#&�E1�6����������-A2�zJ�Ҳ��������8����pi!�9�j싪�ɪ���
���{���������������eb��dcb��d�~�x������z����}N����������ʋ��������eb��dcb��d�~�x������z����}����i��G�{��x��������������������wQ������������I���i��G�{��x��������������������wQ��������7���-�
�Ý��z�C����������������׋���^�v�M_�}c~i���v�_�g��苭�)������~��|�p�p)Qv��������������T�Z9[Ox~��i�`gwtm{xc~P����������ѝ�����n�{�x�{@����������|�������$���-��f�
��Ý���1��������������(�����x����������~���(�⊉������|����������������������������ы���^�v�M_�}c~i���v�_�g���)�����~��|�p�p)Qv��������������T�ZHhhml�$���-�
���������P�4���"�&$�M���"�'����df�ӽ����Ȱ�����_P`u$kOTnX^Z�u���}�
�������������������jg��i^\��_��x�������������|����}��fx@RET�bh�������������w�v�P�>G�c�����u��?�����s��a��
���
7�	��endstream
endobj
88 0 obj
<<
/FontFile3 87 0 R
/Descent -194
/Flags 98
/Type/FontDescriptor
/StemH 0
/CapHeight 665
/XHeight 705
/StemV 68
/FontName/SOPMTL+cmti10
/FontBBox[-163 -250 1146 969]
/ItalicAngle -14
/Ascent 683
>>
endobj
89 0 obj
<<
/Widths[614 566 590 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 361 0 0 0 0 506 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 747 699 711 759 675 650 771 747 385 530 0 626 891 0 771 675 0 735 566 711 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 506 458 458 506 458 301 458 506 301 301 458 253 819 566 506 506 458 422 410 337 542 458 662 470 482]
/Encoding 86 0 R
/Subtype/Type1
/Type/Font
/LastChar 121
/Name/F7
/FirstChar 11
/FontDescriptor 88 0 R
/BaseFont/SOPMTL+cmti10
>>
endobj
90 0 obj
<<
/Type/Encoding
/Differences[43/plus 48/zero/one/two/three/four/five/six/seven/eight/nine]
/BaseEncoding/MacRomanEncoding
>>
endobj
91 0 obj
<<
/Length1 1579
/Length 1579
/Subtype/Type1C
>>
stream




JIZTQJ+cmr6

F��
���LNU
w�����
��
������

IM\1.0Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reservedcmr6Computer Modern




S�
>
�1�f�E��������
v�����w
�M����t�������r�}������qq�r}���}r�qq������}�r�����[v���
�������ԋ���������BC���������������aG��s{ŋ��΋ؙ��ט���u?��V�B>K�&zS4oC~j[v���ګ��
����S��?�@gOdr[Y=tU��o������y�mmxxl:�m�.�� �e������/�@�a�g`��q��IJ��*KMp��{o����Ƌ�����������?c1P;3[v����
�������լü��"�#�)G&M�[�r���~��Ir.S�&��	�Q�����ۋ���a�|�x�Y�g��I���X���ګ���`@>8bo}5H���O�}�~�m�R�</b6�.�5������Ÿ[�v���w
�u�����������bs��dZ����fg�o����ƚ���ዚ��v�}UKsn*�	G�"��,���[����������T���[v����ꬬ
����7�����ޮɷ�ͩNj�����of��q�{�q�u����������]�%��/��,���i���,��ϑ����������N��h_�6EXgPi�$���!��@����忩vk��d�^VF�iicmsk{[[v�����w
������>��������Ë����ɴ����������}gX}JZU��^�����}��{��z���������������*kd�Sjbel]{`FF��s������v�l�a�Y/�3�����/�JYvpk[�����lw
����8��	�N���ry�����]d��;j�7nd��鎷�鈊��n7����8�&����[v�����
�
��������R%�I[Bp$��^������s�jpmza(�S��(����S��ڥ����-��	2U9`�������u�p���拔��s8Tl+'��yp������|{���[����
�������Of�}�I|���:�}��O���Ũ����˪������ҋ������16�-�X������������~�_���ȱ���=:D\BEK���m�����l�G[������w
���������mKI%�gd�͋����j�~$`d��ً��ً���`$���v��?�����o��a��
���ޜ

7�	��endstream
endobj
92 0 obj
<<
/FontFile3 91 0 R
/Descent -194
/Flags 4
/Type/FontDescriptor
/StemH 0
/CapHeight 665
/XHeight 704
/StemV 83
/FontName/JIZTQJ+cmr6
/FontBBox[-20 -250 1193 750]
/ItalicAngle 0
/Ascent 683
>>
endobj
93 0 obj
<<
/Widths[944 0 0 0 0 602 602 602 602 602 602 602 602 602 602]
/Encoding 90 0 R
/Subtype/Type1
/Type/Font
/LastChar 57
/Name/F8
/FirstChar 43
/FontDescriptor 92 0 R
/BaseFont/JIZTQJ+cmr6
>>
endobj
94 0 obj
<<
/Type/Encoding
/Differences[11/alpha 14/delta/epsilon1 21/lambda 25/pi 30/phi 58/period/comma/less/slash/greater 65/A/B/C 69/E 71/G/H 76/L/M 80/P/Q/R/S/T 97/a/b/c/d/e/f/g 105/i/j/k 110/n 112/p/q/r/s/t/u/v/w/x/y/z]
/BaseEncoding/MacRomanEncoding
>>
endobj
95 0 obj
<<
/Length1 7395
/Length 7395
/Subtype/Type1C
>>
stream




LVPWNA+cmmi10

L�!�"
�#�$��J�M��
k������
��
����
U��


	#hn}phialphadeltaepsilon1lambdapi1.100Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reservedcmmi10Computer Modern


-()$L2&
�X
�EWV4CB
�
�[DUTSRQHGF
�5KJ.
�-#"31Z
YO/
�
�]<��f.f���	v	�
�t.�

��^��n*�G��`��)�d�U���UV�u��}��%�
�����K���������E>��]���s�u�q�|�3���6������������r�f��������������������������Č������������t�P�t�l�=�l�����w���������������~��^�f�o��h+"�-���9�������>�c���������������@���ɪ���
�����������������oC��onD��n���w�������������~����~O���������Ӌ��������oC��onD��n���w�������������~��������d��<�y��w�����Ҏ�������������������xfo�����������a�:t,�|�kx�M�|����w��������Ҏ�����������������������xfo��������u��-�
�����K���������E>��]���s�u�q�|�9�
�
�-�׳���ݜ�����������ntDFQFSLzW�1�!���0�Ġ�6�	������>���c��������������������嗡�f�
��������?���~tB��q����y��������w�%�ԇ}����t������������M�����{�I�����������P�c�����������‹����������}�BwtX_x~�������������L�6�������������������������������[��d��{�x���������t�^o]�;Ciedce|�%�V�֤�����
�����J��/�'�F�U�5!��)�l�p�w�}�:�&�$������M��~k�=���K����������DsQrh]|�ׁ�Q�=�i��Х�"�������=�'X�~�<-����BVZYWw����ɀ}k��������sN|�����qm�o��Ǫ���
�X�}��������������(JfH�?�&}������������������vr���m���������������~����������?vyt/-���������!��n9s���p����������������A����r���w��w�������y����y����d��<�z��x����������O�Lv�kw�Xv��w
����I�2�����������z�Q�{�3��'���,�<���l�k�l\�e���������������������������5��%�����V����EO�C���� �)��ׇ�]3�
5�#�*Ȁ��-�
�
̔���P��b��������}�|y�w���\�S�q�m�y�y������tVmld�;��Ջ���������������j�Z�,f�%����������覲�����kr�o�z_�
]e0�h֜��ѳK�Ѕ�ַ�ǥ�٫���p�zrrqu~�������q[in)qXVqhhZ\p�ħ�����$�yv�|w
��K�\����������������M�~����������������-�
�����q���1.�A���#�!.�?��Ӣ��V��l���›���������Zyg��l�٣������
����������y�yLj?\PH@>3>�cOm�˼����Ժ����=f�Q�z����-��f�
�����?���~|,��z����~��������wO��y�n�^��	��'�&-�Iٟ����a��j���������ȍ�������}�JzyPbp��������K��y��|z_Tb{o�Y�}‹��������Ƹ���̋�9���������<���-�
�
˕���h��q�yrsqu~�����w�qgaN�y�	Xt��æԪ�������k�Y-e�%����������𨶢����kr�p�y_�~]`��{��<�߿C���-�
�˖����b��q���������ȍ�������}�S}xGav����������������������������}�|���q��ixB_�CV��c;B�W�����çڥ�������k�Y,f�%����������⤱�����ks�n�|f(vMZ,�r�ͯ���gu��0�
�G�|���K�������}[Rq�W�J�����
:�]�|�o���|�919-)K������������������������S�x�����������ĶQ�}ŋ��
���i�|�t�|�2�u�g���p�i��������ދ�`���k�y���������������l���-��f�
�������?���~tB��q����y���������i�v9��Y�{�h,�M�
��)�$�V�;]bnlmw>�������̸������m�K�Pj�yejH]gd�i�j��Ջ���������-�
���	��yn�^�	��'�&-�Iٟ����a��j���������ȍ�������}�JzyPbp���������������ˏ��Ē��������z�s�|u�uJ���y��|z_Tb{o�Y�}‹��������Ƹ���̋�9���������`��1�
��������I�m*��
+�C�	�1��c�i�g�Pַ������~}���~������{�g��W}�{=g`OU�S�N�u�]�UCIe�;.Tb��ʰ�P�������k��#�
�����v������z�6����������~�zh��'�-��<��̳����������wlfzfQY�㮓����H�Γ������
���Ũ���������衻��������������m[v{s�s��|�x�z�j�@].v�����������Ō������|����g`7Cx{Y^��deGHhR�������������������������n�v�{��������������JtKxjwy��v�i|�v�{����l����㳡
��n�� �{}�}}{|�z�s��������\�D���#�!1�<�#�����������(<�
�Lp�Ǵ���Ī¶���~p����r�����Ww
���b�$��������y3��"�����z�o�h�d�3-w��x����C���zyU�e���&����������#`Vsiv���������H����(Ժ�
��)���
o�wuu}�|������`�?�f%_=�|������Tqt7�}>��t������{�vqmv^R�c�6��
��x��p�n�_�g�c�������㋤����d�`�v��䘡
������|�t�y�����������������ё������������������m�us�q�{�x���������k�XJ_Zox��g�\]xdy�yi~O����������Ҝ������ev��~W��4ij�V��,��-�
���X�C�����ccnz�ud�k�
��(�%)�MԶ�����hj����o��S�~����w����������������������������{�[����������O�؜���
��ժ���̙:��T�o��o|SKS�$�V��,��-�
�6���i���_��x���������������������}Y������7��n��h����&�'�R�?Y[gdj��`�f]xdy�yi~O����������Ҝ������et���zˀ���������������h�P�Pj�yeiE[jf�I�~ދ��������<�a����"�
���k�
�������z�p�g��yh�c��� �$(�P�ƺ�����v2b����i(!xj��o��������pukycb�w���ǚx�W�qtruxvylyn�Y�|�������
��������͋�:���������0�a���p��%䝡
������$��������z8�Ŋ��ŏ��ґ������������y_��h�|�t�����������]�b�iLy(m�v��s�Fx��x����@�y*z0W��r��x������y�xqnue^�s�³Ʊ��ʢ�
���H���p��;�
�����O�{�Ս��ѩ�ƙ�e�F��+*�C%�<�#�����������(<�
�=�߫��������,����ni#�4�bC�v�Ww
��������"��-�t�u����������������������`���vU�\�~�����������G�C�-�\������~z�������O�����
�?����������������=�|�d�q�������������������B��������z��s��x�O�D���}������������/����(�������������f�� �g��x������������������������������qr~��qn������������a������
~�n��!��}�stmtmw�{������]�7?x[RS�|��y��������prnvgc�u������������a�Y%R�%����������Ȥ������at���z�����-���
�Ƕ�����}�tppqpx�z�����?���������������k�Y�-�e�%���������������鳩�������kv�v���q^�{`�q~j�v�\�h��鋰�%�������������|yLjNX�z�����������ڋ��
�
�2��������������z�q��x�
��=�ʈ���q��x��x���������������������czk:��~�y����������������������R�������������������������(�
��#�сd��<�z��x����ώ��������������xfo�������7�v��
�����	�j�(�`H|�p�i_�������������nӋ̧�����������v�x��ue�\_hdq]����������ؼŋ��k�
U�
a0�|�����x����������������������
��T��s�nnssnn�s������yv��w
���7�x��������������~����������������������}���������������yv��w
���7���������������~���������������������������������������
�
�
���������������j9��jmB��m��w�������������~��������d��<�z��w�����c������l�������������{�/i_��A-}���������������
���͡���
����4�d���<z��w�������2�
�
��Q�*������I���x��w�������������~�����������������P_35,��S��}�����������������Q�A`(2*�
싪�]��Yw
�G�cHd}_�����x������������������������������t�s����������������v���mW�w}��w����������ʈ���������~M����N�����z�{�����x�I�Y�ޫ���mI$u�����������ۭ�|���������������ҋ���(�i{FddqqVk1���e~����1���w��w�������������~��������d��<�y��w�����ю���҈���������xfo������������Sh|�l�t�o�fw�����𙗀�������Ar`ztj��������������H�p�������ʪ
�(�����>�"���I���x��x���������������������d��<�z��x����Ҏ�������������������xfo�����������������pFdw5dg^YO�_�!�0�a��㵡�-�
�˖��z�������}�|�{�|����l�y�q�p�p^�H|�`EIX�����ɭ�������k�Y,f�%����������馳�����kr�q�xc!yR\2�mƲ����~WZcVqien]�}�^�z���������������p���t�j{�Z�Y�fɋ���������@v�U�
�I��_��r�djwrop�q��������������}AhOjj������������	7����a䘡
���������������~�o�wrs{�x������P�iQhVt�rU�n#R�r�����������ͤ����QlzHf� M{ha_�t��v������u�|mrqk]�w�ͯё�f��d������������� jGskd{�������[���-�
��ǚ����|�t�y������������������������������������ꋸ��f�j�MZ�{`�t���\�h��&��������|�GwjSZz��������������`�C1ZKtzÆb�]]xdy�{i}P����������Ҝ�����~jv��~Wu��?�������a��
���
7�	��endstream
endobj
96 0 obj
<<
/FontFile3 95 0 R
/Descent -194
/Flags 98
/Type/FontDescriptor
/StemH 0
/CapHeight 683
/XHeight 705
/StemV 72
/FontName/LVPWNA+cmmi10
/FontBBox[-32 -250 1048 750]
/ItalicAngle -14
/Ascent 683
>>
endobj
97 0 obj
<<
/Widths[638 0 0 446 410 0 0 0 0 0 578 0 0 0 566 0 0 0 0 590 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 277 277 783 506 783 0 0 747 759 711 0 735 0 783 831 0 0 0 687 976 0 0 638 795 759 614 590 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 530 434 434 518 470 494 482 0 349 410 518 0 0 602 0 506 446 446 470 361 578 482 711 566 494 470]
/Encoding 94 0 R
/Subtype/Type1
/Type/Font
/LastChar 122
/Name/F9
/FirstChar 11
/FontDescriptor 96 0 R
/BaseFont/LVPWNA+cmmi10
>>
endobj
98 0 obj
<<
/Type/Encoding
/Differences[13/gamma 21/lambda 25/pi 33/omega 58/period 60/less/slash 65/A/B 75/K/L/M/N 80/P 82/R/S 88/X 98/b 110/n 112/p 120/x/y/z]
/BaseEncoding/MacRomanEncoding
>>
endobj
99 0 obj
<<
/Length1 4315
/Length 4315
/Subtype/Type1C
>>
stream





MJMVEV+cmmi9

L�� 
�!�"��J�M��
n�����
��
����
��

]bqomegalambdagammapi1.100Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reservedcmmi9Computer Modern



�
�C
�
�31-Q.#4,9/O[ZY"
�

����W �y	�
����
C�k���UV���w
���u�y����Ř�����{p�kq��[�u�yzrZQJ�D�x̋������󔗋�����������������`ToEqH�Mi3�P״��ӾG��u���̴����m�{rqpt|�����~�p^74� N�Ğ�[�v�Ww
����)���~�q���������������������i���tI�g�~�~��������o�f�/�.�/��������|v���������d���'��f�
�������(���������}3��w����z~�����������ps,��q"}S~X�\�r�m�k�5�A�	���!��*��L�@�X�_htu}R�������\\^o�lVKf_tlYw���������Wv���
�"���|�m�j�\�V���C�)�j��������������蛬��5���T�K�O�}�}q3p$p��|����Ȝ��������6�G������������������tbsWv\��pMl:N�v��
������|Lq#8��f�ge������������lыբ������	�����u�x��sh�\\ppgT����������ռȋ��`�+F�"�|�}�v���~�{���������!�yv�|w
�#�V�Z���������}�������J�}����~���������-mv��w
��H����������}������������~}���������������������������u�������������|���������������ڋ���&�f|@R`s{Yq:��	�p|������,���y�y~����������������������g��@�x��y�������������������������������v�y��{u��������������We����us/��|1�x��𛒅������Wzfhfe�����Ō�������g�Q��4�������ʪ
�7�����;�6����D���y�y~����������������������g��@�x��y�������������������������������v�y��{u��������������������sBv�-W[wu]m5�%����
�
�������������~��tq��sss��sts��u�yl�z�}�y~����������������������g��@�x��y~����l��������R��������w�2i_��C(}����������������V��,��'�
�@���n���`��y�����������������������������z\���������������v�bċ�	���!��*��L�@�v�Y�NG|�]�i�a�vl}pzh}R�����������ڞ�����k|��|���l���������������\�\�^o�lViRamf�J�{ڋ��������苪�
�
�G��������������x�r��x���8�LJ���o��y�y~���������������������~WowI��}�z��������������������������������\�y�������������{����������+���#�ςg��@�y�y�����������������������������v�y��{u�������������̤���
���7�g���@x��y~�����6��
��P�(�������C���y�y~�������������������������������<r2.0��`��}�����������������P��p0(0,�vu��0�
�H����"�:������������}}|��]Uf�Q�V��������b�i�o�m���x�v���lR26-'P������������������z�V�l������������������H燩���������)�l�n�p�h�j�N��׋�������o�f�Uqj��������������]���
�
���5οϽϾ��ɶ��Ƒ����������������O�g�f�h���~��y����������{��~}�������������"���Ӕ���ً��������xs��w�vt�wk���m�wq�x�}�y~����������������������g��@�x��y�������������������������������v�y��{u���������2�-��M�0�M�~���na���y������������������������������h�z�z��U���
�
������ˣ��������ʳ�ߑ��������������i�����t�{�y�x�y�yw��z�~�y�������qzts���8�?2�\�������������������wt��www��vj���sT���|��y~���Ɛ�w�������������||��qn��NNdc7�����{���������������������������������������m����������������������������������{v`���z�������������������‰��������P�����:���
�
��������َ������������u�S�u�r���s�{�v�|���}��y�~��������j��}���Q�y������t��x��y~�����������ZrtE��~�z��������������������������������\�y��������������{������������
��X��t�lltrnn�r�����i���'�
�˕��Q�1���Ԍ����������������V�z�N\��ll���x�U�m��닲�#���������~�6raeg�y�������������I�V.ZIv{��b�Yavlp}zh}R����������ڞ�����k|v�l�q�q�`�~T}U~T�s�����~�{���������������<����
����½���ʢ����ڦ�������~�������~wp`i�w�~�t�s�x�q�>\/r�����������Ƌ������~����lhS[LUY`lmuufd^N���������������ǰ������|�q�r����������������ApD�qxw��m�ws�v������!�a��崤�'�
�ϐ������������u~y�x����b�uY�\�n������a<C�M��ʋ���������������f�Z�+�c�"������������ՠ�����x}z�y�s\�~a[�倰�����~X�^dYmccp_�o�j�}���������{�u�s�kx�]�W�gʋ�
�	N����Y㚤
�������(f��k|x�z������Y�\OhVv�x_�[ Q�q����������ͪ���x\g`�4~[l�mMTwv���������x�xnqriZ�w�ŭ���I�Ƃ�����������|�CuQYWnp����”�����������������������]��Yw
�J�	Z;_�c��������������������������������������e�����������������t�i�r�d�_���|}zQ���~��y������������������������������������O����E�����z�}��~��|�F�^�ް��u��?�������a��
���
7�	��endstream
endobj
100 0 obj
<<
/FontFile3 99 0 R
/Descent -194
/Flags 98
/Type/FontDescriptor
/StemH 0
/CapHeight 683
/XHeight 705
/StemV 74
/FontName/MJMVEV+cmmi9
/FontBBox[-29 -250 1075 750]
/ItalicAngle -14
/Ascent 683
>>
endobj
101 0 obj
<<
/Widths[535 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 602 0 0 0 589 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 642 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 281 0 803 509 0 0 0 776 776 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 870 696 990 816 0 656 0 776 629 0 0 0 0 843 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 442 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 616 0 522 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 589 509 482]
/Encoding 98 0 R
/Subtype/Type1
/Type/Font
/LastChar 122
/Name/F10
/FirstChar 13
/FontDescriptor 100 0 R
/BaseFont/MJMVEV+cmmi9
>>
endobj
102 0 obj
<<
/Type/Encoding
/Differences[0/minus/periodcentered 3/asteriskmath 106/bar]
/BaseEncoding/MacRomanEncoding
>>
endobj
103 0 obj
<<
/Length1 552
/Length 552
/Subtype/Type1C
>>
stream





CMHYQN+cmsy9

M��
����J_LNs
m�Rz��
��
������	


UZiasteriskmath1.0Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reservedcmsy9Computer Modern



�]�r
���
�!�v�Cw
�z��:��������}�}������0��;����{�x�|��y��)��~�����}}}|z�����!J�I{����z|�}��������}�:�~�~�������߈������U���~����������������:���O���yv�|w
�
��8�_���vu�x{�6{�x������-�v�y�
��9�y�����x�{��}v�vu�����v�Y�
��X���s�mmsrnn�r�����u��?����
���
7�	��endstream
endobj
104 0 obj
<<
/FontFile3 103 0 R
/Descent -119
/Flags 4
/Type/FontDescriptor
/StemH 0
/CapHeight 683
/XHeight 705
/StemV 87
/FontName/CMHYQN+cmsy9
/FontBBox[-30 -958 1146 777]
/ItalicAngle -14
/Ascent 683
>>
endobj
105 0 obj
<<
/Widths[803 281 0 509 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 281]
/Encoding 102 0 R
/Subtype/Type1
/Type/Font
/LastChar 106
/Name/F11
/FirstChar 0
/FontDescriptor 104 0 R
/BaseFont/CMHYQN+cmsy9
>>
endobj
106 0 obj
<<
/Type/Encoding
/Differences[0/minus/periodcentered/multiply/asteriskmath 10/circlemultiply 15/bullet 20/lessequal/greaterequal 33/arrowright 54/negationslash/mapsto 102/braceleft/braceright 106/bar 112/radical]
/BaseEncoding/MacRomanEncoding
>>
endobj
107 0 obj
<<
/Length1 1771
/Length 1771
/Subtype/Type1C
>>
stream




VJYORK+cmsy10

L�#�$
�%�&��J_LNt
n�T��
��
��
.
*
M��

*6@GTW���mapstolessequalgreaterequalcirclemultiplyasteriskmatharrowrightradicalnegationslash1.0Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reservedcmsy10Computer Modern



��
�
�
�
�]r
��
�t
�^\
6�

~���Ov��3�[�v�v�:��:w
ó�z�����v������ww�x}��}�x�������v�vw
�'�w�6���[�\����������������\�\�]�\����������������[�\�[�[����������������\�\�\�\�������������������Cv��w
���8�������������������������~�����������������������������w�����x�|��}w�ww�������Cv��w
���7����������������~��������������������������~������������\�����x�|��}w�ww����8����
ä����e���M�+�(�I�M�(�+�J�M�+�(�I�M�(�+�J���v��ծ���pU��d�e�w�wS�r��۪Խ��e�e���e�a�A.;lBYS�e�e�S�v\XAh8AA��N�d�e�$�v�Cw
�q����y�q�p�q���~������������}��%��"ϔ������}�~������.��4����r�{~~~����3��~�����~}{{�����!H�!G����{{���������}�8�|�������������yv�|w
���3�a���ww�x}�:}�x����������v�Y�
��T���s�nnssnn�s�������v�v�2��2w
��z@Tj8��������������ﺗ�����������U�Q�b燔�������������8�T��|y�ww�����v�z�
���)�z�����x�}��}x�ww����I�?v�|w
������F������������(@������������������Z�G�}����������\�D�������������$�v�v�w
��O���3�"�
62" �4�
����Wv�8w
�����:��������}�����V��������~�������$�yv��v��v
�l�����ŋ�W��`K�k���������چ�^�g�����h�*m�X���I�q���
i�D�o�HC�usryytsE��������������侍��K鋛������ʏ������������`�6����$�yv�{��}w
�l�����Ӌ�������я�����������'�2X�C�K-�{qo}}ppL����������������v�'�ZQ�i�fm�̃����������<�f����������*�����~�K�d��
��ҋ�u��?����
���
7�	��endstream
endobj
108 0 obj
<<
/FontFile3 107 0 R
/Descent -119
/Flags 4
/Type/FontDescriptor
/StemH 0
/CapHeight 683
/XHeight 705
/StemV 85
/FontName/VJYORK+cmsy10
/FontBBox[-29 -960 1116 775]
/ItalicAngle -14
/Ascent 683
>>
endobj
109 0 obj
<<
/Widths[783 277 783 506 0 0 0 0 0 0 783 0 0 0 0 506 0 0 0 0 783 783 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 506 506 0 0 277 0 0 0 0 0 831]
/Encoding 106 0 R
/Subtype/Type1
/Type/Font
/LastChar 112
/Name/F12
/FirstChar 0
/FontDescriptor 108 0 R
/BaseFont/VJYORK+cmsy10
>>
endobj
110 0 obj
<<
/Type/Encoding
/Differences[0/minus 3/asteriskmath]
/BaseEncoding/MacRomanEncoding
>>
endobj
111 0 obj
<<
/Length1 457
/Length 457
/Subtype/Type1C
>>
stream





CEJHPM+cmsy7

M��
����J_LNq
|�K�
��
������
�


UZiasteriskmath1.0Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reservedcmsy7Computer Modern

��

�����Q��v�Cw
����k���������x������0��*������w�w�|~��7��~�����xy}y�����(L�(K}����y}�y��������{�7�~�|�������z�-���x�n�i�y������������}���X�X�X����v�v�
��8��v�����t�}��}t�rs���t��?����
�����endstream
endobj
112 0 obj
<<
/FontFile3 111 0 R
/Descent -117
/Flags 4
/Type/FontDescriptor
/StemH 0
/CapHeight 683
/XHeight 708
/StemV 93
/FontName/CEJHPM+cmsy7
/FontBBox[-15 -951 1252 782]
/ItalicAngle -14
/Ascent 683
>>
endobj
113 0 obj
<<
/Widths[895 0 0 585]
/Encoding 110 0 R
/Subtype/Type1
/Type/Font
/LastChar 3
/Name/F13
/FirstChar 0
/FontDescriptor 112 0 R
/BaseFont/CEJHPM+cmsy7
>>
endobj
114 0 obj
<<
/Type/Encoding
/Differences[18/parenleftbigg/parenrightbigg 80/summationtext 82/integraltext 88/summationdisplay]
/BaseEncoding/MacRomanEncoding
>>
endobj
115 0 obj
<<
/Length1 938
/Length 938
/Subtype/Type1C
>>
stream




FNNAIB+cmex10

G� �!
�"�#�LNF
s�p���
��
��


#��	

)9EI���summationtextparenrightbiggparenleftbiggsummationdisplayintegraltext1.00Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reservedcmex10Computer Modern



�
�
�
�
�
o�
Z
�V���UV�.�|��
�{��������������R� ��z��O��5�~��p��l�
�����K�������������rr@HN6n{�Fs�'��=���v	_w
�P����x�1� ����w�e�b����}�������������g�H��5���ً����g��9��<�"88aa������������������^�9���v	_w
�d��P�������f�H�H��5��B�ً�������9���"�ݷ�����������}�}���||���"�^��9�� �����t�b�g�����������������
����
��rd#!G�mv�)q�T������钓����������f�����}�����z�Y�{�^�:��
���bt�������x����h�������������H�롢��ܢ�
����+�{�L�������x�n��t}n�~������Y�O,d*?zTg����
x���8~g^R~m��v������u�xwu~m[�h�����������w��y��
�����

yXO	��endstream
endobj
116 0 obj
<<
/FontFile3 115 0 R
/Descent -1139
/Flags 4
/Type/FontDescriptor
/StemH 0
/CapHeight 772
/XHeight 0
/StemV 47
/FontName/FNNAIB+cmex10
/FontBBox[-24 -2960 1454 772]
/ItalicAngle 0
/Ascent 772
>>
endobj
117 0 obj
<<
/Widths[735 735 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1060 0 470 0 0 0 0 0 1445]
/Encoding 114 0 R
/Subtype/Type1
/Type/Font
/LastChar 88
/Name/F14
/FirstChar 18
/FontDescriptor 116 0 R
/BaseFont/FNNAIB+cmex10
>>
endobj
118 0 obj
<<
/Type/Encoding
/Differences[100/d 105/i/j/k 110/n 120/x]
/BaseEncoding/MacRomanEncoding
>>
endobj
119 0 obj
<<
/Length1 1312
/Length 1312
/Subtype/Type1C
>>
stream





MFCNYD+cmmi7

M��
����J�M��
������
��
�������

KP_1.100Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reservedcmmi7Computer Modern


LEKJOY
�
��^	���UV[����癧�b�
�������,��������w8��r��}�v}�������������!�ʆy����|�z����������D��҄�t�W�������|�����D�k��싩�,����~���}����x`pDZp���������������a�����������Ë������`��i�|�u�|����������s�V�R�WbX\acjlbz[�����b�
����,��������w8��r��}�v}������������R�xv�i�[����!�$*�F����O�Ł���������ď�~��}��p�[xPaq��������A��ouwux��ck`�f�g��ҋ������۾���ы�?���������M�`������
��z��K��~�pnpop{�u������h�6FzVQP~���������x�wlqpke�r��	�����������\�O�K�}~��������Ť�����zk��}����������
�Ҫ�����opnqnz�v������`���~�z\�e����~��}����;t_bdw�����������������揗��������c�T�(�]��z�~�����������ᷯ�����pt�|rM���
�7Ӎ����~�r�u������������������������������������֋ŋ�X�x�O`�{a�o���zV�j����~��}����;t`bcv��������������>�V8SXcmЄP�b`tlt~uf}R�~��������ƚ�����upx�f�p�p�b�u�����K癧
�������i�jUX�m��v������z�tonsfY�t������V��y�����~��}���FvOWScv�����؟������}�k�oyu�|������K�cYcjeu�y]�S�K�m~��������٤ʶ���y[wY�iw��?�������`��
���
7�	��endstream
endobj
120 0 obj
<<
/FontFile3 119 0 R
/Descent -194
/Flags 4
/Type/FontDescriptor
/StemH 0
/CapHeight 683
/XHeight 703
/StemV 81
/FontName/MFCNYD+cmmi7
/FontBBox[0 -250 1171 750]
/ItalicAngle -14
/Ascent 683
>>
endobj
121 0 obj
<<
/Widths[602 0 0 0 0 396 465 602 0 0 705 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 654]
/Encoding 118 0 R
/Subtype/Type1
/Type/Font
/LastChar 120
/Name/F15
/FirstChar 100
/FontDescriptor 120 0 R
/BaseFont/MFCNYD+cmmi7
>>
endobj
122 0 obj
<<
/Type/Encoding
/Differences[43/plus 49/one/two]
/BaseEncoding/MacRomanEncoding
>>
endobj
123 0 obj
<<
/Length1 538
/Length 538
/Subtype/Type1C
>>
stream




OXEDKW+cmr5

G��
���LNT
���Y
��
������
�

KO^1.00BCopyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reservedcmr5Computer Modern



O�
��N8��������w
����"����jKD��wz_��̎����l��!Y_�����䋇��Y!�����&v��w
�z����r�������p�~������oo�p}���~p�oo������}�p���������
ַ
�	�����Ua�x�M{���7�|��Xͼ��dz���ŋ����
�#���(=�)�W������������q�l���ũ΋��Q)7QK>J���c������m�eu��?�����n��b��
����

7�	��endstream
endobj
124 0 obj
<<
/FontFile3 123 0 R
/Descent -194
/Flags 4
/Type/FontDescriptor
/StemH 0
/CapHeight 666
/XHeight 705
/StemV 89
/FontName/OXEDKW+cmr5
/FontBBox[-341 -250 1304 965]
/ItalicAngle 0
/Ascent 683
>>
endobj
125 0 obj
<<
/Widths[1036 0 0 0 0 0 675 675]
/Encoding 122 0 R
/Subtype/Type1
/Type/Font
/LastChar 50
/Name/F16
/FirstChar 43
/FontDescriptor 124 0 R
/BaseFont/OXEDKW+cmr5
>>
endobj
126 0 obj
<<
/Type/Encoding
/Differences[0/minus]
/BaseEncoding/MacRomanEncoding
>>
endobj
127 0 obj
<<
/Length1 282
/Length 282
/Subtype/Type1C
>>
stream





IZNQDE+cmsy6

M��
����J_LNp
��H1��
��
������


IN]1.0Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reservedcmsy6Computer Modern

�

*�Πv�t�
��\���t�����r�}�}r�qq���s��?����
�����endstream
endobj
128 0 obj
<<
/FontFile3 127 0 R
/Descent -118
/Flags 4
/Type/FontDescriptor
/StemH 0
/CapHeight 683
/XHeight 708
/StemV 93
/FontName/IZNQDE+cmsy6
/FontBBox[-4 -948 1329 786]
/ItalicAngle -14
/Ascent 683
>>
endobj
129 0 obj
<<
/Widths[964]
/Encoding 126 0 R
/Subtype/Type1
/Type/Font
/LastChar 0
/Name/F17
/FirstChar 0
/FontDescriptor 128 0 R
/BaseFont/IZNQDE+cmsy6
>>
endobj
130 0 obj
<<
/Type/Encoding
/Differences[110/n]
/BaseEncoding/MacRomanEncoding
>>
endobj
131 0 obj
<<
/Length1 441
/Length 441
/Subtype/Type1C
>>
stream





RCRHPK+cmmi5

M��
����J�M��
���E��
��
������
�

KP_1.100Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reservedcmmi5Computer Modern

O

����UV������
���H��W��r�_�u�~��������������������� �����p�^�Ra$tR��~�z�W�gƋ������z��z��x�Ox]W[t��������������V�,0LT_h݆;�f'n�-�}��������Ś�ŵ��kv}�e�q�p�b�uu��?�������a��
����

@?	��endstream
endobj
132 0 obj
<<
/FontFile3 131 0 R
/Descent -191
/Flags 4
/Type/FontDescriptor
/StemH 0
/CapHeight 683
/XHeight 705
/StemV 90
/FontName/RCRHPK+cmmi5
/FontBBox[37 -250 1349 750]
/ItalicAngle -14
/Ascent 683
>>
endobj
133 0 obj
<<
/Widths[891]
/Encoding 130 0 R
/Subtype/Type1
/Type/Font
/LastChar 110
/Name/F18
/FirstChar 110
/FontDescriptor 132 0 R
/BaseFont/RCRHPK+cmmi5
>>
endobj
134 0 obj
<<
/Type/Encoding
/Differences[33/exclam 37/percent 40/parenleft/parenright 44/comma/hyphen/period 61/equal 68/D 80/P 92/backslash 95/underscore 97/a/b/c/d/e/f/g/h/i 108/l 110/n/o/p/q/r/s/t/u/v 120/x/y/z 124/bar]
/BaseEncoding/MacRomanEncoding
>>
endobj
135 0 obj
<<
/Length1 3751
/Length 3751
/Subtype/Type1C
>>
stream




ECVNDK+cmtt10

H��
����
LN�
���o��
��
����
��

KQ`1.00BCopyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reservedcmtt10Computer Modern


"]1%IQ@DP[SWOE
ZR=Y
FCBV	UTJMHG$
+R�

Y
�Dg��[��L�F�U�N�		�

M
�?���
��Mv��w
�w�������hh�h�?�h�������v���
�0�9�������h���h�hh������L���
�����:��������A��t|q�ml�����}m{r�lm���������q�|m�}��FVV`F+!���}�
������{r�lm�����}u{r�lm����b�� �5�45�*�����}�����	Q������v�Jw
�h�����b���b�Vi��/�^�b�d�b�q�������������̌����‹����u�oouuoo�u�����������
��T��?���X�<H^ixx�N���iB{r�lm�����}_{r�lm����3�����r�{_�E�ձ���oO�wd{r�lm����-�����r�{_��r�/���T������:�������B4+EJE=h��&a�����
���2�![^yli쨉�eB{r�lm������_{r�lm����3�����r�{_�,�
�0�9,�����h���h�hh��������
��s��f�
�n��{��w�~�x\A6C�滧������h��}������#�^�@O�3��%���������
�����g�l�.��.(���,�����a�5AM��������J0.M@A�����
�����U��������u�x��j��j]x�u�����������vw���zi�������������ih�vwe�������T��-�F���r�N���
s��w�������8XKyLT���i�|r�ml�����:|r�ml����������q�|�������
��p�B�������s�{�	|r�ml�����
��
��������s�{�	{s�lm�������i��������������T���T��:����cB{r�lm������_{r�lm����3�����r�{_�E��ձ���oO�wd{r�lm����-�����r�{_�|�X�<H^ixx���T��������|���g�}�������q�}^�����iB{r�lm�����2��jb�`�
+,���*�õ����kDS^8>DO������˼ST��
v��
������|M\{���y��w�|�z�������d�_�c�tm�k�e�r����������x���
���B�������s�{�	|r�ml����C�i~f�y�l�������.��������s�{�	{s�lm�����"���������r9~rnTg�|���������y�r�p�zy�q�a�c�������r�/���
�����T� ���ih�ze�pb�R�%,���*�Ϲ����kZ|r�ml����;�����s�{ZF��RZ99AJ������ָ>I�8�"���#�
��������C�������|�ws�x����E������x�{����������f�YYfPAA�P�����4Dx��������p__xp�U���d�[ZeQ@=�S�����4Dx��������mb_xo�Mv��w
�,��/����uw|zy�������G���z�������������v�W���
��T�M�������f�}��}f�hh�����,�����j���j�hh��������
��i���r��(������q�|�	|r�ml���A&?𥋡����r�|�	|q�lm�����
�(��5c|q�lm����	�����v�l��o�u��lm����	�����q�|c���
�\�����m�kerllf�q������Nv��w
�������]�h��V@�sr�w�|�����8�
��5J'f��0|���|��w���`��������
�����<�S�����K��+'���&���大n��y��x�XuU�o@@��{��ԙ�����r$����iv�������|�:��J���iB{r�lm������w�v������a�����
���2�![^yli�Y������B4+EJE=h����T�1�����`�M�v��l���������r�|a�����l�U�$`%�Bm�{����������������׿lD��E��Y+F�J�ɒ����N7t�vdyzg^��Mb����%����T�����T�x���k����������q�}^�����iB{r�lm�����i�1:k<��������iB{r�lm������+�sԴ�����Nv��w
�A��IU���y���]�������������qn�`�����1�YB��S����������w
�-�2��r��8�����s�{�8����ih�vw94{r�lm����+�g��ܶ䝋�hj�vzM�R�t>�����������l���t�w�r�n�G��������ދ�m�q�z�z������������ms�}���__�x�;t9g/�z�}較�~Vffj0\S��r����qh�vw*{�r������g�����2�޻��k���������e�F������i�"|q�ml������
{r�lm����������q�|"��u�oouuoo�u��������}�
�x��������i�2{r�lm�����}�{r�lm����������s�{���y�A���]���x�Tв�Q����}�DUa��ķ����\VR__W1h���t����䩂�z��������p������������x�U���Z�]i{�h�]�-�D@�6�`�j�x��{�umh�r�A^�G�5�N�����y�X��~a�1E�~���|����������������'@��������������5_@`'������
�L������������s�{���΋���d������;�{;>]4V'{r�lm�����&|q�ml����������q�|&������S��y��
���

yXO	��endstream
endobj
136 0 obj
<<
/FontFile3 135 0 R
/Descent -222
/Flags 5
/Type/FontDescriptor
/StemH 0
/CapHeight 611
/XHeight 622
/StemV 69
/FontName/ECVNDK+cmtt10
/FontBBox[-4 -235 731 800]
/ItalicAngle 0
/Ascent 611
>>
endobj
137 0 obj
<<
/Widths[530 0 0 0 530 0 0 530 530 0 0 530 530 530 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 530 0 0 0 0 0 0 530 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 530 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 530 0 0 530 0 530 530 530 530 530 530 530 530 530 0 0 530 0 530 530 530 530 530 530 530 530 530 0 530 530 530 0 530]
/Encoding 134 0 R
/Subtype/Type1
/Type/Font
/LastChar 124
/Name/F19
/FirstChar 33
/FontDescriptor 136 0 R
/BaseFont/ECVNDK+cmtt10
>>
endobj
138 0 obj
<<
/Type/Encoding
/Differences[110/n]
/BaseEncoding/MacRomanEncoding
>>
endobj
139 0 obj
<<
/Length1 462
/Length 462
/Subtype/Type1C
>>
stream





BVLOOY+cmmi6

M��
����J�M��
�����
��
������
�

KP_1.100Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reservedcmmi6Computer Modern

O

���UV�����
�������׆E�eeqtkyrbV����������۟�����b�{�c�o�p�b�u�r�q�r�oY���u����������������������������������������ˋ�X�x�P` y^�z�{�z�X�g‹�������y�}��x�V{bQXx��������������M�?YK{<Kv��?�������`��
���
7�	��endstream
endobj
140 0 obj
<<
/FontFile3 139 0 R
/Descent -194
/Flags 4
/Type/FontDescriptor
/StemH 0
/CapHeight 683
/XHeight 704
/StemV 85
/FontName/BVLOOY+cmmi6
/FontBBox[11 -250 1241 750]
/ItalicAngle -14
/Ascent 683
>>
endobj
141 0 obj
<<
/Widths[763]
/Encoding 138 0 R
/Subtype/Type1
/Type/Font
/LastChar 110
/Name/F20
/FirstChar 110
/FontDescriptor 140 0 R
/BaseFont/BVLOOY+cmmi6
>>
endobj
142 0 obj
<<
/Type/Encoding
/Differences[77/M 97/a 101/e 104/h 112/p 114/r 116/t]
/BaseEncoding/MacRomanEncoding
>>
endobj
143 0 obj
<<
/Length1 1293
/Length 1293
/Subtype/Type1C
>>
stream





ZGUIUJ+cmsl9

N��
����`
�LN]
N��~��
��
�������

IN]1.0Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reservedcmsl9Computer Modern


SFQIUB.
�
p�7�̖�������
����`�1�쑬������‹���v}on��������t�^@\Flz��$��lƋ���p����z^���b|�M����}������������Ɖ��vI���������W���h��>�
�����L�y����?�;��	����:�
������������=dCr^TM������� �ੳ՜HYq�q��@�V��,��$�
�~����N�*��lċ���s����z=�j�a{�N��l�������������X�v��������q��h����
�%�;�#KWlmj�M������������Ӌ�B�?��,�.�;�s׋���@�����f�
�X�����������[�B0UIu|���*��lƋ���p����z4���b|�M����}����������������Yu����������͓���𪶋���y�\�|�Z�k�mu��z�d|�M����}���������������Y�u���������������Lw
�����$�%�������%��Lo}6U%+��������^���y����1�{������������o�I�{�syfqvo�X������������!���v��鮤
�������%�e�p���x|rt�o�������������������K�,�"�IO�U�s�{�������m�����ƍ�ΡTc����SX�=�Bk'^zG�n�G�pϋߋ�ě��I������š�Ѝ������2��c�_�gyLM`R�_�j�������"�������
�
���(����t�<���}���̔�v����{8���k{d/��lʍ�����������o�K�����������"���������������	�+�ӆk��C�t�l�������͋��������uG�������������Ӌ����=w��x����u��?�����n��b��
���
7�	��endstream
endobj
144 0 obj
<<
/FontFile3 143 0 R
/Descent -194
/Flags 4
/Type/FontDescriptor
/StemH 0
/CapHeight 666
/XHeight 705
/StemV 82
/FontName/ZGUIUJ+cmsl9
/FontBBox[-61 -250 1150 750]
/ItalicAngle -9
/Ascent 683
>>
endobj
145 0 obj
<<
/Widths[937 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 509 0 0 0 455 0 0 575 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 575 0 402 0 402]
/Encoding 142 0 R
/Subtype/Type1
/Type/Font
/LastChar 116
/Name/F21
/FirstChar 77
/FontDescriptor 144 0 R
/BaseFont/ZGUIUJ+cmsl9
>>
endobj
146 0 obj
<<
/Kids[147 0 R 148 0 R 149 0 R 150 0 R 151 0 R 152 0 R]
/Type/Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 153 0 R
>>
endobj
147 0 obj
<<
/Contents 2 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 146 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<<
/F5 81 0 R
/F1 65 0 R
/F6 85 0 R
/F2 69 0 R
/F7 89 0 R
/F3 73 0 R
/F4 77 0 R
/F0 61 0 R
>>
/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
148 0 obj
<<
/Contents 4 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 146 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<</F1 65 0 R/F2 69 0 R/F7 89 0 R/F3 73 0 R/F8 93 0 R>>/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
149 0 obj
<<
/Contents 5 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 146 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<</F9 97 0 R/F1 65 0 R/F2 69 0 R/F7 89 0 R/F3 73 0 R/F8 93 0 R>>/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
150 0 obj
<<
/Contents 6 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 146 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<</F1 65 0 R/F5 81 0 R/F11 105 0 R/F3 73 0 R/F10 101 0 R/F4 77 0 R>>/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
151 0 obj
<<
/Contents 7 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 146 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<<
/F5 81 0 R
/F1 65 0 R
/F6 85 0 R
/F2 69 0 R
/F7 89 0 R
/F3 73 0 R
/F8 93 0 R
>>
/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
152 0 obj
<<
/Contents 8 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 146 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<<
/F9 97 0 R
/F1 65 0 R
/F12 109 0 R
/F2 69 0 R
/F7 89 0 R
/F3 73 0 R
/F8 93 0 R
>>
/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
154 0 obj
<<
/Kids[155 0 R 156 0 R 157 0 R 158 0 R 159 0 R 160 0 R]
/Type/Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 153 0 R
>>
endobj
155 0 obj
<<
/Contents 9 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 154 0 R
/Resources<</ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<</F1 65 0 R/F12 109 0 R/F6 85 0 R/F7 89 0 R/F3 73 0 R>>/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
156 0 obj
<<
/Contents 10 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 154 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<<
/F9 97 0 R
/F1 65 0 R
/F12 109 0 R
/F2 69 0 R
/F7 89 0 R
/F3 73 0 R
/F10 101 0 R
/F8 93 0 R
>>
/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
157 0 obj
<<
/Contents 11 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 154 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<<
/F5 81 0 R
/F9 97 0 R
/F1 65 0 R
/F12 109 0 R
/F2 69 0 R
/F7 89 0 R
/F3 73 0 R
/F10 101 0 R
/F8 93 0 R
>>
/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
158 0 obj
<<
/Contents 12 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 154 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<</F9 97 0 R/F1 65 0 R/F2 69 0 R/F7 89 0 R/F3 73 0 R/F8 93 0 R>>/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
159 0 obj
<<
/Contents 13 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 154 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<<
/F5 81 0 R
/F9 97 0 R
/F1 65 0 R
/F12 109 0 R
/F2 69 0 R
/F6 85 0 R
/F7 89 0 R
/F3 73 0 R
/F10 101 0 R
/F8 93 0 R
>>
/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
160 0 obj
<<
/Contents 14 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 154 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<<
/F9 97 0 R
/F1 65 0 R
/F12 109 0 R
/F6 85 0 R
/F7 89 0 R
/F3 73 0 R
/F10 101 0 R
>>
/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
161 0 obj
<<
/Kids[162 0 R 163 0 R 164 0 R 165 0 R 166 0 R 167 0 R]
/Type/Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 153 0 R
>>
endobj
162 0 obj
<<
/Contents 15 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 161 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<</F9 97 0 R/F1 65 0 R/F2 69 0 R/F7 89 0 R/F3 73 0 R/F8 93 0 R>>/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
163 0 obj
<<
/Contents 16 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 161 0 R
/Resources<</ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<</F9 97 0 R/F1 65 0 R/F12 109 0 R/F6 85 0 R/F7 89 0 R/F3 73 0 R>>/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
164 0 obj
<<
/Contents 17 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 161 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<</F1 65 0 R/F7 89 0 R/F3 73 0 R/F8 93 0 R>>/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
165 0 obj
<<
/Contents 18 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 161 0 R
/Resources<</ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<<
/F13 113 0 R
/F9 97 0 R
/F1 65 0 R
/F12 109 0 R
/F2 69 0 R
/F7 89 0 R
/F3 73 0 R
>>
/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
166 0 obj
<<
/Contents 19 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 161 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<<
/F5 81 0 R
/F13 113 0 R
/F9 97 0 R
/F1 65 0 R
/F12 109 0 R
/F2 69 0 R
/F11 105 0 R
/F7 89 0 R
/F3 73 0 R
/F10 101 0 R
/F8 93 0 R
>>
/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
167 0 obj
<<
/Contents 20 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 161 0 R
/Resources<</ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<</F9 97 0 R/F1 65 0 R/F12 109 0 R/F6 85 0 R/F7 89 0 R/F3 73 0 R>>/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
168 0 obj
<<
/Kids[169 0 R 170 0 R 171 0 R 172 0 R 173 0 R 174 0 R]
/Type/Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 153 0 R
>>
endobj
169 0 obj
<<
/Contents 21 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 168 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<<
/F5 81 0 R
/F9 97 0 R
/F1 65 0 R
/F12 109 0 R
/F2 69 0 R
/F7 89 0 R
/F3 73 0 R
/F10 101 0 R
/F8 93 0 R
>>
/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
170 0 obj
<<
/Contents 22 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 168 0 R
/Resources<</ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<</F9 97 0 R/F1 65 0 R/F12 109 0 R/F2 69 0 R/F7 89 0 R/F3 73 0 R>>/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
171 0 obj
<<
/Contents 23 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 168 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<<
/F13 113 0 R
/F9 97 0 R
/F1 65 0 R
/F12 109 0 R
/F2 69 0 R
/F7 89 0 R
/F3 73 0 R
/F8 93 0 R
>>
/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
172 0 obj
<<
/Contents 24 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 168 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<<
/F13 113 0 R
/F9 97 0 R
/F1 65 0 R
/F12 109 0 R
/F2 69 0 R
/F3 73 0 R
/F8 93 0 R
>>
/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
173 0 obj
<<
/Contents 25 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 168 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<<
/F9 97 0 R
/F1 65 0 R
/F12 109 0 R
/F2 69 0 R
/F6 85 0 R
/F7 89 0 R
/F3 73 0 R
/F10 101 0 R
/F8 93 0 R
>>
/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
174 0 obj
<<
/Contents 26 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 168 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<<
/F1 65 0 R
/F9 97 0 R
/F12 109 0 R
/F16 125 0 R
/F2 69 0 R
/F15 121 0 R
/F7 89 0 R
/F3 73 0 R
/F10 101 0 R
/F14 117 0 R
/F8 93 0 R
>>
/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
175 0 obj
<<
/Kids[176 0 R 177 0 R 178 0 R 179 0 R 180 0 R 181 0 R]
/Type/Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 153 0 R
>>
endobj
176 0 obj
<<
/Contents 27 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 175 0 R
/Resources<</ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<<
/F9 97 0 R
/F1 65 0 R
/F12 109 0 R
/F2 69 0 R
/F6 85 0 R
/F7 89 0 R
/F3 73 0 R
>>
/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
177 0 obj
<<
/Contents 28 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 175 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<<
/F9 97 0 R
/F1 65 0 R
/F12 109 0 R
/F2 69 0 R
/F15 121 0 R
/F3 73 0 R
/F8 93 0 R
>>
/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
178 0 obj
<<
/Contents 29 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 175 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<<
/F9 97 0 R
/F1 65 0 R
/F5 81 0 R
/F12 109 0 R
/F17 129 0 R
/F2 69 0 R
/F11 105 0 R
/F7 89 0 R
/F3 73 0 R
/F10 101 0 R
/F8 93 0 R
/F4 77 0 R
>>
/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
179 0 obj
<<
/Contents 30 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 175 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<<
/F9 97 0 R
/F1 65 0 R
/F12 109 0 R
/F2 69 0 R
/F15 121 0 R
/F3 73 0 R
/F8 93 0 R
>>
/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
180 0 obj
<<
/Contents 31 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 175 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<<
/F9 97 0 R
/F1 65 0 R
/F2 69 0 R
/F18 133 0 R
/F15 121 0 R
/F7 89 0 R
/F3 73 0 R
>>
/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
181 0 obj
<<
/Contents 32 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 175 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<<
/F9 97 0 R
/F1 65 0 R
/F16 125 0 R
/F2 69 0 R
/F7 89 0 R
/F15 121 0 R
/F18 133 0 R
/F3 73 0 R
/F8 93 0 R
>>
/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
182 0 obj
<<
/Kids[183 0 R 184 0 R 185 0 R 186 0 R 187 0 R 188 0 R]
/Type/Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 153 0 R
>>
endobj
183 0 obj
<<
/Contents 33 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 182 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<<
/F9 97 0 R
/F1 65 0 R
/F12 109 0 R
/F2 69 0 R
/F18 133 0 R
/F7 89 0 R
/F3 73 0 R
>>
/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
184 0 obj
<<
/Contents 34 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 182 0 R
/Resources<</ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<</F9 97 0 R/F1 65 0 R/F12 109 0 R/F6 85 0 R/F7 89 0 R/F3 73 0 R>>/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
185 0 obj
<<
/Contents 35 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 182 0 R
/Resources<</ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<</F9 97 0 R/F1 65 0 R/F12 109 0 R/F7 89 0 R/F3 73 0 R>>/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
186 0 obj
<<
/Contents 36 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 182 0 R
/Resources<</ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<<
/F9 97 0 R
/F1 65 0 R
/F12 109 0 R
/F2 69 0 R
/F15 121 0 R
/F7 89 0 R
/F3 73 0 R
>>
/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
187 0 obj
<<
/Contents 37 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 182 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<<
/F9 97 0 R
/F1 65 0 R
/F12 109 0 R
/F2 69 0 R
/F7 89 0 R
/F3 73 0 R
/F8 93 0 R
>>
/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
188 0 obj
<<
/Contents 38 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 182 0 R
/Resources<</ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<</F9 97 0 R/F1 65 0 R/F6 85 0 R/F7 89 0 R/F3 73 0 R>>/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
153 0 obj
<<
/Kids[146 0 R 154 0 R 161 0 R 168 0 R 175 0 R 182 0 R]
/Type/Pages
/Count 36
/Parent 189 0 R
>>
endobj
190 0 obj
<<
/Kids[191 0 R 192 0 R 193 0 R 194 0 R 195 0 R 196 0 R]
/Type/Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 197 0 R
>>
endobj
191 0 obj
<<
/Contents 39 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 190 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<</F5 81 0 R/F9 97 0 R/F1 65 0 R/F2 69 0 R/F3 73 0 R/F8 93 0 R>>/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
192 0 obj
<<
/Contents 40 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 190 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<<
/F9 97 0 R
/F1 65 0 R
/F2 69 0 R
/F15 121 0 R
/F7 89 0 R
/F3 73 0 R
/F10 101 0 R
/F14 117 0 R
/F8 93 0 R
>>
/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
193 0 obj
<<
/Contents 41 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 190 0 R
/Resources<</ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<<
/F13 113 0 R
/F9 97 0 R
/F1 65 0 R
/F12 109 0 R
/F2 69 0 R
/F6 85 0 R
/F15 121 0 R
/F18 133 0 R
/F3 73 0 R
>>
/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
194 0 obj
<<
/Contents 42 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 190 0 R
/Resources<</ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<</F9 97 0 R/F1 65 0 R/F12 109 0 R/F19 137 0 R/F3 73 0 R>>/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
195 0 obj
<<
/Contents 43 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 190 0 R
/Resources<</ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<</F1 65 0 R/F19 137 0 R/F3 73 0 R>>/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
196 0 obj
<<
/Contents 44 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 190 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<<
/F5 81 0 R
/F13 113 0 R
/F9 97 0 R
/F1 65 0 R
/F12 109 0 R
/F19 137 0 R
/F2 69 0 R
/F3 73 0 R
/F8 93 0 R
>>
/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
198 0 obj
<<
/Kids[199 0 R 200 0 R 201 0 R 202 0 R 203 0 R 204 0 R]
/Type/Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 197 0 R
>>
endobj
199 0 obj
<<
/Contents 45 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 198 0 R
/Resources<</ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<</F9 97 0 R/F1 65 0 R/F12 109 0 R/F6 85 0 R/F3 73 0 R>>/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
200 0 obj
<<
/Contents 46 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 198 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<</F1 65 0 R/F2 69 0 R/F3 73 0 R/F8 93 0 R>>/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
201 0 obj
<<
/Contents 47 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 198 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<</F5 81 0 R/F1 65 0 R/F6 85 0 R/F2 69 0 R/F3 73 0 R/F8 93 0 R>>/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
202 0 obj
<<
/Contents 48 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 198 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<<
/F9 97 0 R
/F1 65 0 R
/F2 69 0 R
/F20 141 0 R
/F7 89 0 R
/F3 73 0 R
/F10 101 0 R
/F8 93 0 R
>>
/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
203 0 obj
<<
/Contents 49 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 198 0 R
/Resources<</ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<</F9 97 0 R/F1 65 0 R/F2 69 0 R/F3 73 0 R>>/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
204 0 obj
<<
/Contents 50 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 198 0 R
/Resources<</XObject<</Im1 1 0 R>>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<<
/F5 81 0 R
/F9 97 0 R
/F1 65 0 R
/F6 85 0 R
/F2 69 0 R
/F3 73 0 R
/F8 93 0 R
/F4 77 0 R
>>
/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
205 0 obj
<<
/Kids[206 0 R 207 0 R 208 0 R 209 0 R 210 0 R 211 0 R]
/Type/Pages
/Count 6
/Parent 197 0 R
>>
endobj
206 0 obj
<<
/Contents 51 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 205 0 R
/Resources<</ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<</F5 81 0 R/F21 145 0 R/F3 73 0 R/F4 77 0 R>>/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
207 0 obj
<<
/Contents 52 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 205 0 R
/Resources<</ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<</F5 81 0 R/F3 73 0 R/F4 77 0 R>>/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
208 0 obj
<<
/Contents 53 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 205 0 R
/Resources<</ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<</F5 81 0 R/F3 73 0 R/F10 101 0 R/F4 77 0 R>>/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
209 0 obj
<<
/Contents 54 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 205 0 R
/Resources<</ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<</F5 81 0 R/F3 73 0 R/F10 101 0 R/F4 77 0 R>>/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
210 0 obj
<<
/Contents 55 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 205 0 R
/Resources<</ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<</F5 81 0 R/F3 73 0 R/F4 77 0 R>>/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
211 0 obj
<<
/Contents 56 0 R
/Type/Page
/Parent 205 0 R
/Resources<</ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB]/Font<</F5 81 0 R/F3 73 0 R/F4 77 0 R>>/ExtGState<</GS4 3 0 R>>>>
/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]
>>
endobj
197 0 obj
<<
/Kids[190 0 R 198 0 R 205 0 R]
/Type/Pages
/Count 18
/Parent 189 0 R
>>
endobj
189 0 obj
<<
/Type/Pages
/Kids[153 0 R 197 0 R]
/Count 54
>>
endobj
212 0 obj
<<
/Pages 189 0 R
/Type/Catalog
/PageLabels 57 0 R
>>
endobj
213 0 obj
<<
/Subject()
/Author(Beeson, Michael )
/Keywords(automated deduction, computerization of mathematics)
/Producer(PCTeX V4.2 Distiller)
/Creator(dvips 5.72 Copyright 1997 Radical Eye Software (www.radicaleye.com))
/Title(Mechanization of Mathematics)
/CreationDate(9/18/2003 10:17:51 PM)
>>
endobj
xref
0 214
0000000000 65535 f 
0000000015 00000 n 
0000000223 00000 n 
0000006473 00000 n 
0000006520 00000 n 
0000014863 00000 n 
0000022484 00000 n 
0000032043 00000 n 
0000039841 00000 n 
0000048574 00000 n 
0000055528 00000 n 
0000065184 00000 n 
0000075695 00000 n 
0000083224 00000 n 
0000091269 00000 n 
0000101463 00000 n 
0000110318 00000 n 
0000117814 00000 n 
0000125576 00000 n 
0000136049 00000 n 
0000145987 00000 n 
0000153976 00000 n 
0000163458 00000 n 
0000172203 00000 n 
0000183177 00000 n 
0000191866 00000 n 
0000207065 00000 n 
0000216290 00000 n 
0000223854 00000 n 
0000234479 00000 n 
0000245478 00000 n 
0000256534 00000 n 
0000264845 00000 n 
0000273525 00000 n 
0000285096 00000 n 
0000293759 00000 n 
0000303674 00000 n 
0000312833 00000 n 
0000321376 00000 n 
0000328728 00000 n 
0000335495 00000 n 
0000343984 00000 n 
0000353362 00000 n 
0000360119 00000 n 
0000367260 00000 n 
0000376977 00000 n 
0000385543 00000 n 
0000393655 00000 n 
0000401308 00000 n 
0000410542 00000 n 
0000418551 00000 n 
0000426237 00000 n 
0000434830 00000 n 
0000443054 00000 n 
0000452175 00000 n 
0000460977 00000 n 
0000469204 00000 n 
0000476849 00000 n 
0000476888 00000 n 
0000477030 00000 n 
0000478890 00000 n 
0000479107 00000 n 
0000479386 00000 n 
0000479877 00000 n 
0000490853 00000 n 
0000491065 00000 n 
0000491638 00000 n 
0000491790 00000 n 
0000493514 00000 n 
0000493723 00000 n 
0000493940 00000 n 
0000494421 00000 n 
0000505051 00000 n 
0000505261 00000 n 
0000505830 00000 n 
0000506026 00000 n 
0000508738 00000 n 
0000508954 00000 n 
0000509303 00000 n 
0000509628 00000 n 
0000520412 00000 n 
0000520625 00000 n 
0000521153 00000 n 
0000521436 00000 n 
0000527619 00000 n 
0000527836 00000 n 
0000528333 00000 n 
0000528543 00000 n 
0000536701 00000 n 
0000536916 00000 n 
0000537390 00000 n 
0000537533 00000 n 
0000539194 00000 n 
0000539403 00000 n 
0000539610 00000 n 
0000539877 00000 n 
0000547354 00000 n 
0000547568 00000 n 
0000548042 00000 n 
0000548244 00000 n 
0000552641 00000 n 
0000552855 00000 n 
0000553281 00000 n 
0000553410 00000 n 
0000554043 00000 n 
0000554257 00000 n 
0000554639 00000 n 
0000554904 00000 n 
0000556758 00000 n 
0000556973 00000 n 
0000557387 00000 n 
0000557493 00000 n 
0000558031 00000 n 
0000558245 00000 n 
0000558415 00000 n 
0000558583 00000 n 
0000559602 00000 n 
0000559815 00000 n 
0000560130 00000 n 
0000560241 00000 n 
0000561636 00000 n 
0000561848 00000 n 
0000562064 00000 n 
0000562166 00000 n 
0000562785 00000 n 
0000562997 00000 n 
0000563179 00000 n 
0000563270 00000 n 
0000563633 00000 n 
0000563846 00000 n 
0000564008 00000 n 
0000564097 00000 n 
0000564619 00000 n 
0000564832 00000 n 
0000564998 00000 n 
0000565262 00000 n 
0000569096 00000 n 
0000569307 00000 n 
0000569723 00000 n 
0000569812 00000 n 
0000570355 00000 n 
0000570568 00000 n 
0000570734 00000 n 
0000570857 00000 n 
0000572233 00000 n 
0000572446 00000 n 
0000572701 00000 n 
0000572816 00000 n 
0000573091 00000 n 
0000573326 00000 n 
0000573571 00000 n 
0000573820 00000 n 
0000574084 00000 n 
0000582804 00000 n 
0000574350 00000 n 
0000574465 00000 n 
0000574680 00000 n 
0000574960 00000 n 
0000575251 00000 n 
0000575497 00000 n 
0000575799 00000 n 
0000576068 00000 n 
0000576183 00000 n 
0000576429 00000 n 
0000576655 00000 n 
0000576881 00000 n 
0000577128 00000 n 
0000577445 00000 n 
0000577671 00000 n 
0000577786 00000 n 
0000578077 00000 n 
0000578303 00000 n 
0000578583 00000 n 
0000578852 00000 n 
0000579143 00000 n 
0000579462 00000 n 
0000579577 00000 n 
0000579822 00000 n 
0000580091 00000 n 
0000580419 00000 n 
0000580688 00000 n 
0000580957 00000 n 
0000581250 00000 n 
0000581365 00000 n 
0000581634 00000 n 
0000581860 00000 n 
0000582076 00000 n 
0000582323 00000 n 
0000582590 00000 n 
0000587524 00000 n 
0000582920 00000 n 
0000583035 00000 n 
0000583281 00000 n 
0000583574 00000 n 
0000583847 00000 n 
0000584065 00000 n 
0000584261 00000 n 
0000587432 00000 n 
0000584554 00000 n 
0000584669 00000 n 
0000584885 00000 n 
0000585111 00000 n 
0000585357 00000 n 
0000585637 00000 n 
0000585841 00000 n 
0000586117 00000 n 
0000586232 00000 n 
0000586438 00000 n 
0000586632 00000 n 
0000586838 00000 n 
0000587044 00000 n 
0000587238 00000 n 
0000587592 00000 n 
0000587663 00000 n 
trailer
<<
/Size 214
/Root 212 0 R
/Info 213 0 R
/ID[<AA2B855C431DAB3DF51FB481CA36F1FC><AA2B855C431DAB3DF51FB481CA36F1FC>]
>>
startxref
587970
%%EOF