Sindbad~EG File Manager
����; � TeX output 2003.09.18:2217� ������ ��>� � � �Le�� � ��
@ ���! � � ����孄 � ���^�ō����>;�)�ō���>;��? ���N� ff cmbx12�The�ffMec���hanization�of�Mathematics��"�%��? �K�`y
cmr10�Mic���hael�UUBeeson���^��ٓ�R cmr7�1����i��? �o��� cmr9�San�TJos������We�State�Univ��9ersit�y��:�,�TSan�Jose,�CA�95192,�USA��:.2����? �t�: cmbx9�Summary���.���r�4�The�����j�� cmti9�me��chanization��of�mathematics��refers�to�the�use�of�computers�to�� ��? nd,�z�or�to�help�nd,�mathematical�pro�A�ofs.�T��:�uring�sho��9w�ed�z�that�a�complete�reduction����? of��Smathematics�to�computation�is�not�p�A�ossible,�but�nev��9ertheless�the�art�and�science����? of�1�automated�deduction�has�made�progress.�This�pap�A�er�describ�es�some�of�the�history����? and�Tsurv��9eys�the�state�of�the�art.��!���? ���N� cmbx12�1��S@ In�� tro�` duction���F��? �In�Ⱥthe�nineteen���th�cen�tury��*�,�mac�hines�replaced�h�umans�and�animals�as�ph�ys-�� ��? ical��Glab�Gorers.�While�for�the�most�part�this�w���as�a�w�elcome�relief,�there�w�ere����? o�Gccasional��p�o�c���k�ets�of�resistance.�The�folk�song��� ':
cmti10�John��Henry��commemorates�an����? o�Gccasion��when�a�man�and�a�mac���hine�comp�eted�at�the�task�of�drilling�railroad����? tunnels��7through�moun���tains.�The�\drilling"�w�as�done�b�y�hammering�a�steel����? spik���e.��The�mac�hine�w�as�steam-p�Go�w�ered.�The�man�w�as�an�ex-sla�v�e,�a�banjo����? pla���y�er���with�a�deep�singing�v���oice�and�a�reputation�for�ph�ysical�strength�and����? endurance.�(He�b�Geat�the�mac���hine,�drilling�fourteen�feet�to�its�nine,�but�it�w�as����? a�UUPyrrhic�victory��*�,�as�he�died�after�the�eort.����N Ev���en�c�b�Gefore�the�rst�computers�w�ere�dev�elop�Ged,�p�eople�w���ere�sp�eculating����? ab�Gout��the�p�ossibilit���y�that�mac�hines�migh�t�b�Ge�made�to�p�erform�in���tellectual����? as�rmw���ell�as�ph�ysical�tasks.�Alan�T��*�uring�w�as�the�rst�to�mak�e�a�careful�analy-����? sis�r�of�the�p�Goten���tial�capabilities�of�mac�hines,�in�v�en�ting�his�famous�\T��*�uring����? mac���hines"��for�the�purp�Gose.�He�argued�that�if�an�y�mac�hine�could�p�Gerform�a����? computation,�)qthen�some�T��*�uring�mac���hine�could�p�Gerform�it.�The�argumen�t�fo-����? cuses��@on�the�assertion�that�an���y�mac�hine's�op�Gerations�could�b�e�sim���ulated,�one����? step�D�at�a�time,�b���y�certain�simple�op�Gerations,�and�that�T��*�uring�mac�hines�w�ere����? capable���of�those�simple�op�Gerations.�T��*�uring's�rst�fame�resulted�from�applying����? this��analysis�to�a�problem�p�Gosed�earlier�b���y�Hilb�ert,�whic���h�concerned�the�p�os-����? sibilit���y��of�mec�hanizing�mathematics.�T��*�uring�sho�w�ed�that�in�a�certain�sense,����? it���is�imp�Gossible�to�mec���hanize�mathematics:�W��*�e�shall�nev�er�b�Ge�able�to�build����? an�]s\oracle"�mac���hine�that�can�correctly�answ�er�all�mathematical�questions����? presen���ted�k�to�it�with�a�\y�es"�or�\no"�answ�er.�In�another�famous�pap�Ger�[101],����? T��*�uring�Iqw���en�t�on�to�consider�the�somewhat�dieren�t�question,�\Can�mac�hines����? think?".���It�is�a�dieren���t�question,�b�Gecause�p�erhaps�mac���hines�can�think,�but����? they���migh���t�not�b�Ge�an�y�b�Getter�at�mathematics�than�h�umans�are;�or�p�Gerhaps����? they�0�migh���t�b�Ge�b�etter�at�mathematics�than�h���umans�are,�but�not�b�y�thinking,������ *�c�ō���>;����? �2���`- Mic��9hael�TBeeson����)�ō���>;��? �just�9b���y�brute-force�calculation�p�Go�w�er.�These�t�w�o�pap�Gers�of�T��*�uring�lie�near�� ��? the��Aro�Gots�of�the�sub� �8jects�to�da���y�kno�wn�as��automate��}'d��dde�duction��A�and��articial����? intel� ��ligenc��}'e�.����^��1������N �Although�3@T��*�uring�had�already�pro���v�ed�3@there�w���ere�limits�to�what�one�could����? exp�Gect�-Aof�mac���hines,�nev�ertheless�mac�hines�b�Gegan�to�comp�ete�with�h���umans����? at�Klin���tellectual�tasks.�Arithmetic�came�rst,�but�b�y�the�end�of�the�cen�tury����? computers�^�could�pla���y�excellen�t�c�hess,�and�in�1997�a�computer�program�b�Geat����? w���orld��-c�hampion�Garry�Kasparo�v.�The�New�Y��*�ork�Times�describ�Ged�the�matc�h:����? \In��Xa�dazzling�hourlong�game,�the�Deep�Blue�IBM���computer�demolished����? an��yob���viously�o�v�erwhelmed�Garry�Kasparo�v�and�w�on�the�six-game�man-vs.-����? mac���hine�UUc�hess�matc�h."����^��2������N �In�(1956,�Herb�Simon,�one�of�the�\fathers�of�articial�in���telligence",�pre-����? dicted�a�that�within�ten�y���ears,�computers�w�ould�b�Geat�the�w�orld�c�hess�c�hampion,����? comp�Gose��\aesthetically�satisfying"�original�m���usic,�and�pro�v�e�new�mathemati-����? cal��Ntheorems.����^��3�����It�to�Gok�fort���y�y�ears,�not�ten,�but�all�these�goals�w�ere�ac�hiev�ed|����? and�_�within�a�few�y���ears�of�eac�h�other!�The�m�usic�comp�Gosed�b�y�Da�vid�Cop�Ge's����? programs�Q�[33{35]�cannot�b�Ge�distinguished,�ev���en�b�y�professors�of�m�usic,�from����? that�UUcomp�Gosed�b���y�Mozart,�Beetho�v�en,�and�Bac�h.����^��4������N �In��b1976,�a�computer�w���as�used�in�the�pro�Gof�of�the�long-unsolv�ed�\four����? color��Gproblem'.����^��5���n��This�did�not�fulll�Simon's�prediction,�b�Gecause�the�role�of����? the��Jcomputer�w���as�simply�to�c�hec�k�b�y�calculation�the�1476�dieren�t�sp�Gecic����? cases���to�whic���h�the�mathematicians�had�reduced�the�problem�[2,3].�T��*�o�Gda�y�this����? w���ould���not�cause�a�ripple;�but�in�1976�it�created�quite�a�stir,�and�there�w�as����? serious��discussion�ab�Gout�whether�suc���h�a�\pro�of� �"�w���as�acceptable!�The�journal����? editors�<�required�an�indep�Genden���t�computer�program�to�b�e�written�to�c���hec�k����? the�4�result.�The�use�of�computer�calculations�to�pro���vide�\empirical"�evidence��? �h�� ff 8�ϟ
L͍����� ��-=��Aa� cmr6�1����� ?��One��con��9tro�v�ersy�concerns�the�question�whether�the�limiting�theorems�ab�A�out�T��:�ur-�� �� ?�ing�r;mac��9hines�also�apply�to�h�uman�in�telligence,�or�whether�h�uman�in�telligence�has���� ?�some��uqualit��9y�not�imitable�b�y�a�T��:�uring�mac�hine�(a�vital�force,�free�will,�quan�tum���� ?�indeterminacy��in�the�synapses?)�These�questions�w��9ere�already�tak�en�up�b�y�T��:�ur-���� ?�ing,��and�w��9ere�still�under�discussion�(without�agreemen�t)�b�y�scien�tic�luminaries���� ?�at�Tthe�end�of�the�t��9w�en�tieth�Tcen�tury�[79,80].�� ������ ��-=�2����� ?��After� �the�game,�IBM� @retired�Deep�Blue,�\quitting�while�it�w��9as�ahead."�Some���� ?�said��that�Kasparo��9v�lost�only�b�A�ecause�he�got�nerv�ous�and�blundered.�No�rematc�h���� ?�w��9as�\%held.�In�Octob�A�er,�2002,�another�c�hampion�pla�y�ed�another�computer�program:���� ?�This�Ttime�it�w��9as�a�dra�w.�������� ��-=�3����� ?��This���prediction�is�usually�cited�as�ha��9ving�b�A�een�made�in�1957,�but�I���b�eliev��9e�it���� ?�w��9as���actually�rst�made�in�1956�at�Simon's�inaugural�address�as�Presiden�t�of�the���� ?�Op�A�erations�TResearc��9h�So�ciet��9y�of�America.�������� ��-=�4����� ?��That�h4lev��9el�of�p�A�erformance�w�as�not�demanded�b�y�Simon's�prediction,�and�his���� ?�criterion�lof�\aesthetically�satisfying"�m��9usic�w�as�met�m�uc�h�earlier.�It�is�in�teresting���� ?�that��Simon�set�a�lo��9w�er��bar�for�m��9usic�than�for�mathematics�and�c�hess,�but�m�usic���� ?�turned�Tout�to�b�A�e�easier�to�computerize�than�mathematics.�������� ��-=�5����� ?��This��problem�asks�whether�it�is�p�A�ossible�to�color�an��9y�map�that�can�b�e�dra��9wn�on���� ?�a�e�plane�using�at�most�four�colors,�in�suc��9h�a�w�a�y�that�coun�tries�with�a�common���� ?�b�A�order�Treceiv��9e�dieren�t�colors.�����
Ϡc�ō���>;���� �IȻThe�TMec��9hanization�of�Mathematics����E�3����)�ō���>;��? �for�(mathematical�claims�has�led�to�\exp�Gerimen���tal�mathematics"�and�ev�en�to�� ��? rep�Gorts� $of�the�\death�of�pro�of� �"�[53].�As�Mark�Tw���ain�said,�\the�rep�orts�of�m���y����? death�UUare�greatly�exaggerated".����N On���Decem���b�Ger�10,�1996,�Simon's�prediction�came�true.�The�fron�t�page�of����? the�"7New�Y��*�ork�Times�carried�the�follo���wing�headline:��Computer�PeMath�Pr��}'o�of����? Shows���R��}'e�asoning�Power�.�UUThe�story�b�Gegan:���#��P �Computers�Q�are�whizzes�when�it�comes�to�the�grun��9t�w�ork�of�mathematics.�� ��P But��for�creativ��9e�and�elegan�t�solutions�to�hard�mathematical�problems,����P nothing��has�b�A�een�able�to�b�eat�the�h��9uman�mind.�That�is,�p�erhaps,�un��9til����P no��9w.��YA���computer�program�written�b�y�researc�hers�at�Argonne�National����P Lab�A�oratory�-|in�Illinois�has�come�up�with�a�ma� ��jor�mathematical�pro�of�that����P w��9ould��~ha�v�e�b�A�een�called�creativ�e�if�a�h�uman�had�though�t�of�it.�In�doing�so,����P the�Vcomputer�has,�for�the�rst�time,�got�a�to�A�ehold�in��9to�pure�mathematics,����P a��ueld�describ�A�ed�b��9y�its�practitioners�as�more�of�an�art�form�than�a�science.������N �The�V(theorem�w���as�pro�v�ed�b�y�the�computer�program�EQP��*�,�written�b�y�Bill�� ��? McCune.��Before�it�w���as�pro�v�ed,�it�w�as�kno�wn�as�the��R��}'obbins� �Conje�ctur�e�,����? and�i�p�Geople�seem�reluctan���t�to�c�hange�the�name�to�\EQP's�theorem".�It�is����? ab�Gout�� certain�algebras.�An�algebra�is�a�set�with�t���w�o�� op�erations,�written�as����? w���e�cusually�write�addition�and�m�ultiplication,�and�another�op�Geration�called����? \complemen���t"��and�written��
�b>